Julie Beischel | Living-Agent-Psi Is Dead

Dr. Julie Beischel of the Windbridge Research Center discusses the critical limitations of language used to describe mediumistic phenomena. She highlights how terms like "trance medium," "clairvoyant," and "living-agent psi" fail to accurately represent the multimodal, experiential reality of modern mental mediums. Through empirical research, Beischel demonstrates that mediums can reliably distinguish between receiving communication from the deceased (survival psi) and obtaining psychic information about the living (somatic psi).

The presentation details a comprehensive study published in the journal Threshold, analyzing quantitative and qualitative data from over 120 mediums. The findings reveal distinct cognitive and sensory differences between mediumistic and psychic experiences. Notably, the research challenges traditional boundaries by showing that deceased individuals can sometimes act as sources of information even during purely psychic readings, calling for a major shift in how researchers categorize and discuss these phenomena.

Key takeaways

• Mediumship is a multimodal sensory experience involving taste, smell, touch, and sound, making the term "clairvoyant" too restrictive.
• Living-agent psi is an imprecise and misleading term; the Windbridge Research Center prefers somatic psi to describe psychic information about the living.
• Quantitative text analysis shows mediumistic descriptions contain more social and perceptual words, while psychic descriptions feature more cognitive insight words.
• About 97% of surveyed mediums report they can clearly distinguish between communication from the deceased and psychic information about the living.
• The discovery that deceased spirits can provide information during psychic readings challenges existing theoretical frameworks that strictly separate the two phenomena.

Highlights

• 1:06 — Defining the difference between a medium and a psychic
• 3:08 — Why clairvoyant mediumship is an inaccurate term
• 5:12 — The problems with the term living-agent psi
• 8:00 — Mediums describe the physical differences in their readings
• 11:55 — Quantitative findings from the LIWC text analysis
• 13:49 — The surprising role of deceased spirits in psychic readings

00:00:00 Language Limitations in Mediumship Research
00:01:06 Defining Mediums and Psychics
00:01:50 Physical Versus Mental Mediumship
00:03:00 The Multimodal Nature of Mediumship
00:05:12 Survival Psi Versus Somatic Psi
00:07:05 Self-Reports and Distinct Internal Experiences
00:09:41 The Threshold Survey of Mediums
00:11:11 Quantitative and Qualitative Study Findings
00:13:49 Deceased Sources in Psychic Readings
00:20:22 Audience Questions and Answers

WEBVTT

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:07.440
Good<00:00:00.321> morning,<00:00:00.643> everyone.<00:00:00.964> Like<00:00:01.286> Steve<00:00:01.607> said,<00:00:01.929> today<00:00:02.250> I'm<00:00:02.571> going<00:00:02.893> to<00:00:03.214> be<00:00:03.536> talking<00:00:03.857> about<00:00:04.179> the<00:00:04.500> limitations<00:00:04.821> of<00:00:05.143> the<00:00:05.464> language<00:00:05.786> used<00:00:06.107> to<00:00:06.429> describe<00:00:06.750> mediumistic

00:00:07.440 --> 00:00:15.870
phenomena.<00:00:08.130> And<00:00:08.340> so,<00:00:08.910> to<00:00:09.000> demonstrate<00:00:09.750> the<00:00:09.990> importance<00:00:10.650> and<00:00:10.740> the<00:00:10.800> power<00:00:11.040> of<00:00:11.250> language,<00:00:11.429> I'm<00:00:11.759> going<00:00:11.790> to<00:00:12.000> use<00:00:12.210> an<00:00:12.719> example<00:00:13.019> from<00:00:13.320> one<00:00:13.500> of<00:00:13.530> my<00:00:13.710> favorite<00:00:14.130> art<00:00:14.309> forms:<00:00:14.870> newspaper

00:00:15.870 --> 00:00:24.300
comic<00:00:16.320> strips.<00:00:17.810> So,<00:00:18.810> in<00:00:19.439> this<00:00:19.619> comic<00:00:19.890> strip,<00:00:19.920> this<00:00:20.250> child<00:00:20.580> is<00:00:20.699> saying,<00:00:20.850> "Words<00:00:21.090> are<00:00:21.300> weird.<00:00:21.480> With<00:00:21.600> arbitrary<00:00:22.199> grunts<00:00:22.710> and<00:00:22.859> moans,<00:00:22.980> I<00:00:23.250> can<00:00:23.430> implant<00:00:23.789> an<00:00:24.000> idea

00:00:24.300 --> 00:00:32.640
directly<00:00:24.960> in<00:00:25.109> someone's<00:00:25.500> brain."<00:00:25.830> And<00:00:26.180> to<00:00:27.180> a<00:00:27.210> passerby,<00:00:27.660> he<00:00:28.019> says,<00:00:28.230> "Giraffes<00:00:28.740> pimp,"<00:00:29.160> and<00:00:29.400> the<00:00:30.240> passerby<00:00:30.630> thinks<00:00:31.050> of<00:00:31.170> a<00:00:31.260> giraffe<00:00:31.470> dressed<00:00:31.949> like<00:00:32.099> a<00:00:32.130> pimp,<00:00:32.460> and

00:00:32.640 --> 00:00:41.219
the<00:00:33.059> child<00:00:33.270> says,<00:00:33.480> "I<00:00:33.719> refuse<00:00:34.290> to<00:00:34.410> use<00:00:35.010> this<00:00:35.190> power<00:00:35.399> wisely."<00:00:37.370> So,<00:00:38.370> I'll<00:00:38.520> get<00:00:38.700> to<00:00:38.730> my<00:00:39.090> actual<00:00:39.600> topic<00:00:39.930> now,<00:00:40.079> even<00:00:41.040> though

00:00:41.219 --> 00:00:49.379
hundreds,<00:00:41.583> if<00:00:41.947> not<00:00:42.311> thousands<00:00:42.676> or<00:00:43.040> millions<00:00:43.404> of<00:00:43.768> people<00:00:44.132> are<00:00:44.496> receiving<00:00:44.860> readings<00:00:45.225> from<00:00:45.589> psychic<00:00:45.953> mediums<00:00:46.317> every<00:00:46.681> day,<00:00:47.045> and<00:00:47.409> even<00:00:47.773> though<00:00:48.138> dozens<00:00:48.502> of<00:00:48.866> mediums<00:00:49.230> have

00:00:49.379 --> 00:00:58.500
written<00:00:49.739> books<00:00:49.980> and<00:00:50.219> several<00:00:50.430> even<00:00:50.850> have<00:00:51.000> their<00:00:51.210> own<00:00:51.360> TV<00:00:51.600> shows,<00:00:51.989> as<00:00:52.289> a<00:00:52.350> research<00:00:52.920> community,<00:00:53.190> we<00:00:53.640> really<00:00:54.030> don't<00:00:54.210> know<00:00:54.480> a<00:00:54.750> whole<00:00:54.809> lot<00:00:55.050> about<00:00:55.940> modern<00:00:57.500> American

00:00:58.500 --> 00:01:06.869
mental<00:00:58.890> mediums.<00:00:59.309> So,<00:00:59.910> there<00:01:00.090> we're<00:01:00.270> already<00:01:00.660> running<00:01:01.050> into<00:01:01.500> language<00:01:01.980> issues.<00:01:02.370> What's<00:01:02.670> a<00:01:02.820> medium<00:01:03.210> and<00:01:03.449> what's<00:01:03.600> a<00:01:03.750> mental<00:01:04.140> medium?<00:01:04.489> Hold<00:01:05.489> your<00:01:05.670> horses,<00:01:06.000> and<00:01:06.360> I<00:01:06.420> will<00:01:06.659> tell

00:01:06.869 --> 00:01:15.540
you.<00:01:07.381> So,<00:01:07.893> we<00:01:08.405> define<00:01:08.917> a<00:01:09.429> medium<00:01:09.941> at<00:01:10.453> the<00:01:10.965> Windbridge<00:01:11.476> Research<00:01:11.988> Center<00:01:12.500> as<00:01:13.012> an<00:01:13.524> individual<00:01:14.036> who<00:01:14.548> experiences<00:01:15.060> regular

00:01:15.540 --> 00:01:23.759
communication<00:01:16.259> with<00:01:16.290> the<00:01:16.500> deceased,<00:01:16.890> and<00:01:17.250> this<00:01:17.490> is<00:01:17.670> in<00:01:17.820> contrast<00:01:18.299> to<00:01:18.540> a<00:01:18.689> psychic,<00:01:19.320> which<00:01:20.100> is<00:01:20.250> an<00:01:20.369> individual<00:01:20.970> who<00:01:21.240> experiences<00:01:21.869> information<00:01:22.530> about<00:01:22.890> or<00:01:23.100> from<00:01:23.340> living

00:01:23.759 --> 00:01:32.009
people,<00:01:24.097> distant<00:01:24.434> locations,<00:01:24.772> or<00:01:25.109> events,<00:01:25.447> and<00:01:25.784> at<00:01:26.122> times<00:01:26.459> in<00:01:26.797> the<00:01:27.134> future<00:01:27.472> or<00:01:27.810> in<00:01:28.147> the<00:01:28.485> past<00:01:28.822> that<00:01:29.160> they<00:01:29.497> did<00:01:29.835> not<00:01:30.172> originally<00:01:30.510> experience.<00:01:30.847> And<00:01:31.185> it's<00:01:31.522> often<00:01:31.860> said

00:01:32.009 --> 00:01:40.950
that<00:01:32.435> all<00:01:32.861> mediums<00:01:33.287> are<00:01:33.713> psychic<00:01:34.139> but<00:01:34.565> not<00:01:34.991> all<00:01:35.417> psychics<00:01:35.843> are<00:01:36.270> mediums.<00:01:36.696> And<00:01:37.122> though<00:01:37.548> anyone<00:01:37.974> can<00:01:38.400> have<00:01:38.826> mediumistic<00:01:39.252> or<00:01:39.678> psychic<00:01:40.104> experiences,<00:01:40.530> only

00:01:40.950 --> 00:01:50.430
people<00:01:41.280> who<00:01:41.400> have<00:01:41.610> these<00:01:42.500> experiences<00:01:43.500> regularly<00:01:44.189> and<00:01:44.430> reliably<00:01:46.159> are<00:01:47.159> accurately<00:01:48.090> termed<00:01:49.430> mediums

00:01:50.430 --> 00:01:59.430
and<00:01:50.610> psychics.<00:01:51.920> So,<00:01:52.920> there's<00:01:53.100> two<00:01:53.310> kinds<00:01:53.579> of<00:01:54.979> mediums:<00:01:55.979> physical<00:01:56.790> and<00:01:57.000> mental.<00:01:57.360> And<00:01:57.659> the<00:01:58.430> states

00:01:59.430 --> 00:02:07.920
of<00:01:59.610> consciousness<00:01:59.880> that<00:02:00.240> exist<00:02:00.930> in<00:02:01.079> each<00:02:01.290> are<00:02:01.590> arrayed<00:02:02.460> along<00:02:02.640> a<00:02:02.820> continuum<00:02:03.659> of<00:02:04.340> waking<00:02:05.340> state<00:02:05.549> to<00:02:05.729> trance<00:02:06.030> states<00:02:06.420> of<00:02:06.719> various<00:02:07.229> depth<00:02:07.619> and

00:02:07.920 --> 00:02:16.219
levels<00:02:08.374> of<00:02:08.829> dissociation.<00:02:09.283> So,<00:02:09.738> in<00:02:10.192> the<00:02:10.646> in<00:02:11.101> the<00:02:11.555> literature<00:02:12.010> previously,<00:02:12.464> the<00:02:12.918> term<00:02:13.373> "trance<00:02:13.827> medium"<00:02:14.281> was<00:02:14.736> used,<00:02:15.190> but<00:02:15.645> because<00:02:16.099> of

00:02:16.219 --> 00:02:24.650
this<00:02:16.430> continuum<00:02:17.180> of<00:02:18.969> of<00:02:19.969> different<00:02:20.599> trance<00:02:20.840> states,<00:02:21.230> it's<00:02:21.560> not<00:02:21.650> really<00:02:22.250> an<00:02:22.370> accurate<00:02:22.579> term,<00:02:23.060> since<00:02:23.450> any<00:02:23.659> given<00:02:24.109> medium<00:02:24.409> can

00:02:24.650 --> 00:02:33.170
be<00:02:25.026> in<00:02:25.403> full<00:02:25.779> trance<00:02:26.155> one<00:02:26.532> day<00:02:26.908> and<00:02:27.285> and<00:02:27.661> basically<00:02:28.037> a<00:02:28.414> waking<00:02:28.790> state<00:02:29.166> the<00:02:29.543> next<00:02:29.919> day.<00:02:30.295> So,<00:02:30.672> going<00:02:31.048> to<00:02:31.425> the<00:02:31.801> two<00:02:32.177> types:<00:02:32.554> physical,<00:02:32.930> mental.

