> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://famouspsychicmediums.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Legendary Psi Researcher On Telepathy, Reincarnation & Precognition | Dr. Ed Kelly
- URL: https://famouspsychicmediums.com/episodes/legendary-psi-researcher-on-telepathy-reincarnation-precognition-dr-ed-kelly/
- Published: 2025-04-25T17:45:47.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-11T15:50:13.000Z
- Description: Dr. Ed Kelly shares insights from over 50 years of psychical research, demonstrating how evidence for psi phenomena, near-death experiences, and altered states points to a reality where mind is primary to matter.
- Author: Angie Li
- Tags: Science

In this episode, Dr. Edward Kelly, research professor at the University of Virginia's Division of Perceptual Studies (DOPS), shares insights from his more than 50 years of experimental research into psychical phenomena, altered states of consciousness, and post-mortem survival. Drawing from laboratory testing, case studies, and field research into telepathy, precognition, mediumship, and children with past-life memories, Dr. Kelly outlines why standard physicalism is insufficient to explain the empirical facts of nature.

Dr. Kelly examines why mainstream science historically marginalized anomalous phenomena and presents evidence from near-death experiences under extreme physiological conditions, stigmata, and hypnotic influence that challenge materialist paradigms. He discusses alternative theoretical frameworks, including the Myers-James model of the subliminal self, filter theories of brain function, evolutionary panentheism, and realist idealism.

Finally, the conversation explores how expanding scientific models to accommodate spiritual and mystical experiences could positively impact society, academia, and our broader understanding of human potential and the fundamental nature of reality.

### Key takeaways

- Decades of experimental and field research demonstrate that psi phenomena like telepathy, precognition, and post-mortem survival exist as natural facts.
- Strict physicalism cannot adequately account for complex anomalies such as stigmata, hypnotic blisters, past-life memories, or NDEs during cardiac arrest.
- The Myers-James model views everyday ego consciousness as embedded within a larger subliminal self, with the brain acting as a filter or permitting mechanism rather than the generator of mind.
- Realist idealism and evolutionary panentheism offer promising metaphysical frameworks that integrate empirical science with spiritual experience.
- Emerging shifts in theoretical biology and neuroimaging studies of psychedelics and meditation point toward a major transformation in how science understands consciousness.

### Highlights

- 0:02:07 — Empirical evidence for the primacy of mind
- 0:12:10 — Physicalism versus idealism in science
- 0:20:55 — Anomalous psychophysical influence and stigmata
- 0:27:25 — Near-death experiences and mystical states
- 0:42:23 — Evolutionary panentheism and the Myers-James model
- 1:18:03 — The mind-brain relationship and filter theory
- 1:28:50 — Evidence for post-mortem survival and the subliminal self

```chapters
00:00:00 Intro
00:02:07 The primacy of mind: the empirical evidence.
00:12:10 Materialism and physicalism vs. idealism: where is the truth?
00:20:55 Why science ignores parapsychology: hypnotic blisters, stigmata, skin writing…
00:23:35 Past life memories, mediumship: the difficulty of explaining consciousness by physicalist paradigm.
00:26:28 Multiple personality and dissociative identity disorders.
00:27:25 Are NDEs & OBEs essentially mystical experiences?
00:29:08 Extreme forms of genius and mystical experiences.
00:30:45 Different dimensions of reality & failed mainstream explanations.
00:38:15 The alternative model of reality that makes room for anomalous phenomena.
00:42:23 Evolutionary panentheism. Jung. Analytic Idealism.
00:47:20 Implications of physicalism for society at large and the alternatives.
00:48:58 Metaphysics in science: inevitable or superfluous?
00:54:35 Survival after biological death: agree to disagree with Bernardo Kastrup.
00:55:54 Is idealism a crazy joke? Matter derived from consciousness?
01:00:05 What Spirit is like, what Spirit is not, and the direct experience of Spirit…
01:01:30 A shift in theoretical biology: the impact of mental activity on genomes.
01:05:20 Mainstream science's approach to anomalous phenomena. Future trends & tendencies.
01:09:42 Why take anomalous phenomena seriously? Advice for students and young scientists.
01:11:05 Why mystical & spiritual experiences are problematic for science.
01:18:03 Mind-brain relationship: is our mind limited to our brain? The role of the brain.
01:24:36 Physiological conditions correlated with psychedelics. The Subliminal Self vs. the everyday Self. Similarity to the effects of meditation.
01:27:30 Where are memories stored? Not in the brain at all?
01:28:50 Who or what survives the death of the physical body: the evidence. Is there karma? Individual vs. Universal Consciousness.
01:34:15 Change is upon us! Exciting times we live in!
01:35:30 Books and online resources.
```

```vtt
WEBVTT

00:00:00.240 --> 00:00:05.200
Professor<00:00:00.241> Ed<00:00:00.242> Kelly<00:00:00.243> has<00:00:00.244> spent<00:00:00.245> a<00:00:00.246> lifetime<00:00:00.247> studying<00:00:00.248> and<00:00:00.249> collecting<00:00:00.250> compelling<00:00:00.251> evidence

00:00:05.200 --> 00:00:13.840
on<00:00:05.201> phenomena<00:00:05.202> such<00:00:05.203> as<00:00:05.204> telepathy,<00:00:05.205> precognition,<00:00:05.206> and<00:00:05.207> [music]<00:00:05.208> reincarnation.<00:00:05.209> Enough<00:00:05.210> evidence<00:00:05.211> has

00:00:13.840 --> 00:00:19.920
accumulated<00:00:13.841> from<00:00:13.842> case<00:00:13.843> and<00:00:13.844> field<00:00:13.845> studies,<00:00:13.846> plus<00:00:13.847> a<00:00:13.848> couple<00:00:13.849> of<00:00:13.850> thousand<00:00:13.851> experimental<00:00:13.852> studies,<00:00:13.853> to

00:00:19.920 --> 00:00:25.840
convince<00:00:19.921> any<00:00:19.922> reasonably<00:00:19.923> open-minded<00:00:19.924> person<00:00:19.925> that<00:00:19.926> these<00:00:19.927> phenomena<00:00:19.928> exist<00:00:19.929> as<00:00:19.930> facts<00:00:19.931> of<00:00:19.932> nature.

00:00:25.840 --> 00:00:32.480
Is<00:00:25.841> consciousness<00:00:25.842> fundamental?<00:00:25.843> Some<00:00:25.844> kind<00:00:25.845> of<00:00:25.846> highest<00:00:25.847> consciousness<00:00:25.848> is<00:00:25.849> primary.

00:00:32.480 --> 00:00:36.880
Everything<00:00:32.481> else<00:00:32.482> has<00:00:32.483> to<00:00:32.484> come<00:00:32.485> from<00:00:32.486> that<00:00:32.487> somehow,<00:00:32.488> instead<00:00:32.489> of<00:00:32.490> this<00:00:32.491> minute<00:00:32.492> physical

00:00:36.880 --> 00:00:43.200
stuff.<00:00:36.881> Matter,<00:00:36.882> as<00:00:36.883> classically<00:00:36.884> conceived,<00:00:36.885> does<00:00:36.886> not<00:00:36.887> exist.<00:00:36.888> How<00:00:36.889> does<00:00:36.890> mainstream<00:00:36.891> science<00:00:36.892> deal

00:00:43.200 --> 00:00:48.240
with<00:00:43.201> anomalous<00:00:43.202> phenomena<00:00:43.203> today?<00:00:43.204> It's,<00:00:43.205> it's<00:00:43.206> really<00:00:43.207> an<00:00:43.208> embarrassment.<00:00:43.209> For<00:00:43.210> the<00:00:43.211> most<00:00:43.212> part,

00:00:48.240 --> 00:00:55.840
ignored<00:00:48.241> entirely.<00:00:48.242> Even<00:00:48.243> when<00:00:48.244> people<00:00:48.245> pay<00:00:48.246> attention<00:00:48.247> to<00:00:48.248> them,<00:00:48.249> it's<00:00:48.250> usually<00:00:48.251> to<00:00:48.252> marginalize<00:00:48.253> and<00:00:48.254> pathologize<00:00:48.255> them.

00:00:55.840 --> 00:01:02.400
Our<00:00:55.841> egoism,<00:00:55.842> our<00:00:55.843> consumerism,<00:00:55.844> our<00:00:55.845> plundering<00:00:55.846> of<00:00:55.847> the<00:00:55.848> planet,<00:00:55.849> I<00:00:55.850> think<00:00:55.851> all<00:00:55.852> has<00:00:55.853> deep<00:00:55.854> roots<00:00:55.855> in<00:00:55.856> the

00:01:02.400 --> 00:01:09.120
kind<00:01:02.401> of<00:01:02.402> worldview<00:01:02.403> that<00:01:02.404> has<00:01:02.405> dominated<00:01:02.406> until<00:01:02.407> right<00:01:02.408> about<00:01:02.409> now.<00:01:02.410> I<00:01:02.411> don't<00:01:02.412> see<00:01:02.413> any<00:01:02.414> reason<00:01:02.415> why

00:01:09.120 --> 00:01:16.240
we<00:01:09.121> cannot<00:01:09.122> get<00:01:09.123> deep<00:01:09.124> into<00:01:09.125> spiritual<00:01:09.126> matters<00:01:09.127> with<00:01:09.128> the<00:01:09.129> tools<00:01:09.130> of<00:01:09.131> science.<00:01:09.132> What<00:01:09.133> this<00:01:09.134> will<00:01:09.135> ultimately

00:01:16.240 --> 00:01:24.400
force<00:01:16.241> is<00:01:16.242> a<00:01:16.243> massive<00:01:16.244> overhaul<00:01:16.245> in<00:01:16.246> our<00:01:16.247> science-based<00:01:16.248> picture<00:01:16.249> of<00:01:16.250> reality.<00:01:16.251> I<00:01:16.252> think<00:01:16.253> the<00:01:16.254> battle<00:01:16.255> is<00:01:16.256> over.<00:01:16.257> In

00:01:24.400 --> 00:01:32.880
fact,<00:01:24.401> has<00:01:24.402> been<00:01:24.403> over<00:01:24.404> for<00:01:24.405> a<00:01:24.406> while.<00:01:24.407> It's<00:01:24.408> just<00:01:24.409> that<00:01:24.410> most<00:01:24.411> of<00:01:24.412> the<00:01:24.413> combatants<00:01:24.414> aren't<00:01:24.415> aware<00:01:24.416> of<00:01:24.417> it<00:01:24.418> yet.

00:01:32.880 --> 00:01:37.760
Welcome<00:01:32.881> to<00:01:32.882> Essentia<00:01:32.883> Foundation<00:01:32.884> channel.<00:01:32.885> Thank<00:01:32.886> you<00:01:32.887> for<00:01:32.888> watching.<00:01:32.889> Today,<00:01:32.890> I<00:01:32.891> will<00:01:32.892> be<00:01:32.893> speaking<00:01:32.894> with

00:01:37.760 --> 00:01:45.040
Dr.<00:01:37.761> Edward<00:01:37.762> Kelly<00:01:37.763> about<00:01:37.764> his<00:01:37.765> psychical<00:01:37.766> research,<00:01:37.767> his<00:01:37.768> philosophical<00:01:37.769> and<00:01:37.770> scientific<00:01:37.771> views.<00:01:37.772> Hello,

00:01:45.040 --> 00:01:50.480
Ed,<00:01:45.041> welcome<00:01:45.042> and<00:01:45.043> thank<00:01:45.044> you<00:01:45.045> very<00:01:45.046> much<00:01:45.047> for<00:01:45.048> taking<00:01:45.049> the<00:01:45.050> time<00:01:45.051> for<00:01:45.052> this<00:01:45.053> interview.<00:01:45.054> Thanks<00:01:45.055> for<00:01:45.056> having

00:01:50.480 --> 00:01:56.320
me.<00:01:50.481> You've<00:01:50.482> been<00:01:50.483> researching<00:01:50.484> psychical<00:01:50.485> phenomena<00:01:50.486> and<00:01:50.487> altered<00:01:50.488> states<00:01:50.489> of<00:01:50.490> consciousness<00:01:50.491> for<00:01:50.492> over

00:01:56.320 --> 00:02:02.000
20<00:01:56.321> years.<00:01:56.322> Your<00:01:56.323> background<00:01:56.324> is<00:01:56.325> in<00:01:56.326> experimental<00:01:56.327> psychology<00:01:56.328> and<00:01:56.329> neuroscience,<00:01:56.330> and<00:01:56.331> you<00:01:56.332> are<00:01:56.333> a

00:02:02.000 --> 00:02:08.160
research<00:02:02.001> professor<00:02:02.002> in<00:02:02.003> the<00:02:02.004> Division<00:02:02.005> of<00:02:02.006> Perceptual<00:02:02.007> Studies<00:02:02.008> at<00:02:02.009> the<00:02:02.010> University<00:02:02.011> of<00:02:02.012> Virginia.<00:02:02.013> So<00:02:02.014> I<00:02:02.015> wanted

00:02:08.160 --> 00:02:15.200
to<00:02:08.161> ask<00:02:08.162> you,<00:02:08.163> what<00:02:08.164> has<00:02:08.165> your<00:02:08.166> lifelong<00:02:08.167> research<00:02:08.168> shown?<00:02:08.169> Is<00:02:08.170> consciousness<00:02:08.171> a<00:02:08.172> byproduct<00:02:08.173> of<00:02:08.174> brain<00:02:08.175> activity

00:02:15.200 --> 00:02:25.920
or<00:02:15.201> the<00:02:15.202> mind<00:02:15.203> is<00:02:15.204> primary<00:02:15.205> to<00:02:15.206> matter?<00:02:15.207> And<00:02:15.208> is<00:02:15.209> there<00:02:15.210> reliable<00:02:15.211> evidence<00:02:15.212> that<00:02:15.213> led<00:02:15.214> you<00:02:15.215> to<00:02:15.216> your<00:02:15.217> conclusions?

00:02:25.920 --> 00:02:34.720
Wow,<00:02:25.921> that's<00:02:25.922> a<00:02:25.923> whopper.<00:02:25.924> Um,<00:02:25.925> yeah,<00:02:25.926> maybe<00:02:25.927> I<00:02:25.928> should,<00:02:25.929> uh,<00:02:25.930> kind<00:02:25.931> of<00:02:25.932> sketch<00:02:25.933> the<00:02:25.934> history<00:02:25.935> of<00:02:25.936> this<00:02:25.937> a<00:02:25.938> little<00:02:25.939> bit.

00:02:34.720 --> 00:02:43.440
Uh,<00:02:34.721> I,<00:02:34.722> uh,<00:02:34.723> I<00:02:34.724> started<00:02:34.725> in,<00:02:34.726> in<00:02:34.727> psychical<00:02:34.728> research<00:02:34.729> right<00:02:34.730> out<00:02:34.731> of<00:02:34.732> graduate<00:02:34.733> school,<00:02:34.734> basically.<00:02:34.735> I,<00:02:34.736> I

00:02:43.440 --> 00:02:50.400
did<00:02:43.441> a<00:02:43.442> postdoc<00:02:43.443> and,<00:02:43.444> uh,<00:02:43.445> during<00:02:43.446> that<00:02:43.447> time,<00:02:43.448> I,<00:02:43.449> late<00:02:43.450> in<00:02:43.451> graduate<00:02:43.452> school,<00:02:43.453> I<00:02:43.454> had<00:02:43.455> become<00:02:43.456> interested<00:02:43.457> in

00:02:50.400 --> 00:02:58.880
experimental<00:02:50.401> parapsychology.<00:02:50.402> Uh,<00:02:50.403> it<00:02:50.404> turned<00:02:50.405> out<00:02:50.406> that<00:02:50.407> my<00:02:50.408> older<00:02:50.409> sister,<00:02:50.410> my<00:02:50.411> only<00:02:50.412> sibling,<00:02:50.413> had<00:02:50.414> developed

00:02:58.880 --> 00:03:05.680
mediumistic<00:02:58.881> abilities,<00:02:58.882> and<00:02:58.883> my<00:02:58.884> mother<00:02:58.885> had,<00:02:58.886> uh,<00:02:58.887> been<00:02:58.888> nervous<00:02:58.889> about<00:02:58.890> that<00:02:58.891> and<00:02:58.892> inquired<00:02:58.893> with<00:02:58.894> me<00:02:58.895> since<00:02:58.896> I

00:03:05.680 --> 00:03:11.440
was<00:03:05.681> a<00:03:05.682> graduate<00:03:05.683> student<00:03:05.684> in<00:03:05.685> psychology.<00:03:05.686> So<00:03:05.687> I<00:03:05.688> went<00:03:05.689> to<00:03:05.690> the<00:03:05.691> library.<00:03:05.692> I<00:03:05.693> knew<00:03:05.694> nothing<00:03:05.695> about<00:03:05.696> the<00:03:05.697> subject,

00:03:11.440 --> 00:03:18.000
discovered<00:03:11.441> for<00:03:11.442> the<00:03:11.443> first<00:03:11.444> time<00:03:11.445> that<00:03:11.446> there's<00:03:11.447> this<00:03:11.448> whole<00:03:11.449> body<00:03:11.450> of<00:03:11.451> experimental<00:03:11.452> research,<00:03:11.453> uh,<00:03:11.454> using

00:03:18.000 --> 00:03:25.280
the<00:03:18.001> same<00:03:18.002> kinds<00:03:18.003> of<00:03:18.004> methods<00:03:18.005> that<00:03:18.006> we<00:03:18.007> were<00:03:18.008> being<00:03:18.009> taught<00:03:18.010> to<00:03:18.011> study<00:03:18.012> garden-variety<00:03:18.013> things,<00:03:18.014> uh,<00:03:18.015> using

00:03:25.280 --> 00:03:31.520
those<00:03:25.281> methods<00:03:25.282> to<00:03:25.283> study<00:03:25.284> things<00:03:25.285> that<00:03:25.286> seem<00:03:25.287> to<00:03:25.288> be<00:03:25.289> impossible<00:03:25.290> if<00:03:25.291> the<00:03:25.292> prevailing<00:03:25.293> picture<00:03:25.294> of<00:03:25.295> reality,

00:03:31.520 --> 00:03:39.680
science-based<00:03:31.521> picture<00:03:31.522> of<00:03:31.523> reality,<00:03:31.524> were<00:03:31.525> correct.<00:03:31.526> Uh,<00:03:31.527> so<00:03:31.528> I<00:03:31.529> was<00:03:31.530> intrigued<00:03:31.531> by<00:03:31.532> that.<00:03:31.533> I<00:03:31.534> began<00:03:31.535> corresponding

00:03:39.680 --> 00:03:47.280
with<00:03:39.681> J.B.<00:03:39.682> Rhine<00:03:39.683> down<00:03:39.684> in<00:03:39.685> Durham,<00:03:39.686> North<00:03:39.687> Carolina.<00:03:39.688> Uh,<00:03:39.689> he<00:03:39.690> had<00:03:39.691> a<00:03:39.692> little<00:03:39.693> research<00:03:39.694> institute.<00:03:39.695> He<00:03:39.696> had<00:03:39.697> left<00:03:39.698> Duke

00:03:47.280 --> 00:03:53.920
University<00:03:47.281> at<00:03:47.282> that<00:03:47.283> point,<00:03:47.284> uh,<00:03:47.285> but<00:03:47.286> this<00:03:47.287> was<00:03:47.288> still<00:03:47.289> kind<00:03:47.290> of<00:03:47.291> the,<00:03:47.292> certainly<00:03:47.293> the<00:03:47.294> American<00:03:47.295> center<00:03:47.296> of

00:03:53.920 --> 00:04:02.720
experimental<00:03:53.921> parapsychology.<00:03:53.922> And<00:03:53.923> so,<00:03:53.924> uh,<00:03:53.925> after<00:03:53.926> moving<00:03:53.927> down<00:03:53.928> to<00:03:53.929> North<00:03:53.930> Carolina<00:03:53.931> and<00:03:53.932> writing<00:03:53.933> a<00:03:53.934> book<00:03:53.935> based

00:04:02.720 --> 00:04:12.240
on<00:04:02.721> my<00:04:02.722> dissertation,<00:04:02.723> I<00:04:02.724> went<00:04:02.725> to<00:04:02.726> work<00:04:02.727> for<00:04:02.728> him<00:04:02.729> in,<00:04:02.730> uh,<00:04:02.731> January<00:04:02.732> of<00:04:02.733> 1972.<00:04:02.734> Uh,<00:04:02.735> and<00:04:02.736> at<00:04:02.737> that<00:04:02.738> time,<00:04:02.739> I'd<00:04:02.740> have<00:04:02.741> to

00:04:12.240 --> 00:04:17.280
say<00:04:12.241> I<00:04:12.242> was<00:04:12.243> pretty<00:04:12.244> convinced<00:04:12.245> already<00:04:12.246> that<00:04:12.247> these<00:04:12.248> phenomena<00:04:12.249> must<00:04:12.250> be<00:04:12.251> real.<00:04:12.252> I'd<00:04:12.253> read<00:04:12.254> enough<00:04:12.255> of<00:04:12.256> the

00:04:17.280 --> 00:04:26.480
literature<00:04:17.281> during<00:04:17.282> my<00:04:17.283> supposed<00:04:17.284> postdoc,<00:04:17.285> uh,<00:04:17.286> to<00:04:17.287> be<00:04:17.288> pretty<00:04:17.289> persuaded.<00:04:17.290> It<00:04:17.291> really<00:04:17.292> looked<00:04:17.293> as<00:04:17.294> though<00:04:17.295> the

00:04:26.480 --> 00:04:34.080
phenomena<00:04:26.481> must<00:04:26.482> be<00:04:26.483> real.<00:04:26.484> But<00:04:26.485> then<00:04:26.486> I<00:04:26.487> had,<00:04:26.488> within<00:04:26.489> six<00:04:26.490> weeks<00:04:26.491> of<00:04:26.492> arriving<00:04:26.493> at<00:04:26.494> Rhine's<00:04:26.495> place,<00:04:26.496> I<00:04:26.497> met<00:04:26.498> a

00:04:34.080 --> 00:04:41.200
guy<00:04:34.081> who<00:04:34.082> was<00:04:34.083> certainly<00:04:34.084> one<00:04:34.085> of<00:04:34.086> the<00:04:34.087> best<00:04:34.088> subjects<00:04:34.089> ever<00:04:34.090> to<00:04:34.091> appear<00:04:34.092> in<00:04:34.093> a<00:04:34.094> parapsychology<00:04:34.095> laboratory.

