Could We Choose Our Own Afterlife? | Jeffrey Mishlove

In this conversation, Jeffrey Mishlove, winner of the Bigelow competition on consciousness, is asked to assume that human consciousness survives bodily death and to explore what such an afterlife might actually look like. He suggests that personal identity can persist, and leans toward describing the afterlife using mathematical hyperspace concepts to account for folkloric notions like astral or etheric bodies.

The discussion turns to whether individuals have genuine choice over what kind of afterlife reality they enter, or whether such choice only applies to experiences within a fixed structure. Mishlove argues that consciousness does have a real choice, drawing an analogy to choosing where to live, and he distinguishes between horizontal choices (location within a realm) and vertical choices tied to spiritual or ethical evolution.

Using near-death experience literature, particularly the 'life review' phenomenon, Mishlove describes how people may judge themselves and, with guidance from teachers or guides, choose what kind of experience—reincarnation, astral existence, or higher planes—would best serve their continued growth. The host pushes back, noting that this pluralistic, choice-based view conflicts with the fixed, judgment-based theology of the Abrahamic religions, including examples from Jewish mysticism (Gilgul) that seem inconsistent with strict religious doctrine.

The episode closes with a respectful but pointed disagreement: the host contends that if an afterlife exists as a fixed reality set by God or ultimate truth, there may be no choice at all, while Mishlove maintains that choice remains central to whatever the true nature of survival turns out to be.

Key takeaways

• Mishlove argues that the evidence suggests personal identity can survive bodily death, not just a dissolving into a universal consciousness.
• He frames the afterlife using mathematical hyperspace concepts to explain subtle bodies like astral or etheric forms.
• Mishlove believes consciousness has real choice after death, comparing it to choosing where to live within a given reality.
• Near-death experience 'life review' accounts suggest self-judgment, guided decision-making, and choices about reincarnation or moving to higher planes.
• Jewish mysticism (Gilgul) permits reincarnation, yet reported past-life accounts sometimes contradict strict religious expectations.
• The host challenges Mishlove by noting that pluralistic, choice-based afterlife models conflict with the fixed, judgment-centered theology of Abrahamic religions.
• The conversation ends without resolution, highlighting genuine philosophical tension between structured and chosen afterlives.

Highlights

• 0:34 — Assuming consciousness survives: what is the afterlife?
• 2:03 — Describing the afterlife through mathematical hyperspace
• 4:43 — Does ultimate reality itself offer a choice?
• 6:34 — Horizontal vs vertical dimensions of the afterlife
• 7:13 — The near-death 'life review' and self-judgment
• 9:39 — Reincarnation in Jewish mysticism and past-life anecdotes
• 11:06 — Contradiction between pluralistic choice and Abrahamic theology

00:00:00 Assuming Consciousness Survives Bodily Death
00:01:22 Personal Identity and Many Afterlife Options
00:02:03 Describing Afterlife Through Mathematical Hyperspace
00:03:46 Clarifying What Kind of Choice Exists
00:04:43 Choosing Within a Given Afterlife Structure
00:06:17 Horizontal Versus Vertical Dimensions
00:07:13 The Near-Death Past Life Review
00:09:08 Guides, Judgment, and Making Choices
00:09:39 Reincarnation in Jewish Mysticism
00:10:17 Anecdotes Versus Religious Theology
00:11:15 Contradictions Among Afterlife Accounts
00:12:01 Final Disagreement on Choice and Fate

WEBVTT

00:00:00.320 --> 00:00:08.520
Jeff,<00:00:01.280> you<00:00:01.560> won<00:00:02.080> the<00:00:02.520> Bigelow<00:00:03.800> competition<00:00:04.640> for<00:00:05.520> consciousness<00:00:06.440> and<00:00:06.920> your<00:00:07.160> paper,<00:00:08.040> Beyond<00:00:08.400> the

00:00:08.520 --> 00:00:17.440
Brain:<00:00:08.920> The<00:00:09.040> Survival<00:00:09.640> of<00:00:09.760> Human<00:00:10.000> Consciousness<00:00:10.680> After<00:00:11.040> Permanent<00:00:11.560> Bodily<00:00:12.040> Death,<00:00:13.360> is<00:00:13.680> a<00:00:14.160> terrific<00:00:14.720> organization<00:00:15.520> of<00:00:15.640> the<00:00:15.760> different<00:00:16.440> levels<00:00:16.920> of

00:00:17.440 --> 00:00:25.920
proof<00:00:17.840> and<00:00:18.040> in<00:00:18.200> your<00:00:18.720> point<00:00:18.960> of<00:00:19.040> view,<00:00:19.320> each<00:00:19.560> one<00:00:19.840> I<00:00:20.680> couldn't<00:00:20.960> challenge<00:00:21.480> and<00:00:21.600> have<00:00:21.880> in<00:00:22.000> other<00:00:22.200> segments,<00:00:23.000> but<00:00:23.120> what<00:00:23.240> I<00:00:23.320> want<00:00:23.520> to<00:00:23.560> do<00:00:23.760> now<00:00:24.360> is<00:00:25.280> assume<00:00:25.760> it's

00:00:25.920 --> 00:00:34.200
right.<00:00:26.720> Assume<00:00:27.400> that<00:00:27.560> human<00:00:27.920> consciousness<00:00:29.080> does<00:00:29.400> survive<00:00:29.960> bodily<00:00:30.400> death,<00:00:31.320> what<00:00:31.720> is<00:00:32.680> an<00:00:32.800> afterlife?

00:00:34.200 --> 00:00:40.840
And<00:00:35.400> you<00:00:35.520> know,<00:00:35.680> I'm<00:00:35.840> sure<00:00:36.200> you<00:00:36.560> as<00:00:36.760> well<00:00:36.960> as<00:00:37.080> anybody<00:00:37.400> else<00:00:37.600> really<00:00:37.880> don't<00:00:38.240> know,<00:00:38.960> but<00:00:39.240> what<00:00:39.480> what<00:00:39.600> are<00:00:39.680> the<00:00:39.800> alternatives?