00:02:33.170 --> 00:02:41.750
So,<00:02:33.560> in<00:02:33.799> physical<00:02:34.989> mediumship,<00:02:36.189> it<00:02:37.189> consists<00:02:37.250> of<00:02:37.819> phenomena<00:02:38.269> including<00:02:38.659> independent<00:02:39.170> voices,<00:02:40.159> paranormal<00:02:40.400> lights,<00:02:40.760> apports,<00:02:41.420> which

00:02:41.750 --> 00:02:51.109
are<00:02:41.900> objects<00:02:42.349> that<00:02:42.500> mysteriously<00:02:43.069> appear,<00:02:43.549> the<00:02:44.090> levitation<00:02:44.599> or<00:02:44.810> movement<00:02:45.349> of<00:02:45.470> objects,<00:02:45.980> ectoplasm,<00:02:46.849> and<00:02:47.299> raps<00:02:47.870> on<00:02:48.079> walls<00:02:48.349> or<00:02:48.530> tables.<00:02:49.720> The<00:02:50.720> purpose

00:02:51.109 --> 00:02:59.659
of<00:02:51.230> mental<00:02:51.620> mediumship<00:02:52.129> is<00:02:52.400> to<00:02:52.579> convey<00:02:52.909> messages<00:02:53.569> from<00:02:53.810> deceased<00:02:54.139> animals<00:02:55.099> or<00:02:55.250> people,<00:02:55.400> called<00:02:56.030> discarnates,<00:02:57.019> to<00:02:57.260> living<00:02:57.590> people,<00:02:57.620> called<00:02:58.280> sitters,<00:02:58.669> during<00:02:59.569> a

00:02:59.659 --> 00:03:08.840
specific<00:03:00.139> event<00:03:00.290> called<00:03:00.709> a<00:03:00.829> reading.<00:03:01.220> So,<00:03:02.799> previously<00:03:03.799> in<00:03:03.919> the<00:03:04.010> literature,<00:03:04.280> terms<00:03:04.669> have<00:03:05.060> been<00:03:05.269> used:<00:03:07.329> clairvoyant<00:03:08.329> mediumship

00:03:08.840 --> 00:03:17.239
is<00:03:08.989> a<00:03:09.019> term<00:03:09.260> that's<00:03:09.470> been<00:03:09.680> used,<00:03:09.919> but<00:03:10.159> this<00:03:10.370> also<00:03:10.669> is<00:03:10.909> a<00:03:11.030> term<00:03:11.299> that<00:03:11.329> isn't<00:03:11.720> necessarily<00:03:12.139> accurate.<00:03:13.329> Clairvoyant<00:03:14.329> means<00:03:14.510> clear<00:03:14.840> seeing,<00:03:15.290> but<00:03:16.190> the<00:03:16.519> process<00:03:17.060> of

00:03:17.239 --> 00:03:25.790
mediumship<00:03:18.049> is<00:03:18.500> actually<00:03:19.340> multimodal;<00:03:20.150> it<00:03:20.449> consists<00:03:20.900> of<00:03:21.019> all<00:03:21.319> of<00:03:21.379> the<00:03:21.739> senses.<00:03:22.190> So,<00:03:23.769> this<00:03:24.769> is<00:03:24.949> an<00:03:25.099> example<00:03:25.430> quote

00:03:25.790 --> 00:03:34.250
of<00:03:26.030> a<00:03:26.120> medium<00:03:26.419> describing<00:03:26.989> those<00:03:27.139> experiences.<00:03:28.010> So,<00:03:28.159> she<00:03:28.790> said,<00:03:29.090> "I<00:03:29.120> get<00:03:29.720> a<00:03:29.750> sense<00:03:30.079> in<00:03:30.290> my<00:03:30.440> body<00:03:30.680> of<00:03:30.919> how<00:03:31.069> they<00:03:31.310> passed.<00:03:31.579> I<00:03:31.940> will<00:03:32.150> hear<00:03:32.329> names<00:03:32.599> and<00:03:32.870> dates,<00:03:33.079> see<00:03:33.829> numbers

00:03:34.250 --> 00:03:43.900
and<00:03:34.430> letters<00:03:34.579> and<00:03:34.699> places.<00:03:35.329> Sometimes<00:03:36.109> I<00:03:36.260> get<00:03:36.409> smells<00:03:36.769> or<00:03:36.979> odors,<00:03:37.340> and<00:03:37.669> I'm<00:03:38.060> able<00:03:38.150> to<00:03:38.329> taste<00:03:38.690> foods<00:03:39.049> with<00:03:39.260> special<00:03:39.650> connection<00:03:40.099> to<00:03:40.129> the<00:03:40.430> discarnate<00:03:40.819> or<00:03:41.060> the<00:03:41.209> sitter."

00:03:43.900 --> 00:03:52.340
So,<00:03:45.250> there's<00:03:46.250> where<00:03:46.760> the<00:03:46.790> bullet<00:03:47.209> is,<00:03:47.299> it<00:03:47.540> fell<00:03:47.780> to<00:03:47.959> the<00:03:47.989> next<00:03:48.319> slide.<00:03:48.500> So,<00:03:49.690> clairvoyant,<00:03:50.690> it<00:03:50.780> would<00:03:50.930> just<00:03:51.109> be<00:03:51.229> clear<00:03:51.500> seeing,<00:03:51.799> which<00:03:52.190> is

00:03:52.340 --> 00:04:01.150
limited<00:03:52.760> to<00:03:53.180> just<00:03:53.600> seeing,<00:03:54.020> but<00:03:54.440> clearly<00:03:54.860> from<00:03:55.280> this<00:03:55.700> quote,<00:03:56.120> you<00:03:56.540> can<00:03:56.959> see<00:03:57.379> that<00:03:57.799> they<00:03:58.219> do<00:03:58.639> clear<00:03:59.059> their<00:03:59.479> clairaudient<00:03:59.899> and<00:04:00.319> clairsentient<00:04:00.739> and

00:04:01.150 --> 00:04:09.769
clairsentient.<00:04:01.539> So,<00:04:01.928> again,<00:04:02.317> it's<00:04:02.706> a<00:04:03.095> term<00:04:03.484> that's<00:04:03.873> been<00:04:04.262> used<00:04:04.651> in<00:04:05.040> the<00:04:05.429> literature<00:04:05.818> that's<00:04:06.207> probably<00:04:06.596> not<00:04:06.985> accurate.<00:04:07.374> It<00:04:07.763> doesn't<00:04:08.152> accurately<00:04:08.541> reflect<00:04:08.930> how<00:04:09.319> mediumship

00:04:09.769 --> 00:04:18.209
actually<00:04:10.258> works<00:04:10.748> in<00:04:11.237> the<00:04:11.727> real<00:04:12.216> world.<00:04:12.706> Modern<00:04:13.195> American<00:04:13.685> mental<00:04:14.174> mediums<00:04:14.664> perform<00:04:15.153> readings<00:04:15.643> in<00:04:16.132> person,<00:04:16.622> often—not<00:04:17.111> often,<00:04:17.601> but<00:04:18.090> sometimes—in

00:04:18.209 --> 00:04:27.980
groups,<00:04:19.700> over<00:04:20.700> the<00:04:20.730> phone,<00:04:21.120> and<00:04:21.530> over<00:04:22.530> the<00:04:22.650> internet.<00:04:23.100> And<00:04:24.020> during<00:04:25.020> these<00:04:25.170> readings,<00:04:25.500> they<00:04:25.650> provide<00:04:26.010> both<00:04:26.250> mediumistic

00:04:27.980 --> 00:04:36.600
messages<00:04:28.980> from<00:04:29.250> the<00:04:29.520> deceased<00:04:29.910> and<00:04:30.180> psychic<00:04:30.720> information<00:04:31.320> about<00:04:31.620> the<00:04:31.860> living<00:04:32.220> reading<00:04:33.090> recipient.<00:04:35.120> My<00:04:36.120> previous

00:04:36.600 --> 00:04:45.240
research<00:04:37.089> demonstrated—we<00:04:37.578> won't<00:04:38.066> go<00:04:38.555> through<00:04:39.044> all<00:04:39.533> this,<00:04:40.022> but<00:04:40.511> in<00:04:40.999> this<00:04:41.488> case,<00:04:41.977> 20<00:04:42.466> mediums<00:04:42.955> during<00:04:43.444> 58<00:04:43.932> quintuple-blinded<00:04:44.421> readings—the<00:04:44.910> mediums

00:04:45.240 --> 00:04:54.210
are<00:04:45.390> able<00:04:45.660> to<00:04:45.690> accurately<00:04:46.820> were<00:04:47.820> able<00:04:48.060> to<00:04:48.150> report<00:04:48.360> accurate<00:04:48.750> and<00:04:48.870> specific<00:04:49.290> information<00:04:49.470> about<00:04:50.130> the<00:04:50.340> deceased<00:04:50.900> under<00:04:52.700> blinded<00:04:53.700> conditions

00:04:54.210 --> 00:05:03.960
with<00:04:54.420> no<00:04:54.600> prior<00:04:54.900> knowledge,<00:04:55.200> no<00:04:55.800> feedback<00:04:56.490> during<00:04:57.090> or<00:04:57.210> after<00:04:57.360> the<00:04:57.630> reading,<00:04:58.170> and<00:04:58.320> without<00:04:58.890> using<00:04:59.340> fraud<00:04:59.850> or<00:05:00.120> deception.<00:05:00.450> And<00:05:00.870> so,<00:05:01.380> these<00:05:01.560> are<00:05:01.910> significant<00:05:02.960> p-values

00:05:03.960 --> 00:05:12.300
and,<00:05:05.000> no<00:05:06.000> pun<00:05:06.300> intended,<00:05:06.390> medium<00:05:07.140> effect<00:05:07.440> sizes.<00:05:09.260> So,<00:05:10.260> but<00:05:10.950> where<00:05:11.130> are<00:05:11.370> the<00:05:11.490> mediums<00:05:11.820> getting<00:05:12.150> their

00:05:12.300 --> 00:05:20.520
information?<00:05:12.702> So,<00:05:13.104> there's<00:05:13.506> two<00:05:13.908> competing<00:05:14.310> psi-based<00:05:14.712> theories<00:05:15.114> of<00:05:15.516> where<00:05:15.918> a<00:05:16.320> medium<00:05:16.722> is<00:05:17.124> getting<00:05:17.526> that<00:05:17.928> this<00:05:18.330> accurate<00:05:18.732> information<00:05:19.134> she's<00:05:19.536> reporting.<00:05:19.938> The<00:05:20.340> first

00:05:20.520 --> 00:05:28.770
is<00:05:20.730> called<00:05:20.910> survival<00:05:21.419> psi,<00:05:21.630> and<00:05:22.130> it<00:05:23.130> suggests<00:05:23.580> that<00:05:23.640> she's<00:05:24.000> communicating<00:05:24.750> telepathically<00:05:24.930> with<00:05:25.620> the<00:05:26.130> deceased.<00:05:26.520> And<00:05:27.440> the<00:05:28.440> other<00:05:28.620> is