00:04:41.200 --> 00:04:47.200
This<00:04:41.201> guy<00:04:41.202> could<00:04:41.203> do<00:04:41.204> pretty<00:04:41.205> much<00:04:41.206> anything<00:04:41.207> we<00:04:41.208> asked<00:04:41.209> him<00:04:41.210> to<00:04:41.211> do,<00:04:41.212> often<00:04:41.213> to<00:04:41.214> extreme<00:04:41.215> levels<00:04:41.216> of<00:04:41.217> statistical

00:04:47.200 --> 00:04:54.880
success,<00:04:47.201> and<00:04:47.202> he<00:04:47.203> essentially<00:04:47.204> erased<00:04:47.205> any<00:04:47.206> residual<00:04:47.207> doubts<00:04:47.208> I<00:04:47.209> had<00:04:47.210> about<00:04:47.211> the<00:04:47.212> reality<00:04:47.213> of<00:04:47.214> the<00:04:47.215> phenomena.

00:04:54.880 --> 00:05:02.240
Um,<00:04:54.881> I<00:04:54.882> mean,<00:04:54.883> the<00:04:54.884> very<00:04:54.885> first<00:04:54.886> day<00:04:54.887> he<00:04:54.888> arrived<00:04:54.889> at<00:04:54.890> the<00:04:54.891> lab,<00:04:54.892> um,<00:04:54.893> we<00:04:54.894> had,<00:04:54.895> at<00:04:54.896> the<00:04:54.897> time,<00:04:54.898> our<00:04:54.899> director

00:05:02.240 --> 00:05:10.560
of<00:05:02.241> research<00:05:02.242> was<00:05:02.243> Helmut<00:05:02.244> Schmidt.<00:05:02.245> Uh,<00:05:02.246> he<00:05:02.247> was<00:05:02.248> a<00:05:02.249> former,<00:05:02.250> he's<00:05:02.251> a<00:05:02.252> physicist,<00:05:02.253> former<00:05:02.254> researcher<00:05:02.255> at<00:05:02.256> Boeing<00:05:02.257> in

00:05:10.560 --> 00:05:18.000
uh<00:05:10.561> Seattle,<00:05:10.562> had<00:05:10.563> recently<00:05:10.564> taken<00:05:10.565> over<00:05:10.566> as<00:05:10.567> director<00:05:10.568> of<00:05:10.569> research<00:05:10.570> for<00:05:10.571> Rhine.<00:05:10.572> Uh,<00:05:10.573> during<00:05:10.574> the<00:05:10.575> time<00:05:10.576> he<00:05:10.577> was

00:05:18.000 --> 00:05:27.360
at<00:05:18.001> Boeing,<00:05:18.002> he<00:05:18.003> had<00:05:18.004> constructed<00:05:18.005> a,<00:05:18.006> an<00:05:18.007> electronic<00:05:18.008> test<00:05:18.009> device.<00:05:18.010> This<00:05:18.011> was<00:05:18.012> a<00:05:18.013> box.<00:05:18.014> It<00:05:18.015> had,<00:05:18.016> uh,<00:05:18.017> four<00:05:18.018> big<00:05:18.019> colored

00:05:27.360 --> 00:05:33.840
buttons<00:05:27.361> and<00:05:27.362> four<00:05:27.363> correspondingly<00:05:27.364> colored<00:05:27.365> lights,<00:05:27.366> and<00:05:27.367> the<00:05:27.368> subject's<00:05:27.369> task<00:05:27.370> is,<00:05:27.371> of<00:05:27.372> course,<00:05:27.373> to<00:05:27.374> guess<00:05:27.375> which

00:05:33.840 --> 00:05:40.720
one<00:05:33.841> the<00:05:33.842> machine<00:05:33.843> will<00:05:33.844> pick<00:05:33.845> as<00:05:33.846> the<00:05:33.847> target.<00:05:33.848> And<00:05:33.849> the<00:05:33.850> way<00:05:33.851> it<00:05:33.852> did<00:05:33.853> that<00:05:33.854> was<00:05:33.855> extremely<00:05:33.856> sophisticated.<00:05:33.857> Had<00:05:33.858> a

00:05:40.720 --> 00:05:47.840
uh,<00:05:40.721> uh,<00:05:40.722> a<00:05:40.723> four-position<00:05:40.724> switch<00:05:40.725> that's<00:05:40.726> going<00:05:40.727> around<00:05:40.728> and<00:05:40.729> around<00:05:40.730> at<00:05:40.731> a<00:05:40.732> very<00:05:40.733> high<00:05:40.734> rate.<00:05:40.735> And<00:05:40.736> after<00:05:40.737> the

00:05:47.840 --> 00:05:55.600
subject<00:05:47.841> re-<00:05:47.842> pushed<00:05:47.843> a<00:05:47.844> button<00:05:47.845> corresponding<00:05:47.846> to<00:05:47.847> his<00:05:47.848> guess,<00:05:47.849> the<00:05:47.850> circuitry<00:05:47.851> would<00:05:47.852> change<00:05:47.853> such<00:05:47.854> that<00:05:47.855> when

00:05:55.600 --> 00:06:02.080
a<00:05:55.601> decay<00:05:55.602> particle<00:05:55.603> arrived<00:05:55.604> from<00:05:55.605> a<00:05:55.606> piece<00:05:55.607> of<00:05:55.608> strontium<00:05:55.609> inside<00:05:55.610> the<00:05:55.611> machine,<00:05:55.612> it<00:05:55.613> would<00:05:55.614> interrupt<00:05:55.615> the<00:05:55.616> stepping

00:06:02.080 --> 00:06:08.880
of<00:06:02.081> that<00:06:02.082> switch<00:06:02.083> and<00:06:02.084> pick<00:06:02.085> the<00:06:02.086> target.<00:06:02.087> And<00:06:02.088> in<00:06:02.089> the<00:06:02.090> absence<00:06:02.091> of<00:06:02.092> a<00:06:02.093> subject,<00:06:02.094> this<00:06:02.095> thing<00:06:02.096> always<00:06:02.097> exemplified

00:06:08.880 --> 00:06:16.080
the<00:06:08.881> expected<00:06:08.882> chance<00:06:08.883> behavior.<00:06:08.884> Now,<00:06:08.885> Helmut<00:06:08.886> had<00:06:08.887> spent<00:06:08.888> a<00:06:08.889> couple<00:06:08.890> of<00:06:08.891> years<00:06:08.892> looking<00:06:08.893> for<00:06:08.894> people<00:06:08.895> who<00:06:08.896> could<00:06:08.897> do

00:06:16.080 --> 00:06:23.440
better<00:06:16.081> than<00:06:16.082> that<00:06:16.083> 25%.<00:06:16.084> Uh,<00:06:16.085> and<00:06:16.086> he<00:06:16.087> had<00:06:16.088> found<00:06:16.089> a<00:06:16.090> couple<00:06:16.091> of<00:06:16.092> people<00:06:16.093> who<00:06:16.094> could<00:06:16.095> reliably<00:06:16.096> score<00:06:16.097> either<00:06:16.098> a<00:06:16.099> little

00:06:23.440 --> 00:06:32.640
bit<00:06:23.441> above<00:06:23.442> or<00:06:23.443> a<00:06:23.444> little<00:06:23.445> bit<00:06:23.446> below<00:06:23.447> chance,<00:06:23.448> couple<00:06:23.449> of<00:06:23.450> percent.<00:06:23.451> Anyway,<00:06:23.452> this<00:06:23.453> fellow<00:06:23.454> comes<00:06:23.455> into<00:06:23.456> our<00:06:23.457> library,

00:06:32.640 --> 00:06:37.840
he<00:06:32.641> sees<00:06:32.642> the<00:06:32.643> machines<00:06:32.644> sitting<00:06:32.645> there<00:06:32.646> on<00:06:32.647> the<00:06:32.648> table<00:06:32.649> and<00:06:32.650> says,<00:06:32.651> "What's<00:06:32.652> that?"<00:06:32.653> And<00:06:32.654> Helmut<00:06:32.655> explained<00:06:32.656> it

00:06:37.840 --> 00:06:44.400
to<00:06:37.841> him<00:06:37.842> anyway.<00:06:37.843> And<00:06:37.844> so<00:06:37.845> he<00:06:37.846> then<00:06:37.847> began<00:06:37.848> to<00:06:37.849> tell<00:06:37.850> us<00:06:37.851> his<00:06:37.852> life<00:06:37.853> story,<00:06:37.854> and<00:06:37.855> every<00:06:37.856> so<00:06:37.857> often<00:06:37.858> he'd<00:06:37.859> reach<00:06:37.860> out<00:06:37.861> and

00:06:44.400 --> 00:06:53.440
push<00:06:44.401> a<00:06:44.402> button,<00:06:44.403> and<00:06:44.404> it<00:06:44.405> quickly<00:06:44.406> became<00:06:44.407> apparent<00:06:44.408> that<00:06:44.409> he<00:06:44.410> was<00:06:44.411> doing<00:06:44.412> way<00:06:44.413> better<00:06:44.414> than<00:06:44.415> 25%.<00:06:44.416> And<00:06:44.417> I<00:06:44.418> could<00:06:44.419> see

00:06:53.440 --> 00:07:00.240
Helmut's<00:06:53.441> eyes<00:06:53.442> kind<00:06:53.443> of<00:06:53.444> getting<00:06:53.445> bigger<00:06:53.446> and<00:06:53.447> bigger.<00:06:53.448> And,<00:06:53.449> uh,<00:06:53.450> by<00:06:53.451> the<00:06:53.452> end<00:06:53.453> of<00:06:53.454> the<00:06:53.455> hour,<00:06:53.456> he<00:06:53.457> had<00:06:53.458> 180<00:06:53.459> hits

00:07:00.240 --> 00:07:09.120
in<00:07:00.241> 508<00:07:00.242> trials,<00:07:00.243> which<00:07:00.244> is<00:07:00.245> a<00:07:00.246> bit<00:07:00.247> over<00:07:00.248> 35%,<00:07:00.249> where<00:07:00.250> 25%<00:07:00.251> is<00:07:00.252> expected.<00:07:00.253> And<00:07:00.254> when<00:07:00.255> you<00:07:00.256> do<00:07:00.257> the<00:07:00.258> math<00:07:00.259> on<00:07:00.260> that,<00:07:00.261> it

00:07:09.120 --> 00:07:14.720
turns<00:07:09.121> out<00:07:09.122> that<00:07:09.123> something<00:07:09.124> that<00:07:09.125> good<00:07:09.126> or<00:07:09.127> better<00:07:09.128> would<00:07:09.129> happen<00:07:09.130> by<00:07:09.131> chance<00:07:09.132> like<00:07:09.133> one<00:07:09.134> in<00:07:09.135> a<00:07:09.136> million<00:07:09.137> times<00:07:09.138> or

00:07:14.720 --> 00:07:20.880
something<00:07:14.721> of<00:07:14.722> that<00:07:14.723> sort.<00:07:14.724> So<00:07:14.725> we<00:07:14.726> might<00:07:14.727> have<00:07:14.728> sat<00:07:14.729> there<00:07:14.730> for<00:07:14.731> a<00:07:14.732> million<00:07:14.733> such<00:07:14.734> hours<00:07:14.735> before<00:07:14.736> seeing<00:07:14.737> something

00:07:20.880 --> 00:07:27.280
like<00:07:20.881> that<00:07:20.882> happened<00:07:20.883> by<00:07:20.884> chance.<00:07:20.885> And<00:07:20.886> that<00:07:20.887> was<00:07:20.888> really<00:07:20.889> just<00:07:20.890> the<00:07:20.891> beginning<00:07:20.892> with<00:07:20.893> this<00:07:20.894> guy.<00:07:20.895> I,<00:07:20.896> I've<00:07:20.897> seen<00:07:20.898> him

00:07:27.280 --> 00:07:34.640
score<00:07:27.281> at<00:07:27.282> rates<00:07:27.283> close<00:07:27.284> to<00:07:27.285> 50%<00:07:27.286> for<00:07:27.287> hundreds<00:07:27.288> of<00:07:27.289> trials.<00:07:27.290> Uh,<00:07:27.291> he<00:07:27.292> also<00:07:27.293> turned<00:07:27.294> out<00:07:27.295> to<00:07:27.296> be<00:07:27.297> able<00:07:27.298> to<00:07:27.299> guess<00:07:27.300> playing

00:07:34.640 --> 00:07:42.720
cards<00:07:34.641> at<00:07:34.642> about<00:07:34.643> three<00:07:34.644> times<00:07:34.645> chance<00:07:34.646> expectation<00:07:34.647> or<00:07:34.648> thousands<00:07:34.649> of<00:07:34.650> trials,<00:07:34.651> that<00:07:34.652> sort<00:07:34.653> of<00:07:34.654> thing,<00:07:34.655> far<00:07:34.656> beyond

00:07:42.720 --> 00:07:50.880
what<00:07:42.721> would<00:07:42.722> you<00:07:42.723> could<00:07:42.724> expect<00:07:42.725> to<00:07:42.726> happen<00:07:42.727> by<00:07:42.728> chance,<00:07:42.729> very<00:07:42.730> far<00:07:42.731> beyond.<00:07:42.732> Period.<00:07:42.733> I<00:07:42.734> mean,<00:07:42.735> and,<00:07:42.736> and<00:07:42.737> in<00:07:42.738> multiple

00:07:50.880 --> 00:07:58.000
experimental<00:07:50.881> contexts.<00:07:50.882> Yeah,<00:07:50.883> let<00:07:50.884> me<00:07:50.885> just<00:07:50.886> say<00:07:50.887> in<00:07:50.888> general,<00:07:50.889> I<00:07:50.890> mean,<00:07:50.891> I<00:07:50.892> have<00:07:50.893> no<00:07:50.894> idea<00:07:50.895> who<00:07:50.896> we're<00:07:50.897> talking<00:07:50.898> to

00:07:58.000 --> 00:08:05.200
here<00:07:58.001> or<00:07:58.002> what<00:07:58.003> they<00:07:58.004> might<00:07:58.005> know<00:07:58.006> about<00:07:58.007> parapsychology,<00:07:58.008> uh,<00:07:58.009> but<00:07:58.010> I<00:07:58.011> would<00:07:58.012> say<00:07:58.013> simply<00:07:58.014> to<00:07:58.015> summarize<00:07:58.016> that<00:07:58.017> whole

00:08:05.200 --> 00:08:14.720
dimension<00:08:05.201> of<00:08:05.202> the<00:08:05.203> subject,<00:08:05.204> that<00:08:05.205> in<00:08:05.206> the<00:08:05.207> past<00:08:05.208> 150<00:08:05.209> or<00:08:05.210> so<00:08:05.211> years,<00:08:05.212> enough<00:08:05.213> evidence<00:08:05.214> has<00:08:05.215> accumulated<00:08:05.216> from

00:08:14.720 --> 00:08:21.760
case<00:08:14.721> and<00:08:14.722> field<00:08:14.723> studies,<00:08:14.724> plus<00:08:14.725> a<00:08:14.726> couple<00:08:14.727> of<00:08:14.728> thousand<00:08:14.729> experimental<00:08:14.730> studies,<00:08:14.731> to<00:08:14.732> convince<00:08:14.733> any<00:08:14.734> reasonably

00:08:21.760 --> 00:08:28.480
open-minded<00:08:21.761> person<00:08:21.762> who<00:08:21.763> takes<00:08:21.764> the<00:08:21.765> trouble<00:08:21.766> to<00:08:21.767> study<00:08:21.768> it<00:08:21.769> that<00:08:21.770> these<00:08:21.771> phenomena<00:08:21.772> exist<00:08:21.773> as<00:08:21.774> facts<00:08:21.775> of<00:08:21.776> nature.

00:08:28.480 --> 00:08:36.480
Period.<00:08:28.481> And<00:08:28.482> that<00:08:28.483> our<00:08:28.484> science<00:08:28.485> will<00:08:28.486> have<00:08:28.487> to<00:08:28.488> expand<00:08:28.489> in<00:08:28.490> some<00:08:28.491> way<00:08:28.492> that<00:08:28.493> permits<00:08:28.494> it<00:08:28.495> to<00:08:28.496> accommodate<00:08:28.497> them.<00:08:28.498> And<00:08:28.499> I

00:08:36.480 --> 00:08:44.720
think<00:08:36.481> you<00:08:36.482> can<00:08:36.483> take<00:08:36.484> that<00:08:36.485> to<00:08:36.486> the<00:08:36.487> bank.<00:08:36.488> Uh,<00:08:36.489> it's<00:08:36.490> a<00:08:36.491> very<00:08:36.492> big<00:08:36.493> literature.<00:08:36.494> It's<00:08:36.495> not<00:08:36.496> a<00:08:36.497> simple<00:08:36.498> thing<00:08:36.499> to<00:08:36.500> learn

00:08:44.720 --> 00:08:54.000
about<00:08:44.721> it,<00:08:44.722> but<00:08:44.723> there<00:08:44.724> are<00:08:44.725> plenty<00:08:44.726> of<00:08:44.727> good<00:08:44.728> summaries<00:08:44.729> out<00:08:44.730> there,<00:08:44.731> lots<00:08:44.732> of,<00:08:44.733> uh,<00:08:44.734> popular<00:08:44.735> and<00:08:44.736> scientific<00:08:44.737> books.