00:00:40.840 --> 00:00:50.000
I<00:00:40.920> mean,<00:00:41.080> what's<00:00:41.320> the<00:00:41.840> the<00:00:42.240> the<00:00:42.360> spectrum<00:00:43.000> of<00:00:43.160> possibilities<00:00:44.120> that<00:00:44.280> it<00:00:44.400> might<00:00:44.720> be<00:00:45.360> that<00:00:45.560> would<00:00:45.680> be<00:00:45.840> consistent<00:00:47.240> with<00:00:47.520> your<00:00:47.960> paper<00:00:48.480> that<00:00:48.680> there<00:00:48.960> is

00:00:50.000 --> 00:00:58.920
a<00:00:50.480> survival<00:00:51.040> of<00:00:51.120> human<00:00:51.440> consciousness<00:00:53.200> and<00:00:53.400> you're<00:00:53.520> very<00:00:53.720> specific<00:00:54.160> means<00:00:54.800> survival<00:00:55.240> of<00:00:55.360> human<00:00:56.000> consciousness<00:00:56.720> which<00:00:56.880> sounds<00:00:57.240> like<00:00:57.360> it's<00:00:57.520> personalized<00:00:58.720> as

00:00:58.920 --> 00:01:07.240
opposed<00:00:59.280> to<00:00:59.400> survival<00:00:59.920> of<00:01:00.000> consciousness<00:01:00.680> meaning<00:01:01.040> I<00:01:01.600> you<00:01:01.720> know,<00:01:01.840> my<00:01:02.040> drop<00:01:02.440> of<00:01:02.560> consciousness<00:01:03.200> is<00:01:03.560> is<00:01:03.760> absorbed<00:01:04.320> into<00:01:04.600> the<00:01:04.720> great<00:01:05.040> ocean<00:01:05.840> of<00:01:06.280> the<00:01:06.400> infinite<00:01:06.800> ocean<00:01:07.120> of

00:01:07.240 --> 00:01:14.720
consciousness<00:01:07.840> beyond.<00:01:08.560> I<00:01:08.600> think<00:01:08.760> by<00:01:08.880> saying<00:01:09.120> human<00:01:09.400> consciousness<00:01:10.480> sort<00:01:10.720> of<00:01:10.800> implies<00:01:11.680> a<00:01:11.760> personal<00:01:12.840> consciousness<00:01:13.480> survival.

00:01:14.720 --> 00:01:22.320
First<00:01:14.960> of<00:01:15.040> all,<00:01:15.160> is<00:01:15.320> that<00:01:15.560> true<00:01:16.920> and<00:01:17.880> in<00:01:18.000> terms<00:01:18.320> of<00:01:18.760> your<00:01:18.960> view<00:01:19.280> and<00:01:19.400> if<00:01:19.560> it<00:01:19.680> is,<00:01:19.880> what<00:01:20.040> are<00:01:20.120> the<00:01:20.240> possibilities?

00:01:22.320 --> 00:01:30.800
<00:01:22.906> I<00:01:23.491> believe<00:01:24.077> that<00:01:24.663> the<00:01:25.249> evidence<00:01:25.834> points<00:01:26.420> to<00:01:27.006> the<00:01:27.591> survival<00:01:28.177> of<00:01:28.763> personal<00:01:29.349> identity<00:01:29.934> in<00:01:30.520> some

00:01:30.800 --> 00:01:39.560
instances.<00:01:31.880> I'm<00:01:32.080> inclined<00:01:32.560> to<00:01:32.680> think<00:01:33.040> that<00:01:33.320> there<00:01:33.560> are<00:01:34.080> many<00:01:34.600> options<00:01:35.600> available<00:01:36.480> and<00:01:36.640> that<00:01:37.160> some<00:01:37.400> people<00:01:38.120> really<00:01:38.440> don't<00:01:38.760> want<00:01:39.080> to

00:01:39.560 --> 00:01:48.720
have<00:01:39.840> their<00:01:40.040> personal<00:01:40.640> identity<00:01:41.280> survive<00:01:41.960> and<00:01:42.120> other<00:01:42.360> people<00:01:43.160> maybe<00:01:43.560> are<00:01:43.800> ready<00:01:44.160> to<00:01:44.400> evolve<00:01:44.960> to<00:01:45.080> something<00:01:45.520> completely<00:01:46.160> different<00:01:46.920> than<00:01:47.120> human<00:01:47.520> consciousness.

00:01:48.720 --> 00:01:56.880
We<00:01:48.880> don't<00:01:49.160> know<00:01:49.520> all<00:01:49.720> the<00:01:49.840> possibilities.<00:01:51.240> However,<00:01:52.320> I<00:01:52.520> would<00:01:52.800> say<00:01:53.160> that<00:01:54.200> the<00:01:54.360> first<00:01:54.760> thing<00:01:55.440> that<00:01:55.680> comes<00:01:56.080> to<00:01:56.200> me<00:01:56.520> when<00:01:56.760> I

00:01:56.880 --> 00:01:59.880
think<00:01:57.240> of<00:01:57.360> the<00:01:57.560> afterlife<00:01:58.320> is<00:01:58.480> that<00:01:58.680> it's<00:01:58.840> a<00:01:58.920> place.

00:01:59.880 --> 00:02:03.280
It<00:02:00.080> exists<00:02:00.760> in<00:02:00.920> a<00:02:01.000> space<00:02:01.880> of<00:02:02.080> some<00:02:02.400> sort.

00:02:03.280 --> 00:02:10.920
So,<00:02:03.520> I'm<00:02:03.640> inclined<00:02:04.680> towards<00:02:05.400> the<00:02:05.840> approach<00:02:06.720> of<00:02:07.680> thinking<00:02:08.119> of<00:02:08.240> it<00:02:08.360> in<00:02:08.479> terms<00:02:08.800> of<00:02:08.920> mathematical<00:02:09.800> hyperspaces.

00:02:10.920 --> 00:02:19.920
That<00:02:11.520> there<00:02:11.800> are<00:02:12.520> ways<00:02:13.000> of<00:02:13.120> describing<00:02:13.959> other<00:02:14.240> dimensions<00:02:14.959> mathematically<00:02:16.000> that<00:02:16.240> are<00:02:17.000> quite<00:02:17.320> consistent<00:02:18.720> mathematically<00:02:19.720> and

00:02:19.920 --> 00:02:25.040
even<00:02:20.520> are<00:02:20.680> found<00:02:21.120> to<00:02:21.200> be<00:02:21.360> very<00:02:21.720> useful<00:02:22.600> in<00:02:22.880> theoretical<00:02:23.640> physics<00:02:24.120> these<00:02:24.480> days.

00:02:25.040 --> 00:02:28.040
So,<00:02:25.480> I<00:02:25.959> I<00:02:26.080> lean<00:02:26.600> in<00:02:26.760> that<00:02:27.040> direction.