00:05:28.770 --> 00:05:37.320
called<00:05:28.919> somatic<00:05:29.550> psi,<00:05:29.760> and<00:05:30.230> it<00:05:31.230> states<00:05:31.620> that<00:05:31.740> mediums<00:05:32.370> are<00:05:32.490> using<00:05:32.790> clairvoyance,<00:05:33.419> precognition,<00:05:34.050> and/or<00:05:34.620> telepathy<00:05:34.980> with<00:05:35.340> the<00:05:35.490> living<00:05:35.790> to<00:05:35.970> acquire<00:05:36.270> information<00:05:36.930> about

00:05:37.320 --> 00:05:45.660
the<00:05:37.650> deceased.<00:05:37.980> So,<00:05:38.550> no<00:05:38.730> actual<00:05:39.090> dead<00:05:39.360> people,<00:05:39.720> just<00:05:40.380> information<00:05:41.310> about<00:05:41.610> them.<00:05:42.770> Somatic<00:05:43.770> psi<00:05:43.950> has<00:05:44.160> also<00:05:44.340> been<00:05:44.640> referred<00:05:45.180> to<00:05:45.210> as<00:05:45.390> living

00:05:45.660 --> 00:05:54.350
agent<00:05:46.230> psi,<00:05:46.440> but<00:05:46.950> this<00:05:47.310> terminology<00:05:47.790> is<00:05:48.090> problematic.<00:05:49.310> We<00:05:50.310> don't<00:05:50.640> like<00:05:50.880> it.<00:05:51.919> The<00:05:52.919> word<00:05:53.490> "living"<00:05:53.880> is

00:05:54.350 --> 00:06:03.120
imprecise<00:05:55.350> and<00:05:55.590> cryptic<00:05:56.370> because<00:05:56.880> of<00:05:58.550> the<00:05:59.550> both<00:05:59.820> the<00:06:00.060> medium<00:06:00.480> and<00:06:00.720> the<00:06:01.500> alleged<00:06:02.040> people<00:06:02.910> she's

00:06:03.120 --> 00:06:11.520
reading<00:06:03.480> during<00:06:04.050> this<00:06:04.520> theory<00:06:05.520> are<00:06:05.820> both<00:06:06.390> living.<00:06:06.810> So,<00:06:07.650> what<00:06:08.520> is<00:06:08.850> the<00:06:09.060> "living"<00:06:09.270> referring<00:06:09.840> to?<00:06:09.960> Because<00:06:10.169> in<00:06:10.380> any<00:06:10.560> case,<00:06:10.830> the<00:06:11.040> medium<00:06:11.370> is

00:06:11.520 --> 00:06:19.830
living.<00:06:11.850> And<00:06:12.140> then,<00:06:13.140> but<00:06:14.070> wise,<00:06:14.370> we<00:06:14.550> just<00:06:14.730> learned<00:06:14.880> from<00:06:14.970> that<00:06:15.090> quote,<00:06:15.390> mediumship<00:06:15.930> is<00:06:16.110> perception,<00:06:16.620> and<00:06:17.130> the<00:06:17.940> word<00:06:18.090> "agent"<00:06:18.330> implies<00:06:18.930> agency<00:06:19.680> that

00:06:19.830 --> 00:06:29.139
the<00:06:19.980> medium<00:06:20.280> has<00:06:20.430> some<00:06:20.669> sort<00:06:20.850> of<00:06:20.910> power<00:06:21.210> over<00:06:21.419> what's<00:06:21.930> happening.<00:06:22.380> But<00:06:22.590> that's<00:06:23.040> like,<00:06:23.430> I<00:06:23.960> smell<00:06:24.960> a<00:06:25.020> banana,<00:06:25.440> like<00:06:25.770> that<00:06:25.979> means<00:06:26.190> the<00:06:26.370> banana<00:06:26.669> has<00:06:26.880> power,<00:06:27.120> you<00:06:27.720> know?<00:06:27.810> Like<00:06:28.110> it's

00:06:29.139 --> 00:06:37.779
that<00:06:30.039> it's<00:06:30.370> it's<00:06:30.939> misleading.<00:06:31.330> The<00:06:31.930> agency,<00:06:32.379> that<00:06:32.499> the<00:06:32.650> medium<00:06:32.889> has<00:06:33.039> agency<00:06:33.669> because<00:06:33.999> she's<00:06:34.379> experiencing<00:06:35.379> it<00:06:35.530> as<00:06:35.710> perception,<00:06:36.580> and<00:06:36.789> you<00:06:36.879> end<00:06:37.090> up,<00:06:37.300> though,

00:06:37.779 --> 00:06:48.360
what<00:06:38.363> is<00:06:38.947> being<00:06:39.532> perceived<00:06:40.116> is<00:06:40.700> it's<00:06:41.284> she<00:06:41.868> doesn't<00:06:42.452> have<00:06:43.037> agency.<00:06:43.621> You<00:06:44.205> get<00:06:44.789> it?

00:06:48.360 --> 00:06:57.310
So,<00:06:48.715> we<00:06:49.070> like<00:06:49.426> the<00:06:49.781> term<00:06:50.136> somatic<00:06:50.491> psi,<00:06:50.846> which<00:06:51.201> we<00:06:51.557> coined<00:06:51.912> in<00:06:52.267> 2009.<00:06:52.622> However,<00:06:52.977> whatever<00:06:53.332> you<00:06:53.688> want<00:06:54.043> to<00:06:54.398> call<00:06:54.753> it,<00:06:55.108> there's<00:06:55.463> no<00:06:55.819> empirical<00:06:56.174> evidence<00:06:56.529> that

00:06:57.310 --> 00:07:05.830
any<00:06:57.680> medium<00:06:58.049> ever<00:06:58.419> was<00:06:58.788> doing<00:06:59.158> that.<00:06:59.527> Survival<00:06:59.897> psi,<00:07:00.266> on<00:07:00.636> the<00:07:01.005> other<00:07:01.375> hand,<00:07:01.744> has<00:07:02.114> the<00:07:02.483> evidence<00:07:02.853> of<00:07:03.222> self-reports<00:07:03.592> of<00:07:03.961> mediums.<00:07:04.331> They<00:07:04.700> know<00:07:05.070> what<00:07:05.439> psychic

00:07:05.830 --> 00:07:14.529
readings<00:07:06.229> feel<00:07:06.627> like,<00:07:07.026> they<00:07:07.424> know<00:07:07.823> what<00:07:08.221> communication<00:07:08.620> with<00:07:09.018> the<00:07:09.417> deceased<00:07:09.815> feels<00:07:10.214> like,<00:07:10.612> and<00:07:11.011> they<00:07:11.409> feel<00:07:11.808> different.<00:07:12.206> So,<00:07:12.605> these<00:07:13.003> are<00:07:13.402> self-reports,<00:07:13.800> and<00:07:14.199> self-report

00:07:14.529 --> 00:07:24.599
is<00:07:14.620> important.<00:07:15.419> It's<00:07:16.419> sort<00:07:16.900> of<00:07:16.960> the<00:07:17.110> only<00:07:17.289> way<00:07:17.500> we<00:07:17.650> can<00:07:17.800> collect<00:07:18.189> some<00:07:18.430> data<00:07:19.000> about<00:07:19.240> internal<00:07:19.900> experience.<00:07:20.849> William<00:07:21.849> James<00:07:22.060> said,<00:07:23.279> "Introspect

00:07:24.599 --> 00:07:34.810
introspective<00:07:25.599> observation<00:07:26.259> is<00:07:26.439> what<00:07:26.620> we<00:07:26.770> have<00:07:26.949> to<00:07:27.099> rely<00:07:27.370> on<00:07:27.400> first<00:07:27.879> and<00:07:28.150> foremost<00:07:28.210> and<00:07:28.930> always."<00:07:29.729> So,<00:07:30.729> there<00:07:30.999> are<00:07:31.089> things<00:07:31.300> we<00:07:31.449> can<00:07:31.569> only<00:07:31.749> study<00:07:32.080> within<00:07:33.810> report:

00:07:34.810 --> 00:07:43.870
self-reports,<00:07:35.482> pain,<00:07:36.153> quality<00:07:36.825> of<00:07:37.497> life,<00:07:38.168> sensory<00:07:38.840> perceptions,<00:07:39.512> the<00:07:40.183> aforementioned<00:07:40.855> banana,<00:07:41.527> bodily<00:07:42.198> sensations.<00:07:42.870> So,

00:07:43.870 --> 00:07:52.509
in<00:07:44.199> the<00:07:44.349> medium's<00:07:44.649> experience,<00:07:45.129> they<00:07:45.279> switch<00:07:45.639> between<00:07:45.909> reporting<00:07:47.219> psychic<00:07:48.219> information<00:07:48.370> about<00:07:48.909> the<00:07:49.089> living<00:07:49.449> and<00:07:49.629> messages<00:07:50.139> from<00:07:50.169> the<00:07:50.680> deceased.<00:07:51.069> And<00:07:51.370> not<00:07:51.759> like<00:07:51.969> moment

00:07:52.509 --> 00:08:00.250
to<00:07:52.599> moment,<00:07:52.750> but<00:07:53.110> they'll<00:07:53.259> do<00:07:53.469> a<00:07:53.500> part<00:07:53.800> of<00:07:53.889> a<00:07:54.009> reading<00:07:54.339> for<00:07:54.849> the<00:07:55.180> deceased<00:07:55.479> and<00:07:55.509> part<00:07:55.930> of<00:07:56.050> a<00:07:56.139> reading<00:07:56.289> for<00:07:56.740> the<00:07:57.009> living.<00:07:58.020> Previous<00:07:59.020> qualitative<00:07:59.620> research<00:07:59.889> has<00:08:00.099> demonstrated

00:08:00.250 --> 00:08:09.189
that<00:08:00.759> their<00:08:01.089> experiences<00:08:01.659> during<00:08:01.870> those<00:08:02.110> two<00:08:02.379> are<00:08:02.729> distinct<00:08:03.729> and<00:08:03.849> distinguishable.<00:08:05.159> So,<00:08:06.159> these<00:08:06.490> are<00:08:06.669> some<00:08:06.909> quotes<00:08:07.210> from<00:08:07.960> mediums<00:08:08.439> discussing

00:08:09.189 --> 00:08:17.469
those<00:08:09.587> differences.<00:08:09.984> So,<00:08:10.382> they<00:08:10.779> talked<00:08:11.177> about<00:08:11.574> sensory<00:08:11.972> perceptions.<00:08:12.369> There's<00:08:12.767> a<00:08:13.164> heaviness<00:08:13.562> around<00:08:13.959> the<00:08:14.357> sensation<00:08:14.754> of<00:08:15.152> living<00:08:15.549> people,<00:08:15.947> like,<00:08:16.344> compared<00:08:16.742> to<00:08:17.139> helium.

00:08:17.469 --> 00:08:25.389
The<00:08:18.129> auditory<00:08:18.639> aspect<00:08:19.089> is<00:08:19.240> much<00:08:19.419> sharper<00:08:19.629> when<00:08:19.990> I'm<00:08:20.139> perceiving<00:08:20.560> someone<00:08:20.979> who<00:08:21.099> is<00:08:21.219> deceased.<00:08:21.610> Their<00:08:21.969> energy<00:08:22.330> is<00:08:22.449> more<00:08:22.629> like<00:08:22.839> helium.<00:08:23.319> With<00:08:24.219> psychic<00:08:24.610> information,<00:08:25.120> I<00:08:25.210> have

00:08:25.389 --> 00:08:35.320
to<00:08:25.569> squint<00:08:25.899> from<00:08:26.199> the<00:08:26.319> inside<00:08:26.680> out,<00:08:26.710> like<00:08:27.069> to<00:08:27.250> focus<00:08:27.460> on<00:08:27.729> something<00:08:28.089> in<00:08:28.449> the<00:08:28.569> distance.<00:08:28.800> When<00:08:29.800> I<00:08:29.830> do<00:08:29.949> mediumship,<00:08:30.580> it's<00:08:30.789> not<00:08:30.969> squinting<00:08:31.479> at<00:08:31.599> all,<00:08:31.750> it's<00:08:32.019> just<00:08:32.079> receiving.<00:08:34.320> They

00:08:35.320 --> 00:08:43.120
also<00:08:35.634> talked<00:08:35.949> about<00:08:36.263> physical<00:08:36.577> sensations.<00:08:36.892> So,<00:08:37.206> once<00:08:37.520> it<00:08:37.835> physically,<00:08:38.149> mediumship<00:08:38.463> charges<00:08:38.778> me<00:08:39.092> up.<00:08:39.407> It's<00:08:39.721> like<00:08:40.035> having<00:08:40.350> eight<00:08:40.664> cups<00:08:40.978> of<00:08:41.293> cappuccino.<00:08:41.607> It's<00:08:41.921> like<00:08:42.236> a<00:08:42.550> buzzing.