00:08:54.000 --> 00:09:04.160
Um,<00:08:54.001> anyway,<00:08:54.002> that<00:08:54.003> was<00:08:54.004> what<00:08:54.005> started<00:08:54.006> me<00:08:54.007> on<00:08:54.008> this<00:08:54.009> path.<00:08:54.010> And<00:08:54.011> I<00:08:54.012> think,<00:08:54.013> uh,<00:08:54.014> like<00:08:54.015> most<00:08:54.016> people<00:08:54.017> coming<00:08:54.018> to<00:08:54.019> the

00:09:04.160 --> 00:09:10.560
subject<00:09:04.161> from<00:09:04.162> the<00:09:04.163> scientific<00:09:04.164> side,<00:09:04.165> I<00:09:04.166> really<00:09:04.167> hoped<00:09:04.168> at<00:09:04.169> the<00:09:04.170> beginning<00:09:04.171> that<00:09:04.172> some<00:09:04.173> little<00:09:04.174> adjustment

00:09:10.560 --> 00:09:17.360
somewhere<00:09:10.561> in<00:09:10.562> our<00:09:10.563> scientific<00:09:10.564> scheme<00:09:10.565> of<00:09:10.566> things,<00:09:10.567> uh,<00:09:10.568> would<00:09:10.569> make<00:09:10.570> all<00:09:10.571> these<00:09:10.572> problems<00:09:10.573> go<00:09:10.574> away<00:09:10.575> and

00:09:17.360 --> 00:09:28.240
you<00:09:17.361> know,<00:09:17.362> enable<00:09:17.363> our,<00:09:17.364> our<00:09:17.365> system<00:09:17.366> to<00:09:17.367> be<00:09:17.368> healed,<00:09:17.369> so<00:09:17.370> to<00:09:17.371> speak.<00:09:17.372> But<00:09:17.373> as<00:09:17.374> time<00:09:17.375> has<00:09:17.376> gone<00:09:17.377> by,<00:09:17.378> I've<00:09:17.379> become<00:09:17.380> more

00:09:28.240 --> 00:09:39.040
and<00:09:28.241> more<00:09:28.242> convinced<00:09:28.243> that,<00:09:28.244> uh,<00:09:28.245> there<00:09:28.246> really<00:09:28.247> is<00:09:28.248> no<00:09:28.249> simple<00:09:28.250> fix,<00:09:28.251> and,<00:09:28.252> and<00:09:28.253> that,<00:09:28.254> uh,<00:09:28.255> what,<00:09:28.256> what<00:09:28.257> this<00:09:28.258> will

00:09:39.040 --> 00:09:47.440
ultimately<00:09:39.041> force<00:09:39.042> is<00:09:39.043> a<00:09:39.044> massive<00:09:39.045> overhaul<00:09:39.046> in<00:09:39.047> our<00:09:39.048> science-based<00:09:39.049> picture<00:09:39.050> of<00:09:39.051> reality.<00:09:39.052> Now,<00:09:39.053> it's<00:09:39.054> taken

00:09:47.440 --> 00:09:51.680
me<00:09:47.441> a<00:09:47.442> long<00:09:47.443> time<00:09:47.444> to<00:09:47.445> get<00:09:47.446> there.<00:09:47.447> And<00:09:47.448> by<00:09:47.449> the<00:09:47.450> way,<00:09:47.451> I've<00:09:47.452> been<00:09:47.453> at<00:09:47.454> this<00:09:47.455> for<00:09:47.456> over<00:09:47.457> 50<00:09:47.458> years,<00:09:47.459> not<00:09:47.460> 20

00:09:51.680 --> 00:09:59.840
years.<00:09:51.681> I<00:09:51.682> started<00:09:51.683> in<00:09:51.684> 1972<00:09:51.685> with<00:09:51.686> Rhine.<00:09:51.687> I<00:09:51.688> had<00:09:51.689> a<00:09:51.690> long,<00:09:51.691> uh,<00:09:51.692> digression<00:09:51.693> in<00:09:51.694> the<00:09:51.695> middle<00:09:51.696> of<00:09:51.697> my<00:09:51.698> career.<00:09:51.699> I,<00:09:51.700> I<00:09:51.701> had

00:09:59.840 --> 00:10:05.760
two<00:09:59.841> children<00:09:59.842> at<00:09:59.843> the<00:09:59.844> time,<00:09:59.845> had<00:09:59.846> to<00:09:59.847> feed<00:09:59.848> them,<00:09:59.849> wasn't<00:09:59.850> making<00:09:59.851> any<00:09:59.852> money<00:09:59.853> in<00:09:59.854> parapsychology,<00:09:59.855> so<00:09:59.856> I<00:09:59.857> had<00:09:59.858> to<00:09:59.859> go

00:10:05.760 --> 00:10:14.000
back<00:10:05.761> into<00:10:05.762> mainstream<00:10:05.763> type<00:10:05.764> research.<00:10:05.765> And<00:10:05.766> I<00:10:05.767> did<00:10:05.768> that<00:10:05.769> at<00:10:05.770> the<00:10:05.771> University<00:10:05.772> of<00:10:05.773> North<00:10:05.774> Carolina,<00:10:05.775> doing,<00:10:05.776> uh,<00:10:05.777> uh,

00:10:14.000 --> 00:10:23.360
neuroimaging<00:10:14.001> studies<00:10:14.002> of<00:10:14.003> somatosensation<00:10:14.004> in<00:10:14.005> humans.<00:10:14.006> Uh,<00:10:14.007> these<00:10:14.008> are<00:10:14.009> tactile<00:10:14.010> stimuli,<00:10:14.011> especially<00:10:14.012> vibrations

00:10:23.360 --> 00:10:29.200
applied<00:10:23.361> to<00:10:23.362> fingers<00:10:23.363> and<00:10:23.364> things<00:10:23.365> like<00:10:23.366> that.<00:10:23.367> We,<00:10:23.368> we<00:10:23.369> had<00:10:23.370> a<00:10:23.371> large<00:10:23.372> neuroscience<00:10:23.373> group<00:10:23.374> there,<00:10:23.375> and<00:10:23.376> I<00:10:23.377> worked<00:10:23.378> at

00:10:29.200 --> 00:10:37.200
that<00:10:29.201> for<00:10:29.202> about<00:10:29.203> 14<00:10:29.204> years<00:10:29.205> in<00:10:29.206> the<00:10:29.207> middle<00:10:29.208> of<00:10:29.209> my<00:10:29.210> career.<00:10:29.211> Then<00:10:29.212> came<00:10:29.213> back<00:10:29.214> to,<00:10:29.215> uh,<00:10:29.216> well,<00:10:29.217> moved<00:10:29.218> to<00:10:29.219> Virginia<00:10:29.220> where

00:10:37.200 --> 00:10:45.520
I<00:10:37.201> am<00:10:37.202> now.<00:10:37.203> Came<00:10:37.204> here<00:10:37.205> in<00:10:37.206> 2003,<00:10:37.207> and<00:10:37.208> that<00:10:37.209> was<00:10:37.210> because<00:10:37.211> I<00:10:37.212> had<00:10:37.213> remarried<00:10:37.214> a<00:10:37.215> woman<00:10:37.216> who<00:10:37.217> was<00:10:37.218> working<00:10:37.219> with<00:10:37.220> Ian

00:10:45.520 --> 00:10:55.520
Stevenson,<00:10:45.521> who<00:10:45.522> is<00:10:45.523> the<00:10:45.524> founder<00:10:45.525> of<00:10:45.526> our<00:10:45.527> division.<00:10:45.528> Ian,<00:10:45.529> you<00:10:45.530> probably<00:10:45.531> know,<00:10:45.532> is<00:10:45.533> best<00:10:45.534> known,<00:10:45.535> uh,<00:10:45.536> for<00:10:45.537> his

00:10:55.520 --> 00:11:03.200
development<00:10:55.521> of<00:10:55.522> a<00:10:55.523> new<00:10:55.524> line<00:10:55.525> of<00:10:55.526> research<00:10:55.527> related<00:10:55.528> to<00:10:55.529> the<00:10:55.530> possibility<00:10:55.531> of<00:10:55.532> post-mortem<00:10:55.533> survival.<00:10:55.534> That<00:10:55.535> is,

00:11:03.200 --> 00:11:09.440
uh,<00:11:03.201> cases<00:11:03.202> involving<00:11:03.203> small<00:11:03.204> children<00:11:03.205> who<00:11:03.206> begin<00:11:03.207> speaking<00:11:03.208> or<00:11:03.209> acting<00:11:03.210> as<00:11:03.211> though<00:11:03.212> they're<00:11:03.213> experiencing

00:11:09.440 --> 00:11:16.000
something<00:11:09.441> from<00:11:09.442> a<00:11:09.443> previous<00:11:09.444> life<00:11:09.445> that<00:11:09.446> happened<00:11:09.447> recently<00:11:09.448> enough<00:11:09.449> that<00:11:09.450> you<00:11:09.451> can<00:11:09.452> actually<00:11:09.453> go<00:11:09.454> check,

00:11:16.000 --> 00:11:23.120
see<00:11:16.001> whether<00:11:16.002> they<00:11:16.003> really<00:11:16.004> do<00:11:16.005> know<00:11:16.006> things<00:11:16.007> they<00:11:16.008> would<00:11:16.009> have<00:11:16.010> no<00:11:16.011> normal<00:11:16.012> way<00:11:16.013> of<00:11:16.014> knowing.<00:11:16.015> And<00:11:16.016> Ian<00:11:16.017> eventually,

00:11:23.120 --> 00:11:33.120
u,<00:11:23.121> uh,<00:11:23.122> and<00:11:23.123> his<00:11:23.124> colleagues<00:11:23.125> found<00:11:23.126> something<00:11:23.127> over<00:11:23.128> 2,500<00:11:23.129> such<00:11:23.130> cases,<00:11:23.131> of<00:11:23.132> which<00:11:23.133> about<00:11:23.134> 2,200<00:11:23.135> are<00:11:23.136> now<00:11:23.137> entered

00:11:33.120 --> 00:11:40.880
into<00:11:33.121> a<00:11:33.122> big<00:11:33.123> database<00:11:33.124> at,<00:11:33.125> at<00:11:33.126> our<00:11:33.127> division,<00:11:33.128> DOPS,<00:11:33.129> Division<00:11:33.130> of<00:11:33.131> Perceptual<00:11:33.132> Studies.<00:11:33.133> I<00:11:33.134> want<00:11:33.135> to<00:11:33.136> hear<00:11:33.137> your

00:11:40.880 --> 00:11:49.440
your<00:11:40.881> conclusion<00:11:40.882> from<00:11:40.883> the<00:11:40.884> whole<00:11:40.885> experience<00:11:40.886> that<00:11:40.887> you've<00:11:40.888> had.<00:11:40.889> Are<00:11:40.890> you<00:11:40.891> at<00:11:40.892> some<00:11:40.893> point<00:11:40.894> became<00:11:40.895> convinced

00:11:49.440 --> 00:11:55.520
that<00:11:49.441> consciousness<00:11:49.442> is<00:11:49.443> not<00:11:49.444> a<00:11:49.445> byproduct<00:11:49.446> of<00:11:49.447> brain<00:11:49.448> activity,<00:11:49.449> or<00:11:49.450> are<00:11:49.451> you<00:11:49.452> still<00:11:49.453> doubting<00:11:49.454> that,<00:11:49.455> or<00:11:49.456> are

00:11:55.520 --> 00:12:01.680
you<00:11:55.521> saying<00:11:55.522> with<00:11:55.523> 100%<00:11:55.524> certainty,<00:11:55.525> in<00:11:55.526> my<00:11:55.527> experience<00:11:55.528> and<00:11:55.529> as<00:11:55.530> a<00:11:55.531> researcher,<00:11:55.532> you<00:11:55.533> know,<00:11:55.534> for<00:11:55.535> what<00:11:55.536> over<00:11:55.537> 30

00:12:01.680 --> 00:12:09.920
years<00:12:01.681> you<00:12:01.682> say<00:12:01.683> you're<00:12:01.684> doing<00:12:01.685> this<00:12:01.686> research,<00:12:01.687> uh,<00:12:01.688> mind<00:12:01.689> is<00:12:01.690> primary<00:12:01.691> to<00:12:01.692> matter?<00:12:01.693> What<00:12:01.694> is<00:12:01.695> your<00:12:01.696> conclusion?

00:12:09.920 --> 00:12:18.400
Well,<00:12:09.921> I'm<00:12:09.922> definitely<00:12:09.923> in<00:12:09.924> the<00:12:09.925> idealist<00:12:09.926> camp<00:12:09.927> at<00:12:09.928> this<00:12:09.929> point.<00:12:09.930> Uh,<00:12:09.931> I<00:12:09.932> became<00:12:09.933> convinced.<00:12:09.934> I<00:12:09.935> mean,<00:12:09.936> there's,<00:12:09.937> yeah,<00:12:09.938> let<00:12:09.939> me

00:12:18.400 --> 00:12:26.800
go<00:12:18.401> back<00:12:18.402> just<00:12:18.403> a<00:12:18.404> step<00:12:18.405> here.<00:12:18.406> Um,<00:12:18.407> the,<00:12:18.408> the,<00:12:18.409> the<00:12:18.410> picture<00:12:18.411> of<00:12:18.412> the<00:12:18.413> world<00:12:18.414> that<00:12:18.415> is<00:12:18.416> challenged<00:12:18.417> by<00:12:18.418> the<00:12:18.419> existence

00:12:26.800 --> 00:12:35.760
of<00:12:26.801> these<00:12:26.802> paranormal<00:12:26.803> or<00:12:26.804> psi<00:12:26.805> phenomena<00:12:26.806> that<00:12:26.807> I<00:12:26.808> was<00:12:26.809> studying<00:12:26.810> experimentally<00:12:26.811> way<00:12:26.812> back<00:12:26.813> at<00:12:26.814> the<00:12:26.815> beginning

00:12:35.760 --> 00:12:42.960
um,<00:12:35.761> is<00:12:35.762> what's<00:12:35.763> generally<00:12:35.764> known<00:12:35.765> as<00:12:35.766> physicalism.<00:12:35.767> It's<00:12:35.768> a<00:12:35.769> kind<00:12:35.770> of<00:12:35.771> austere<00:12:35.772> modern<00:12:35.773> descendant<00:12:35.774> of<00:12:35.775> the

00:12:42.960 --> 00:12:49.360
materialism<00:12:42.961> of<00:12:42.962> previous<00:12:42.963> centuries.<00:12:42.964> And<00:12:42.965> it<00:12:42.966> says,<00:12:42.967> it's<00:12:42.968> the<00:12:42.969> kind<00:12:42.970> of<00:12:42.971> stuff<00:12:42.972> that<00:12:42.973> we<00:12:42.974> all<00:12:42.975> learned<00:12:42.976> growing<00:12:42.977> up

00:12:49.360 --> 00:12:59.440
in<00:12:49.361> school,<00:12:49.362> that,<00:12:49.363> uh,<00:12:49.364> reality<00:12:49.365> exists<00:12:49.366> independent<00:12:49.367> of<00:12:49.368> us,<00:12:49.369> um,<00:12:49.370> um,<00:12:49.371> space<00:12:49.372> and<00:12:49.373> time,<00:12:49.374> if<00:12:49.375> have<00:12:49.376> been<00:12:49.377> there<00:12:49.378> from

00:12:59.440 --> 00:13:05.600
the<00:12:59.441> beginning<00:12:59.442> as<00:12:59.443> a<00:12:59.444> kind<00:12:59.445> of<00:12:59.446> container<00:12:59.447> in<00:12:59.448> which<00:12:59.449> things<00:12:59.450> can<00:12:59.451> happen.<00:12:59.452> Uh,<00:12:59.453> reality<00:12:59.454> consists<00:12:59.455> at<00:12:59.456> bottom

00:13:05.600 --> 00:13:17.360
of<00:13:05.601> some<00:13:05.602> kind<00:13:05.603> of<00:13:05.604> ultimate<00:13:05.605> tiny<00:13:05.606> stuff,<00:13:05.607> self-existent,<00:13:05.608> unconscious,<00:13:05.609> um,<00:13:05.610> no<00:13:05.611> sentience<00:13:05.612> of<00:13:05.613> any<00:13:05.614> kind,<00:13:05.615> uh,<00:13:05.616> moving

00:13:17.360 --> 00:13:24.720
around<00:13:17.361> in<00:13:17.362> accordance<00:13:17.363> with<00:13:17.364> mathematical<00:13:17.365> laws<00:13:17.366> under<00:13:17.367> the<00:13:17.368> influence<00:13:17.369> of<00:13:17.370> fields<00:13:17.371> of<00:13:17.372> force.<00:13:17.373> And<00:13:17.374> everything

00:13:24.720 --> 00:13:31.040
else<00:13:24.721> that<00:13:24.722> exists,<00:13:24.723> including<00:13:24.724> our<00:13:24.725> minds<00:13:24.726> and<00:13:24.727> consciousness,<00:13:24.728> is<00:13:24.729> built<00:13:24.730> somehow<00:13:24.731> from<00:13:24.732> that<00:13:24.733> ultimate

00:13:31.040 --> 00:13:41.120
stuff,<00:13:31.041> whatever<00:13:31.042> it<00:13:31.043> is.<00:13:31.044> And<00:13:31.045> it's<00:13:31.046> changed,<00:13:31.047> of<00:13:31.048> course,<00:13:31.049> over<00:13:31.050> the<00:13:31.051> centuries.<00:13:31.052> Um,<00:13:31.053> so,<00:13:31.054> uh,<00:13:31.055> everything<00:13:31.056> in<00:13:31.057> mind<00:13:31.058> and

00:13:41.120 --> 00:13:48.800
consciousness<00:13:41.121> is<00:13:41.122> manufactured<00:13:41.123> by<00:13:41.124> neurophysiological<00:13:41.125> processes<00:13:41.126> in<00:13:41.127> our<00:13:41.128> brains.<00:13:41.129> We're,<00:13:41.130> we're<00:13:41.131> nothing<00:13:41.132> but

00:13:48.800 --> 00:13:57.440
immensely<00:13:48.801> complicated<00:13:48.802> biological<00:13:48.803> machines.<00:13:48.804> Uh,<00:13:48.805> when<00:13:48.806> the<00:13:48.807> machinery<00:13:48.808> dies,<00:13:48.809> consciousness,<00:13:48.810> personality<00:13:48.811> are

00:13:57.440 --> 00:14:04.000
necessarily<00:13:57.441> extinguished.<00:13:57.442> There<00:13:57.443> can't<00:13:57.444> be<00:13:57.445> anything<00:13:57.446> like<00:13:57.447> post-mortem<00:13:57.448> survival.<00:13:57.449> Period.

00:14:04.000 --> 00:14:12.800
Um,<00:14:04.001> that's<00:14:04.002> the<00:14:04.003> basic<00:14:04.004> physicalist<00:14:04.005> picture.<00:14:04.006> Uh,<00:14:04.007> psi<00:14:04.008> phenomena<00:14:04.009> are<00:14:04.010> one<00:14:04.011> of<00:14:04.012> the<00:14:04.013> things

00:14:12.800 --> 00:14:18.720
that<00:14:12.801> challenge<00:14:12.802> it,<00:14:12.803> but<00:14:12.804> hardly<00:14:12.805> the<00:14:12.806> only<00:14:12.807> things.<00:14:12.808> And<00:14:12.809> this<00:14:12.810> is<00:14:12.811> where<00:14:12.812> I<00:14:12.813> made<00:14:12.814> my<00:14:12.815> turn<00:14:12.816> toward<00:14:12.817> the

00:14:18.720 --> 00:14:29.760
theory<00:14:18.721> side.<00:14:18.722> This<00:14:18.723> happened<00:14:18.724> actually<00:14:18.725> in<00:14:18.726> 1998.<00:14:18.727> Uh,<00:14:18.728> by<00:14:18.729> that<00:14:18.730> time,<00:14:18.731> I<00:14:18.732> had,<00:14:18.733> uh,<00:14:18.734> married<00:14:18.735> Emily,<00:14:18.736> my<00:14:18.737> wife,<00:14:18.738> who<00:14:18.739> is

00:14:29.760 --> 00:14:36.480
uh,<00:14:29.761> was<00:14:29.762> working<00:14:29.763> with<00:14:29.764> Ian<00:14:29.765> Stevenson<00:14:29.766> and<00:14:29.767> moved<00:14:29.768> to<00:14:29.769> Charlottesville,<00:14:29.770> actually<00:14:29.771> in<00:14:29.772> 2003.

00:14:36.480 --> 00:14:43.120
But<00:14:36.481> in<00:14:36.482> 1998,<00:14:36.483> the<00:14:36.484> year<00:14:36.485> that,<00:14:36.486> uh,<00:14:36.487> Emily<00:14:36.488> and<00:14:36.489> I<00:14:36.490> were<00:14:36.491> married,<00:14:36.492> we<00:14:36.493> were<00:14:36.494> also<00:14:36.495> invited<00:14:36.496> by<00:14:36.497> Mike

00:14:43.120 --> 00:14:49.920
Murphy,<00:14:43.121> the<00:14:43.122> co-founder<00:14:43.123> of<00:14:43.124> Esalen<00:14:43.125> Institute,<00:14:43.126> to<00:14:43.127> participate<00:14:43.128> in<00:14:43.129> a<00:14:43.130> new<00:14:43.131> fellowship<00:14:43.132> that<00:14:43.133> Mike<00:14:43.134> was

00:14:49.920 --> 00:14:56.960
creating<00:14:49.921> specifically<00:14:49.922> to<00:14:49.923> look<00:14:49.924> at<00:14:49.925> the<00:14:49.926> evidence<00:14:49.927> for<00:14:49.928> post-mortem<00:14:49.929> survival.<00:14:49.930> Now,<00:14:49.931> I<00:14:49.932> should<00:14:49.933> say<00:14:49.934> a<00:14:49.935> little<00:14:49.936> bit

00:14:56.960 --> 00:15:04.800
about<00:14:56.961> Mike<00:14:56.962> Murphy.<00:14:56.963> He's<00:14:56.964> a<00:14:56.965> really<00:14:56.966> extraordinary<00:14:56.967> character,<00:14:56.968> a<00:14:56.969> Renaissance<00:14:56.970> man,<00:14:56.971> right<00:14:56.972> in<00:14:56.973> the

00:15:04.800 --> 00:15:12.960
uh<00:15:04.801> lineage<00:15:04.802> of<00:15:04.803> the<00:15:04.804> founders<00:15:04.805> of<00:15:04.806> the<00:15:04.807> Society<00:15:04.808> for<00:15:04.809> Psychical<00:15:04.810> Research<00:15:04.811> in<00:15:04.812> 1882<00:15:04.813> in<00:15:04.814> England.<00:15:04.815> I<00:15:04.816> mean,<00:15:04.817> he

00:15:12.960 --> 00:15:21.280
uh<00:15:12.961> he<00:15:12.962> had<00:15:12.963> read<00:15:12.964> the<00:15:12.965> masterwork<00:15:12.966> of<00:15:12.967> F.W.H.<00:15:12.968> Myers,<00:15:12.969> one<00:15:12.970> of<00:15:12.971> the<00:15:12.972> founders,<00:15:12.973> Human<00:15:12.974> Personality<00:15:12.975> and<00:15:12.976> Its<00:15:12.977> Survival

00:15:21.280 --> 00:15:30.800
of<00:15:21.281> Bodily<00:15:21.282> Death,<00:15:21.283> a<00:15:21.284> 1,400-page<00:15:21.285> two-volume<00:15:21.286> treatise<00:15:21.287> in<00:15:21.288> which<00:15:21.289> Myers<00:15:21.290> put<00:15:21.291> together<00:15:21.292> all<00:15:21.293> the<00:15:21.294> evidence<00:15:21.295> that

00:15:30.800 --> 00:15:38.800
he<00:15:30.801> and<00:15:30.802> his<00:15:30.803> colleagues<00:15:30.804> had<00:15:30.805> been<00:15:30.806> able<00:15:30.807> to<00:15:30.808> assemble<00:15:30.809> up<00:15:30.810> to<00:15:30.811> that<00:15:30.812> point<00:15:30.813> and<00:15:30.814> to<00:15:30.815> advance<00:15:30.816> a<00:15:30.817> theory<00:15:30.818> of

00:15:38.800 --> 00:15:51.520
human<00:15:38.801> personality<00:15:38.802> that<00:15:38.803> is<00:15:38.804> quite<00:15:38.805> different<00:15:38.806> from<00:15:38.807> the<00:15:38.808> kind<00:15:38.809> of<00:15:38.810> thing<00:15:38.811> we<00:15:38.812> have<00:15:38.813> now.<00:15:38.814> Um,<00:15:38.815> and<00:15:38.816> um,<00:15:38.817> among

00:15:51.520 --> 00:16:01.360
his<00:15:51.521> colleagues<00:15:51.522> was<00:15:51.523> William<00:15:51.524> James,<00:15:51.525> the<00:15:51.526> American<00:15:51.527> psychologist<00:15:51.528> and<00:15:51.529> philosopher.<00:15:51.530> Uh,<00:15:51.531> they<00:15:51.532> were<00:15:51.533> friends

00:16:01.360 --> 00:16:10.400
and<00:16:01.361> colleagues.<00:16:01.362> James<00:16:01.363> greatly<00:16:01.364> admired<00:16:01.365> Myers's<00:16:01.366> work,<00:16:01.367> wasn't<00:16:01.368> entirely<00:16:01.369> convinced<00:16:01.370> by<00:16:01.371> it<00:16:01.372> early<00:16:01.373> on,

00:16:10.400 --> 00:16:22.720
uh<00:16:10.401> but<00:16:10.402> ultimately<00:16:10.403> advanced<00:16:10.404> his<00:16:10.405> own<00:16:10.406> metaphysical<00:16:10.407> picture<00:16:10.408> that<00:16:10.409> built<00:16:10.410> upon<00:16:10.411> Myers's<00:16:10.412> work.<00:16:10.413> Now,<00:16:10.414> before

00:16:22.720 --> 00:16:30.720
I<00:16:22.721> get<00:16:22.722> to<00:16:22.723> that,<00:16:22.724> let<00:16:22.725> me<00:16:22.726> say<00:16:22.727> a<00:16:22.728> little<00:16:22.729> bit<00:16:22.730> more<00:16:22.731> about<00:16:22.732> this<00:16:22.733> uh<00:16:22.734> fellowship<00:16:22.735> that<00:16:22.736> we<00:16:22.737> created<00:16:22.738> at<00:16:22.739> Esalen.