00:02:28.040 --> 00:02:38.280
I<00:02:28.160> think<00:02:28.480> that<00:02:29.440> we<00:02:29.640> have<00:02:29.959> to<00:02:30.640> take<00:02:31.240> what<00:02:31.440> you<00:02:31.560> might<00:02:31.840> call<00:02:32.160> a<00:02:32.240> Platonic<00:02:33.040> view<00:02:33.320> of<00:02:33.520> things<00:02:34.800> accounting<00:02:35.440> for<00:02:36.000> hyperspace<00:02:37.120> well

00:02:38.280 --> 00:02:46.600
and<00:02:38.720> and<00:02:38.920> the<00:02:39.120> idea<00:02:39.640> that<00:02:40.240> the<00:02:40.400> folkloric<00:02:41.720> descriptions<00:02:42.800> of<00:02:43.240> other<00:02:43.560> kinds<00:02:44.040> of<00:02:44.200> bodies,<00:02:44.760> an<00:02:44.920> astral<00:02:45.480> body,<00:02:46.240> or<00:02:46.480> an

00:02:46.600 --> 00:02:51.920
etheric<00:02:47.240> body<00:02:47.920> as<00:02:48.120> it's<00:02:48.320> sometimes<00:02:48.959> referred<00:02:49.480> to,<00:02:49.760> or<00:02:50.080> a<00:02:50.360> bioenergetic<00:02:51.560> body.

00:02:51.920 --> 00:02:58.280
There<00:02:52.360> There<00:02:52.520> many<00:02:52.800> different<00:02:53.160> ways<00:02:53.640> of<00:02:54.040> linguistically<00:02:55.640> referring<00:02:56.320> to<00:02:56.880> a<00:02:57.000> subtle<00:02:57.440> body.

00:02:58.280 --> 00:03:08.000
For<00:02:58.520> example,<00:02:59.440> that<00:03:00.000> that<00:03:00.160> these<00:03:00.519> possibilities<00:03:01.560> could<00:03:01.800> be<00:03:01.959> accounted<00:03:02.680> for<00:03:03.400> if<00:03:04.480> we<00:03:04.680> take<00:03:05.000> into<00:03:05.400> account<00:03:06.880> hyperspace

00:03:08.000 --> 00:03:11.800
and<00:03:09.120> and<00:03:09.280> the<00:03:09.360> mathematics<00:03:10.160> of<00:03:10.280> hyperspace.

00:03:11.800 --> 00:03:16.560
But<00:03:12.200> ultimately<00:03:13.640> as<00:03:14.160> you<00:03:14.320> point<00:03:14.720> out,<00:03:15.040> it's<00:03:15.360> we<00:03:15.560> don't<00:03:15.840> know.

00:03:16.560 --> 00:03:25.200
We<00:03:17.080> We<00:03:17.280> have<00:03:17.600> reports.<00:03:18.200> They're<00:03:18.400> very<00:03:18.800> detailed<00:03:19.560> reports<00:03:20.239> from<00:03:20.760> people<00:03:21.160> who<00:03:21.360> claim<00:03:21.920> that<00:03:22.120> they're<00:03:22.360> able<00:03:22.680> to<00:03:23.080> travel<00:03:23.680> through<00:03:24.000> the<00:03:24.200> afterlife<00:03:25.080> and

00:03:25.200 --> 00:03:29.600
describe<00:03:25.920> its<00:03:26.440> many<00:03:26.720> different<00:03:27.160> dimensions<00:03:27.840> and<00:03:28.000> come<00:03:28.200> back<00:03:28.560> to<00:03:28.680> talk<00:03:29.000> about<00:03:29.400> it.

00:03:29.600 --> 00:03:37.880
There<00:03:30.200> even<00:03:31.000> wonderful<00:03:31.600> books<00:03:32.120> where<00:03:32.320> people<00:03:32.720> have<00:03:32.959> used<00:03:33.480> AI<00:03:34.400> to<00:03:34.800> paint<00:03:35.160> pictures<00:03:36.480> of<00:03:36.680> what<00:03:36.880> it<00:03:37.040> looks<00:03:37.440> like.

00:03:37.880 --> 00:03:46.600
So,<00:03:38.800> I<00:03:39.440> think<00:03:39.920> I<00:03:40.040> think<00:03:40.320> these<00:03:40.680> descriptions<00:03:41.560> are<00:03:42.200> quite<00:03:42.519> interesting<00:03:43.239> even<00:03:43.560> if<00:03:43.680> it's<00:03:43.920> nothing<00:03:44.360> more<00:03:44.640> than<00:03:44.880> human<00:03:45.200> imagination.

00:03:46.600 --> 00:03:48.800
<00:03:46.763> Let<00:03:46.927> Let<00:03:47.090> me<00:03:47.253> Let<00:03:47.417> me<00:03:47.580> focus<00:03:47.743> on<00:03:47.907> on<00:03:48.070> a<00:03:48.233> couple<00:03:48.397> of<00:03:48.560> things.

00:03:48.800 --> 00:03:53.480
First<00:03:49.080> of<00:03:49.239> all,<00:03:49.600> at<00:03:49.760> the<00:03:49.840> beginning<00:03:50.440> you<00:03:50.600> talked<00:03:50.920> about<00:03:51.360> there<00:03:51.640> are<00:03:51.840> different<00:03:52.280> options.

00:03:53.480 --> 00:04:01.320
Now,<00:03:53.840> are<00:03:53.920> those<00:03:54.320> options<00:03:55.000> meaning<00:03:56.600> what<00:03:56.920> ultimate<00:03:57.320> reality<00:03:57.840> is,<00:03:58.120> that<00:03:58.240> there<00:03:58.360> are<00:03:58.600> these<00:03:58.840> different<00:03:59.160> possibilities,<00:03:59.760> we<00:03:59.840> don't<00:04:00.000> know<00:04:00.120> which<00:04:00.320> is<00:04:00.440> right,<00:04:00.920> but<00:04:01.080> we<00:04:01.160> know

00:04:01.320 --> 00:04:10.080
there<00:04:01.480> are<00:04:01.520> different<00:04:01.800> possibilities,<00:04:02.480> or<00:04:03.800> do<00:04:04.040> you<00:04:04.160> mean<00:04:04.360> by<00:04:04.560> options<00:04:05.160> is<00:04:05.400> that<00:04:06.120> in<00:04:06.280> some<00:04:06.640> sense<00:04:07.600> the<00:04:08.160> the<00:04:08.280> human<00:04:08.680> consciousness<00:04:09.880> that

00:04:10.080 --> 00:04:18.840
you<00:04:10.200> say<00:04:10.760> will<00:04:10.959> survive<00:04:11.400> bodily<00:04:11.760> death<00:04:13.080> has<00:04:13.320> a<00:04:13.360> choice,<00:04:14.600> and<00:04:14.920> it<00:04:15.120> it<00:04:15.280> can<00:04:15.560> decide<00:04:16.160> which<00:04:16.440> one<00:04:16.640> of<00:04:16.760> these<00:04:17.040> it<00:04:17.160> wants<00:04:17.560> to<00:04:17.680> do.