00:08:43.120 --> 00:08:50.140
I've<00:08:43.600> learned<00:08:43.870> I<00:08:43.990> can't<00:08:44.230> do<00:08:44.380> readings<00:08:44.770> too<00:08:44.980> late<00:08:45.160> at<00:08:45.310> night<00:08:45.490> because<00:08:45.880> I'll<00:08:46.000> just<00:08:46.180> be<00:08:46.360> up<00:08:46.510> all<00:08:46.690> night.<00:08:46.720> It's<00:08:47.140> like<00:08:47.290> a<00:08:47.320> supercharged.<00:08:48.100> Psychic<00:08:49.030> information<00:08:49.600> doesn't<00:08:49.840> do

00:08:50.140 --> 00:08:58.510
that.<00:08:50.700> Another<00:08:51.700> medium<00:08:52.120> said,<00:08:52.330> "The<00:08:52.510> physical<00:08:52.960> feeling<00:08:53.290> I<00:08:53.380> get<00:08:53.620> is<00:08:53.800> a<00:08:53.860> tingling<00:08:54.790> or<00:08:54.910> a<00:08:55.000> pressure<00:08:55.240> in<00:08:55.510> my<00:08:55.630> head<00:08:55.810> when<00:08:56.050> the<00:08:56.200> medium<00:08:56.500> stuff<00:08:56.920> starts<00:08:57.310> to<00:08:57.340> happen,<00:08:57.430> or<00:08:58.210> when

00:08:58.510 --> 00:09:07.360
they're<00:08:59.050> meeting<00:08:59.770> the<00:09:00.070> deceased<00:09:00.460> or<00:09:00.910> entering<00:09:01.300> the<00:09:01.540> room.<00:09:01.690> I<00:09:01.990> don't<00:09:02.560> get<00:09:02.890> that<00:09:03.040> at<00:09:03.100> all<00:09:03.340> during<00:09:03.580> a<00:09:03.700> psychic<00:09:04.150> reading."<00:09:04.330> And<00:09:06.090> these<00:09:07.090> quotes

00:09:07.360 --> 00:09:15.220
are<00:09:07.640> from<00:09:07.921> Windbridge<00:09:08.201> certified<00:09:08.482> research<00:09:08.762> mediums.<00:09:09.042> We<00:09:09.323> have<00:09:09.603> a<00:09:09.883> team<00:09:10.164> that<00:09:10.444> we<00:09:10.725> work<00:09:11.005> with<00:09:11.285> of<00:09:11.566> about<00:09:11.846> 20<00:09:12.127> mediums.<00:09:12.407> We<00:09:12.687> had<00:09:12.968> 20<00:09:13.248> when<00:09:13.528> we<00:09:13.809> started,<00:09:14.089> but<00:09:14.370> two<00:09:14.650> have

00:09:15.220 --> 00:09:24.370
since<00:09:15.490> retired<00:09:15.790> from<00:09:15.970> research.<00:09:16.540> So,<00:09:17.440> these<00:09:18.370> mediums<00:09:19.090> have<00:09:19.710> successfully<00:09:20.710> completed<00:09:20.890> a<00:09:21.870> step<00:09:22.870> peer-reviewed<00:09:23.770> screening,

00:09:24.370 --> 00:09:33.430
testing,<00:09:24.820> training<00:09:25.750> procedure,<00:09:26.110> and<00:09:26.470> are<00:09:27.540> based<00:09:28.540> on<00:09:28.750> the<00:09:28.930> premise<00:09:29.530> that,<00:09:29.560> oh,<00:09:29.950> if<00:09:30.100> we<00:09:30.190> study<00:09:30.430> a<00:09:30.520> small<00:09:31.180> number,<00:09:31.630> they're<00:09:32.020> probably<00:09:32.310> representative<00:09:33.310> of

00:09:33.430 --> 00:09:41.890
the<00:09:33.580> larger<00:09:33.970> group<00:09:34.570> of<00:09:34.750> American<00:09:35.260> mediums.<00:09:35.650> And<00:09:36.360> but<00:09:37.360> our<00:09:37.480> recent<00:09:37.900> research,<00:09:38.230> we've<00:09:38.670> brought<00:09:39.670> in<00:09:39.880> to<00:09:40.090> look<00:09:40.300> at<00:09:40.450> a<00:09:40.620> much<00:09:41.620> greater

00:09:41.890 --> 00:09:50.050
number<00:09:41.980> of<00:09:42.280> mediums.<00:09:42.820> So,<00:09:43.060> the<00:09:43.480> research<00:09:43.750> I'll<00:09:43.930> be<00:09:44.020> talking<00:09:44.170> about<00:09:44.320> today<00:09:44.650> is<00:09:45.250> from<00:09:46.240> that<00:09:46.600> larger<00:09:47.140> group.<00:09:48.240> So,<00:09:49.240> a<00:09:49.270> few<00:09:49.810> months<00:09:49.990> ago,

00:09:50.050 --> 00:09:58.570
we<00:09:50.320> published<00:09:51.040> this<00:09:51.190> paper:<00:09:51.400> "Quantitative<00:09:52.270> and<00:09:52.390> Qualitative<00:09:52.840> Analyses<00:09:53.470> of<00:09:53.530> Mediumistic<00:09:54.160> and<00:09:54.490> Psychic<00:09:54.850> Experiences."<00:09:55.630> It's<00:09:56.530> 40<00:09:56.890> pages<00:09:57.130> long,<00:09:57.310> so<00:09:57.880> I<00:09:57.910> would<00:09:58.390> be

00:09:58.570 --> 00:10:06.130
here<00:09:58.750> till<00:09:58.960> tomorrow<00:09:58.990> if<00:09:59.470> I<00:09:59.680> went<00:09:59.890> through<00:10:00.010> every<00:10:00.340> single<00:10:00.370> bit,<00:10:00.880> but<00:10:01.360> it's<00:10:01.510> available.<00:10:01.740> It's<00:10:02.740> from<00:10:03.010> the<00:10:03.130> journal<00:10:03.430> Threshold,<00:10:04.000> and<00:10:04.270> it's<00:10:04.840> available<00:10:05.110> for<00:10:05.380> free<00:10:05.710> through

00:10:06.130 --> 00:10:14.710
our<00:10:06.649> website<00:10:07.169> at<00:10:07.688> windbridge.org.<00:10:08.208> So,<00:10:08.727> the<00:10:09.246> study<00:10:09.766> that<00:10:10.285> this<00:10:10.804> data<00:10:11.324> is<00:10:11.843> from<00:10:12.363> was<00:10:12.882> an<00:10:13.401> online<00:10:13.921> survey<00:10:14.440> of

00:10:14.710 --> 00:10:23.020
mediums<00:10:15.058> and<00:10:15.407> non-mediums<00:10:15.755> all<00:10:16.103> over<00:10:16.451> the<00:10:16.800> US.<00:10:17.148> And<00:10:17.496> this<00:10:17.844> particular<00:10:18.193> piece<00:10:18.541> that<00:10:18.889> I'll<00:10:19.237> be<00:10:19.586> talking<00:10:19.934> about<00:10:20.282> is<00:10:20.630> from<00:10:20.979> 127<00:10:21.327> mediums<00:10:21.675> who<00:10:22.023> were<00:10:22.372> over<00:10:22.720> 90

00:10:23.020 --> 00:10:31.360
percent<00:10:23.350> female,<00:10:23.740> over<00:10:24.010> 90<00:10:24.280> percent<00:10:24.330> white,<00:10:25.330> and<00:10:25.360> about<00:10:25.780> 54<00:10:27.000> years<00:10:28.000> old<00:10:28.180> as<00:10:28.540> the<00:10:28.870> average<00:10:29.020> age.<00:10:30.330> One<00:10:31.330> of

00:10:31.360 --> 00:10:37.570
the<00:10:31.570> questions<00:10:31.930> in<00:10:32.050> the<00:10:32.140> survey<00:10:32.290> was,<00:10:32.620> "Can<00:10:32.890> you<00:10:33.010> tell<00:10:33.250> the<00:10:33.400> difference<00:10:33.730> between<00:10:33.880> communication<00:10:34.570> from<00:10:34.870> the<00:10:35.050> deceased<00:10:35.470> and<00:10:35.770> psychic<00:10:36.100> information<00:10:36.280> about<00:10:37.000> the<00:10:37.180> living?"

00:10:37.570 --> 00:10:45.940
And<00:10:37.810> about<00:10:38.620> 97%<00:10:39.310> said,<00:10:39.820> "Yes,<00:10:40.090> I<00:10:40.300> can."<00:10:40.440> Three<00:10:41.440> said,<00:10:41.680> "I<00:10:41.710> don't<00:10:42.040> know,"<00:10:42.250> and<00:10:42.490> one<00:10:42.700> said,<00:10:42.940> "No,<00:10:43.180> I<00:10:43.210> can't."<00:10:43.860> So,<00:10:44.860> then<00:10:45.010> the<00:10:45.100> people<00:10:45.340> who<00:10:45.430> said<00:10:45.610> yes,

00:10:45.940 --> 00:10:54.310
we<00:10:46.480> then<00:10:46.840> asked,<00:10:47.200> "In<00:10:47.380> your<00:10:47.410> own<00:10:47.650> words,<00:10:47.890> describe<00:10:48.250> your<00:10:48.640> experiences<00:10:49.210> when<00:10:49.360> receiving<00:10:49.780> communication<00:10:50.530> from<00:10:50.800> the<00:10:50.860> deceased,"<00:10:51.610> and,<00:10:51.700> "In<00:10:52.570> your<00:10:52.720> own<00:10:52.839> words,<00:10:53.050> describe<00:10:53.560> your<00:10:53.740> experiences

00:10:54.310 --> 00:11:02.589
when<00:10:54.490> getting<00:10:54.790> psychic<00:10:55.329> information<00:10:56.110> about<00:10:56.440> the<00:10:56.620> living."<00:10:57.010> And<00:10:57.220> those<00:10:58.120> questions<00:10:58.660> were<00:10:58.750> counterbalanced,<00:10:59.649> and<00:11:00.360> the<00:11:01.470> responses<00:11:02.470> were

00:11:02.589 --> 00:11:11.250
from<00:11:03.137> 14<00:11:03.685> Windbridge<00:11:04.233> mediums<00:11:04.781> and<00:11:05.329> 108<00:11:05.877> self-identified<00:11:06.425> mediums.<00:11:06.974> So,<00:11:07.522> we<00:11:08.070> took<00:11:08.618> those<00:11:09.166> 244<00:11:09.714> text<00:11:10.262> descriptions<00:11:10.810> and

00:11:11.250 --> 00:11:20.019
quantitatively<00:11:12.250> and<00:11:12.610> qualitatively<00:11:13.140> analyzed<00:11:14.140> them.<00:11:14.730> So,<00:11:15.730> for<00:11:16.180> quantitative<00:11:16.720> analysis,<00:11:17.610> excuse<00:11:18.610> me,<00:11:18.760> we<00:11:19.149> use<00:11:19.300> Linguistic