00:16:30.720 --> 00:16:38.800
Um,<00:16:30.721> as<00:16:30.722> I<00:16:30.723> mentioned,<00:16:30.724> the<00:16:30.725> the<00:16:30.726> original<00:16:30.727> intent<00:16:30.728> was<00:16:30.729> simply<00:16:30.730> to<00:16:30.731> look<00:16:30.732> at<00:16:30.733> evidence<00:16:30.734> for<00:16:30.735> survival<00:16:30.736> and<00:16:30.737> to

00:16:38.800 --> 00:16:45.280
that<00:16:38.801> end,<00:16:38.802> Mike<00:16:38.803> had<00:16:38.804> brought<00:16:38.805> together<00:16:38.806> about<00:16:38.807> 20<00:16:38.808> people<00:16:38.809> from<00:16:38.810> across<00:16:38.811> the<00:16:38.812> planet<00:16:38.813> that<00:16:38.814> he<00:16:38.815> knew<00:16:38.816> were<00:16:38.817> actually

00:16:45.280 --> 00:16:52.560
working<00:16:45.281> in<00:16:45.282> this<00:16:45.283> area.<00:16:45.284> Uh,<00:16:45.285> Mike<00:16:45.286> was<00:16:45.287> perfectly<00:16:45.288> well<00:16:45.289> aware<00:16:45.290> that<00:16:45.291> if<00:16:45.292> the<00:16:45.293> prevailing<00:16:45.294> picture<00:16:45.295> is<00:16:45.296> correct,

00:16:52.560 --> 00:16:57.440
there<00:16:52.561> can't<00:16:52.562> be<00:16:52.563> any<00:16:52.564> survival,<00:16:52.565> and<00:16:52.566> he<00:16:52.567> also<00:16:52.568> knew<00:16:52.569> that<00:16:52.570> here<00:16:52.571> were<00:16:52.572> these<00:16:52.573> people<00:16:52.574> here<00:16:52.575> and<00:16:52.576> there<00:16:52.577> who

00:16:57.440 --> 00:17:03.520
apparently<00:16:57.441> producing<00:16:57.442> evidence<00:16:57.443> supporting<00:16:57.444> the<00:16:57.445> idea,<00:16:57.446> so<00:16:57.447> he<00:16:57.448> wanted<00:16:57.449> to<00:16:57.450> hear<00:16:57.451> about<00:16:57.452> all<00:16:57.453> that<00:16:57.454> in<00:16:57.455> his<00:16:57.456> typical

00:17:03.520 --> 00:17:10.800
way,<00:17:03.521> and<00:17:03.522> he<00:17:03.523> organized<00:17:03.524> this<00:17:03.525> fellowship.<00:17:03.526> So<00:17:03.527> the<00:17:03.528> the<00:17:03.529> setup<00:17:03.530> was<00:17:03.531> that<00:17:03.532> we<00:17:03.533> would<00:17:03.534> go<00:17:03.535> to<00:17:03.536> Esalen<00:17:03.537> for<00:17:03.538> a<00:17:03.539> week

00:17:10.800 --> 00:17:18.800
each<00:17:10.801> year,<00:17:10.802> as<00:17:10.803> it<00:17:10.804> turned<00:17:10.805> out,<00:17:10.806> and<00:17:10.807> it<00:17:10.808> went<00:17:10.809> on<00:17:10.810> much<00:17:10.811> longer<00:17:10.812> than<00:17:10.813> originally<00:17:10.814> expected.<00:17:10.815> And<00:17:10.816> Esalen<00:17:10.817> is<00:17:10.818> kind

00:17:18.800 --> 00:17:25.120
of<00:17:18.801> perched<00:17:18.802> on<00:17:18.803> a<00:17:18.804> cliff<00:17:18.805> over<00:17:18.806> the<00:17:18.807> Pacific<00:17:18.808> Ocean.<00:17:18.809> It's<00:17:18.810> a<00:17:18.811> fantastically<00:17:18.812> beautiful<00:17:18.813> place,<00:17:18.814> one<00:17:18.815> of

00:17:25.120 --> 00:17:34.240
Mike's<00:17:25.121> many<00:17:25.122> accomplishments,<00:17:25.123> creating<00:17:25.124> that<00:17:25.125> place.<00:17:25.126> Uh,<00:17:25.127> yeah,<00:17:25.128> amazing<00:17:25.129> guy.<00:17:25.130> Anyway,<00:17:25.131> so<00:17:25.132> uh<00:17:25.133> we<00:17:25.134> did<00:17:25.135> that<00:17:25.136> for<00:17:25.137> the

00:17:34.240 --> 00:17:40.560
first<00:17:34.241> two<00:17:34.242> years<00:17:34.243> we<00:17:34.244> mainly<00:17:34.245> presented<00:17:34.246> and<00:17:34.247> discussed<00:17:34.248> various<00:17:34.249> kinds<00:17:34.250> of<00:17:34.251> evidence<00:17:34.252> for<00:17:34.253> survival,<00:17:34.254> and<00:17:34.255> at<00:17:34.256> the

00:17:40.560 --> 00:17:48.640
end<00:17:40.561> of<00:17:40.562> that<00:17:40.563> second<00:17:40.564> meeting,<00:17:40.565> uh<00:17:40.566> it<00:17:40.567> had<00:17:40.568> become<00:17:40.569> clear<00:17:40.570> that<00:17:40.571> while<00:17:40.572> we<00:17:40.573> had<00:17:40.574> some<00:17:40.575> somewhat<00:17:40.576> differing<00:17:40.577> views

00:17:48.640 --> 00:17:57.760
about<00:17:48.641> survival<00:17:48.642> itself,<00:17:48.643> some<00:17:48.644> convinced,<00:17:48.645> others<00:17:48.646> not,<00:17:48.647> we<00:17:48.648> were<00:17:48.649> all<00:17:48.650> completely<00:17:48.651> convinced<00:17:48.652> that<00:17:48.653> physicalism,<00:17:48.654> the

00:17:57.760 --> 00:18:04.000
prevailing<00:17:57.761> picture—I<00:17:57.762> mean,<00:17:57.763> this<00:17:57.764> is<00:17:57.765> the<00:17:57.766> received<00:17:57.767> wisdom<00:17:57.768> of<00:17:57.769> opinion<00:17:57.770> elites<00:17:57.771> all<00:17:57.772> over<00:17:57.773> the<00:17:57.774> planet,

00:18:04.000 --> 00:18:10.800
including<00:18:04.001> main<00:18:04.002> central<00:18:04.003> parts<00:18:04.004> of<00:18:04.005> the<00:18:04.006> American,<00:18:04.007> certainly,<00:18:04.008> uh<00:18:04.009> scientific<00:18:04.010> establishment,

00:18:10.800 --> 00:18:21.520
non-physicists<00:18:10.801> mainly—um,<00:18:10.802> so<00:18:10.803> we<00:18:10.804> were<00:18:10.805> convinced<00:18:10.806> that<00:18:10.807> physicalism<00:18:10.808> has<00:18:10.809> to<00:18:10.810> go,<00:18:10.811> and<00:18:10.812> we<00:18:10.813> decided<00:18:10.814> that

00:18:21.520 --> 00:18:27.920
we<00:18:21.521> would<00:18:21.522> assault<00:18:21.523> it<00:18:21.524> in<00:18:21.525> a<00:18:21.526> two-stage<00:18:21.527> process.<00:18:21.528> In<00:18:21.529> the<00:18:21.530> first<00:18:21.531> stage,<00:18:21.532> we<00:18:21.533> wanted<00:18:21.534> to<00:18:21.535> put<00:18:21.536> together<00:18:21.537> a

00:18:27.920 --> 00:18:37.920
whole<00:18:27.921> bunch<00:18:27.922> of<00:18:27.923> empirical<00:18:27.924> evidence<00:18:27.925> against<00:18:27.926> or<00:18:27.927> things<00:18:27.928> that<00:18:27.929> physicalism<00:18:27.930> uh<00:18:27.931> could<00:18:27.932> not<00:18:27.933> explain.

00:18:37.920 --> 00:18:45.520
Um,<00:18:37.921> well,<00:18:37.922> let<00:18:37.923> me<00:18:37.924> let<00:18:37.925> me<00:18:37.926> go<00:18:37.927> back<00:18:37.928> one<00:18:37.929> step<00:18:37.930> further<00:18:37.931> even.<00:18:37.932> I<00:18:37.933> mean,<00:18:37.934> the<00:18:37.935> the<00:18:37.936> philosophical<00:18:37.937> context<00:18:37.938> here,<00:18:37.939> the

00:18:45.520 --> 00:18:53.440
mind-brain<00:18:45.521> relation,<00:18:45.522> everybody<00:18:45.523> agrees<00:18:45.524> that<00:18:45.525> normally<00:18:45.526> uh<00:18:45.527> physical<00:18:45.528> things<00:18:45.529> and<00:18:45.530> mental<00:18:45.531> things<00:18:45.532> go<00:18:45.533> together

00:18:53.440 --> 00:19:01.040
pretty<00:18:53.441> well,<00:18:53.442> and<00:18:53.443> furthermore,<00:18:53.444> we<00:18:53.445> can<00:18:53.446> be<00:18:53.447> absolutely<00:18:53.448> sure<00:18:53.449> that<00:18:53.450> there<00:18:53.451> is<00:18:53.452> physical-to-mental<00:18:53.453> causation.

00:19:01.040 --> 00:19:08.080
I<00:19:01.041> mean,<00:19:01.042> if<00:19:01.043> you<00:19:01.044> get<00:19:01.045> hit<00:19:01.046> in<00:19:01.047> the<00:19:01.048> head<00:19:01.049> hard<00:19:01.050> enough<00:19:01.051> or<00:19:01.052> drink<00:19:01.053> too<00:19:01.054> much<00:19:01.055> or<00:19:01.056> ingest<00:19:01.057> a<00:19:01.058> psychedelic<00:19:01.059> or

00:19:08.080 --> 00:19:13.760
grow<00:19:08.081> a<00:19:08.082> invasive<00:19:08.083> brain<00:19:08.084> tumor<00:19:08.085> or<00:19:08.086> something<00:19:08.087> of<00:19:08.088> that<00:19:08.089> sort,<00:19:08.090> mental<00:19:08.091> things<00:19:08.092> will<00:19:08.093> change.<00:19:08.094> We<00:19:08.095> know<00:19:08.096> that<00:19:08.097> for

00:19:13.760 --> 00:19:22.160
absolute<00:19:13.761> certain,<00:19:13.762> so<00:19:13.763> there<00:19:13.764> is<00:19:13.765> physical-to-mental<00:19:13.766> causation.<00:19:13.767> But<00:19:13.768> what<00:19:13.769> about<00:19:13.770> causation<00:19:13.771> in<00:19:13.772> the<00:19:13.773> other<00:19:13.774> direction?<00:19:13.775> Let's

00:19:22.160 --> 00:19:27.600
say<00:19:22.161> I'm<00:19:22.162> listening<00:19:22.163> to<00:19:22.164> a<00:19:22.165> lecture<00:19:22.166> by<00:19:22.167> a<00:19:22.168> physicist<00:19:22.169> and<00:19:22.170> I'm<00:19:22.171> getting<00:19:22.172> irritated<00:19:22.173> and<00:19:22.174> want<00:19:22.175> to<00:19:22.176> ask<00:19:22.177> a<00:19:22.178> question,

00:19:27.600 --> 00:19:35.920
so<00:19:27.601> I<00:19:27.602> raise<00:19:27.603> my<00:19:27.604> hand.<00:19:27.605> Isn't<00:19:27.606> that<00:19:27.607> mental-to-physical<00:19:27.608> causation?<00:19:27.609> It<00:19:27.610> certainly<00:19:27.611> seems<00:19:27.612> so,<00:19:27.613> naively.<00:19:27.614> Well,<00:19:27.615> no,

00:19:35.920 --> 00:19:41.600
says<00:19:35.921> the<00:19:35.922> physicist,<00:19:35.923> you<00:19:35.924> see,<00:19:35.925> you<00:19:35.926> just<00:19:35.927> misunderstood<00:19:35.928> the<00:19:35.929> causality<00:19:35.930> here<00:19:35.931> because<00:19:35.932> that,<00:19:35.933> you<00:19:35.934> know,<00:19:35.935> that

00:19:41.600 --> 00:19:49.680
uh<00:19:41.601> idea<00:19:41.602> and<00:19:41.603> that<00:19:41.604> urge<00:19:41.605> to<00:19:41.606> ask<00:19:41.607> a<00:19:41.608> question,<00:19:41.609> that's<00:19:41.610> those<00:19:41.611> things<00:19:41.612> are<00:19:41.613> all<00:19:41.614> just<00:19:41.615> physical<00:19:41.616> processes<00:19:41.617> in

00:19:49.680 --> 00:19:56.480
your<00:19:49.681> brain.<00:19:49.682> Physical<00:19:49.683> causes<00:19:49.684> physical,<00:19:49.685> no<00:19:49.686> problem.<00:19:49.687> The<00:19:49.688> mental<00:19:49.689> stuff<00:19:49.690> is<00:19:49.691> just<00:19:49.692> kind<00:19:49.693> of<00:19:49.694> there

00:19:56.480 --> 00:20:04.400
along<00:19:56.481> for<00:19:56.482> the<00:19:56.483> ride.<00:19:56.484> Now,<00:19:56.485> that<00:19:56.486> kind<00:19:56.487> of<00:19:56.488> argument<00:19:56.489> is<00:19:56.490> extremely<00:19:56.491> difficult<00:19:56.492> to<00:19:56.493> refute<00:19:56.494> in<00:19:56.495> normal<00:19:56.496> everyday

00:20:04.400 --> 00:20:11.440
kinds<00:20:04.401> of<00:20:04.402> contexts,<00:20:04.403> and<00:20:04.404> the<00:20:04.405> trick<00:20:04.406> is—and<00:20:04.407> this<00:20:04.408> is<00:20:04.409> what<00:20:04.410> Myers<00:20:04.411> was<00:20:04.412> trying<00:20:04.413> to<00:20:04.414> do<00:20:04.415> so<00:20:04.416> long<00:20:04.417> ago—is<00:20:04.418> to

00:20:11.440 --> 00:20:20.160
find<00:20:11.441> things<00:20:11.442> that<00:20:11.443> unaided<00:20:11.444> brains<00:20:11.445> cannot<00:20:11.446> accomplish,<00:20:11.447> that<00:20:11.448> resist<00:20:11.449> or<00:20:11.450> defy<00:20:11.451> explanation<00:20:11.452> in<00:20:11.453> conventional

00:20:20.160 --> 00:20:27.920
physical<00:20:20.161> terms.<00:20:20.162> So<00:20:20.163> top<00:20:20.164> of<00:20:20.165> any<00:20:20.166> such<00:20:20.167> list,<00:20:20.168> of<00:20:20.169> course,<00:20:20.170> is<00:20:20.171> all<00:20:20.172> the<00:20:20.173> psi<00:20:20.174> phenomena.<00:20:20.175> That's<00:20:20.176> what<00:20:20.177> makes<00:20:20.178> them

00:20:27.920 --> 00:20:35.920
so<00:20:27.921> objectionable<00:20:27.922> to<00:20:27.923> lots<00:20:27.924> of<00:20:27.925> mainstream<00:20:27.926> scientists,<00:20:27.927> especially<00:20:27.928> those<00:20:27.929> for<00:20:27.930> whom<00:20:27.931> physicalism<00:20:27.932> is<00:20:27.933> a<00:20:27.934> kind<00:20:27.935> of

00:20:35.920 --> 00:20:42.960
secular<00:20:35.921> religion.<00:20:35.922> For<00:20:35.923> people<00:20:35.924> like<00:20:35.925> that,<00:20:35.926> to<00:20:35.927> to<00:20:35.928> even<00:20:35.929> suggest<00:20:35.930> anything<00:20:35.931> different<00:20:35.932> is<00:20:35.933> to<00:20:35.934> uh<00:20:35.935> commit<00:20:35.936> heresy

00:20:42.960 --> 00:20:52.560
and<00:20:42.961> invite<00:20:42.962> excommunication,<00:20:42.963> if<00:20:42.964> not<00:20:42.965> crucification.<00:20:42.966> It's<00:20:42.967> really<00:20:42.968> quite<00:20:42.969> astonishing<00:20:42.970> how<00:20:42.971> emotional<00:20:42.972> some

00:20:52.560 --> 00:21:01.520
people<00:20:52.561> can<00:20:52.562> get<00:20:52.563> about<00:20:52.564> these<00:20:52.565> matters.<00:20:52.566> Anyway,<00:20:52.567> uh<00:20:52.568> lots<00:20:52.569> of<00:20:52.570> psychologists<00:20:52.571> and<00:20:52.572> neuroscientists<00:20:52.573> would<00:20:52.574> like<00:20:52.575> to

00:21:01.520 --> 00:21:08.160
think<00:21:01.521> that,<00:21:01.522> well<00:21:01.523> okay,<00:21:01.524> this<00:21:01.525> parapsychology<00:21:01.526> stuff,<00:21:01.527> yeah,<00:21:01.528> it's<00:21:01.529> a<00:21:01.530> problem,<00:21:01.531> but<00:21:01.532> uh<00:21:01.533> there<00:21:01.534> are<00:21:01.535> lots<00:21:01.536> of

00:21:08.160 --> 00:21:12.560
questions<00:21:08.161> about<00:21:08.162> it,<00:21:08.163> maybe<00:21:08.164> we<00:21:08.165> can<00:21:08.166> just<00:21:08.167> kind<00:21:08.168> of<00:21:08.169> put<00:21:08.170> it<00:21:08.171> off<00:21:08.172> in<00:21:08.173> the<00:21:08.174> corner<00:21:08.175> somewhere,<00:21:08.176> ignore<00:21:08.177> it<00:21:08.178> and<00:21:08.179> go

00:21:12.560 --> 00:21:19.040
on<00:21:12.561> about<00:21:12.562> our<00:21:12.563> business.<00:21:12.564> But<00:21:12.565> in<00:21:12.566> fact,<00:21:12.567> there<00:21:12.568> are<00:21:12.569> lots<00:21:12.570> of<00:21:12.571> other<00:21:12.572> things<00:21:12.573> that<00:21:12.574> are<00:21:12.575> difficult<00:21:12.576> to<00:21:12.577> explain<00:21:12.578> in

00:21:19.040 --> 00:21:24.960
conventional<00:21:19.041> physical<00:21:19.042> terms,<00:21:19.043> and<00:21:19.044> so<00:21:19.045> we<00:21:19.046> sought<00:21:19.047> to<00:21:19.048> revisit<00:21:19.049> those,<00:21:19.050> a<00:21:19.051> number<00:21:19.052> of<00:21:19.053> which<00:21:19.054> Myers<00:21:19.055> had<00:21:19.056> worked

00:21:24.960 --> 00:21:33.280
on<00:21:24.961> 100-plus<00:21:24.962> years<00:21:24.963> ago,<00:21:24.964> uh<00:21:24.965> but<00:21:24.966> to<00:21:24.967> revisit<00:21:24.968> them<00:21:24.969> in<00:21:24.970> light<00:21:24.971> of<00:21:24.972> the<00:21:24.973> subsequent<00:21:24.974> century-plus<00:21:24.975> of<00:21:24.976> refereed

00:21:33.280 --> 00:21:39.760
biomedical<00:21:33.281> research<00:21:33.282> in<00:21:33.283> the<00:21:33.284> main.<00:21:33.285> And<00:21:33.286> so<00:21:33.287> we<00:21:33.288> did<00:21:33.289> that.<00:21:33.290> So<00:21:33.291> we<00:21:33.292> have<00:21:33.293> chapters<00:21:33.294> on<00:21:33.295> things<00:21:33.296> we<00:21:33.297> we<00:21:33.298> wrote<00:21:33.299> a<00:21:33.300> book

00:21:39.760 --> 00:21:46.400
eventually.<00:21:39.761> First<00:21:39.762> book<00:21:39.763> was<00:21:39.764> called<00:21:39.765> Irreducible<00:21:39.766> Mind,<00:21:39.767> in<00:21:39.768> which<00:21:39.769> we<00:21:39.770> collected<00:21:39.771> a<00:21:39.772> lot<00:21:39.773> of<00:21:39.774> this<00:21:39.775> stuff.