00:04:18.840 --> 00:04:21.120
That's<00:04:19.120> very<00:04:19.400> different<00:04:20.079> than<00:04:20.239> saying<00:04:20.480> you<00:04:20.560> have<00:04:20.680> a<00:04:20.760> choice.

00:04:21.120 --> 00:04:39.360
If<00:04:21.239> you<00:04:21.320> have<00:04:21.480> a<00:04:21.519> choice,<00:04:22.240> that<00:04:22.480> implies<00:04:23.200> something

00:04:39.360 --> 00:04:43.400
pretty<00:04:39.720> dramatic<00:04:40.400> about<00:04:40.680> the<00:04:40.800> structure<00:04:41.360> of<00:04:41.680> ultimate<00:04:42.120> reality.

00:04:43.400 --> 00:04:47.760
<00:04:43.673> I<00:04:43.947> think<00:04:44.220> we<00:04:44.493> have<00:04:44.767> a<00:04:45.040> choice.<00:04:45.313> I<00:04:45.587> go<00:04:45.860> for<00:04:46.133> the<00:04:46.407> second<00:04:46.680> description.

00:04:47.760 --> 00:04:55.919
<00:04:48.141> Okay.<00:04:48.522> That<00:04:48.903> that<00:04:49.284> would<00:04:49.665> that<00:04:50.046> would<00:04:50.427> that<00:04:50.808> would<00:04:51.189> baffle<00:04:51.570> me<00:04:51.950> about<00:04:52.331> ultimate<00:04:52.712> reality,<00:04:53.093> that<00:04:53.474> ultimate<00:04:53.855> reality<00:04:54.236> gives<00:04:54.617> you<00:04:54.998> a<00:04:55.379> choice<00:04:55.760> of

00:04:55.919 --> 00:05:02.160
different<00:04:56.416> kinds<00:04:56.912> of<00:04:57.409> realities.<00:04:57.906> <00:04:58.403> Well,<00:04:58.900> you<00:04:59.396> have<00:04:59.893> something<00:05:00.390> of<00:05:00.887> a<00:05:01.383> choice<00:05:01.880> here.

00:05:02.160 --> 00:05:06.880
You<00:05:02.320> can<00:05:02.520> live<00:05:02.760> in<00:05:02.880> New<00:05:03.080> York<00:05:03.440> City<00:05:03.880> or<00:05:04.360> San<00:05:04.640> Francisco<00:05:05.520> or<00:05:05.680> go<00:05:05.880> to<00:05:06.000> China.

00:05:06.880 --> 00:05:15.360
<00:05:07.261> Okay.<00:05:07.642> Okay.<00:05:08.023> That's<00:05:08.404> good,<00:05:08.785> but<00:05:09.166> that's<00:05:09.547> that's<00:05:09.928> a<00:05:10.309> different<00:05:10.690> thing,<00:05:11.070> and<00:05:11.451> that<00:05:11.832> means<00:05:12.213> if<00:05:12.594> I<00:05:12.975> have<00:05:13.356> an<00:05:13.737> astro<00:05:14.118> if<00:05:14.499> astral<00:05:14.880> bodies

00:05:15.360 --> 00:05:22.960
are<00:05:15.440> right,<00:05:15.720> I<00:05:15.800> could<00:05:15.919> have<00:05:16.040> an<00:05:16.120> astral<00:05:16.480> body<00:05:16.919> of<00:05:17.520> different<00:05:17.840> shapes<00:05:18.240> or<00:05:18.400> forms,<00:05:18.880> and<00:05:18.960> I<00:05:19.040> can<00:05:19.200> choose<00:05:19.520> my<00:05:19.680> form,<00:05:20.040> or<00:05:20.200> I<00:05:20.280> can<00:05:20.680> have<00:05:20.880> that<00:05:21.120> astral<00:05:21.520> body<00:05:21.919> be<00:05:22.120> in<00:05:22.280> one<00:05:22.440> dimension

00:05:22.960 --> 00:05:27.120
or<00:05:23.080> another.<00:05:23.840> That's<00:05:24.040> a<00:05:24.080> different<00:05:24.640> kind<00:05:25.000> of<00:05:25.120> choice<00:05:25.440> than<00:05:25.600> what<00:05:25.720> I'm<00:05:25.840> talking<00:05:26.120> about.

00:05:27.120 --> 00:05:35.560
The<00:05:27.200> kind<00:05:27.480> of<00:05:27.560> choice<00:05:27.800> I'm<00:05:27.919> talking<00:05:28.120> about<00:05:28.320> is<00:05:28.440> one<00:05:28.680> choice<00:05:29.080> says<00:05:30.400> I'm<00:05:30.600> absorbed<00:05:31.480> my<00:05:31.680> drop<00:05:32.040> of<00:05:32.200> conscious<00:05:32.560> absorbed<00:05:33.000> into<00:05:33.200> the<00:05:33.320> infinite<00:05:33.760> ocean,<00:05:34.080> another<00:05:34.400> says<00:05:34.680> I<00:05:35.080> maintain

00:05:35.560 --> 00:05:43.960
my<00:05:35.720> personality,<00:05:36.520> another<00:05:36.880> says<00:05:37.480> we're<00:05:37.680> all<00:05:37.919> astral<00:05:38.320> bodies,<00:05:38.840> another<00:05:39.200> says<00:05:40.880> in<00:05:40.960> Abrahamic<00:05:41.480> religions,<00:05:42.080> it's<00:05:42.360> a<00:05:42.960> it's<00:05:43.160> a<00:05:43.240> heaven<00:05:43.760> in

00:05:43.960 --> 00:05:51.960
some<00:05:44.320> sense,<00:05:45.320> whether<00:05:45.520> it's<00:05:45.640> a<00:05:45.720> beatific<00:05:46.520> vision<00:05:46.920> of<00:05:47.040> some<00:05:47.360> versions<00:05:48.120> or<00:05:49.160> Edenic<00:05:50.440> gardens<00:05:51.160> that<00:05:51.360> you<00:05:51.480> live<00:05:51.720> in.