00:11:20.019 --> 00:11:29.320
Inquiry<00:11:20.732> and<00:11:21.444> Word<00:11:22.157> Count,<00:11:22.869> LIWC<00:11:23.582> text<00:11:24.295> analysis<00:11:25.007> software.<00:11:25.720> And<00:11:26.432> LIWC<00:11:27.145> counts<00:11:27.857> the<00:11:28.570> content

00:11:29.320 --> 00:11:38.110
of<00:11:29.500> the<00:11:30.070> quantity<00:11:30.579> of<00:11:30.790> words<00:11:31.060> and<00:11:31.329> different<00:11:31.450> psychologically<00:11:32.320> meaningful<00:11:32.980> categories.<00:11:33.399> And<00:11:34.180> then<00:11:35.019> for<00:11:35.290> qualitative,<00:11:35.860> we<00:11:36.100> use<00:11:36.279> content<00:11:37.269> analysis,<00:11:37.570> which

00:11:38.110 --> 00:11:46.630
is<00:11:38.140> a<00:11:38.290> research<00:11:38.680> method<00:11:39.100> for<00:11:39.279> the<00:11:39.399> subjective<00:11:39.970> interpretation<00:11:40.839> of<00:11:41.050> the<00:11:41.740> content<00:11:42.279> of<00:11:42.430> text<00:11:42.700> through<00:11:43.510> the<00:11:44.010> systematic<00:11:45.010> classification<00:11:45.160> and<00:11:46.000> coding<00:11:46.480> and

00:11:46.630 --> 00:11:55.420
identifying<00:11:47.230> common<00:11:47.740> themes.<00:11:48.810> So,<00:11:49.810> what<00:11:50.019> we<00:11:50.140> found<00:11:50.410> was<00:11:50.950> the<00:11:51.310> the<00:11:51.640> LIWC<00:11:51.850> findings,<00:11:52.300> the<00:11:52.420> quantitative<00:11:53.079> findings,<00:11:53.370> we<00:11:54.370> found<00:11:54.640> that

00:11:55.420 --> 00:12:04.990
the<00:11:55.750> descriptions<00:11:56.320> of<00:11:56.470> mediumistic<00:11:56.980> experiences<00:11:57.730> contained<00:11:58.209> a<00:11:58.510> larger<00:11:59.290> proportion<00:12:00.010> of<00:12:00.130> words<00:12:00.459> describing<00:12:01.120> social<00:12:01.810> and<00:12:02.050> perceptual<00:12:02.620> processes<00:12:03.990> than

00:12:04.990 --> 00:12:13.959
did<00:12:05.350> descriptions<00:12:06.339> of<00:12:06.459> psychic<00:12:06.880> experiences.<00:12:07.660> So,<00:12:07.930> this<00:12:08.140> implies<00:12:08.470> that<00:12:09.240> the<00:12:10.240> that<00:12:10.600> mediumship<00:12:11.170> involves<00:12:11.709> a<00:12:11.829> more<00:12:12.100> more<00:12:12.610> interpersonal<00:12:13.360> connections

00:12:13.959 --> 00:12:22.269
as<00:12:14.260> well<00:12:14.339> as<00:12:15.390> seems<00:12:16.390> to<00:12:16.449> be<00:12:16.600> a<00:12:16.630> more<00:12:16.810> complex<00:12:17.290> or<00:12:17.500> vivid<00:12:17.890> experience<00:12:18.519> than<00:12:18.850> the<00:12:19.329> reporting<00:12:19.810> of<00:12:19.899> psychic<00:12:20.290> information<00:12:20.470> about<00:12:21.430> the<00:12:21.579> living.<00:12:21.850> We<00:12:22.120> also

00:12:22.269 --> 00:12:30.880
found<00:12:22.630> that<00:12:24.300> the<00:12:25.300> descriptions<00:12:25.899> of<00:12:26.140> psychic<00:12:26.709> experiences<00:12:27.490> from<00:12:27.760> these<00:12:27.910> 122<00:12:28.660> participants<00:12:30.070> contained<00:12:30.699> a

00:12:30.880 --> 00:12:39.250
larger<00:12:31.390> proportion<00:12:31.570> of<00:12:31.990> words<00:12:33.029> that<00:12:34.029> describe<00:12:34.510> the<00:12:34.660> category<00:12:35.140> "insight,"<00:12:35.740> which<00:12:36.100> is<00:12:36.250> a<00:12:36.279> cognitive<00:12:36.970> process.<00:12:37.600> So,<00:12:38.350> that<00:12:38.829> implies<00:12:39.190> that

00:12:39.250 --> 00:12:48.070
the<00:12:39.739> psychic<00:12:40.228> experience<00:12:40.716> may<00:12:41.205> be<00:12:41.694> more<00:12:42.183> analytical<00:12:42.672> or<00:12:43.161> metaphorically<00:12:43.649> left-brained,<00:12:44.138> and<00:12:44.627> the<00:12:45.116> mediumship<00:12:45.605> process<00:12:46.094> might<00:12:46.582> be<00:12:47.071> more<00:12:47.560> intuitive

00:12:48.070 --> 00:12:56.470
or<00:12:48.987> metaphorically<00:12:49.903> right-brained.<00:12:50.820> For<00:12:51.737> the<00:12:52.653> qualitative<00:12:53.570> content<00:12:54.487> analysis,<00:12:55.403> we<00:12:56.320> found

00:12:56.470 --> 00:13:05.260
many<00:12:56.829> themes.<00:12:57.490> I<00:12:57.880> just<00:12:58.600> want<00:12:58.779> to<00:12:58.839> go<00:12:58.959> through<00:12:59.199> one<00:12:59.709> specific<00:13:00.160> one<00:13:00.279> today<00:13:00.579> in<00:13:00.940> the<00:13:01.449> mediumistic<00:13:01.899> experience,<00:13:03.250> that<00:13:03.400> the<00:13:03.820> experience<00:13:04.180> was<00:13:04.630> discernment

00:13:05.260 --> 00:13:13.630
as<00:13:05.380> the<00:13:05.590> communication<00:13:06.250> was<00:13:06.370> triangulated.<00:13:07.330> And<00:13:07.660> this<00:13:08.560> makes<00:13:08.800> sense.<00:13:09.330> The<00:13:10.330> way<00:13:10.540> we<00:13:10.720> define<00:13:11.110> mediumship<00:13:11.650> is<00:13:11.830> that<00:13:12.040> they<00:13:12.250> experience<00:13:12.730> communication<00:13:13.450> from

00:13:13.630 --> 00:13:22.350
the<00:13:13.690> deceased<00:13:14.230> and<00:13:14.500> then<00:13:14.590> report<00:13:14.980> the<00:13:15.130> messages<00:13:15.580> to<00:13:15.760> the<00:13:15.880> sitter.<00:13:16.120> But<00:13:16.600> in<00:13:16.900> that<00:13:17.260> hearing<00:13:17.800> of<00:13:18.100> the<00:13:18.220> messages<00:13:18.730> from<00:13:19.450> the<00:13:19.690> medium,<00:13:20.050> the<00:13:20.380> sitter<00:13:20.620> now<00:13:20.920> experiences<00:13:21.850> an

00:13:22.350 --> 00:13:30.730
after-death<00:13:23.031> communication<00:13:23.712> with<00:13:24.393> their<00:13:25.073> deceased<00:13:25.754> loved<00:13:26.435> one.<00:13:27.116> For<00:13:27.797> the<00:13:28.478> psychic<00:13:29.158> experiences,<00:13:29.839> the<00:13:30.520> piece

00:13:30.730 --> 00:13:39.970
that<00:13:30.880> I<00:13:30.970> wanted<00:13:31.270> to<00:13:31.360> talk<00:13:31.570> about<00:13:31.600> was<00:13:32.230> this,<00:13:33.210> which<00:13:34.210> was<00:13:34.510> that<00:13:34.720> they<00:13:35.410> reported<00:13:35.890> the<00:13:36.010> information<00:13:36.640> flowing<00:13:37.090> from<00:13:37.330> various<00:13:37.810> sources,<00:13:38.050> including<00:13:38.380> self,<00:13:39.250> angels,

00:13:39.970 --> 00:13:49.060
God,<00:13:40.450> and<00:13:40.980> nonspecific<00:13:42.330> deceased<00:13:43.330> people<00:13:43.870> during<00:13:44.650> a<00:13:44.860> psychic<00:13:45.340> reading<00:13:45.580> for<00:13:46.570> the<00:13:46.810> living.<00:13:47.580> So,<00:13:48.580> having

00:13:49.060 --> 00:13:58.300
done<00:13:49.450> this<00:13:49.690> research<00:13:50.110> full-time<00:13:50.650> for<00:13:50.890> 15<00:13:51.340> years,<00:13:51.820> my<00:13:52.270> natural<00:13:52.480> response<00:13:53.200> was,<00:13:53.500> "Wait,<00:13:54.370> what?<00:13:54.750> Dead<00:13:55.750> people<00:13:56.140> in<00:13:56.410> a<00:13:56.560> psychic<00:13:57.010> reading?"<00:13:57.300> So

00:13:58.300 --> 00:14:06.750
we<00:13:58.570> knew<00:13:58.840> that<00:13:59.260> dead<00:13:59.500> people<00:13:59.800> reported<00:14:00.490> information<00:14:01.120> about<00:14:01.870> the<00:14:02.080> living<00:14:02.760> during<00:14:03.760> mediumship<00:14:04.660> readings.<00:14:05.110> It's<00:14:05.410> one<00:14:05.680> of<00:14:05.830> the<00:14:05.920> categories<00:14:06.580> that

00:14:06.750 --> 00:14:15.910
that<00:14:07.327> we<00:14:07.903> talked<00:14:08.480> about,<00:14:09.057> that<00:14:09.633> the<00:14:10.210> deceased<00:14:10.787> person<00:14:11.363> will<00:14:11.940> often<00:14:12.517> include<00:14:13.093> information<00:14:13.670> identifying<00:14:14.247> themselves,<00:14:14.823> information<00:14:15.400> about

00:14:15.910 --> 00:14:22.720
the<00:14:16.060> sitter's<00:14:16.330> life<00:14:16.480> since<00:14:16.750> they've<00:14:16.930> died.<00:14:17.140> So,<00:14:17.410> "I'm<00:14:17.589> it's<00:14:17.860> me,<00:14:18.070> and<00:14:18.400> I'm<00:14:18.520> still<00:14:18.820> here.<00:14:18.940> I<00:14:19.000> still<00:14:19.360> saw<00:14:19.630> you<00:14:19.690> get<00:14:20.050> married.<00:14:20.290> I<00:14:20.470> still<00:14:20.740> saw<00:14:20.980> you<00:14:21.550> paint<00:14:21.790> the<00:14:21.910> kitchen,"<00:14:22.060> those<00:14:22.450> sort

00:14:22.720 --> 00:14:31.120
of<00:14:22.780> things.<00:14:23.160> So,<00:14:24.160> we<00:14:24.280> knew<00:14:24.430> that<00:14:24.670> part.<00:14:24.940> But<00:14:25.150> dead<00:14:26.080> people<00:14:26.470> giving<00:14:26.830> information<00:14:27.280> about<00:14:27.610> the<00:14:27.730> living<00:14:28.000> during<00:14:28.150> psychic<00:14:28.780> readings,<00:14:29.260> like,<00:14:29.500> that<00:14:29.830> was<00:14:30.130> new.<00:14:30.400> And<00:14:30.700> so<00:14:31.089> I

00:14:31.120 --> 00:14:38.500
didn't<00:14:31.510> know,<00:14:31.570> I<00:14:31.690> didn't,<00:14:32.110> and<00:14:32.260> so<00:14:32.410> I<00:14:32.440> didn't<00:14:32.710> want<00:14:32.740> to<00:14:32.980> make<00:14:33.100> any<00:14:33.160> guesses<00:14:33.580> or<00:14:33.850> claims.<00:14:34.120> So,<00:14:34.450> I<00:14:34.690> asked<00:14:35.560> the<00:14:35.680> mediums<00:14:36.070> on<00:14:36.250> our<00:14:36.430> team.<00:14:36.640> So,<00:14:36.880> I<00:14:36.910> sent<00:14:37.240> them<00:14:37.420> the<00:14:37.570> Threshold<00:14:38.050> article