00:21:46.400 --> 00:21:53.920
Uh,<00:21:46.401> Emily's<00:21:46.402> got<00:21:46.403> a<00:21:46.404> great<00:21:46.405> chapter<00:21:46.406> in<00:21:46.407> that<00:21:46.408> book<00:21:46.409> on<00:21:46.410> uh<00:21:46.411> extreme<00:21:46.412> psychophysical<00:21:46.413> influence,<00:21:46.414> starting<00:21:46.415> in

00:21:53.920 --> 00:22:01.840
a<00:21:53.921> very<00:21:53.922> Myers-like<00:21:53.923> way<00:21:53.924> from<00:21:53.925> easy<00:21:53.926> stuff<00:21:53.927> where<00:21:53.928> the<00:21:53.929> physicalism<00:21:53.930> still<00:21:53.931> sounds<00:21:53.932> pretty<00:21:53.933> plausible,<00:21:53.934> but

00:22:01.840 --> 00:22:08.000
moving<00:22:01.841> progressively<00:22:01.842> toward<00:22:01.843> things<00:22:01.844> that<00:22:01.845> are<00:22:01.846> less<00:22:01.847> and<00:22:01.848> less<00:22:01.849> open<00:22:01.850> to<00:22:01.851> that<00:22:01.852> kind<00:22:01.853> of<00:22:01.854> approach,<00:22:01.855> things<00:22:01.856> like,

00:22:08.000 --> 00:22:20.240
for<00:22:08.001> example,<00:22:08.002> uh<00:22:08.003> hypnotic<00:22:08.004> blisters<00:22:08.005> or<00:22:08.006> stigmata,<00:22:08.007> in<00:22:08.008> which<00:22:08.009> uh<00:22:08.010> devout<00:22:08.011> Christians<00:22:08.012> with<00:22:08.013> vivid<00:22:08.014> imaginations

00:22:20.240 --> 00:22:26.480
uh<00:22:20.241> can<00:22:20.242> produce<00:22:20.243> upon<00:22:20.244> their<00:22:20.245> own<00:22:20.246> bodies<00:22:20.247> imitations<00:22:20.248> of<00:22:20.249> the<00:22:20.250> wounds<00:22:20.251> that<00:22:20.252> they<00:22:20.253> believed<00:22:20.254> Christ<00:22:20.255> suffered

00:22:26.480 --> 00:22:34.880
during<00:22:26.481> the<00:22:26.482> crucifixion.<00:22:26.483> Um,<00:22:26.484> there<00:22:26.485> was<00:22:26.486> another<00:22:26.487> uh<00:22:26.488> phenomenon<00:22:26.489> studied<00:22:26.490> by<00:22:26.491> two<00:22:26.492> eminent

00:22:34.880 --> 00:22:43.760
uh<00:22:34.881> French<00:22:34.882> physiologists<00:22:34.883> called<00:22:34.884> skin<00:22:34.885> writing,<00:22:34.886> in<00:22:34.887> which<00:22:34.888> uh<00:22:34.889> answers<00:22:34.890> to<00:22:34.891> questions<00:22:34.892> would<00:22:34.893> appear<00:22:34.894> in<00:22:34.895> the

00:22:43.760 --> 00:22:52.240
person's<00:22:43.761> skin,<00:22:43.762> uh<00:22:43.763> inside<00:22:43.764> the<00:22:43.765> skin,<00:22:43.766> not<00:22:43.767> on<00:22:43.768> the<00:22:43.769> skin,<00:22:43.770> and<00:22:43.771> sometimes<00:22:43.772> the<00:22:43.773> questions<00:22:43.774> were<00:22:43.775> only<00:22:43.776> being<00:22:43.777> asked

00:22:52.240 --> 00:22:59.680
in<00:22:52.241> the<00:22:52.242> next<00:22:52.243> room,<00:22:52.244> not<00:22:52.245> directly<00:22:52.246> to<00:22:52.247> the<00:22:52.248> subject.<00:22:52.249> It<00:22:52.250> was<00:22:52.251> a<00:22:52.252> woman<00:22:52.253> who<00:22:52.254> had<00:22:52.255> this<00:22:52.256> very<00:22:52.257> unusual<00:22:52.258> ability,<00:22:52.259> and

00:22:59.680 --> 00:23:05.440
there<00:22:59.681> are<00:22:59.682> things<00:22:59.683> like<00:22:59.684> maternal<00:22:59.685> impressions,<00:22:59.686> in<00:22:59.687> which<00:22:59.688> a<00:22:59.689> uh<00:22:59.690> a<00:22:59.691> woman<00:22:59.692> early<00:22:59.693> in<00:22:59.694> pregnancy,<00:22:59.695> in

00:23:05.440 --> 00:23:13.600
particular<00:23:05.441> first<00:23:05.442> trimester,<00:23:05.443> sees<00:23:05.444> some<00:23:05.445> ghastly<00:23:05.446> uh<00:23:05.447> physical<00:23:05.448> injury<00:23:05.449> and<00:23:05.450> the<00:23:05.451> uh<00:23:05.452> resulting<00:23:05.453> infant<00:23:05.454> bears

00:23:13.600 --> 00:23:23.360
a<00:23:13.601> a<00:23:13.602> copy<00:23:13.603> or<00:23:13.604> resemblance<00:23:13.605> uh<00:23:13.606> in<00:23:13.607> its<00:23:13.608> organism<00:23:13.609> to<00:23:13.610> what<00:23:13.611> the<00:23:13.612> woman<00:23:13.613> had<00:23:13.614> witnessed.<00:23:13.615> Here<00:23:13.616> it's<00:23:13.617> actually

00:23:23.360 --> 00:23:29.680
an<00:23:23.361> effect<00:23:23.362> on<00:23:23.363> another<00:23:23.364> person's<00:23:23.365> body,<00:23:23.366> not<00:23:23.367> your<00:23:23.368> own<00:23:23.369> body,<00:23:23.370> uh<00:23:23.371> so<00:23:23.372> at<00:23:23.373> that<00:23:23.374> point<00:23:23.375> it<00:23:23.376> connects<00:23:23.377> with<00:23:23.378> all

00:23:29.680 --> 00:23:36.320
the<00:23:29.681> literature<00:23:29.682> about<00:23:29.683> psychokinesis<00:23:29.684> or<00:23:29.685> mind<00:23:29.686> over<00:23:29.687> matter<00:23:29.688> in<00:23:29.689> the<00:23:29.690> world<00:23:29.691> of<00:23:29.692> experimental<00:23:29.693> parapsychology.

00:23:36.320 --> 00:23:42.160
Let's<00:23:36.321> see,<00:23:36.322> then<00:23:36.323> we<00:23:36.324> had<00:23:36.325> a<00:23:36.326> uh<00:23:36.327> a<00:23:36.328> chapter<00:23:36.329> on<00:23:36.330> memory<00:23:36.331> by<00:23:36.332> Alan<00:23:36.333> G.,<00:23:36.334> a<00:23:36.335> guy<00:23:36.336> who<00:23:36.337> spent<00:23:36.338> a<00:23:36.339> good<00:23:36.340> part<00:23:36.341> of<00:23:36.342> his

00:23:42.160 --> 00:23:52.640
lifetime<00:23:42.161> studying<00:23:42.162> that<00:23:42.163> subject<00:23:42.164> in<00:23:42.165> relation<00:23:42.166> to<00:23:42.167> the<00:23:42.168> uh<00:23:42.169> apparent<00:23:42.170> memories<00:23:42.171> of<00:23:42.172> past<00:23:42.173> lives<00:23:42.174> and<00:23:42.175> and

00:23:52.640 --> 00:23:58.800
mediumistic<00:23:52.641> communications,<00:23:52.642> things<00:23:52.643> of<00:23:52.644> that<00:23:52.645> sort.<00:23:52.646> And<00:23:52.647> Alan<00:23:52.648> summarized<00:23:52.649> a<00:23:52.650> variety<00:23:52.651> of<00:23:52.652> conceptual

00:23:58.800 --> 00:24:04.880
and<00:23:58.801> empirical<00:23:58.802> problems<00:23:58.803> in<00:23:58.804> existing<00:23:58.805> memory<00:23:58.806> research.<00:23:58.807> Uh,<00:23:58.808> the<00:23:58.809> arguments<00:23:58.810> he<00:23:58.811> presents<00:23:58.812> in

00:24:04.880 --> 00:24:11.040
that<00:24:04.881> chapter<00:24:04.882> are<00:24:04.883> overlap<00:24:04.884> a<00:24:04.885> good<00:24:04.886> deal<00:24:04.887> with<00:24:04.888> arguments<00:24:04.889> that<00:24:04.890> have<00:24:04.891> appeared<00:24:04.892> more<00:24:04.893> recently,

00:24:11.040 --> 00:24:18.240
uh<00:24:11.041> including<00:24:11.042> arguments<00:24:11.043> by<00:24:11.044> people<00:24:11.045> like<00:24:11.046> Bernardo<00:24:11.047> Kastrup<00:24:11.048> about<00:24:11.049> the<00:24:11.050> difficulties<00:24:11.051> of<00:24:11.052> explaining

00:24:18.240 --> 00:24:27.920
consciousness<00:24:18.241> in<00:24:18.242> physicalist<00:24:18.243> terms.<00:24:18.244> And<00:24:18.245> in<00:24:18.246> fact,<00:24:18.247> let<00:24:18.248> me<00:24:18.249> say<00:24:18.250> parenthetically<00:24:18.251> here<00:24:18.252> that<00:24:18.253> one<00:24:18.254> of<00:24:18.255> the<00:24:18.256> uh<00:24:18.257> uh

00:24:27.920 --> 00:24:32.800
one<00:24:27.921> of<00:24:27.922> the<00:24:27.923> really<00:24:27.924> important<00:24:27.925> things<00:24:27.926> that's<00:24:27.927> happened<00:24:27.928> in<00:24:27.929> the<00:24:27.930> last<00:24:27.931> few<00:24:27.932> decades<00:24:27.933> is<00:24:27.934> the<00:24:27.935> reappearance

00:24:32.800 --> 00:24:38.320
of<00:24:32.801> consciousness<00:24:32.802> research.<00:24:32.803> You<00:24:32.804> know,<00:24:32.805> when<00:24:32.806> I<00:24:32.807> was<00:24:32.808> a<00:24:32.809> graduate<00:24:32.810> student<00:24:32.811> in<00:24:32.812> the<00:24:32.813> '60s,<00:24:32.814> consciousness

00:24:38.320 --> 00:24:45.360
was<00:24:38.321> a<00:24:38.322> dirty<00:24:38.323> word,<00:24:38.324> but<00:24:38.325> we<00:24:38.326> were<00:24:38.327> still<00:24:38.328> suffering<00:24:38.329> the<00:24:38.330> uh<00:24:38.331> aftereffects<00:24:38.332> of<00:24:38.333> behaviorism.<00:24:38.334> In<00:24:38.335> fact,

00:24:45.360 --> 00:24:50.320
B.F.<00:24:45.361> Skinner<00:24:45.362> and<00:24:45.363> company<00:24:45.364> were<00:24:45.365> on<00:24:45.366> another<00:24:45.367> floor<00:24:45.368> of<00:24:45.369> the<00:24:45.370> same<00:24:45.371> building<00:24:45.372> that<00:24:45.373> I<00:24:45.374> worked<00:24:45.375> in<00:24:45.376> as<00:24:45.377> a<00:24:45.378> graduate

00:24:50.320 --> 00:25:00.000
student,<00:24:50.321> William<00:24:50.322> James<00:24:50.323> Hall.<00:24:50.324> Um,<00:24:50.325> anyway,<00:24:50.326> um<00:24:50.327> yeah,<00:24:50.328> you<00:24:50.329> consciousness<00:24:50.330> was<00:24:50.331> not<00:24:50.332> a<00:24:50.333> word<00:24:50.334> spoken<00:24:50.335> in<00:24:50.336> polite

00:25:00.000 --> 00:25:09.040
scientific<00:25:00.001> company<00:25:00.002> during<00:25:00.003> that<00:25:00.004> period<00:25:00.005> of<00:25:00.006> time.<00:25:00.007> Are<00:25:00.008> you<00:25:00.009> serious?<00:25:00.010> Is<00:25:00.011> it<00:25:00.012> really<00:25:00.013> was<00:25:00.014> that<00:25:00.015> was<00:25:00.016> it<00:25:00.017> that<00:25:00.018> bad?

00:25:09.040 --> 00:25:15.200
Yes,<00:25:09.041> absolutely.<00:25:09.042> In<00:25:09.043> fact,<00:25:09.044> let<00:25:09.045> me<00:25:09.046> just<00:25:09.047> mention<00:25:09.048> here<00:25:09.049> that<00:25:09.050> uh<00:25:09.051> if<00:25:09.052> there's<00:25:09.053> anybody<00:25:09.054> out<00:25:09.055> there<00:25:09.056> who<00:25:09.057> has<00:25:09.058> never

00:25:15.200 --> 00:25:22.880
seen<00:25:15.201> John<00:25:15.202> B.<00:25:15.203> Watson's<00:25:15.204> behaviorist<00:25:15.205> manifesto<00:25:15.206> of<00:25:15.207> 1913,<00:25:15.208> it's<00:25:15.209> really<00:25:15.210> worth<00:25:15.211> looking<00:25:15.212> at.<00:25:15.213> It<00:25:15.214> is

00:25:22.880 --> 00:25:30.320
so<00:25:22.881> bizarre<00:25:22.882> that<00:25:22.883> it's<00:25:22.884> hard<00:25:22.885> to<00:25:22.886> believe<00:25:22.887> that<00:25:22.888> anybody<00:25:22.889> took<00:25:22.890> it<00:25:22.891> seriously<00:25:22.892> at<00:25:22.893> the<00:25:22.894> time,<00:25:22.895> and<00:25:22.896> yet<00:25:22.897> behaviorism

00:25:30.320 --> 00:25:36.160
ruled<00:25:30.321> the<00:25:30.322> roost<00:25:30.323> in<00:25:30.324> American<00:25:30.325> psychology<00:25:30.326> for<00:25:30.327> at<00:25:30.328> least<00:25:30.329> half<00:25:30.330> a<00:25:30.331> century.<00:25:30.332> It<00:25:30.333> was<00:25:30.334> just<00:25:30.335> beginning<00:25:30.336> to

00:25:36.160 --> 00:25:44.720
break<00:25:36.161> down<00:25:36.162> at<00:25:36.163> the<00:25:36.164> time<00:25:36.165> I<00:25:36.166> started<00:25:36.167> graduate<00:25:36.168> school,<00:25:36.169> but<00:25:36.170> that's<00:25:36.171> all<00:25:36.172> changed.<00:25:36.173> Uh,<00:25:36.174> and<00:25:36.175> I<00:25:36.176> mean<00:25:36.177> consciousness

00:25:44.720 --> 00:25:51.200
itself<00:25:44.721> is<00:25:44.722> one<00:25:44.723> of<00:25:44.724> the<00:25:44.725> things<00:25:44.726> that<00:25:44.727> physicalism<00:25:44.728> has<00:25:44.729> great<00:25:44.730> difficulty<00:25:44.731> with,<00:25:44.732> and<00:25:44.733> a<00:25:44.734> lot<00:25:44.735> of<00:25:44.736> philosophers

00:25:51.200 --> 00:25:57.680
have<00:25:51.201> come<00:25:51.202> to<00:25:51.203> the<00:25:51.204> conclusion<00:25:51.205> at<00:25:51.206> this<00:25:51.207> point<00:25:51.208> that<00:25:51.209> we<00:25:51.210> will<00:25:51.211> never<00:25:51.212> have<00:25:51.213> a<00:25:51.214> physicalist<00:25:51.215> explanation<00:25:51.216> of

00:25:57.680 --> 00:26:04.240
consciousness,<00:25:57.681> and<00:25:57.682> that's<00:25:57.683> been<00:25:57.684> a<00:25:57.685> great<00:25:57.686> boon.<00:25:57.687> I<00:25:57.688> mean,<00:25:57.689> we<00:25:57.690> used<00:25:57.691> to<00:25:57.692> be<00:25:57.693> like<00:25:57.694> parapsychology<00:25:57.695> people,<00:25:57.696> used<00:25:57.697> to

00:26:04.240 --> 00:26:10.640
be<00:26:04.241> like<00:26:04.242> a<00:26:04.243> little<00:26:04.244> rowboat<00:26:04.245> trying<00:26:04.246> to<00:26:04.247> steer<00:26:04.248> the<00:26:04.249> Titanic<00:26:04.250> and<00:26:04.251> not<00:26:04.252> having<00:26:04.253> very<00:26:04.254> much<00:26:04.255> success,<00:26:04.256> but<00:26:04.257> now<00:26:04.258> at<00:26:04.259> least

00:26:10.640 --> 00:26:15.920
there<00:26:10.641> are<00:26:10.642> other<00:26:10.643> rowboats,<00:26:10.644> some<00:26:10.645> quite<00:26:10.646> quite<00:26:10.647> a<00:26:10.648> bit<00:26:10.649> bigger<00:26:10.650> than<00:26:10.651> ours,<00:26:10.652> in<00:26:10.653> the<00:26:10.654> same<00:26:10.655> territory<00:26:10.656> pushing

00:26:15.920 --> 00:26:22.800
in<00:26:15.921> the<00:26:15.922> same<00:26:15.923> pulling<00:26:15.924> in<00:26:15.925> the<00:26:15.926> same<00:26:15.927> direction.<00:26:15.928> So<00:26:15.929> uh<00:26:15.930> we're<00:26:15.931> we're<00:26:15.932> in<00:26:15.933> better<00:26:15.934> shape<00:26:15.935> now.<00:26:15.936> Anyway,<00:26:15.937> let<00:26:15.938> me

00:26:22.800 --> 00:26:32.720
let<00:26:22.801> me<00:26:22.802> get<00:26:22.803> back<00:26:22.804> to<00:26:22.805> our<00:26:22.806> uh<00:26:22.807> developing<00:26:22.808> book.<00:26:22.809> Um,<00:26:22.810> one<00:26:22.811> one<00:26:22.812> other<00:26:22.813> uh<00:26:22.814> well,<00:26:22.815> two<00:26:22.816> heavily<00:26:22.817> empirical<00:26:22.818> chapters.<00:26:22.819> One

00:26:32.720 --> 00:26:39.600
was<00:26:32.721> on<00:26:32.722> multiple<00:26:32.723> personality<00:26:32.724> and<00:26:32.725> dissociative<00:26:32.726> identity<00:26:32.727> disorder,<00:26:32.728> uh<00:26:32.729> secondary<00:26:32.730> centers<00:26:32.731> of

00:26:39.600 --> 00:26:47.280
consciousness<00:26:39.601> and<00:26:39.602> psychological<00:26:39.603> automatisms.<00:26:39.604> That<00:26:39.605> was<00:26:39.606> by<00:26:39.607> Adam<00:26:39.608> Crabtree,<00:26:39.609> who's<00:26:39.610> a<00:26:39.611> clinical<00:26:39.612> psychologist

00:26:47.280 --> 00:26:53.280
and<00:26:47.281> philosopher<00:26:47.282> who<00:26:47.283> spent<00:26:47.284> a<00:26:47.285> historian,<00:26:47.286> spent<00:26:47.287> a<00:26:47.288> lot<00:26:47.289> of<00:26:47.290> time<00:26:47.291> in<00:26:47.292> that<00:26:47.293> world.<00:26:47.294> And<00:26:47.295> there<00:26:47.296> you<00:26:47.297> have

00:26:53.280 --> 00:26:59.280
the<00:26:53.281> challenge<00:26:53.282> of<00:26:53.283> explaining<00:26:53.284> how<00:26:53.285> what<00:26:53.286> appears<00:26:53.287> to<00:26:53.288> be<00:26:53.289> multiple<00:26:53.290> personalities<00:26:53.291> can<00:26:53.292> occupy<00:26:53.293> the<00:26:53.294> same

00:26:59.280 --> 00:27:09.520
organism,<00:26:59.281> uh<00:26:59.282> sometimes<00:26:59.283> concurrently<00:26:59.284> rather<00:26:59.285> than<00:26:59.286> successively,<00:26:59.287> and<00:26:59.288> sharing<00:26:59.289> neural<00:26:59.290> mechanisms<00:26:59.291> somehow

00:27:09.520 --> 00:27:17.120
and<00:27:09.521> sharing<00:27:09.522> consciousness<00:27:09.523> in<00:27:09.524> peculiar<00:27:09.525> ways<00:27:09.526> where<00:27:09.527> a<00:27:09.528> secondary<00:27:09.529> personality<00:27:09.530> may<00:27:09.531> be<00:27:09.532> a<00:27:09.533> lot<00:27:09.534> more<00:27:09.535> capable

00:27:17.120 --> 00:27:23.360
than<00:27:17.121> the<00:27:17.122> primary<00:27:17.123> personality<00:27:17.124> and<00:27:17.125> know<00:27:17.126> a<00:27:17.127> lot<00:27:17.128> about<00:27:17.129> what<00:27:17.130> goes<00:27:17.131> on<00:27:17.132> in<00:27:17.133> the<00:27:17.134> primary<00:27:17.135> personality<00:27:17.136> but<00:27:17.137> not

00:27:23.360 --> 00:27:31.520
vice<00:27:23.361> versa.<00:27:23.362> Then<00:27:23.363> there<00:27:23.364> was<00:27:23.365> another<00:27:23.366> chapter,<00:27:23.367> uh<00:27:23.368> Emily<00:27:23.369> was<00:27:23.370> again<00:27:23.371> the<00:27:23.372> lead,<00:27:23.373> about<00:27:23.374> things<00:27:23.375> like<00:27:23.376> out-of-body

00:27:31.520 --> 00:27:38.560
and<00:27:31.521> near-death<00:27:31.522> experiences.<00:27:31.523> And<00:27:31.524> let<00:27:31.525> me<00:27:31.526> mention<00:27:31.527> here<00:27:31.528> that<00:27:31.529> there's<00:27:31.530> one<00:27:31.531> class<00:27:31.532> in<00:27:31.533> particular<00:27:31.534> of<00:27:31.535> near-death

00:27:38.560 --> 00:27:45.840
experiences<00:27:38.561> that<00:27:38.562> I<00:27:38.563> think<00:27:38.564> is<00:27:38.565> uh<00:27:38.566> of<00:27:38.567> particular<00:27:38.568> importance<00:27:38.569> and<00:27:38.570> that<00:27:38.571> may<00:27:38.572> I<00:27:38.573> think<00:27:38.574> is<00:27:38.575> actually

00:27:45.840 --> 00:27:53.680