00:05:51.960 --> 00:06:00.680
I<00:05:52.000> mean,<00:05:53.480> those<00:05:53.680> are<00:05:53.800> different<00:05:54.960> radically<00:05:55.680> different<00:05:56.600> kinds<00:05:57.360> of<00:05:57.920> structures<00:05:59.160> of<00:05:59.400> what<00:05:59.600> the<00:05:59.760> afterlife<00:06:00.480> would

00:06:00.680 --> 00:06:09.200
be.<00:06:01.520> And<00:06:01.880> so<00:06:01.960> what<00:06:02.160> I'm<00:06:02.280> saying<00:06:02.640> is<00:06:02.800> that<00:06:03.080> I<00:06:03.160> don't<00:06:04.560> would<00:06:04.680> not<00:06:05.040> make<00:06:05.280> sense<00:06:05.640> to<00:06:05.760> me<00:06:05.920> to<00:06:06.040> have<00:06:06.240> a<00:06:06.960> have<00:06:07.080> a<00:06:07.160> choice<00:06:07.640> of<00:06:07.760> which<00:06:08.040> one<00:06:08.280> of<00:06:08.400> those<00:06:08.760> kinds

00:06:09.200 --> 00:06:17.240
of<00:06:09.320> structures,<00:06:10.560> but<00:06:11.280> once<00:06:11.600> I'm<00:06:11.720> in<00:06:11.840> a<00:06:11.920> structure,<00:06:12.560> then<00:06:12.960> then<00:06:13.200> there's<00:06:13.400> a<00:06:13.440> lot<00:06:13.560> of<00:06:13.680> options<00:06:14.160> where<00:06:14.320> my,<00:06:14.680> you<00:06:14.760> know,<00:06:15.040> where<00:06:15.240> where<00:06:15.440> that<00:06:15.720> where<00:06:15.920> I<00:06:16.000> can<00:06:16.200> be.

00:06:17.240 --> 00:06:23.520
<00:06:17.620> Right.<00:06:18.000> So<00:06:18.380> like<00:06:18.760> we<00:06:19.140> could<00:06:19.520> consider<00:06:19.900> it<00:06:20.280> in<00:06:20.660> terms<00:06:21.040> of<00:06:21.420> horizontal<00:06:21.800> or<00:06:22.180> versus<00:06:22.560> vertical.

00:06:23.520 --> 00:06:30.960
That<00:06:23.924> right<00:06:24.329> now<00:06:24.733> we're<00:06:25.138> in<00:06:25.542> the<00:06:25.947> three-dimensional<00:06:26.351> world<00:06:26.756> and<00:06:27.160> our<00:06:27.564> choices<00:06:27.969> are<00:06:28.373> limited,<00:06:28.778> let's<00:06:29.182> say<00:06:29.587> horizontally<00:06:29.991> to<00:06:30.396> <00:06:30.800> Right.

00:06:30.960 --> 00:06:34.160
Right.<00:06:31.313> <00:06:31.667> other<00:06:32.020> locations<00:06:32.373> within<00:06:32.727> this<00:06:33.080> dimension.

00:06:34.160 --> 00:06:41.440
I<00:06:34.800> gather<00:06:35.400> from<00:06:36.120> the<00:06:36.240> various<00:06:36.800> accounts<00:06:37.360> that<00:06:37.560> the<00:06:37.720> afterlife<00:06:38.640> also<00:06:39.080> has<00:06:39.360> a<00:06:39.400> vertical<00:06:40.320> dimension.

00:06:41.440 --> 00:06:49.880
And<00:06:41.880> and<00:06:42.040> the<00:06:42.120> vertical<00:06:42.600> dimension<00:06:43.240> might<00:06:43.520> be<00:06:44.720> along<00:06:45.200> the<00:06:45.280> lines<00:06:45.840> of<00:06:46.560> spirituality<00:06:47.800> or<00:06:48.080> ethics<00:06:49.080> that<00:06:49.680> we

00:06:49.880 --> 00:06:57.240
go<00:06:50.160> from<00:06:50.800> evil<00:06:51.280> to<00:06:51.919> the<00:06:52.040> highest<00:06:52.880> good,<00:06:53.680> from<00:06:53.880> the<00:06:54.440> the<00:06:54.560> greatest<00:06:55.120> evil<00:06:55.440> to<00:06:55.560> the<00:06:55.680> highest<00:06:56.480> form<00:06:56.800> of<00:06:56.960> good.

00:06:57.240 --> 00:07:02.520
And<00:06:57.400> we<00:06:57.520> can<00:06:57.720> only<00:06:58.000> go<00:06:58.200> so<00:06:58.480> far<00:06:59.120> depending<00:06:59.720> on<00:06:59.880> the<00:07:00.200> evolution<00:07:00.919> of<00:07:01.080> our<00:07:01.240> consciousness.

00:07:02.520 --> 00:07:07.560
So<00:07:03.000> it's<00:07:03.240> not<00:07:03.520> as<00:07:03.720> if<00:07:04.520> everybody<00:07:05.160> can<00:07:05.400> choose<00:07:06.680> any<00:07:06.960> of<00:07:07.120> those.

00:07:07.560 --> 00:07:13.919
Our<00:07:08.000> our<00:07:08.120> choices<00:07:08.680> are<00:07:08.800> going<00:07:09.000> to<00:07:09.080> be<00:07:09.240> limited<00:07:10.200> by<00:07:10.760> how<00:07:12.280> how<00:07:12.480> we<00:07:12.640> perceive<00:07:13.280> things.

00:07:13.919 --> 00:07:22.280
And<00:07:14.760> a<00:07:15.160> great<00:07:15.440> example<00:07:16.040> of<00:07:16.200> that<00:07:16.520> would<00:07:16.680> be<00:07:16.880> what's<00:07:17.160> known<00:07:17.520> in<00:07:17.640> the<00:07:17.760> near-death<00:07:18.360> literature<00:07:19.280> as<00:07:19.520> the<00:07:19.680> past<00:07:20.160> life<00:07:20.560> review,<00:07:21.720> where<00:07:21.960> many

00:07:22.280 --> 00:07:30.680
people<00:07:22.800> report<00:07:23.280> about<00:07:23.600> 20%<00:07:24.919> of<00:07:25.080> near-death<00:07:25.640> experiencers<00:07:27.040> say<00:07:27.320> that<00:07:27.760> their<00:07:27.919> whole<00:07:28.200> life<00:07:28.600> flashes<00:07:29.200> in<00:07:29.360> front<00:07:29.640> of<00:07:29.760> them<00:07:30.000> moment<00:07:30.480> by

00:07:30.680 --> 00:07:37.760
moment.<00:07:31.480> They<00:07:31.680> experience<00:07:32.640> it<00:07:33.040> and<00:07:33.200> they<00:07:33.360> experience<00:07:34.240> also<00:07:35.360> how<00:07:35.720> other<00:07:36.040> people<00:07:36.480> perceive<00:07:37.120> them.