00:14:38.500 --> 00:14:45.010
and<00:14:38.800> I<00:14:39.400> asked<00:14:39.790> them<00:14:39.850> in<00:14:40.030> an<00:14:40.150> email,<00:14:40.300> "Have<00:14:40.630> you<00:14:40.750> ever<00:14:40.930> experienced<00:14:41.470> information<00:14:41.980> about<00:14:42.190> the<00:14:42.339> living<00:14:42.640> person<00:14:43.000> getting<00:14:43.180> a<00:14:43.330> psychic<00:14:43.660> reading<00:14:43.810> as<00:14:44.110> coming<00:14:44.470> from<00:14:44.500> deceased

00:14:45.010 --> 00:14:52.450
people?"<00:14:45.220> And<00:14:45.700> some<00:14:46.480> said,<00:14:46.720> "Yes,<00:14:46.750> unless<00:14:47.260> I'm<00:14:47.530> doing<00:14:47.680> a<00:14:47.860> medium<00:14:48.220> reading,<00:14:48.490> I<00:14:48.580> assume<00:14:48.850> all<00:14:49.030> information<00:14:49.660> comes<00:14:49.870> from<00:14:49.990> my<00:14:50.170> guides,<00:14:50.470> and<00:14:50.890> since<00:14:51.310> I<00:14:51.430> believe<00:14:51.610> guides<00:14:51.970> are<00:14:52.180> people

00:14:52.450 --> 00:14:59.380
who've<00:14:52.570> lived<00:14:52.780> on<00:14:53.020> earth,<00:14:53.050> they're<00:14:53.560> deceased<00:14:53.920> people."<00:14:54.330> Another<00:14:55.330> said,<00:14:55.570> "Accessing<00:14:56.110> higher<00:14:56.200> streams<00:14:56.589> of<00:14:56.740> consciousness<00:14:56.980> brings<00:14:57.610> information<00:14:57.910> not<00:14:58.480> just<00:14:58.720> from<00:14:58.839> the<00:14:59.020> person's

00:14:59.380 --> 00:15:06.790
own<00:14:59.530> energy<00:14:59.950> but<00:14:59.980> other<00:15:00.370> energies<00:15:00.880> as<00:15:01.060> well."<00:15:01.240> But<00:15:02.020> some<00:15:02.230> said,<00:15:02.470> "No,<00:15:02.710> the<00:15:03.070> way<00:15:03.190> I<00:15:03.220> work<00:15:03.460> with<00:15:03.670> spirit<00:15:04.030> is<00:15:04.120> to<00:15:04.240> create<00:15:04.450> a<00:15:04.480> boundary<00:15:04.930> between<00:15:05.020> mediumistic<00:15:05.800> and<00:15:06.130> psychic,<00:15:06.520> and

00:15:06.790 --> 00:15:15.370
if<00:15:07.510> I<00:15:07.600> didn't<00:15:07.930> control<00:15:08.260> it,<00:15:08.410> then<00:15:08.589> yeah,<00:15:08.830> but<00:15:09.160> I<00:15:09.190> know<00:15:09.370> how<00:15:09.760> to<00:15:09.820> control<00:15:10.089> it,<00:15:10.180> so<00:15:10.450> that<00:15:10.600> doesn't<00:15:10.780> happen<00:15:11.110> anymore."<00:15:12.720> This<00:15:13.720> I<00:15:13.930> wanted<00:15:14.260> to<00:15:14.320> bring<00:15:14.410> up:<00:15:14.530> mediums<00:15:15.040> often

00:15:15.370 --> 00:15:23.530
use<00:15:15.490> words<00:15:15.670> like<00:15:15.760> "energy,"<00:15:16.240> "vibration,"<00:15:16.870> or<00:15:16.990> "level,"<00:15:17.380> and<00:15:17.620> these<00:15:18.130> are<00:15:18.280> words<00:15:18.490> that<00:15:18.640> come<00:15:19.120> from<00:15:19.270> fields<00:15:19.630> like<00:15:19.750> physics,<00:15:19.780> but<00:15:20.470> there<00:15:21.040> aren't<00:15:21.460> words<00:15:21.640> in<00:15:22.120> English<00:15:22.750> that<00:15:23.050> describe

00:15:23.530 --> 00:15:31.360
exactly<00:15:23.800> what<00:15:24.100> a<00:15:24.250> medium<00:15:24.670> is<00:15:24.880> experiencing,<00:15:25.570> so<00:15:25.810> they<00:15:25.990> sort<00:15:26.230> of<00:15:26.320> have<00:15:26.500> to<00:15:26.680> steal<00:15:26.920> these<00:15:27.190> words<00:15:27.400> from<00:15:27.550> other<00:15:27.760> fields.<00:15:28.740> One<00:15:29.740> medium<00:15:30.040> said,<00:15:30.220> "If<00:15:30.340> some<00:15:30.520> mediums<00:15:30.790> are<00:15:30.940> reporting

00:15:31.360 --> 00:15:39.040
that<00:15:31.390> they're<00:15:31.750> receiving<00:15:32.110> information<00:15:32.380> from<00:15:32.770> random<00:15:33.250> spirits,<00:15:33.640> maybe<00:15:33.850> they're<00:15:34.090> not<00:15:34.300> fully<00:15:34.630> developed."<00:15:35.230> Well,<00:15:36.130> thank<00:15:36.490> you,<00:15:36.670> research<00:15:37.270> medium,<00:15:37.840> that's<00:15:38.200> a<00:15:38.320> hypothesis<00:15:38.920> I

00:15:39.040 --> 00:15:46.690
can<00:15:39.220> test.<00:15:39.460> And<00:15:39.850> so,<00:15:40.480> in<00:15:40.810> our<00:15:41.020> survey,<00:15:41.470> we<00:15:41.620> had<00:15:41.800> also<00:15:42.010> asked<00:15:42.520> the<00:15:42.640> people,<00:15:42.850> "How<00:15:43.150> long<00:15:43.360> have<00:15:43.540> you<00:15:43.660> been<00:15:43.690> performing<00:15:44.260> mediumship<00:15:44.710> readings<00:15:45.010> for<00:15:45.160> other<00:15:45.190> people?"<00:15:45.730> And<00:15:46.000> all<00:15:46.540> the

00:15:46.690 --> 00:15:55.630
Windbridge<00:15:47.064> mediums<00:15:47.439> [had]<00:15:47.813> over<00:15:48.187> ten<00:15:48.562> years,<00:15:48.936> but<00:15:49.310> only<00:15:49.685> 30%<00:15:50.059> of<00:15:50.433> the<00:15:50.808> self-identified<00:15:51.182> mediums.<00:15:51.557> So,<00:15:51.931> maybe<00:15:52.305> that's<00:15:52.680> why<00:15:53.054> I<00:15:53.428> hadn't<00:15:53.803> heard<00:15:54.177> this<00:15:54.551> before,<00:15:54.926> was<00:15:55.300> that

00:15:55.630 --> 00:16:03.670
the<00:15:55.926> mediums<00:15:56.223> I<00:15:56.519> work<00:15:56.816> with<00:15:57.112> all<00:15:57.408> have<00:15:57.705> a<00:15:58.001> lot<00:15:58.298> of<00:15:58.594> experience,<00:15:58.890> and<00:15:59.187> they<00:15:59.483> may<00:15:59.780> have<00:16:00.076> learned<00:16:00.372> how<00:16:00.669> to<00:16:00.965> block<00:16:01.262> it.<00:16:01.558> So,<00:16:01.854> this<00:16:02.151> indicates<00:16:02.447> a<00:16:02.744> blocking<00:16:03.040> communication

00:16:03.670 --> 00:16:13.540
from<00:16:03.820> the<00:16:03.970> deceased<00:16:04.300> during<00:16:04.570> a<00:16:04.660> psychic<00:16:04.990> reading<00:16:05.140> maybe<00:16:05.440> a<00:16:05.590> learned<00:16:05.890> skill.<00:16:06.280> And<00:16:06.580> this<00:16:06.970> also<00:16:07.180> may<00:16:07.540> be<00:16:07.570> why<00:16:07.960> some<00:16:08.650> people<00:16:08.980> in<00:16:09.490> this<00:16:09.850> group<00:16:10.210> are<00:16:10.450> saying<00:16:10.660> no,<00:16:10.900> and<00:16:11.640> and<00:16:12.640> I

00:16:13.540 --> 00:16:21.820
don't<00:16:14.020> know<00:16:14.260> that<00:16:14.650> how<00:16:14.890> to<00:16:14.950> tell<00:16:15.280> the<00:16:15.400> difference<00:16:15.430> between<00:16:15.850> those.<00:16:16.030> Maybe<00:16:16.300> it's<00:16:16.510> something<00:16:16.720> that<00:16:16.990> you<00:16:17.080> learn<00:16:17.110> along<00:16:17.710> the<00:16:17.740> way.<00:16:19.020> So,<00:16:20.020> this<00:16:20.380> finding<00:16:20.920> of<00:16:21.040> discarnates<00:16:21.700> as

00:16:21.820 --> 00:16:28.990
a<00:16:21.850> source<00:16:22.270> of<00:16:22.480> psychic<00:16:22.870> information<00:16:23.020> calls<00:16:23.620> into<00:16:23.890> question<00:16:23.940> theoretical<00:16:24.940> frameworks<00:16:25.420> that<00:16:25.630> posit<00:16:26.020> separating<00:16:26.500> mediums'<00:16:27.250> experiences<00:16:27.850> into<00:16:28.090> categories<00:16:28.630> that<00:16:28.780> do

00:16:28.990 --> 00:16:38.500
and<00:16:29.170> do<00:16:29.290> not<00:16:29.440> involve<00:16:29.740> communication<00:16:30.520> with<00:16:30.640> the<00:16:30.760> deceased,<00:16:31.150> and<00:16:32.340> the<00:16:33.340> continued<00:16:33.790> use<00:16:33.940> of<00:16:34.090> terminology<00:16:34.300> reflecting<00:16:35.110> such<00:16:35.320> a<00:16:35.350> separation.<00:16:36.570> So,<00:16:37.570> again,

00:16:38.500 --> 00:16:46.990
we<00:16:38.907> know<00:16:39.313> the<00:16:39.720> way<00:16:40.126> that<00:16:40.533> we've<00:16:40.939> defined<00:16:41.346> is<00:16:41.752> that<00:16:42.159> the<00:16:42.565> deceased<00:16:42.972> provide<00:16:43.378> messages<00:16:43.785> for<00:16:44.191> sitters<00:16:44.598> during<00:16:45.004> mediumship<00:16:45.411> readings<00:16:45.817> and<00:16:46.224> information<00:16:46.630> about

00:16:46.990 --> 00:16:56.020
those<00:16:47.260> sitters'<00:16:47.620> lives<00:16:47.890> during<00:16:48.190> mediumship<00:16:48.790> readings.<00:16:49.210> And<00:16:49.480> this<00:16:49.750> new<00:16:50.080> data<00:16:50.520> demonstrates<00:16:51.520> there<00:16:51.790> that<00:16:52.450> the<00:16:52.600> deceased<00:16:52.960> can<00:16:53.250> provide<00:16:54.250> information<00:16:54.580> about<00:16:54.880> psychic<00:16:55.660> reading

00:16:56.020 --> 00:17:04.570
recipients<00:16:56.860> during<00:16:57.310> psychic<00:16:57.730> readings,<00:16:58.980> but<00:16:59.980> also<00:17:00.250> the<00:17:00.670> deceased<00:17:01.060> during<00:17:01.360> mediumship<00:17:01.780> readings<00:17:02.110> can<00:17:02.700> provide<00:17:03.700> information<00:17:03.970> about<00:17:04.240> other.