driving<00:27:45.841> uh<00:27:45.842> changes<00:27:45.843> of<00:27:45.844> opinion<00:27:45.845> within<00:27:45.846> the<00:27:45.847> world<00:27:45.848> of<00:27:45.849> biomedical<00:27:45.850> science,<00:27:45.851> and<00:27:45.852> these<00:27:45.853> are<00:27:45.854> near-death

00:27:53.680 --> 00:28:02.000
experiences<00:27:53.681> occurring<00:27:53.682> under<00:27:53.683> extreme<00:27:53.684> physiological<00:27:53.685> conditions<00:27:53.686> such<00:27:53.687> as<00:27:53.688> deep<00:27:53.689> general<00:27:53.690> anesthesia<00:27:53.691> and/or

00:28:02.000 --> 00:28:12.000
cardiac<00:28:02.001> arrest.<00:28:02.002> Uh,<00:28:02.003> the<00:28:02.004> reason<00:28:02.005> why<00:28:02.006> that's<00:28:02.007> important<00:28:02.008> is<00:28:02.009> that<00:28:02.010> in<00:28:02.011> these<00:28:02.012> conditions,<00:28:02.013> um<00:28:02.014> the<00:28:02.015> the<00:28:02.016> brain

00:28:12.000 --> 00:28:20.560
conditions<00:28:12.001> that<00:28:12.002> most<00:28:12.003> neuroscientists<00:28:12.004> believe<00:28:12.005> are<00:28:12.006> necessary<00:28:12.007> for<00:28:12.008> conscious<00:28:12.009> experience<00:28:12.010> are<00:28:12.011> severely

00:28:20.560 --> 00:28:28.960
degraded<00:28:20.561> or<00:28:20.562> abolished<00:28:20.563> altogether,<00:28:20.564> and<00:28:20.565> yet<00:28:20.566> people<00:28:20.567> report<00:28:20.568> not<00:28:20.569> only<00:28:20.570> experiences<00:28:20.571> of<00:28:20.572> any<00:28:20.573> old<00:28:20.574> kind<00:28:20.575> but

00:28:28.960 --> 00:28:37.280
the<00:28:28.961> most<00:28:28.962> powerful,<00:28:28.963> impactful,<00:28:28.964> transformative<00:28:28.965> experiences<00:28:28.966> of<00:28:28.967> their<00:28:28.968> entire<00:28:28.969> lives.<00:28:28.970> They're

00:28:37.280 --> 00:28:42.960
essentially<00:28:37.281> mystical<00:28:37.282> experiences<00:28:37.283> occurring<00:28:37.284> under<00:28:37.285> suboptimal<00:28:37.286> conditions<00:28:37.287> where<00:28:37.288> you<00:28:37.289> almost<00:28:37.290> have<00:28:37.291> to<00:28:37.292> die

00:28:42.960 --> 00:28:53.120
in<00:28:42.961> order<00:28:42.962> to<00:28:42.963> have<00:28:42.964> the<00:28:42.965> experience.<00:28:42.966> Um,<00:28:42.967> there's<00:28:42.968> a<00:28:42.969> long<00:28:42.970> story<00:28:42.971> to<00:28:42.972> be<00:28:42.973> told<00:28:42.974> about<00:28:42.975> those<00:28:42.976> and<00:28:42.977> the<00:28:42.978> the<00:28:42.979> uh<00:28:42.980> the

00:28:53.120 --> 00:28:59.920
attempts<00:28:53.121> made<00:28:53.122> by<00:28:53.123> physicalists<00:28:53.124> to<00:28:53.125> escape<00:28:53.126> the<00:28:53.127> force<00:28:53.128> of<00:28:53.129> those<00:28:53.130> experiences,<00:28:53.131> but<00:28:53.132> that<00:28:53.133> argument<00:28:53.134> I<00:28:53.135> think<00:28:53.136> has

00:28:59.920 --> 00:29:09.360
held<00:28:59.921> together<00:28:59.922> since<00:28:59.923> we<00:28:59.924> first<00:28:59.925> wrote<00:28:59.926> it<00:28:59.927> down<00:28:59.928> in<00:28:59.929> 2007.<00:28:59.930> We<00:28:59.931> also<00:28:59.932> have<00:28:59.933> chapters<00:28:59.934> on<00:28:59.935> things<00:28:59.936> like<00:28:59.937> um<00:28:59.938> uh

00:29:09.360 --> 00:29:18.400
extreme<00:29:09.361> forms<00:29:09.362> of<00:29:09.363> genius<00:29:09.364> and<00:29:09.365> mystical<00:29:09.366> experiences<00:29:09.367> themselves,<00:29:09.368> and<00:29:09.369> uh<00:29:09.370> these<00:29:09.371> these<00:29:09.372> are<00:29:09.373> both<00:29:09.374> topics<00:29:09.375> that

00:29:18.400 --> 00:29:26.160
have<00:29:18.401> been<00:29:18.402> fairly<00:29:18.403> poorly<00:29:18.404> handled<00:29:18.405> by<00:29:18.406> psychology<00:29:18.407> and<00:29:18.408> neuroscience.<00:29:18.409> That's<00:29:18.410> true<00:29:18.411> even<00:29:18.412> of<00:29:18.413> creativity,<00:29:18.414> which

00:29:26.160 --> 00:29:32.880
you<00:29:26.161> think<00:29:26.162> might<00:29:26.163> think<00:29:26.164> would<00:29:26.165> be<00:29:26.166> kind<00:29:26.167> of<00:29:26.168> central<00:29:26.169> to<00:29:26.170> an<00:29:26.171> interesting<00:29:26.172> psychological<00:29:26.173> science,<00:29:26.174> but<00:29:26.175> it's<00:29:26.176> even

00:29:32.880 --> 00:29:40.400
more<00:29:32.881> true<00:29:32.882> of<00:29:32.883> mystical<00:29:32.884> experience.<00:29:32.885> So<00:29:32.886> I<00:29:32.887> think<00:29:32.888> one<00:29:32.889> of<00:29:32.890> the<00:29:32.891> main<00:29:32.892> things<00:29:32.893> um<00:29:32.894> I've<00:29:32.895> learned<00:29:32.896> in<00:29:32.897> the<00:29:32.898> course

00:29:40.400 --> 00:29:47.040
of<00:29:40.401> working<00:29:40.402> on<00:29:40.403> these<00:29:40.404> books,<00:29:40.405> and<00:29:40.406> there<00:29:40.407> are<00:29:40.408> more<00:29:40.409> that<00:29:40.410> I'll<00:29:40.411> tell<00:29:40.412> you<00:29:40.413> about<00:29:40.414> in<00:29:40.415> a<00:29:40.416> moment,<00:29:40.417> is<00:29:40.418> that<00:29:40.419> it's<00:29:40.420> it's

00:29:47.040 --> 00:29:57.120
really<00:29:47.041> an<00:29:47.042> embarrassment,<00:29:47.043> uh<00:29:47.044> the<00:29:47.045> way<00:29:47.046> our<00:29:47.047> um<00:29:47.048> academia<00:29:47.049> and<00:29:47.050> science<00:29:47.051> has<00:29:47.052> dealt<00:29:47.053> with<00:29:47.054> mystical<00:29:47.055> experience

00:29:57.120 --> 00:30:04.480
uh<00:29:57.121> so<00:29:57.122> far.<00:29:57.123> That<00:29:57.124> is,<00:29:57.125> they're<00:29:57.126> for<00:29:57.127> the<00:29:57.128> most<00:29:57.129> part<00:29:57.130> ignored<00:29:57.131> entirely,<00:29:57.132> and<00:29:57.133> uh<00:29:57.134> even<00:29:57.135> when<00:29:57.136> people<00:29:57.137> pay

00:30:04.480 --> 00:30:14.160
attention<00:30:04.481> to<00:30:04.482> them,<00:30:04.483> it's<00:30:04.484> usually<00:30:04.485> to<00:30:04.486> um<00:30:04.487> marginalize<00:30:04.488> and<00:30:04.489> pathologize<00:30:04.490> them,<00:30:04.491> unlike<00:30:04.492> in<00:30:04.493> particular<00:30:04.494> say

00:30:14.160 --> 00:30:25.760
uh<00:30:14.161> Eastern<00:30:14.162> traditions<00:30:14.163> Southeast<00:30:14.164> Asian<00:30:14.165> Middle<00:30:14.166> Eastern<00:30:14.167> uh<00:30:14.168> that<00:30:14.169> have<00:30:14.170> taken<00:30:14.171> mystical<00:30:14.172> experiences<00:30:14.173> as

00:30:25.760 --> 00:30:34.800
windows<00:30:25.761> into<00:30:25.762> normally<00:30:25.763> hidden<00:30:25.764> parts<00:30:25.765> of<00:30:25.766> reality<00:30:25.767> uh<00:30:25.768> I<00:30:25.769> think<00:30:25.770> we<00:30:25.771> are<00:30:25.772> going<00:30:25.773> to<00:30:25.774> have<00:30:25.775> to<00:30:25.776> do<00:30:25.777> a<00:30:25.778> lot<00:30:25.779> better<00:30:25.780> in

00:30:34.800 --> 00:30:41.600
terms<00:30:34.801> of<00:30:34.802> our<00:30:34.803> philosophical<00:30:34.804> and<00:30:34.805> scientific<00:30:34.806> dealings<00:30:34.807> with<00:30:34.808> mystical<00:30:34.809> experience<00:30:34.810> in<00:30:34.811> order<00:30:34.812> to<00:30:34.813> get<00:30:34.814> a<00:30:34.815> correct

00:30:41.600 --> 00:30:51.520
picture<00:30:41.601> of<00:30:41.602> reality<00:30:41.603> um<00:30:41.604> so<00:30:41.605> that<00:30:41.606> was<00:30:41.607> our<00:30:41.608> first<00:30:41.609> book<00:30:41.610> Irreducible<00:30:41.611> Mind<00:30:41.612> there's<00:30:41.613> also<00:30:41.614> a<00:30:41.615> chapter<00:30:41.616> in<00:30:41.617> which<00:30:41.618> I

00:30:51.520 --> 00:30:59.200
um<00:30:51.521> attempt<00:30:51.522> to<00:30:51.523> evaluate<00:30:51.524> Myers's<00:30:51.525> psychological<00:30:51.526> model<00:30:51.527> which<00:30:51.528> I'll<00:30:51.529> say<00:30:51.530> a<00:30:51.531> bit<00:30:51.532> more<00:30:51.533> about<00:30:51.534> in<00:30:51.535> a<00:30:51.536> moment<00:30:51.537> and

00:30:59.200 --> 00:31:08.400
then<00:30:59.201> also<00:30:59.202> sketched<00:30:59.203> out<00:30:59.204> uh<00:30:59.205> a<00:30:59.206> range<00:30:59.207> of<00:30:59.208> possibilities<00:30:59.209> for<00:30:59.210> an<00:30:59.211> expanded<00:30:59.212> scientific<00:30:59.213> picture<00:30:59.214> that<00:30:59.215> would

00:31:08.400 --> 00:31:17.360
allow<00:31:08.401> us<00:31:08.402> to<00:31:08.403> explain<00:31:08.404> the<00:31:08.405> kinds<00:31:08.406> of<00:31:08.407> phenomena<00:31:08.408> that<00:31:08.409> we<00:31:08.410> had<00:31:08.411> cataloged<00:31:08.412> in<00:31:08.413> the<00:31:08.414> book<00:31:08.415> now<00:31:08.416> the<00:31:08.417> yeah<00:31:08.418> there<00:31:08.419> are

00:31:17.360 --> 00:31:23.360
two<00:31:17.361> aspects<00:31:17.362> to<00:31:17.363> what<00:31:17.364> come<00:31:17.365> out<00:31:17.366> of<00:31:17.367> Irreducible<00:31:17.368> Mind<00:31:17.369> two<00:31:17.370> things<00:31:17.371> I<00:31:17.372> think<00:31:17.373> we<00:31:17.374> accomplish<00:31:17.375> one<00:31:17.376> is<00:31:17.377> to<00:31:17.378> add<00:31:17.379> an

00:31:23.360 --> 00:31:32.480
empirical<00:31:23.361> dimension<00:31:23.362> to<00:31:23.363> the<00:31:23.364> ongoing<00:31:23.365> uh<00:31:23.366> critiques<00:31:23.367> of<00:31:23.368> physicalism<00:31:23.369> uh<00:31:23.370> and<00:31:23.371> it<00:31:23.372> as<00:31:23.373> I<00:31:23.374> indicated<00:31:23.375> kind<00:31:23.376> of

00:31:32.480 --> 00:31:38.880
coheres<00:31:32.481> nicely<00:31:32.482> with<00:31:32.483> the<00:31:32.484> uh<00:31:32.485> modern<00:31:32.486> revolution<00:31:32.487> in<00:31:32.488> thinking<00:31:32.489> about<00:31:32.490> consciousness<00:31:32.491> driven<00:31:32.492> mainly

00:31:38.880 --> 00:31:47.760
by<00:31:38.881> philosophers<00:31:38.882> originally<00:31:38.883> but<00:31:38.884> now<00:31:38.885> gradually<00:31:38.886> penetrating<00:31:38.887> neuroscience<00:31:38.888> and<00:31:38.889> psychology<00:31:38.890> um

00:31:47.760 --> 00:31:58.880
now<00:31:47.761> I<00:31:47.762> think<00:31:47.763> our<00:31:47.764> work<00:31:47.765> has<00:31:47.766> also<00:31:47.767> gone<00:31:47.768> a<00:31:47.769> long<00:31:47.770> way<00:31:47.771> toward<00:31:47.772> supporting<00:31:47.773> the<00:31:47.774> kind<00:31:47.775> of<00:31:47.776> model<00:31:47.777> that<00:31:47.778> Myers

00:31:58.880 --> 00:32:07.760
and<00:31:58.881> James<00:31:58.882> had<00:31:58.883> of<00:31:58.884> the<00:31:58.885> human<00:31:58.886> psyche<00:31:58.887> which<00:31:58.888> is<00:31:58.889> very<00:31:58.890> different<00:31:58.891> from<00:31:58.892> what's<00:31:58.893> on<00:31:58.894> offer<00:31:58.895> now<00:31:58.896> it's<00:31:58.897> related

00:32:07.760 --> 00:32:17.760
to<00:32:07.761> uh<00:32:07.762> models<00:32:07.763> that<00:32:07.764> include<00:32:07.765> a<00:32:07.766> dynamic<00:32:07.767> unconscious<00:32:07.768> such<00:32:07.769> as<00:32:07.770> those<00:32:07.771> of<00:32:07.772> Freud<00:32:07.773> and<00:32:07.774> Jung<00:32:07.775> and<00:32:07.776> the<00:32:07.777> various

00:32:17.760 --> 00:32:30.160
psychoanalysts<00:32:17.761> but<00:32:17.762> with<00:32:17.763> one<00:32:17.764> huge<00:32:17.765> difference<00:32:17.766> that<00:32:17.767> is<00:32:17.768> um<00:32:17.769> all<00:32:17.770> of<00:32:17.771> these<00:32:17.772> things<00:32:17.773> recognize<00:32:17.774> that<00:32:17.775> there's

00:32:30.160 --> 00:32:38.560
a<00:32:30.161> part<00:32:30.162> of<00:32:30.163> the<00:32:30.164> psyche<00:32:30.165> that's<00:32:30.166> inaccessible<00:32:30.167> usually<00:32:30.168> to<00:32:30.169> the<00:32:30.170> everyday<00:32:30.171> consciousness<00:32:30.172> and<00:32:30.173> in<00:32:30.174> that<00:32:30.175> sense

00:32:38.560 --> 00:32:46.400
unconscious<00:32:38.561> in<00:32:38.562> Freud<00:32:38.563> and<00:32:38.564> Jung<00:32:38.565> it<00:32:38.566> is<00:32:38.567> literally<00:32:38.568> unconscious<00:32:38.569> that<00:32:38.570> other<00:32:38.571> dimension<00:32:38.572> of<00:32:38.573> the<00:32:38.574> psyche

00:32:46.400 --> 00:32:54.800
for<00:32:46.401> Myers<00:32:46.402> and<00:32:46.403> James<00:32:46.404> it's<00:32:46.405> quite<00:32:46.406> different<00:32:46.407> there's<00:32:46.408> they<00:32:46.409> picture<00:32:46.410> the<00:32:46.411> everyday<00:32:46.412> consciousness<00:32:46.413> as<00:32:46.414> being

00:32:54.800 --> 00:33:03.840
wholly<00:32:54.801> embedded<00:32:54.802> within<00:32:54.803> a<00:32:54.804> larger<00:32:54.805> more<00:32:54.806> comprehensive<00:32:54.807> consciousness<00:32:54.808> having<00:32:54.809> access<00:32:54.810> to<00:32:54.811> what<00:32:54.812> Myers<00:32:54.813> termed

00:33:03.840 --> 00:33:10.080
addits<00:33:03.841> and<00:33:03.842> operations<00:33:03.843> that<00:33:03.844> is<00:33:03.845> capacities<00:33:03.846> of<00:33:03.847> one<00:33:03.848> or<00:33:03.849> another<00:33:03.850> sort<00:33:03.851> exceeding<00:33:03.852> those<00:33:03.853> normally

00:33:10.080 --> 00:33:16.160
available<00:33:10.081> to<00:33:10.082> the<00:33:10.083> everyday<00:33:10.084> consciousness<00:33:10.085> you<00:33:10.086> know<00:33:10.087> the<00:33:10.088> the<00:33:10.089> standard<00:33:10.090> psychology<00:33:10.091> neuroscience

00:33:16.160 --> 00:33:24.160
picture<00:33:16.161> is<00:33:16.162> that<00:33:16.163> everyday<00:33:16.164> consciousness<00:33:16.165> is<00:33:16.166> all<00:33:16.167> the<00:33:16.168> consciousness<00:33:16.169> there<00:33:16.170> is<00:33:16.171> supported<00:33:16.172> by<00:33:16.173> unconscious

00:33:24.160 --> 00:33:33.840
neurophysiological<00:33:24.161> stuff<00:33:24.162> going<00:33:24.163> on<00:33:24.164> in<00:33:24.165> the<00:33:24.166> brain<00:33:24.167> uh<00:33:24.168> but<00:33:24.169> uh<00:33:24.170> Myers<00:33:24.171> and<00:33:24.172> James<00:33:24.173> both<00:33:24.174> took<00:33:24.175> very<00:33:24.176> seriously

00:33:33.840 --> 00:33:43.680
this<00:33:33.841> idea<00:33:33.842> of<00:33:33.843> a<00:33:33.844> subliminal<00:33:33.845> consciousness<00:33:33.846> of<00:33:33.847> greater<00:33:33.848> capacity<00:33:33.849> than<00:33:33.850> the<00:33:33.851> everyday<00:33:33.852> uh<00:33:33.853> and<00:33:33.854> well<00:33:33.855> James<00:33:33.856> was

00:33:43.680 --> 00:33:49.760
the<00:33:43.681> one<00:33:43.682> who<00:33:43.683> really<00:33:43.684> explicitly<00:33:43.685> formulated<00:33:43.686> the<00:33:43.687> the<00:33:43.688> logic<00:33:43.689> of<00:33:43.690> the<00:33:43.691> situation<00:33:43.692> saying<00:33:43.693> that<00:33:43.694> most

00:33:49.760 --> 00:33:57.280
people<00:33:49.761> take<00:33:49.762> these<00:33:49.763> correlations<00:33:49.764> between<00:33:49.765> mind<00:33:49.766> and<00:33:49.767> brain<00:33:49.768> as<00:33:49.769> uh<00:33:49.770> proof<00:33:49.771> of<00:33:49.772> the<00:33:49.773> standard<00:33:49.774> conception

00:33:57.280 --> 00:34:04.160
but<00:33:57.281> that<00:33:57.282> those<00:33:57.283> those<00:33:57.284> that<00:33:57.285> correlation<00:33:57.286> can<00:33:57.287> be<00:33:57.288> interpreted<00:33:57.289> in<00:33:57.290> a<00:33:57.291> different<00:33:57.292> way<00:33:57.293> namely<00:33:57.294> that

00:34:04.160 --> 00:34:09.440
uh<00:34:04.161> conditions<00:34:04.162> in<00:34:04.163> the<00:34:04.164> brain<00:34:04.165> permit<00:34:04.166> the<00:34:04.167> expression<00:34:04.168> of<00:34:04.169> these<00:34:04.170> higher<00:34:04.171> capacities<00:34:04.172> that

00:34:09.440 --> 00:34:17.360
are<00:34:09.441> normally<00:34:09.442> inaccessible<00:34:09.443> to<00:34:09.444> us<00:34:09.445> that<00:34:09.446> is<00:34:09.447> the<00:34:09.448> higher<00:34:09.449> consciousness<00:34:09.450> can<00:34:09.451> express<00:34:09.452> itself<00:34:09.453> through<00:34:09.454> the<00:34:09.455> brain

00:34:17.360 --> 00:34:23.280
under<00:34:17.361> conditions<00:34:17.362> that<00:34:17.363> we<00:34:17.364> certainly<00:34:17.365> don't<00:34:17.366> know<00:34:17.367> much<00:34:17.368> about<00:34:17.369> right<00:34:17.370> now<00:34:17.371> but<00:34:17.372> we<00:34:17.373> certainly<00:34:17.374> have<00:34:17.375> the

00:34:23.280 --> 00:34:29.440
means<00:34:23.281> to<00:34:23.282> learn<00:34:23.283> a<00:34:23.284> great<00:34:23.285> deal<00:34:23.286> more<00:34:23.287> about<00:34:23.288> especially<00:34:23.289> now<00:34:23.290> that<00:34:23.291> we're<00:34:23.292> beginning<00:34:23.293> to<00:34:23.294> have<00:34:23.295> experimental

00:34:29.440 --> 00:34:38.480
access<00:34:29.441> to<00:34:29.442> those<00:34:29.443> conditions<00:34:29.444> through<00:34:29.445> things<00:34:29.446> for<00:34:29.447> example<00:34:29.448> such<00:34:29.449> as<00:34:29.450> meditation<00:34:29.451> and<00:34:29.452> psychedelics<00:34:29.453> so

00:34:38.480 --> 00:34:46.480
I<00:34:38.481> think<00:34:38.482> that<00:34:38.483> a<00:34:38.484> big<00:34:38.485> part<00:34:38.486> of<00:34:38.487> the<00:34:38.488> future<00:34:38.489> agenda<00:34:38.490> of<00:34:38.491> my<00:34:38.492> field<00:34:38.493> will<00:34:38.494> be<00:34:38.495> to<00:34:38.496> begin<00:34:38.497> seriously<00:34:38.498> studying<00:34:38.499> this