00:07:37.760 --> 00:07:42.240
And<00:07:38.120> you<00:07:38.240> know,<00:07:38.400> the<00:07:38.520> pain<00:07:39.000> or<00:07:39.160> the<00:07:39.320> joy<00:07:40.000> that<00:07:40.200> they<00:07:40.360> may<00:07:40.520> have<00:07:40.720> caused<00:07:41.160> for<00:07:41.440> other<00:07:41.680> people.

00:07:42.240 --> 00:07:51.480
They<00:07:42.440> experience<00:07:43.320> that<00:07:43.720> from<00:07:44.040> their<00:07:44.360> perspective<00:07:45.680> and<00:07:45.880> they<00:07:46.040> say<00:07:46.400> that<00:07:47.120> they<00:07:47.320> can<00:07:47.520> have<00:07:47.920> this<00:07:48.160> experience<00:07:49.040> from<00:07:49.280> birth<00:07:49.760> to<00:07:49.880> death<00:07:50.800> and

00:07:51.480 --> 00:07:56.760
it<00:07:51.680> may<00:07:51.920> only<00:07:52.280> take<00:07:53.360> a<00:07:53.440> matter<00:07:53.960> of<00:07:54.280> minutes<00:07:55.440> in<00:07:55.680> Earth<00:07:56.040> time.

00:07:56.760 --> 00:08:01.200
That<00:07:56.920> somehow<00:07:57.320> time<00:07:57.800> is<00:07:57.920> very<00:07:58.320> different<00:07:59.240> in<00:07:59.440> that<00:07:59.800> realm.

00:08:01.200 --> 00:08:09.800
But<00:08:01.480> they<00:08:01.640> also<00:08:02.080> say<00:08:02.960> there's<00:08:03.280> nobody<00:08:03.960> judging<00:08:04.640> you,<00:08:05.280> but<00:08:05.480> you<00:08:05.640> do<00:08:05.880> judge<00:08:06.280> yourself<00:08:07.320> when<00:08:07.560> you<00:08:08.080> experience<00:08:09.560> your

00:08:09.800 --> 00:08:18.040
past<00:08:10.240> life<00:08:10.600> review.<00:08:11.560> So,<00:08:12.440> in<00:08:12.600> that<00:08:12.919> process<00:08:13.560> of<00:08:13.800> judging<00:08:14.280> yourself<00:08:15.560> and<00:08:15.919> also<00:08:16.320> with<00:08:16.560> the<00:08:16.680> help<00:08:17.080> of<00:08:17.320> teachers<00:08:17.880> and

00:08:18.040 --> 00:08:26.919
guides,<00:08:18.919> you<00:08:19.080> may<00:08:19.320> come<00:08:19.680> to<00:08:20.000> a<00:08:20.240> decision<00:08:21.040> about<00:08:21.880> what<00:08:22.120> kind<00:08:22.520> of<00:08:22.680> an<00:08:22.800> experience<00:08:23.720> would<00:08:23.880> be<00:08:24.040> most<00:08:24.480> appropriate<00:08:25.320> for<00:08:25.560> you<00:08:26.320> next

00:08:26.919 --> 00:08:33.159
to<00:08:27.120> overcome<00:08:27.840> whatever<00:08:28.360> issues,<00:08:29.200> psychological<00:08:30.240> and<00:08:30.400> spiritual,<00:08:31.280> remain<00:08:31.840> in<00:08:31.960> your<00:08:32.200> life.

00:08:33.159 --> 00:08:42.640
For<00:08:33.360> some<00:08:33.599> people,<00:08:34.039> that<00:08:34.320> may<00:08:34.560> be<00:08:35.840> spending<00:08:36.360> more<00:08:36.560> time<00:08:36.919> on<00:08:37.039> the<00:08:37.240> astral<00:08:37.760> plane<00:08:38.240> where<00:08:39.080> you<00:08:39.280> can<00:08:39.560> play<00:08:39.880> golf<00:08:40.320> in<00:08:40.440> an<00:08:40.560> astral<00:08:41.039> golf<00:08:41.400> course.

00:08:42.640 --> 00:08:50.839
For<00:08:42.919> other<00:08:43.159> people,<00:08:43.599> it<00:08:43.760> may<00:08:43.960> be<00:08:44.520> being<00:08:45.000> reincarnated<00:08:46.680> as<00:08:47.480> as<00:08:47.680> an<00:08:47.880> infant<00:08:48.440> who<00:08:48.600> is<00:08:48.800> deformed<00:08:49.680> and<00:08:50.120> is<00:08:50.320> not<00:08:50.600> going<00:08:50.720> to

00:08:50.839 --> 00:08:59.520
live<00:08:51.160> more<00:08:51.400> than<00:08:51.640> 6<00:08:52.000> months.<00:08:52.960> For<00:08:53.200> other<00:08:53.440> people,<00:08:53.920> it<00:08:54.080> may<00:08:54.320> be<00:08:55.240> um<00:08:56.880> to<00:08:57.240> be<00:08:57.400> reborn<00:08:57.960> in<00:08:58.120> a<00:08:58.160> different<00:08:58.600> culture.

00:08:59.520 --> 00:09:08.280
For<00:08:59.720> other<00:08:59.960> people,<00:09:00.440> it<00:09:00.600> may<00:09:00.839> be<00:09:01.080> to<00:09:01.240> move<00:09:01.520> up<00:09:01.760> to<00:09:02.000> a<00:09:02.080> higher<00:09:02.480> plane<00:09:03.320> if<00:09:03.520> you<00:09:03.640> can<00:09:03.920> get<00:09:04.240> there<00:09:04.560> and<00:09:04.720> experience<00:09:06.480> that<00:09:06.880> form<00:09:07.200> of<00:09:07.400> existence.

00:09:08.280 --> 00:09:17.200
<00:09:08.539> But<00:09:08.798> but<00:09:09.057> are<00:09:09.316> these<00:09:09.575> choices<00:09:09.834> that<00:09:10.093> you<00:09:10.352> make<00:09:10.611> or<00:09:10.870> that<00:09:11.130> are<00:09:11.389> imposed<00:09:11.648> upon<00:09:11.907> you<00:09:12.166> in<00:09:12.425> some<00:09:12.684> sort<00:09:12.943> of<00:09:13.202> a<00:09:13.461> karmic<00:09:13.720> system?