00:17:04.570 --> 00:17:12.940
deceased<00:17:05.110> people<00:17:05.440> so<00:17:05.830> someone<00:17:06.190> might<00:17:06.339> say<00:17:06.520> like<00:17:06.670> I'm<00:17:07.060> with<00:17:07.209> your<00:17:07.390> grandmother<00:17:07.810> I<00:17:08.110> have<00:17:08.350> the<00:17:08.530> white<00:17:08.709> dog<00:17:08.980> with<00:17:09.250> me<00:17:09.930> so<00:17:10.930> they<00:17:11.740> provide<00:17:12.190> information<00:17:12.370> of<00:17:12.730> other

00:17:12.940 --> 00:17:21.260
deceased<00:17:13.420> people<00:17:13.630> and<00:17:14.020> even<00:17:14.800> about<00:17:15.100> the<00:17:15.400> future<00:17:16.030> so<00:17:16.690> one<00:17:16.839> of<00:17:16.870> the<00:17:17.050> mediums<00:17:17.320> on<00:17:17.440> our<00:17:17.560> team<00:17:17.800> sent<00:17:18.190> this<00:17:18.740> to<00:17:19.370> me<00:17:19.490> not<00:17:19.730> too<00:17:19.939> long<00:17:20.089> ago<00:17:20.150> as<00:17:21.110> you

00:17:21.260 --> 00:17:29.480
said<00:17:21.410> I<00:17:21.439> did<00:17:21.679> a<00:17:21.709> gallery<00:17:22.189> reading<00:17:22.579> meaning<00:17:22.730> a<00:17:22.819> group<00:17:23.059> reading<00:17:23.329> in<00:17:23.689> a<00:17:23.929> situation<00:17:24.559> like<00:17:24.679> this<00:17:24.860> January<00:17:25.850> 27th<00:17:26.569> and<00:17:26.750> the<00:17:26.870> sitter's<00:17:27.199> mom<00:17:27.470> so<00:17:28.040> the<00:17:28.670> medium<00:17:29.000> was<00:17:29.120> reading<00:17:29.390> a

00:17:29.480 --> 00:17:37.970
female<00:17:30.140> sitter<00:17:30.440> and<00:17:30.710> the<00:17:30.890> sit<00:17:31.130> and<00:17:31.309> the<00:17:31.429> sitters<00:17:31.760> mom<00:17:32.059> was<00:17:32.300> talking<00:17:32.540> her<00:17:32.870> her<00:17:33.679> deceased<00:17:34.010> mom<00:17:34.300> and<00:17:35.300> the<00:17:35.540> the<00:17:35.840> sitters<00:17:36.110> mom<00:17:36.320> said<00:17:36.559> that<00:17:36.590> her<00:17:36.860> grandson<00:17:37.190> the<00:17:37.429> sitter<00:17:37.640> son

00:17:37.970 --> 00:17:46.520
was<00:17:38.360> a<00:17:38.390> football<00:17:38.720> fan<00:17:39.170> told<00:17:39.920> me<00:17:40.070> he<00:17:40.220> liked<00:17:40.429> the<00:17:40.550> Eagles<00:17:40.940> and<00:17:41.210> said<00:17:41.480> he'd<00:17:41.630> be<00:17:41.780> very<00:17:42.020> happy<00:17:42.500> very<00:17:42.710> soon<00:17:43.130> so<00:17:43.640> basically<00:17:44.270> announced<00:17:44.660> all<00:17:44.809> 600<00:17:45.410> attendees<00:17:45.620> that<00:17:45.860> the<00:17:46.220> Eagles

00:17:46.520 --> 00:17:54.620
were<00:17:46.968> going<00:17:47.417> to<00:17:47.865> the<00:17:48.313> Super<00:17:48.762> Bowl<00:17:49.210> so<00:17:49.658> don't<00:17:50.107> box<00:17:50.555> in<00:17:51.003> what<00:17:51.452> the<00:17:51.900> deceased<00:17:52.348> can<00:17:52.797> do<00:17:53.245> they're<00:17:53.693> capable<00:17:54.142> of<00:17:54.590> a

00:17:54.620 --> 00:18:03.410
lot<00:17:55.121> they<00:17:55.621> lead<00:17:56.122> rich<00:17:56.623> lives<00:17:57.123> their<00:17:57.624> deaths<00:17:58.124> or<00:17:58.625> afterlives<00:17:59.126> I<00:17:59.626> guess<00:18:00.127> so<00:18:00.628> we<00:18:01.128> can't<00:18:01.629> disprove<00:18:02.129> that<00:18:02.630> mediums

00:18:03.410 --> 00:18:11.540
are<00:18:03.700> communicating<00:18:04.700> with<00:18:04.820> the<00:18:04.910> deceased<00:18:05.210> and<00:18:05.450> we<00:18:05.660> can't<00:18:05.960> disprove<00:18:06.260> that<00:18:06.470> communication<00:18:07.280> with<00:18:07.400> the<00:18:07.490> deceased<00:18:07.820> is<00:18:08.030> part<00:18:08.270> of<00:18:08.390> every<00:18:08.750> type<00:18:08.960> of<00:18:08.990> psi<00:18:09.290> experience<00:18:10.480> so<00:18:11.480> it

00:18:11.540 --> 00:18:19.910
would<00:18:11.630> be<00:18:11.750> irresponsible<00:18:12.080> to<00:18:12.530> posit<00:18:13.010> a<00:18:13.070> general<00:18:13.520> survival<00:18:14.120> based<00:18:14.300> theory<00:18:14.630> for<00:18:15.050> all<00:18:15.230> psi<00:18:15.679> phenomena<00:18:16.309> precognition<00:18:17.179> dead<00:18:17.690> people<00:18:18.050> telepathy<00:18:18.440> dead<00:18:18.980> people<00:18:19.370> clairvoyance

00:18:19.910 --> 00:18:27.200
dead<00:18:20.210> people<00:18:20.480> but<00:18:20.929> that<00:18:21.080> would<00:18:21.200> be<00:18:21.290> irresponsible<00:18:21.530> because<00:18:22.250> that's<00:18:22.550> not<00:18:22.880> the<00:18:23.210> reports<00:18:23.780> from<00:18:23.990> the<00:18:24.140> people<00:18:24.410> who<00:18:24.500> have<00:18:24.650> those<00:18:24.920> experiences<00:18:25.850> it<00:18:26.510> would<00:18:26.630> also<00:18:26.750> be<00:18:26.990> irresponsible

00:18:27.200 --> 00:18:35.750
to<00:18:27.596> continue<00:18:27.991> to<00:18:28.387> use<00:18:28.783> psi<00:18:29.179> like<00:18:29.574> explanations<00:18:29.970> for<00:18:30.366> mediumistic<00:18:30.761> experiences<00:18:31.157> when<00:18:31.553> we<00:18:31.949> have<00:18:32.344> this<00:18:32.740> data<00:18:33.136> from<00:18:33.531> 122<00:18:33.927> people<00:18:34.323> saying<00:18:34.719> no<00:18:35.114> they're<00:18:35.510> different

00:18:35.750 --> 00:18:43.640
a<00:18:36.170> clear<00:18:37.040> line<00:18:37.280> can't<00:18:37.580> be<00:18:37.700> drawn<00:18:37.940> between<00:18:38.120> purely<00:18:38.600> psi<00:18:38.840> with<00:18:39.080> the<00:18:39.200> living<00:18:39.530> and<00:18:39.650> purely<00:18:39.920> communication<00:18:40.610> with<00:18:40.730> the<00:18:40.820> deceased<00:18:41.120> experiences<00:18:41.960> using<00:18:42.860> terminology<00:18:43.610> that

00:18:43.640 --> 00:18:52.130
implies<00:18:44.059> we<00:18:44.360> actually<00:18:44.720> know<00:18:44.840> what's<00:18:44.990> going<00:18:45.230> on<00:18:45.380> or<00:18:45.559> how<00:18:45.679> it<00:18:45.800> works<00:18:45.980> is<00:18:46.250> dangerous<00:18:46.790> I<00:18:47.350> was<00:18:48.350> going<00:18:48.470> to<00:18:48.530> do<00:18:48.800> a<00:18:48.830> little<00:18:49.040> survey<00:18:49.460> here<00:18:49.490> but<00:18:49.910> move<00:18:50.330> on<00:18:50.480> language<00:18:51.290> should<00:18:51.470> be<00:18:51.590> respectful

00:18:52.130 --> 00:19:01.250
and<00:18:52.593> reflect<00:18:53.057> the<00:18:53.520> preferences<00:18:53.983> of<00:18:54.447> the<00:18:54.910> experiencers<00:18:55.373> so<00:18:55.837> all<00:18:56.300> the<00:18:56.763> people<00:18:57.227> in<00:18:57.690> this<00:18:58.153> study<00:18:58.617> self-identified<00:18:59.080> as<00:18:59.543> mediums<00:19:00.007> they<00:19:00.470> identified

00:19:01.250 --> 00:19:09.610
with<00:19:01.400> the<00:19:01.520> term<00:19:01.700> medium<00:19:02.120> and<00:19:02.330> they<00:19:02.630> may<00:19:02.870> use<00:19:03.110> trance<00:19:03.590> medium<00:19:04.040> and<00:19:04.160> they<00:19:04.220> may<00:19:04.429> use<00:19:04.640> clairvoyant<00:19:05.360> medium<00:19:06.220> but<00:19:07.220> I<00:19:07.429> can't<00:19:07.940> use<00:19:08.179> that<00:19:08.330> as<00:19:08.390> a<00:19:08.540> researcher<00:19:08.900> because<00:19:09.110> it's<00:19:09.380> not

00:19:09.610 --> 00:19:18.350
it's<00:19:10.610> not<00:19:10.790> broadly<00:19:11.150> generalizable<00:19:12.080> to<00:19:12.140> all<00:19:12.380> people<00:19:12.860> so<00:19:13.670> and<00:19:13.910> as<00:19:14.030> a<00:19:14.059> society<00:19:14.360> we're<00:19:14.809> already<00:19:15.080> used<00:19:15.440> to<00:19:15.590> doing<00:19:15.740> this<00:19:15.920> we<00:19:16.100> already<00:19:16.370> know<00:19:16.520> how<00:19:16.700> to<00:19:16.760> do<00:19:17.000> this<00:19:17.150> how<00:19:17.330> to<00:19:17.360> how<00:19:18.290> to

00:19:18.350 --> 00:19:26.539
respect<00:19:18.830> people's<00:19:19.340> preferences<00:19:19.940> because<00:19:20.120> of<00:19:20.770> people's<00:19:22.210> gender<00:19:23.210> identity<00:19:23.720> and<00:19:23.780> sexual<00:19:24.110> preference<00:19:24.530> we<00:19:24.620> already<00:19:24.890> know<00:19:25.010> how<00:19:25.130> to<00:19:25.190> do<00:19:25.340> this<00:19:25.669> so<00:19:26.359> going

00:19:26.539 --> 00:19:54.980
forward<00:19:26.819> will<00:19:27.099> be<00:19:27.379> necessary<00:19:27.659> for<00:19:27.939> language<00:19:28.219> to<00:19:28.499> reflect<00:19:28.779> empirical<00:19:29.059> data<00:19:29.339> and<00:19:29.619> the<00:19:29.899> experiences<00:19:30.179> of<00:19:30.459> modern<00:19:30.739> mediums

00:19:54.980 --> 00:20:22.479
[Music]

00:20:22.479 --> 00:20:31.729
and<00:20:23.479> about<00:20:23.749> what<00:20:24.019> what<00:20:24.349> what<00:20:24.499> decade<00:20:24.950> were<00:20:25.129> these<00:20:25.339> things<00:20:25.549> happening<00:20:25.969> at<00:20:26.719> what<00:20:27.409> what<00:20:27.649> decade<00:20:28.070> were<00:20:28.339> these<00:20:28.489> things<00:20:28.820> happening<00:20:30.729> yeah