00:34:46.480 --> 00:34:52.720
issue<00:34:46.481> of<00:34:46.482> what<00:34:46.483> conditions<00:34:46.484> in<00:34:46.485> the<00:34:46.486> brain<00:34:46.487> permit<00:34:46.488> the<00:34:46.489> expression<00:34:46.490> of<00:34:46.491> these<00:34:46.492> capacities<00:34:46.493> and<00:34:46.494> if<00:34:46.495> we<00:34:46.496> could<00:34:46.497> do

00:34:52.720 --> 00:34:58.800
that<00:34:52.721> you<00:34:52.722> know<00:34:52.723> among<00:34:52.724> other<00:34:52.725> things<00:34:52.726> we<00:34:52.727> could<00:34:52.728> hope<00:34:52.729> to<00:34:52.730> find<00:34:52.731> ways<00:34:52.732> of<00:34:52.733> encouraging<00:34:52.734> the<00:34:52.735> production<00:34:52.736> of<00:34:52.737> these

00:34:58.800 --> 00:35:07.920
states<00:34:58.801> in<00:34:58.802> more<00:34:58.803> people<00:34:58.804> I<00:34:58.805> think<00:34:58.806> it<00:34:58.807> potentially<00:34:58.808> is<00:34:58.809> a<00:34:58.810> tremendous<00:34:58.811> uh<00:34:58.812> step<00:34:58.813> forward<00:34:58.814> both<00:34:58.815> individually<00:34:58.816> and

00:35:07.920 --> 00:35:15.760
collectively<00:35:07.921> to<00:35:07.922> make<00:35:07.923> these<00:35:07.924> kinds<00:35:07.925> of<00:35:07.926> experiences<00:35:07.927> uh<00:35:07.928> more<00:35:07.929> accessible<00:35:07.930> to<00:35:07.931> more<00:35:07.932> people<00:35:07.933> for<00:35:07.934> example<00:35:07.935> one<00:35:07.936> of

00:35:15.760 --> 00:35:21.840
the<00:35:15.761> one<00:35:15.762> of<00:35:15.763> the<00:35:15.764> things<00:35:15.765> that's<00:35:15.766> become<00:35:15.767> clear<00:35:15.768> about<00:35:15.769> near-death<00:35:15.770> experiences<00:35:15.771> and<00:35:15.772> which<00:35:15.773> has<00:35:15.774> been<00:35:15.775> clear

00:35:21.840 --> 00:35:27.920
for<00:35:21.841> a<00:35:21.842> long<00:35:21.843> time<00:35:21.844> about<00:35:21.845> mystical<00:35:21.846> experiences<00:35:21.847> in<00:35:21.848> general<00:35:21.849> is<00:35:21.850> that<00:35:21.851> those<00:35:21.852> who<00:35:21.853> have<00:35:21.854> them<00:35:21.855> whether<00:35:21.856> they

00:35:27.920 --> 00:35:34.320
have<00:35:27.921> them<00:35:27.922> through<00:35:27.923> some<00:35:27.924> kind<00:35:27.925> of<00:35:27.926> deliberate<00:35:27.927> practice<00:35:27.928> or<00:35:27.929> just<00:35:27.930> you<00:35:27.931> know<00:35:27.932> blunder<00:35:27.933> into<00:35:27.934> some<00:35:27.935> condition<00:35:27.936> that

00:35:34.320 --> 00:35:43.040
allows<00:35:34.321> them<00:35:34.322> to<00:35:34.323> happen<00:35:34.324> near-death<00:35:34.325> experiences<00:35:34.326> being<00:35:34.327> the<00:35:34.328> sort<00:35:34.329> of<00:35:34.330> extreme<00:35:34.331> case<00:35:34.332> of<00:35:34.333> that<00:35:34.334> sort<00:35:34.335> is<00:35:34.336> that<00:35:34.337> they

00:35:43.040 --> 00:35:49.360
tend<00:35:43.041> to<00:35:43.042> become<00:35:43.043> become<00:35:43.044> better<00:35:43.045> people<00:35:43.046> less<00:35:43.047> egoistic<00:35:43.048> less<00:35:43.049> selfish<00:35:43.050> less<00:35:43.051> preoccupied<00:35:43.052> with<00:35:43.053> you<00:35:43.054> know<00:35:43.055> money

00:35:49.360 --> 00:35:56.560
and<00:35:49.361> status<00:35:49.362> and<00:35:49.363> all<00:35:49.364> that<00:35:49.365> more<00:35:49.366> communally<00:35:49.367> oriented<00:35:49.368> and<00:35:49.369> uh<00:35:49.370> lots<00:35:49.371> of<00:35:49.372> people<00:35:49.373> have<00:35:49.374> argued<00:35:49.375> that<00:35:49.376> wow<00:35:49.377> if

00:35:56.560 --> 00:36:01.040
more<00:35:56.561> people<00:35:56.562> could<00:35:56.563> be<00:35:56.564> like<00:35:56.565> that<00:35:56.566> you<00:35:56.567> know<00:35:56.568> our<00:35:56.569> whole<00:35:56.570> civilization<00:35:56.571> would<00:35:56.572> probably<00:35:56.573> be<00:35:56.574> a<00:35:56.575> whole<00:35:56.576> lot<00:35:56.577> better

00:36:01.040 --> 00:36:08.880
off<00:36:01.041> so<00:36:01.042> that's<00:36:01.043> where<00:36:01.044> it's<00:36:01.045> headed<00:36:01.046> I<00:36:01.047> think<00:36:01.048> in<00:36:01.049> terms<00:36:01.050> of<00:36:01.051> future<00:36:01.052> science<00:36:01.053> and<00:36:01.054> if<00:36:01.055> I<00:36:01.056> were<00:36:01.057> a<00:36:01.058> young<00:36:01.059> person

00:36:08.880 --> 00:36:14.080
just<00:36:08.881> getting<00:36:08.882> started<00:36:08.883> that<00:36:08.884> is<00:36:08.885> certainly<00:36:08.886> where<00:36:08.887> I<00:36:08.888> would<00:36:08.889> go<00:36:08.890> probably<00:36:08.891> to<00:36:08.892> psychedelic<00:36:08.893> neuroimaging

00:36:14.080 --> 00:36:21.760
research<00:36:14.081> and<00:36:14.082> meditation<00:36:14.083> neuroimaging<00:36:14.084> and<00:36:14.085> maybe<00:36:14.086> other<00:36:14.087> things<00:36:14.088> that<00:36:14.089> kind<00:36:14.090> of<00:36:14.091> push<00:36:14.092> in<00:36:14.093> the<00:36:14.094> same<00:36:14.095> direction

00:36:21.760 --> 00:36:32.080
but<00:36:21.761> now<00:36:21.762> there's<00:36:21.763> also<00:36:21.764> I<00:36:21.765> mean<00:36:21.766> this<00:36:21.767> this<00:36:21.768> kind<00:36:21.769> of<00:36:21.770> a<00:36:21.771> psychological<00:36:21.772> picture<00:36:21.773> lends<00:36:21.774> itself<00:36:21.775> to<00:36:21.776> alliance

00:36:32.080 --> 00:36:41.680
with<00:36:32.081> very<00:36:32.082> different<00:36:32.083> philosophical<00:36:32.084> metaphysical<00:36:32.085> ideas<00:36:32.086> than<00:36:32.087> the<00:36:32.088> classical<00:36:32.089> physicalist<00:36:32.090> picture

00:36:41.680 --> 00:36:48.080
so<00:36:41.681> the<00:36:41.682> phenomena<00:36:41.683> you<00:36:41.684> mentioned<00:36:41.685> there<00:36:41.686> there<00:36:41.687> is<00:36:41.688> a<00:36:41.689> huge<00:36:41.690> range<00:36:41.691> of<00:36:41.692> it<00:36:41.693> right<00:36:41.694> so<00:36:41.695> it's<00:36:41.696> um<00:36:41.697> where<00:36:41.698> you

00:36:48.080 --> 00:36:56.400
see<00:36:48.081> that<00:36:48.082> it<00:36:48.083> appears<00:36:48.084> that<00:36:48.085> the<00:36:48.086> mind<00:36:48.087> influences<00:36:48.088> the<00:36:48.089> body<00:36:48.090> so<00:36:48.091> the<00:36:48.092> mind<00:36:48.093> is<00:36:48.094> actually<00:36:48.095> primary<00:36:48.096> to<00:36:48.097> matter

00:36:56.400 --> 00:37:06.480
in<00:36:56.401> this<00:36:56.402> case<00:36:56.403> but<00:36:56.404> have<00:36:56.405> you<00:36:56.406> explored<00:36:56.407> a<00:36:56.408> traditional<00:36:56.409> uh<00:36:56.410> explanations<00:36:56.411> traditional<00:36:56.412> yeah<00:36:56.413> um<00:36:56.414> root<00:36:56.415> causes

00:37:06.480 --> 00:37:14.000
for<00:37:06.481> such<00:37:06.482> phenomena<00:37:06.483> like<00:37:06.484> skin<00:37:06.485> writing<00:37:06.486> or<00:37:06.487> multiple<00:37:06.488> personality<00:37:06.489> disorder<00:37:06.490> and<00:37:06.491> so<00:37:06.492> forth<00:37:06.493> isn't<00:37:06.494> there<00:37:06.495> an

00:37:14.000 --> 00:37:20.800
sort<00:37:14.001> of<00:37:14.002> traditional<00:37:14.003> mainstream<00:37:14.004> explanation<00:37:14.005> that<00:37:14.006> is<00:37:14.007> plausible<00:37:14.008> in<00:37:14.009> your<00:37:14.010> view<00:37:14.011> uh<00:37:14.012> there<00:37:14.013> are<00:37:14.014> attempted

00:37:20.800 --> 00:37:27.040
explanations<00:37:20.801> for<00:37:20.802> many<00:37:20.803> of<00:37:20.804> these<00:37:20.805> things<00:37:20.806> but<00:37:20.807> I<00:37:20.808> think<00:37:20.809> they<00:37:20.810> fail<00:37:20.811> and<00:37:20.812> and<00:37:20.813> actually<00:37:20.814> the<00:37:20.815> the<00:37:20.816> chapters<00:37:20.817> of<00:37:20.818> our

00:37:27.040 --> 00:37:35.200
book<00:37:27.041> Irreducible<00:37:27.042> Mind<00:37:27.043> uh<00:37:27.044> explain<00:37:27.045> why<00:37:27.046> we<00:37:27.047> think<00:37:27.048> they<00:37:27.049> fail<00:37:27.050> uh<00:37:27.051> those<00:37:27.052> are<00:37:27.053> big<00:37:27.054> subjects<00:37:27.055> each<00:37:27.056> one<00:37:27.057> of

00:37:35.200 --> 00:37:42.000
them<00:37:35.201> um<00:37:35.202> but<00:37:35.203> that's<00:37:35.204> the<00:37:35.205> the<00:37:35.206> general<00:37:35.207> answer<00:37:35.208> I<00:37:35.209> mean<00:37:35.210> these<00:37:35.211> the<00:37:35.212> phenomena<00:37:35.213> that<00:37:35.214> we<00:37:35.215> cataloged<00:37:35.216> in<00:37:35.217> our<00:37:35.218> book

00:37:42.000 --> 00:37:51.840
were<00:37:42.001> chosen<00:37:42.002> specifically<00:37:42.003> because<00:37:42.004> they<00:37:42.005> resist<00:37:42.006> or<00:37:42.007> in<00:37:42.008> some<00:37:42.009> cases<00:37:42.010> defy<00:37:42.011> explanation<00:37:42.012> in<00:37:42.013> conventional<00:37:42.014> terms

00:37:51.840 --> 00:37:59.680
so<00:37:51.841> you're<00:37:51.842> saying<00:37:51.843> that<00:37:51.844> you're<00:37:51.845> you<00:37:51.846> have<00:37:51.847> a<00:37:51.848> well<00:37:51.849> proof<00:37:51.850> maybe<00:37:51.851> I<00:37:51.852> don't<00:37:51.853> know<00:37:51.854> if<00:37:51.855> it's<00:37:51.856> a<00:37:51.857> good<00:37:51.858> word

00:37:59.680 --> 00:38:07.040
sufficient<00:37:59.681> evidence<00:37:59.682> you<00:37:59.683> you<00:37:59.684> collected<00:37:59.685> in<00:37:59.686> your<00:37:59.687> in<00:37:59.688> your<00:37:59.689> lifetime<00:37:59.690> of<00:37:59.691> research<00:37:59.692> to<00:37:59.693> at<00:37:59.694> least<00:37:59.695> say<00:37:59.696> that<00:37:59.697> the

00:38:07.040 --> 00:38:13.680
explanations<00:38:07.041> the<00:38:07.042> mainstream<00:38:07.043> science<00:38:07.044> explanations<00:38:07.045> are<00:38:07.046> not<00:38:07.047> um<00:38:07.048> plausible<00:38:07.049> right<00:38:07.050> that's<00:38:07.051> what<00:38:07.052> you're

00:38:13.680 --> 00:38:20.960
saying<00:38:13.681> now<00:38:13.682> let<00:38:13.683> me<00:38:13.684> say<00:38:13.685> that<00:38:13.686> that<00:38:13.687> was<00:38:13.688> really<00:38:13.689> the<00:38:13.690> easy<00:38:13.691> part<00:38:13.692> I<00:38:13.693> mean<00:38:13.694> that<00:38:13.695> was<00:38:13.696> a<00:38:13.697> kind<00:38:13.698> of<00:38:13.699> a<00:38:13.700> huge<00:38:13.701> huge

00:38:20.960 --> 00:38:28.000
clerical<00:38:20.961> job<00:38:20.962> putting<00:38:20.963> Irreducible<00:38:20.964> Mind<00:38:20.965> together<00:38:20.966> but<00:38:20.967> now<00:38:20.968> comes<00:38:20.969> the<00:38:20.970> much<00:38:20.971> harder<00:38:20.972> problem<00:38:20.973> the<00:38:20.974> conceptual

00:38:28.000 --> 00:38:37.600
one<00:38:28.001> okay<00:38:28.002> if<00:38:28.003> physicalism<00:38:28.004> is<00:38:28.005> not<00:38:28.006> up<00:38:28.007> to<00:38:28.008> the<00:38:28.009> job<00:38:28.010> what<00:38:28.011> sort<00:38:28.012> of<00:38:28.013> alternative<00:38:28.014> description<00:38:28.015> of<00:38:28.016> reality<00:38:28.017> would

00:38:37.600 --> 00:38:46.240
make<00:38:37.601> room<00:38:37.602> for<00:38:37.603> the<00:38:37.604> phenomena<00:38:37.605> that<00:38:37.606> we<00:38:37.607> cataloged<00:38:37.608> in<00:38:37.609> that<00:38:37.610> book<00:38:37.611> how<00:38:37.612> is<00:38:37.613> reality<00:38:37.614> actually<00:38:37.615> constituted

00:38:46.240 --> 00:38:52.240
different<00:38:46.241> from<00:38:46.242> the<00:38:46.243> conventional<00:38:46.244> picture<00:38:46.245> uh<00:38:46.246> that<00:38:46.247> what<00:38:46.248> is<00:38:46.249> it<00:38:46.250> about<00:38:46.251> that<00:38:46.252> that<00:38:46.253> permits<00:38:46.254> these<00:38:46.255> things

00:38:52.240 --> 00:38:59.200
to<00:38:52.241> occur<00:38:52.242> so<00:38:52.243> to<00:38:52.244> approach<00:38:52.245> that<00:38:52.246> we<00:38:52.247> we<00:38:52.248> again<00:38:52.249> kind<00:38:52.250> of<00:38:52.251> stumbled<00:38:52.252> around<00:38:52.253> for<00:38:52.254> a<00:38:52.255> couple<00:38:52.256> of<00:38:52.257> years<00:38:52.258> trying<00:38:52.259> to

00:38:59.200 --> 00:39:07.840
figure<00:38:59.201> out<00:38:59.202> what<00:38:59.203> to<00:38:59.204> do<00:38:59.205> and<00:38:59.206> we<00:38:59.207> then<00:38:59.208> set<00:38:59.209> upon<00:38:59.210> uh<00:38:59.211> a<00:38:59.212> plan<00:38:59.213> which<00:38:59.214> was<00:38:59.215> basically<00:38:59.216> to<00:38:59.217> look<00:38:59.218> at<00:38:59.219> a<00:38:59.220> number

00:39:07.840 --> 00:39:16.320
of<00:39:07.841> systems<00:39:07.842> old<00:39:07.843> and<00:39:07.844> new<00:39:07.845> uh<00:39:07.846> that<00:39:07.847> take<00:39:07.848> the<00:39:07.849> existence<00:39:07.850> of<00:39:07.851> the<00:39:07.852> phenomena<00:39:07.853> that<00:39:07.854> we<00:39:07.855> cataloged<00:39:07.856> in<00:39:07.857> Irreducible

00:39:16.320 --> 00:39:24.080
Mind<00:39:16.321> seriously<00:39:16.322> and<00:39:16.323> attempt<00:39:16.324> to<00:39:16.325> provide<00:39:16.326> some<00:39:16.327> kind<00:39:16.328> of<00:39:16.329> a<00:39:16.330> explanation<00:39:16.331> for<00:39:16.332> at<00:39:16.333> least<00:39:16.334> some<00:39:16.335> of

00:39:24.080 --> 00:39:30.240
And<00:39:24.081> of<00:39:24.082> course<00:39:24.083> we<00:39:24.084> were<00:39:24.085> dependent<00:39:24.086> in<00:39:24.087> pursuing<00:39:24.088> this<00:39:24.089> on<00:39:24.090> the<00:39:24.091> expertise<00:39:24.092> that<00:39:24.093> we<00:39:24.094> happen<00:39:24.095> to<00:39:24.096> have<00:39:24.097> in<00:39:24.098> our

00:39:30.240 --> 00:39:37.280
group<00:39:30.241> which<00:39:30.242> by<00:39:30.243> the<00:39:30.244> way<00:39:30.245> has<00:39:30.246> consisted<00:39:30.247> of<00:39:30.248> something<00:39:30.249> like<00:39:30.250> 50<00:39:30.251> people<00:39:30.252> over<00:39:30.253> the<00:39:30.254> last<00:39:30.255> 20<00:39:30.256> odd<00:39:30.257> years<00:39:30.258> people

00:39:37.280 --> 00:39:47.360
coming<00:39:37.281> and<00:39:37.282> going<00:39:37.283> for<00:39:37.284> various<00:39:37.285> reasons<00:39:37.286> um<00:39:37.287> but<00:39:37.288> uh<00:39:37.289> we<00:39:37.290> then<00:39:37.291> created<00:39:37.292> a<00:39:37.293> second<00:39:37.294> book<00:39:37.295> Beyond<00:39:37.296> Physicalism<00:39:37.297> uh

00:39:47.360 --> 00:39:58.720
which<00:39:47.361> mainly<00:39:47.362> consisted<00:39:47.363> of<00:39:47.364> um<00:39:47.365> chapters<00:39:47.366> presenting<00:39:47.367> and<00:39:47.368> discussing<00:39:47.369> uh<00:39:47.370> these<00:39:47.371> other<00:39:47.372> or<00:39:47.373> general<00:39:47.374> points

00:39:58.720 --> 00:40:05.920
of<00:39:58.721> view<00:39:58.722> some<00:39:58.723> came<00:39:58.724> from<00:39:58.725> physics<00:39:58.726> uh<00:39:58.727> some<00:39:58.728> from<00:39:58.729> quantum<00:39:58.730> theory<00:39:58.731> some<00:39:58.732> from<00:39:58.733> one<00:39:58.734> from<00:39:58.735> relativity

00:40:05.920 --> 00:40:15.920
and<00:40:05.921> string<00:40:05.922> theory<00:40:05.923> and<00:40:05.924> uh<00:40:05.925> one<00:40:05.926> via<00:40:05.927> Harold<00:40:05.928> Atmanspacher<00:40:05.929> from<00:40:05.930> Carl<00:40:05.931> Jung<00:40:05.932> and<00:40:05.933> his<00:40:05.934> dialogue<00:40:05.935> with<00:40:05.936> Pauli<00:40:05.937> uh

00:40:15.920 --> 00:40:21.920
we<00:40:15.921> also<00:40:15.922> looked<00:40:15.923> at<00:40:15.924> mystically<00:40:15.925> inspired<00:40:15.926> religious<00:40:15.927> philosophies<00:40:15.928> in<00:40:15.929> particular<00:40:15.930> a<00:40:15.931> couple<00:40:15.932> of<00:40:15.933> versions<00:40:15.934> of

00:40:21.920 --> 00:40:35.280
Hinduism<00:40:21.921> and<00:40:21.922> Neoplatonism<00:40:21.923> uh<00:40:21.924> and<00:40:21.925> modern<00:40:21.926> expression<00:40:21.927> in<00:40:21.928> uh<00:40:21.929> um<00:40:21.930> Aurobindo<00:40:21.931> a<00:40:21.932> kind<00:40:21.933> of<00:40:21.934> tantric<00:40:21.935> form<00:40:21.936> of

00:40:35.280 --> 00:40:42.720
Hinduism<00:40:35.281> which<00:40:35.282> connects<00:40:35.283> according<00:40:35.284> to<00:40:35.285> the<00:40:35.286> author<00:40:35.287> of<00:40:35.288> that<00:40:35.289> chapter<00:40:35.290> Eric<00:40:35.291> Weiss<00:40:35.292> very<00:40:35.293> nicely<00:40:35.294> with<00:40:35.295> uh<00:40:35.296> White

00:40:42.720 --> 00:40:52.880
head's<00:40:42.721> process<00:40:42.722> metaphysics<00:40:42.723> And<00:40:42.724> we<00:40:42.725> also<00:40:42.726> looked<00:40:42.727> at<00:40:42.728> several<00:40:42.729> western<00:40:42.730> uh<00:40:42.731> philosophical<00:40:42.732> systems<00:40:42.733> those<00:40:42.734> of

00:40:52.880 --> 00:41:08.320
u<00:40:52.881> um<00:40:52.882> Leibniz<00:40:52.883> and<00:40:52.884> eventually<00:40:52.885> Hegel<00:40:52.886> uh<00:40:52.887> Charles<00:40:52.888> Sanders<00:40:52.889> Peirce<00:40:52.890> and<00:40:52.891> Whitehead<00:40:52.892> uh<00:40:52.893> and<00:40:52.894> uh<00:40:52.895> toward<00:40:52.896> the