00:09:17.200 --> 00:09:25.600
<00:09:17.634> There<00:09:18.067> are,<00:09:18.501> of<00:09:18.935> course,<00:09:19.368> different<00:09:19.802> accounts<00:09:20.236> <00:09:20.669> [laughter]<00:09:21.103> <00:09:21.537> of<00:09:21.971> it<00:09:22.404> and<00:09:22.838> the<00:09:23.272> the<00:09:23.705> best<00:09:24.139> interpretation<00:09:24.573> I<00:09:25.006> have<00:09:25.440> is

00:09:25.600 --> 00:09:32.640
that<00:09:25.839> you<00:09:25.960> will<00:09:26.160> be<00:09:26.360> with<00:09:26.640> guides<00:09:27.200> and<00:09:27.360> teachers<00:09:28.360> who<00:09:28.560> will<00:09:29.000> assist<00:09:29.560> you,<00:09:29.680> but<00:09:29.960> ultimately<00:09:31.000> you<00:09:31.240> make<00:09:31.600> that<00:09:31.880> choice.

00:09:32.640 --> 00:09:39.840
<00:09:32.975> So,<00:09:33.310> that's<00:09:33.645> a<00:09:33.980> very<00:09:34.315> different<00:09:34.650> approach<00:09:34.985> to<00:09:35.320> the<00:09:35.655> afterlife<00:09:35.990> than<00:09:36.325> you'd<00:09:36.660> find<00:09:36.995> in<00:09:37.330> the<00:09:37.665> Abrahamic<00:09:38.000> religions.

00:09:39.840 --> 00:09:44.040
<00:09:40.235> In<00:09:40.630> the<00:09:41.025> Jewish<00:09:41.420> mystical<00:09:41.815> tradition,<00:09:42.210> reincarnation<00:09:42.605> is<00:09:43.000> accepted.

00:09:44.040 --> 00:09:52.400
It's<00:09:44.280> called<00:09:44.640> Gilgul<00:09:45.720> and<00:09:46.880> my<00:09:47.200> Orthodox<00:09:47.960> Jewish<00:09:48.360> relatives<00:09:49.000> tell<00:09:49.240> me,<00:09:49.640> "But<00:09:49.800> of<00:09:49.960> course<00:09:50.280> you<00:09:50.400> will<00:09:50.640> only<00:09:50.920> be<00:09:51.120> reincarnated<00:09:52.240> as

00:09:52.400 --> 00:10:01.840
a<00:09:53.145> Jew."<00:09:53.891> <00:09:54.636> [laughter]<00:09:55.382> <00:09:56.127> However,<00:09:56.873> the<00:09:57.618> data<00:09:58.364> from<00:09:59.109> past<00:09:59.855> life<00:10:00.600> experiencers

00:10:01.840 --> 00:10:10.400
is<00:10:02.720> is<00:10:02.960> different.<00:10:03.360> There<00:10:03.520> are<00:10:03.640> people<00:10:04.880> today<00:10:06.120> who<00:10:06.320> were<00:10:06.400> born<00:10:06.800> Jewish<00:10:07.200> who<00:10:07.360> claim<00:10:07.680> to<00:10:07.840> have<00:10:08.360> past<00:10:08.840> life<00:10:09.200> memories<00:10:09.800> of<00:10:09.960> having

00:10:10.400 --> 00:10:17.480
been<00:10:11.600> a<00:10:12.560> German<00:10:13.840> guard<00:10:14.360> in<00:10:14.560> a<00:10:14.800> concentration<00:10:15.800> camp.

00:10:17.480 --> 00:10:27.080
<00:10:18.020> Yeah,<00:10:18.560> I<00:10:19.100> mean<00:10:19.640> we<00:10:20.180> we're<00:10:20.720> we're<00:10:21.260> we're<00:10:21.800> not<00:10:22.340> um<00:10:22.880> subjecting<00:10:23.420> the<00:10:23.960> the<00:10:24.500> the<00:10:25.040> anecdotes<00:10:25.580> to<00:10:26.120> to

00:10:27.080 --> 00:10:31.520
falsification<00:10:27.880> analysis,<00:10:28.520> but<00:10:28.680> we're<00:10:28.760> assuming<00:10:29.200> that<00:10:29.360> they're<00:10:29.520> right<00:10:29.800> what<00:10:30.320> what<00:10:30.560> this<00:10:31.080> would<00:10:31.240> mean.

00:10:31.520 --> 00:10:41.040
But<00:10:31.920> but<00:10:32.680> you<00:10:32.800> know,<00:10:32.880> again,<00:10:33.840> you<00:10:34.200> you<00:10:34.360> point<00:10:34.720> out<00:10:35.080> Jewish<00:10:35.280> mysticism,<00:10:35.880> you<00:10:36.000> can<00:10:36.200> in<00:10:36.320> other<00:10:36.880> the<00:10:37.000> other<00:10:37.240> Abrahamic<00:10:37.720> religions,<00:10:38.080> each<00:10:38.280> has<00:10:38.440> their<00:10:38.600> own<00:10:38.760> kinds<00:10:39.120> of<00:10:39.200> mysticism

00:10:41.040 --> 00:10:44.920
as<00:10:41.800> religions<00:10:42.600> proliferate<00:10:43.400> and<00:10:43.560> divide<00:10:44.080> and<00:10:44.320> everything<00:10:44.680> else.

00:10:44.920 --> 00:10:51.000
But<00:10:45.080> the<00:10:45.200> core<00:10:46.320> I<00:10:46.360> mean<00:10:46.560> theology<00:10:47.400> of<00:10:47.560> the<00:10:47.680> Abrahamic<00:10:48.240> religions<00:10:48.920> is<00:10:49.280> is<00:10:49.880> that's<00:10:50.120> not<00:10:50.480> the<00:10:50.600> case.

00:10:51.000 --> 00:10:57.800
I<00:10:51.040> mean<00:10:51.240> you<00:10:51.360> have<00:10:51.560> a<00:10:51.640> God<00:10:52.080> who<00:10:52.200> makes<00:10:52.520> judgments<00:10:53.480> and<00:10:53.640> there's<00:10:53.920> a<00:10:54.839> a<00:10:55.120> a<00:10:55.280> certainly<00:10:56.000> a<00:10:56.280> a<00:10:56.360> very<00:10:56.600> positive<00:10:57.160> heaven.

00:10:57.800 --> 00:11:03.320
Hell<00:10:58.120> is<00:10:58.760> is<00:10:59.400> is<00:10:59.720> a<00:11:00.160> disputed<00:11:01.480> characterization.