00:20:31.729 --> 00:20:39.469
so<00:20:32.059> that<00:20:32.299> I'm<00:20:32.450> saying<00:20:32.749> about<00:20:32.959> modern<00:20:33.769> mental<00:20:34.249> American<00:20:34.849> mediums<00:20:35.299> that's<00:20:35.899> not<00:20:36.229> their<00:20:36.499> experience<00:20:36.979> so<00:20:37.099> there's<00:20:37.279> no<00:20:37.459> evidence<00:20:37.609> that<00:20:37.969> that's<00:20:38.299> what's<00:20:38.570> happening<00:20:38.959> the<00:20:39.320> way

00:20:39.469 --> 00:20:45.969
mediumship<00:20:39.979> works<00:20:40.279> now

00:20:45.969 --> 00:21:17.070
that<00:20:46.969> is<00:20:47.119> a<00:20:47.149> wonderful<00:20:47.539> argument<00:20:49.890> [Music]

00:21:17.070 --> 00:21:25.640
the<00:21:17.490> assumptions<00:21:18.060> about<00:21:18.540> the<00:21:18.780> nature<00:21:18.960> and<00:21:19.110> character<00:21:19.650> of<00:21:19.680> the<00:21:19.920> afterlife<00:21:20.360> other<00:21:21.360> people<00:21:21.720> would<00:21:21.840> want<00:21:21.870> to<00:21:22.110> communicate

00:21:25.640 --> 00:21:48.320
and<00:21:26.640> compare<00:21:27.090> that<00:21:27.120> to<00:21:27.560> some<00:21:28.560> other<00:21:28.830> offices<00:21:29.610> equally<00:21:30.330> involved<00:21:30.570> of<00:21:30.840> various<00:21:31.200> options<00:21:31.670> so

00:21:48.320 --> 00:21:57.710
that<00:21:49.320> seems<00:21:49.620> like<00:21:49.830> the<00:21:49.980> way<00:21:50.100> that<00:21:50.280> a<00:21:50.310> philosopher<00:21:50.970> would<00:21:51.120> attack<00:21:51.360> this<00:21:51.510> problem<00:21:52.190> as<00:21:53.190> it<00:21:53.430> appears

00:21:57.710 --> 00:22:05.700
as<00:21:58.710> an<00:21:58.890> empiricist<00:21:59.310> I'm<00:21:59.850> just<00:22:00.120> going<00:22:00.270> to<00:22:00.330> ask<00:22:00.480> a<00:22:00.780> bunch<00:22:00.960> of<00:22:01.110> people<00:22:01.530> what's<00:22:02.070> happening<00:22:02.640> and<00:22:02.850> that<00:22:02.910> our<00:22:03.720> mission<00:22:04.170> at<00:22:04.290> the<00:22:04.320> Windbridge<00:22:04.740> Research<00:22:05.040> Center<00:22:05.250> is<00:22:05.370> to<00:22:05.520> alleviate

00:22:05.700 --> 00:22:15.660
suffering<00:22:06.270> so<00:22:06.980> I'm<00:22:07.980> currently<00:22:08.520> doing<00:22:08.790> apparently<00:22:09.330> and<00:22:10.200> these<00:22:10.410> people<00:22:10.950> I'm<00:22:11.760> very<00:22:11.960> very<00:22:12.960> important<00:22:14.660> these

00:22:15.660 --> 00:22:24.780
people<00:22:16.200> are<00:22:16.320> having<00:22:16.530> these<00:22:16.770> experiences<00:22:17.150> and<00:22:18.650> it's<00:22:19.650> very<00:22:20.040> clear<00:22:20.670> that<00:22:21.170> the<00:22:22.170> somatic<00:22:22.800> psi<00:22:23.090> that<00:22:24.090> reading

00:22:24.780 --> 00:22:33.870
for<00:22:24.960> psychic<00:22:25.530> getting<00:22:25.770> psi<00:22:25.980> and<00:22:26.130> phrasing<00:22:26.310> feels<00:22:26.670> different<00:22:27.030> than<00:22:27.530> communication<00:22:28.530> from<00:22:28.740> the<00:22:28.950> deceased<00:22:29.370> so<00:22:30.240> in<00:22:30.690> order<00:22:31.200> to<00:22:31.380> respect<00:22:32.280> their<00:22:32.870> experiences

00:22:33.870 --> 00:22:42.720
I<00:22:34.310> have<00:22:35.310> to<00:22:35.520> follow<00:22:35.790> what<00:22:36.240> they're<00:22:36.630> saying<00:22:37.140> not<00:22:37.910> what<00:22:38.910> we<00:22:39.630> can<00:22:39.930> conjecture<00:22:41.150> philosophically<00:22:42.150> about

00:22:42.720 --> 00:22:48.760
whatever<00:22:43.500> you<00:22:44.040> just<00:22:44.070> said

00:22:48.760 --> 00:22:57.090
yeah<00:22:49.760> over<00:22:50.270> dinner<00:22:50.809> I<00:22:50.960> gotcha

00:22:57.090 --> 00:23:06.070
[Music]

00:23:06.070 --> 00:23:14.420
about<00:23:07.070> 75%<00:23:07.730> succeeded<00:23:08.720> and<00:23:08.900> we're<00:23:09.740> quick<00:23:09.980> to<00:23:10.160> point<00:23:10.340> out<00:23:10.520> that<00:23:10.910> a<00:23:11.210> mediumship<00:23:11.600> reading<00:23:11.809> involves<00:23:12.410> at<00:23:12.500> least<00:23:12.680> three<00:23:12.860> people<00:23:13.040> and<00:23:13.460> the<00:23:13.640> medium<00:23:13.940> is<00:23:14.030> only<00:23:14.150> one

00:23:14.420 --> 00:23:22.910
so<00:23:15.140> the<00:23:15.980> sitter<00:23:16.250> may<00:23:16.520> be<00:23:16.580> a<00:23:16.850> bad<00:23:17.390> sitter<00:23:17.809> the<00:23:18.050> deceased<00:23:18.350> person<00:23:18.890> might<00:23:19.100> not<00:23:19.250> have<00:23:20.000> learned<00:23:20.179> how<00:23:20.450> to<00:23:20.480> do<00:23:20.750> it<00:23:20.929> yet<00:23:21.170> so<00:23:21.590> it's<00:23:22.040> the<00:23:22.190> reason<00:23:22.490> we

00:23:22.910 --> 00:23:31.880
this<00:23:23.240> was<00:23:23.450> through<00:23:23.630> a<00:23:23.690> grant<00:23:23.960> of<00:23:24.200> our<00:23:24.710> gathering<00:23:25.280> of<00:23:25.400> our<00:23:25.550> team<00:23:25.820> and<00:23:26.150> we<00:23:26.690> don't<00:23:26.840> do<00:23:27.080> it<00:23:27.200> anymore<00:23:27.410> because<00:23:27.770> we<00:23:28.250> don't<00:23:28.400> find<00:23:28.640> it<00:23:29.350> ethically<00:23:30.350> sound<00:23:30.679> to<00:23:31.520> test

00:23:31.880 --> 00:23:40.400
someone<00:23:32.358> and<00:23:32.836> then<00:23:33.315> say<00:23:33.793> you<00:23:34.271> didn't<00:23:34.749> pass<00:23:35.228> when<00:23:35.706> it<00:23:36.184> might<00:23:36.662> not<00:23:37.141> be<00:23:37.619> their<00:23:38.097> responsibility<00:23:38.575> it<00:23:39.054> could<00:23:39.532> be<00:23:40.010> the

00:23:40.400 --> 00:24:18.460
sitter

00:24:18.460 --> 00:24:27.050
well<00:24:19.460> my<00:24:20.200> the<00:24:21.200> accuracy<00:24:21.740> data<00:24:21.950> that<00:24:22.130> I<00:24:22.160> present<00:24:22.490> is<00:24:22.670> from<00:24:22.970> 20<00:24:23.480> mediums<00:24:23.809> during<00:24:24.020> 58<00:24:24.970> readings<00:24:25.970> under<00:24:26.150> quintuple<00:24:26.840> blind

00:24:27.050 --> 00:24:34.820
conditions<00:24:27.530> their<00:24:27.679> readings<00:24:28.070> are<00:24:28.160> over<00:24:28.429> the<00:24:28.580> phone<00:24:28.840> if<00:24:29.840> I'm<00:24:30.080> maxing<00:24:30.500> out<00:24:30.590> as<00:24:30.770> the<00:24:31.160> proxy<00:24:31.610> sitter<00:24:31.820> I<00:24:31.880> don't<00:24:32.090> have<00:24:32.240> any<00:24:32.360> information<00:24:32.570> all<00:24:33.500> we<00:24:33.890> have<00:24:34.100> is<00:24:34.250> the<00:24:34.429> first<00:24:34.580> name

00:24:34.820 --> 00:24:40.280
of<00:24:35.037> the<00:24:35.254> deceased<00:24:35.472> person<00:24:35.689> I<00:24:35.906> have<00:24:36.123> specific<00:24:36.340> questions<00:24:36.558> what<00:24:36.775> did<00:24:36.992> the<00:24:37.209> person<00:24:37.426> look<00:24:37.644> like<00:24:37.861> how<00:24:38.078> did<00:24:38.295> they<00:24:38.512> die<00:24:38.730> what<00:24:38.947> were<00:24:39.164> their<00:24:39.381> hobbies<00:24:39.598> what<00:24:39.816> messages<00:24:40.033> do<00:24:40.250> they

00:24:40.280 --> 00:24:50.150
have<00:24:40.460> for<00:24:40.640> the<00:24:40.700> sitter<00:24:41.050> and<00:24:42.050> I<00:24:42.620> could<00:24:43.160> say<00:24:43.340> like<00:24:43.520> I<00:24:43.700> defy<00:24:44.330> you<00:24:44.360> to<00:24:44.690> do<00:24:44.990> it<00:24:45.110> but<00:24:45.290> if<00:24:45.440> he<00:24:45.650> did<00:24:45.890> it<00:24:46.040> and<00:24:46.190> he<00:24:46.370> got<00:24:46.550> it<00:24:46.610> that<00:24:46.940> just<00:24:47.240> means<00:24:47.480> he's<00:24:47.750> a<00:24:47.780> medium<00:24:49.150> so

00:24:50.150 --> 00:24:58.610
I<00:24:50.900> the<00:24:51.470> data<00:24:51.679> we've<00:24:51.920> collected<00:24:52.490> the<00:24:52.520> data<00:24:52.790> it<00:24:53.120> demonstrates<00:24:53.750> they're<00:24:53.990> not<00:24:54.200> doing<00:24:54.980> fraud<00:24:55.220> we've<00:24:55.429> done<00:24:55.640> EEG<00:24:56.179> data<00:24:56.390> that<00:24:57.280> demonstrates<00:24:58.280> they're

00:24:58.610 --> 00:25:07.639
not<00:24:58.850> it's<00:24:59.090> not<00:24:59.270> imagining<00:24:59.929> or<00:25:00.200> recollection<00:25:01.039> so<00:25:02.080> yeah<00:25:03.080> I<00:25:03.499> mean<00:25:03.889> if<00:25:04.039> he<00:25:04.190> changes<00:25:04.519> his<00:25:04.580> mind<00:25:04.700> he<00:25:04.970> doesn't<00:25:05.299> get<00:25:05.360> a<00:25:05.419> TV<00:25:05.779> show<00:25:05.990> I<00:25:06.320> can<00:25:07.129> report

00:25:07.639 --> 00:25:15.519
negative<00:25:07.999> data<00:25:08.389> I<00:25:08.480> can<00:25:08.840> keep<00:25:08.990> my<00:25:09.139> job<00:25:09.679> who<00:25:09.860> are<00:25:09.950> you<00:25:10.039> gonna<00:25:10.159> trust<00:25:10.460> oh<00:25:12.519> thank<00:25:13.519> you