00:11:03.320 --> 00:11:06.680
Many<00:11:04.000> believe<00:11:04.320> it,<00:11:04.839> many<00:11:05.120> now<00:11:05.440> don't.

00:11:06.680 --> 00:11:15.160
But<00:11:07.360> have<00:11:07.640> heaven<00:11:07.960> or<00:11:08.080> something<00:11:08.360> like<00:11:08.680> that<00:11:09.000> is<00:11:09.560> is<00:11:09.760> real<00:11:10.000> and<00:11:10.080> that's<00:11:10.240> very<00:11:10.520> different<00:11:11.520> than<00:11:11.880> the<00:11:12.160> kind<00:11:12.560> of<00:11:12.960> afterlife<00:11:13.600> that<00:11:13.760> you're<00:11:13.920> talking<00:11:14.320> about.

00:11:15.160 --> 00:11:17.680
<00:11:15.584> Yes,<00:11:16.008> okay,<00:11:16.432> I'll<00:11:16.856> concede<00:11:17.280> that.

00:11:17.680 --> 00:11:27.560
Sure.<00:11:18.029> <00:11:18.378> And<00:11:18.726> so<00:11:19.075> it<00:11:19.424> it<00:11:19.773> it<00:11:20.122> is<00:11:20.470> the<00:11:20.819> case<00:11:21.168> that<00:11:21.517> if<00:11:21.866> if<00:11:22.214> there<00:11:22.563> is<00:11:22.912> a<00:11:23.261> life<00:11:23.610> afterlife,<00:11:23.958> there<00:11:24.307> is<00:11:24.656> there<00:11:25.005> is<00:11:25.354> the<00:11:25.702> there<00:11:26.051> are<00:11:26.400> examples

00:11:27.560 --> 00:11:36.280
of<00:11:27.760> it<00:11:27.960> that<00:11:28.280> are<00:11:29.080> that<00:11:29.320> contradict<00:11:30.040> each<00:11:30.240> other<00:11:30.520> and<00:11:31.160> and<00:11:31.280> it's<00:11:31.440> not<00:11:31.720> the<00:11:31.839> case<00:11:32.200> that<00:11:33.160> we<00:11:33.360> can<00:11:33.520> all<00:11:33.680> be<00:11:33.800> happy<00:11:34.160> because<00:11:34.760> uh<00:11:34.880> uh<00:11:35.000> everything<00:11:35.480> is<00:11:35.640> true

00:11:36.280 --> 00:11:44.920
or<00:11:36.920> you<00:11:37.000> know,<00:11:37.520> we<00:11:37.640> can<00:11:37.800> all<00:11:38.040> choose<00:11:38.360> our<00:11:38.560> own<00:11:38.760> realities<00:11:39.600> and<00:11:40.880> you<00:11:40.960> know,<00:11:41.080> that<00:11:41.280> that<00:11:41.520> contradicts<00:11:42.760> the<00:11:43.520> the<00:11:43.640> actual<00:11:44.040> statement<00:11:44.720> of

00:11:44.920 --> 00:11:47.640
what<00:11:45.480> various<00:11:45.960> afterlives<00:11:46.760> are.

00:11:47.640 --> 00:11:56.320
And<00:11:47.920> so,<00:11:48.480> you<00:11:48.560> know,<00:11:48.760> I<00:11:49.000> don't<00:11:49.200> want<00:11:49.320> to<00:11:49.400> be<00:11:49.520> mean,<00:11:50.440> but<00:11:50.840> I<00:11:51.160> would<00:11:51.400> say<00:11:51.880> that,<00:11:52.480> you<00:11:52.600> know,<00:11:52.800> if<00:11:53.000> there<00:11:53.200> is<00:11:53.320> a<00:11:53.400> life<00:11:53.760> afterlife<00:11:54.480> according<00:11:54.920> to<00:11:55.040> your<00:11:55.880> excellent

00:11:56.320 --> 00:12:01.800
paper,<00:11:57.000> not<00:11:57.160> that<00:11:57.280> I<00:11:57.320> agree<00:11:57.560> with<00:11:57.720> the<00:11:57.800> conclusion,<00:11:58.320> but<00:11:58.480> I<00:11:58.520> agree<00:11:58.880> with<00:11:59.000> the<00:11:59.080> methodology<00:11:59.920> and<00:12:00.000> the<00:12:00.040> structure,<00:12:00.480> which<00:12:00.640> is<00:12:00.760> excellent.

00:12:01.800 --> 00:12:11.160
But<00:12:02.000> if<00:12:02.240> I<00:12:02.320> agree<00:12:02.720> with<00:12:02.880> that,<00:12:03.440> if<00:12:03.640> I<00:12:03.720> were<00:12:04.000> to<00:12:04.160> agree,<00:12:05.160> then<00:12:05.520> there<00:12:05.760> would<00:12:06.000> be<00:12:06.240> a<00:12:06.360> kind<00:12:06.720> of<00:12:06.880> afterlife<00:12:07.960> in<00:12:08.200> which<00:12:08.680> that<00:12:10.200> that

00:12:11.160 --> 00:12:15.160
is<00:12:11.360> set<00:12:11.680> by<00:12:11.920> reality,<00:12:12.760> God<00:12:13.160> or<00:12:13.240> whatever,<00:12:14.000> that<00:12:14.160> you<00:12:14.240> don't<00:12:14.440> have<00:12:14.600> a<00:12:14.640> choice.

00:12:15.160 --> 00:12:21.000
That<00:12:15.520> that's<00:12:15.880> where<00:12:16.760> that's<00:12:17.000> what<00:12:17.200> you're<00:12:17.320> going<00:12:17.440> to<00:12:17.520> do,<00:12:17.680> whatever<00:12:18.000> it<00:12:18.120> is.

00:12:21.000 --> 00:12:28.018
<00:12:21.291> Well,<00:12:21.583> I<00:12:21.874> suppose<00:12:22.166> so.<00:12:22.457> And<00:12:22.749> And<00:12:23.040> what<00:12:23.331> I'm<00:12:23.623> suggesting<00:12:23.914> is<00:12:24.206> that<00:12:24.497> whatever<00:12:24.789> it<00:12:25.080> is<00:12:25.371> is<00:12:25.663> that<00:12:25.954> you<00:12:26.246> do<00:12:26.537> have<00:12:26.829> a<00:12:27.120> choice.

00:12:28.018 --> 00:12:30.960
<00:12:28.206> [laughter]<00:12:28.395> <00:12:28.583> And<00:12:28.772> that's<00:12:28.960> fair.