00:41:08.320 --> 00:41:16.240
end<00:41:08.321> of<00:41:08.322> that<00:41:08.323> book<00:41:08.324> Beyond<00:41:08.325> Physicalism<00:41:08.326> um<00:41:08.327> Michael<00:41:08.328> Murphy<00:41:08.329> and<00:41:08.330> I<00:41:08.331> in<00:41:08.332> our<00:41:08.333> different<00:41:08.334> ways<00:41:08.335> attempted<00:41:08.336> to

00:41:16.240 --> 00:41:24.720
kind<00:41:16.241> of<00:41:16.242> see<00:41:16.243> what<00:41:16.244> what<00:41:16.245> is<00:41:16.246> the<00:41:16.247> central<00:41:16.248> tendency<00:41:16.249> of<00:41:16.250> all<00:41:16.251> these<00:41:16.252> systems<00:41:16.253> what<00:41:16.254> do<00:41:16.255> they<00:41:16.256> have<00:41:16.257> in<00:41:16.258> common<00:41:16.259> what

00:41:24.720 --> 00:41:31.600
kind<00:41:24.721> of<00:41:24.722> a<00:41:24.723> picture<00:41:24.724> do<00:41:24.725> they<00:41:24.726> tend<00:41:24.727> toward<00:41:24.728> as<00:41:24.729> opposed<00:41:24.730> to<00:41:24.731> the<00:41:24.732> one<00:41:24.733> that<00:41:24.734> currently<00:41:24.735> dominates<00:41:24.736> uh<00:41:24.737> expert

00:41:31.600 --> 00:41:42.240
opinion<00:41:31.601> in<00:41:31.602> most<00:41:31.603> of<00:41:31.604> science<00:41:31.605> and<00:41:31.606> society<00:41:31.607> and<00:41:31.608> what<00:41:31.609> we<00:41:31.610> came<00:41:31.611> to<00:41:31.612> was<00:41:31.613> essentially<00:41:31.614> a<00:41:31.615> uh<00:41:31.616> realist<00:41:31.617> idealism

00:41:42.240 --> 00:41:50.240
that<00:41:42.241> is<00:41:42.242> essentially<00:41:42.243> the<00:41:42.244> metaphysical<00:41:42.245> opposite<00:41:42.246> of<00:41:42.247> physicalism<00:41:42.248> in<00:41:42.249> which<00:41:42.250> some<00:41:42.251> kind<00:41:42.252> of<00:41:42.253> highest

00:41:50.240 --> 00:41:56.720
consciousness<00:41:50.241> is<00:41:50.242> primary<00:41:50.243> everything<00:41:50.244> else<00:41:50.245> has<00:41:50.246> to<00:41:50.247> come<00:41:50.248> from<00:41:50.249> that<00:41:50.250> somehow<00:41:50.251> instead<00:41:50.252> of<00:41:50.253> this<00:41:50.254> minute

00:41:56.720 --> 00:42:05.920
physical<00:41:56.721> stuff<00:41:56.722> um<00:41:56.723> I'm<00:41:56.724> certainly<00:41:56.725> not<00:41:56.726> going<00:41:56.727> to<00:41:56.728> claim<00:41:56.729> that<00:41:56.730> we<00:41:56.731> have<00:41:56.732> a<00:41:56.733> finished<00:41:56.734> theory<00:41:56.735> of<00:41:56.736> that<00:41:56.737> sort<00:41:56.738> but

00:42:05.920 --> 00:42:12.880
I<00:42:05.921> think<00:42:05.922> we<00:42:05.923> have<00:42:05.924> a<00:42:05.925> strong<00:42:05.926> sense<00:42:05.927> of<00:42:05.928> direction<00:42:05.929> that<00:42:05.930> it's<00:42:05.931> it's<00:42:05.932> out<00:42:05.933> there<00:42:05.934> somewhere<00:42:05.935> that<00:42:05.936> the<00:42:05.937> the<00:42:05.938> right

00:42:12.880 --> 00:42:23.360
answer<00:42:12.881> or<00:42:12.882> a<00:42:12.883> much<00:42:12.884> closer<00:42:12.885> to<00:42:12.886> right<00:42:12.887> answer<00:42:12.888> can<00:42:12.889> be<00:42:12.890> found<00:42:12.891> and<00:42:12.892> uh<00:42:12.893> we're<00:42:12.894> continuing<00:42:12.895> to<00:42:12.896> pursue<00:42:12.897> that<00:42:12.898> um

00:42:23.360 --> 00:42:30.320
from<00:42:23.361> a<00:42:23.362> kind<00:42:23.363> of<00:42:23.364> natural<00:42:23.365> theology<00:42:23.366> point<00:42:23.367> of<00:42:23.368> view<00:42:23.369> uh<00:42:23.370> it<00:42:23.371> goes<00:42:23.372> under<00:42:23.373> the<00:42:23.374> heading<00:42:23.375> of<00:42:23.376> evolutionary

00:42:30.320 --> 00:42:38.240
panentheism<00:42:30.321> uh<00:42:30.322> this<00:42:30.323> tries<00:42:30.324> panentheism<00:42:30.325> tries<00:42:30.326> to<00:42:30.327> split<00:42:30.328> the<00:42:30.329> difference<00:42:30.330> between<00:42:30.331> traditional<00:42:30.332> theisms

00:42:38.240 --> 00:42:44.080
you<00:42:38.241> know<00:42:38.242> with<00:42:38.243> a<00:42:38.244> kind<00:42:38.245> of<00:42:38.246> all<00:42:38.247> powerful<00:42:38.248> being<00:42:38.249> who<00:42:38.250> creates<00:42:38.251> everything<00:42:38.252> and<00:42:38.253> lets<00:42:38.254> it<00:42:38.255> run<00:42:38.256> on<00:42:38.257> may<00:42:38.258> or<00:42:38.259> may

00:42:44.080 --> 00:42:54.800
not<00:42:44.081> intervene<00:42:44.082> in<00:42:44.083> various<00:42:44.084> ways<00:42:44.085> and<00:42:44.086> um<00:42:44.087> pantheisms<00:42:44.088> in<00:42:44.089> which<00:42:44.090> um<00:42:44.091> the<00:42:44.092> ultimate<00:42:44.093> reality<00:42:44.094> is<00:42:44.095> identified<00:42:44.096> with

00:42:54.800 --> 00:43:03.200
everything<00:42:54.801> that<00:42:54.802> exists<00:42:54.803> in<00:42:54.804> actuality<00:42:54.805> panentheism<00:42:54.806> splits<00:42:54.807> the<00:42:54.808> difference<00:42:54.809> in<00:42:54.810> in<00:42:54.811> the<00:42:54.812> sense<00:42:54.813> that<00:42:54.814> the

00:43:03.200 --> 00:43:10.800
highest<00:43:03.201> consciousness<00:43:03.202> whatever<00:43:03.203> it<00:43:03.204> is<00:43:03.205> is<00:43:03.206> present<00:43:03.207> in<00:43:03.208> everything<00:43:03.209> and<00:43:03.210> yet<00:43:03.211> there's<00:43:03.212> something<00:43:03.213> left<00:43:03.214> over

00:43:10.800 --> 00:43:18.720
from<00:43:10.801> what<00:43:10.802> we<00:43:10.803> find<00:43:10.804> around<00:43:10.805> us<00:43:10.806> you<00:43:10.807> know<00:43:10.808> here<00:43:10.809> we<00:43:10.810> find<00:43:10.811> ourselves<00:43:10.812> in<00:43:10.813> this<00:43:10.814> world<00:43:10.815> as<00:43:10.816> seemingly<00:43:10.817> independent

00:43:18.720 --> 00:43:26.480
beings<00:43:18.721> who<00:43:18.722> generally<00:43:18.723> experience<00:43:18.724> the<00:43:18.725> same<00:43:18.726> stuff<00:43:18.727> around<00:43:18.728> us<00:43:18.729> we<00:43:18.730> can<00:43:18.731> agree<00:43:18.732> about<00:43:18.733> what's<00:43:18.734> there

00:43:26.480 --> 00:43:42.000
um<00:43:26.481> the<00:43:26.482> trick<00:43:26.483> will<00:43:26.484> be<00:43:26.485> to<00:43:26.486> find<00:43:26.487> a<00:43:26.488> system<00:43:26.489> that<00:43:26.490> in<00:43:26.491> some<00:43:26.492> detail<00:43:26.493> allows<00:43:26.494> us<00:43:26.495> to<00:43:26.496> explain<00:43:26.497> how<00:43:26.498> both<00:43:26.499> we<00:43:26.500> and<00:43:26.501> it<00:43:26.502> can

00:43:42.000 --> 00:43:51.200
come<00:43:42.001> out<00:43:42.002> of<00:43:42.003> this<00:43:42.004> ultimate<00:43:42.005> consciousness<00:43:42.006> whatever<00:43:42.007> it<00:43:42.008> is<00:43:42.009> William<00:43:42.010> James<00:43:42.011> and<00:43:42.012> I<00:43:42.013> traced<00:43:42.014> this<00:43:42.015> in<00:43:42.016> the

00:43:51.200 --> 00:43:58.400
uh<00:43:51.201> last<00:43:51.202> part<00:43:51.203> of<00:43:51.204> chapter<00:43:51.205> 14<00:43:51.206> of<00:43:51.207> Beyond<00:43:51.208> Physicalism<00:43:51.209> William<00:43:51.210> James<00:43:51.211> built<00:43:51.212> explicitly<00:43:51.213> on<00:43:51.214> the

00:43:58.400 --> 00:44:05.840
psychological<00:43:58.401> theory<00:43:58.402> of<00:43:58.403> Myers<00:43:58.404> which<00:43:58.405> he<00:43:58.406> held<00:43:58.407> to<00:43:58.408> be<00:43:58.409> empirically<00:43:58.410> justified<00:43:58.411> uh<00:43:58.412> but<00:43:58.413> he<00:43:58.414> was<00:43:58.415> also<00:43:58.416> in<00:43:58.417> league

00:44:05.840 --> 00:44:14.320
with<00:44:05.841> people<00:44:05.842> like<00:44:05.843> uh<00:44:05.844> Gustav<00:44:05.845> Fechner<00:44:05.846> and<00:44:05.847> Henri<00:44:05.848> Bergson<00:44:05.849> and<00:44:05.850> FCS<00:44:05.851> Schiller<00:44:05.852> another<00:44:05.853> metaphysician

00:44:14.320 --> 00:44:22.960
at<00:44:14.321> Oxford<00:44:14.322> at<00:44:14.323> the<00:44:14.324> time<00:44:14.325> James<00:44:14.326> imagined<00:44:14.327> oh<00:44:14.328> and<00:44:14.329> let<00:44:14.330> me<00:44:14.331> just<00:44:14.332> say<00:44:14.333> too<00:44:14.334> that<00:44:14.335> James<00:44:14.336> kind<00:44:14.337> of<00:44:14.338> previewed

00:44:22.960 --> 00:44:29.840
what<00:44:22.961> where<00:44:22.962> he<00:44:22.963> was<00:44:22.964> headed<00:44:22.965> in<00:44:22.966> Varieties<00:44:22.967> of<00:44:22.968> Religious<00:44:22.969> Experience<00:44:22.970> which<00:44:22.971> is<00:44:22.972> probably<00:44:22.973> still<00:44:22.974> the<00:44:22.975> bestselling

00:44:29.840 --> 00:44:37.520
book<00:44:29.841> in<00:44:29.842> the<00:44:29.843> history<00:44:29.844> of<00:44:29.845> psychology<00:44:29.846> and<00:44:29.847> he<00:44:29.848> says<00:44:29.849> multiple<00:44:29.850> times<00:44:29.851> in<00:44:29.852> that<00:44:29.853> book<00:44:29.854> that<00:44:29.855> explicitly<00:44:29.856> that

00:44:37.520 --> 00:44:43.760
he<00:44:37.521> is<00:44:37.522> building<00:44:37.523> on<00:44:37.524> the<00:44:37.525> work<00:44:37.526> of<00:44:37.527> FW<00:44:37.528> Myers<00:44:37.529> using<00:44:37.530> Myers's<00:44:37.531> psychological<00:44:37.532> model<00:44:37.533> to<00:44:37.534> explain<00:44:37.535> various

00:44:43.760 --> 00:44:53.280
kinds<00:44:43.761> of<00:44:43.762> religious<00:44:43.763> phenomena<00:44:43.764> and<00:44:43.765> at<00:44:43.766> the<00:44:43.767> end<00:44:43.768> he<00:44:43.769> hints<00:44:43.770> at<00:44:43.771> the<00:44:43.772> direction<00:44:43.773> he<00:44:43.774> is<00:44:43.775> going<00:44:43.776> to<00:44:43.777> take<00:44:43.778> this

00:44:53.280 --> 00:44:59.200
which<00:44:53.281> is<00:44:53.282> more<00:44:53.283> fully<00:44:53.284> worked<00:44:53.285> out<00:44:53.286> in<00:44:53.287> his<00:44:53.288> last<00:44:53.289> book<00:44:53.290> A<00:44:53.291> Pluralistic<00:44:53.292> Universe<00:44:53.293> published<00:44:53.294> in<00:44:53.295> 1909<00:44:53.296> the<00:44:53.297> year

00:44:59.200 --> 00:45:07.360
before<00:44:59.201> he<00:44:59.202> died<00:44:59.203> in<00:44:59.204> which<00:44:59.205> he<00:44:59.206> takes<00:44:59.207> Myers's<00:44:59.208> model<00:44:59.209> with<00:44:59.210> this<00:44:59.211> subliminal<00:44:59.212> consciousness<00:44:59.213> and<00:44:59.214> by<00:44:59.215> the<00:44:59.216> way

00:45:07.360 --> 00:45:15.680
that's<00:45:07.361> the<00:45:07.362> part<00:45:07.363> of<00:45:07.364> the<00:45:07.365> psyche<00:45:07.366> that<00:45:07.367> Myers<00:45:07.368> imagined<00:45:07.369> uh<00:45:07.370> surviving<00:45:07.371> bodily<00:45:07.372> death<00:45:07.373> he<00:45:07.374> imagines<00:45:07.375> it<00:45:07.376> having

00:45:15.680 --> 00:45:25.360
a<00:45:15.681> higher<00:45:15.682> environment<00:45:15.683> of<00:45:15.684> its<00:45:15.685> own<00:45:15.686> possibly<00:45:15.687> several<00:45:15.688> levels<00:45:15.689> of<00:45:15.690> higher<00:45:15.691> integration<00:45:15.692> leading<00:45:15.693> toward<00:45:15.694> some

00:45:25.360 --> 00:45:34.080
highest<00:45:25.361> consciousness<00:45:25.362> which<00:45:25.363> is<00:45:25.364> not<00:45:25.365> quite<00:45:25.366> however<00:45:25.367> the<00:45:25.368> absolute<00:45:25.369> of<00:45:25.370> the<00:45:25.371> uh<00:45:25.372> British<00:45:25.373> idealists<00:45:25.374> of<00:45:25.375> the

00:45:34.080 --> 00:45:43.040
late<00:45:34.081> 19th<00:45:34.082> early<00:45:34.083> 20th<00:45:34.084> century<00:45:34.085> uh<00:45:34.086> and<00:45:34.087> all<00:45:34.088> this<00:45:34.089> is<00:45:34.090> kind<00:45:34.091> of<00:45:34.092> traced<00:45:34.093> in<00:45:34.094> some<00:45:34.095> detail<00:45:34.096> in<00:45:34.097> that<00:45:34.098> chapter<00:45:34.099> in

00:45:43.040 --> 00:45:50.000
Beyond<00:45:43.041> Physicalism<00:45:43.042> so<00:45:43.043> it's<00:45:43.044> in<00:45:43.045> that<00:45:43.046> direction<00:45:43.047> that<00:45:43.048> I've<00:45:43.049> gone<00:45:43.050> we<00:45:43.051> have<00:45:43.052> another<00:45:43.053> book<00:45:43.054> I<00:45:43.055> should<00:45:43.056> mention

00:45:50.000 --> 00:45:56.320
uh<00:45:50.001> Consciousness<00:45:50.002> Unbound<00:45:50.003> published<00:45:50.004> in<00:45:50.005> 2021<00:45:50.006> which<00:45:50.007> continues<00:45:50.008> the<00:45:50.009> themes<00:45:50.010> of<00:45:50.011> the<00:45:50.012> first<00:45:50.013> two

00:45:56.320 --> 00:46:03.600
books<00:45:56.321> they're<00:45:56.322> there<00:45:56.323> are<00:45:56.324> empirical<00:45:56.325> chapters<00:45:56.326> for<00:45:56.327> example<00:45:56.328> state<00:45:56.329> state<00:45:56.330> of<00:45:56.331> the<00:45:56.332> science<00:45:56.333> summaries<00:45:56.334> of

00:46:03.600 --> 00:46:11.120
uh<00:46:03.601> things<00:46:03.602> like<00:46:03.603> near-death<00:46:03.604> experiences<00:46:03.605> precognition<00:46:03.606> which<00:46:03.607> is<00:46:03.608> theoretically<00:46:03.609> crucial<00:46:03.610> and<00:46:03.611> cases<00:46:03.612> of<00:46:03.613> the

00:46:11.120 --> 00:46:17.360
reincarnation<00:46:11.121> type<00:46:11.122> and<00:46:11.123> then<00:46:11.124> a<00:46:11.125> bunch<00:46:11.126> more<00:46:11.127> theoretical<00:46:11.128> positions<00:46:11.129> that<00:46:11.130> fall<00:46:11.131> into<00:46:11.132> the

00:46:17.360 --> 00:46:24.240
same<00:46:17.361> general<00:46:17.362> category<00:46:17.363> uh<00:46:17.364> chapter<00:46:17.365> on<00:46:17.366> the<00:46:17.367> late<00:46:17.368> transformation<00:46:17.369> of<00:46:17.370> Jung<00:46:17.371> for<00:46:17.372> example<00:46:17.373> by<00:46:17.374> Rodrik

00:46:24.240 --> 00:46:30.880
Many<00:46:24.241> young<00:46:24.242> scholars<00:46:24.243> who<00:46:24.244> show<00:46:24.245> clearly<00:46:24.246> that<00:46:24.247> Jung<00:46:24.248> himself,<00:46:24.249> following<00:46:24.250> a<00:46:24.251> near-death<00:46:24.252> experience<00:46:24.253> of<00:46:24.254> his

00:46:30.880 --> 00:46:39.360
own<00:46:30.881> connection<00:46:30.882> with<00:46:30.883> a<00:46:30.884> heart<00:46:30.885> attack,<00:46:30.886> was<00:46:30.887> moving<00:46:30.888> very<00:46:30.889> strongly<00:46:30.890> in<00:46:30.891> the<00:46:30.892> panentheism<00:46:30.893> direction,<00:46:30.894> uh,

00:46:39.360 --> 00:46:49.120
then<00:46:39.361> we<00:46:39.362> had<00:46:39.363> chapters<00:46:39.364> by,<00:46:39.365> uh,<00:46:39.366> Bernardo<00:46:39.367> Kastrup<00:46:39.368> on<00:46:39.369> his<00:46:39.370> analytic<00:46:39.371> idealism,<00:46:39.372> one<00:46:39.373> by<00:46:39.374> Federico<00:46:39.375> Faggin,<00:46:39.376> which<00:46:39.377> I

00:46:49.120 --> 00:46:55.120
personally<00:46:49.121> find<00:46:49.122> particularly<00:46:49.123> congenial,<00:46:49.124> mainly<00:46:49.125> because<00:46:49.126> it<00:46:49.127> lines<00:46:49.128> up<00:46:49.129> very<00:46:49.130> well<00:46:49.131> with<00:46:49.132> the<00:46:49.133> Myers-

00:46:55.120 --> 00:47:04.320
James<00:46:55.121> picture<00:46:55.122> of<00:46:55.123> things,<00:46:55.124> uh,<00:46:55.125> and<00:46:55.126> a<00:46:55.127> couple<00:46:55.128> others,<00:46:55.129> um,<00:46:55.130> and<00:46:55.131> then<00:46:55.132> some<00:46:55.133> for<00:46:55.134> the<00:46:55.135> first<00:46:55.136> time<00:46:55.137> we<00:46:55.138> began<00:46:55.139> at

00:47:04.320 --> 00:47:14.800
at<00:47:04.321> least<00:47:04.322> beginning<00:47:04.323> to<00:47:04.324> look<00:47:04.325> at<00:47:04.326> how<00:47:04.327> ascendants<00:47:04.328> of<00:47:04.329> a<00:47:04.330> picture<00:47:04.331> of<00:47:04.332> this<00:47:04.333> general<00:47:04.334> sort<00:47:04.335> might<00:47:04.336> have<00:47:04.337> positive

00:47:14.800 --> 00:47:22.800
impacts<00:47:14.801> on<00:47:14.802> both<00:47:14.803> academia<00:47:14.804> and<00:47:14.805> society<00:47:14.806> as<00:47:14.807> a<00:47:14.808> whole.<00:47:14.809> I<00:47:14.810> mean,<00:47:14.811> I<00:47:14.812> think<00:47:14.813> something<00:47:14.814> that<00:47:14.815> we<00:47:14.816> share<00:47:14.817> deeply<00:47:14.818> with

00:47:22.800 --> 00:47:31.440
Bernardo<00:47:22.801> and<00:47:22.802> a<00:47:22.803> lot<00:47:22.804> of<00:47:22.805> other<00:47:22.806> people<00:47:22.807> is<00:47:22.808> the<00:47:22.809> sense<00:47:22.810> that<00:47:22.811> the,<00:47:22.812> the<00:47:22.813> prevalence<00:47:22.814> of<00:47:22.815> physicalism<00:47:22.816> and<00:47:22.817> the

00:47:31.440 --> 00:47:39.920
kinds<00:47:31.441> of<00:47:31.442> behaviors<00:47:31.443> that<00:47:31.444> it<00:47:31.445> encourages,<00:47:31.446> uh,<00:47:31.447> is<00:47:31.448> the<00:47:31.449> source<00:47:31.450> of<00:47:31.451> a<00:47:31.452> lot<00:47:31.453> of<00:47:31.454> our<00:47:31.455> gigantic<00:47:31.456> and<00:47:31.457> potentially

00:47:39.920 --> 00:47:49.680
lethal<00:47:39.921> problems<00:47:39.922> as<00:47:39.923> a<00:47:39.924> civilization:<00:47:39.925> our,<00:47:39.926> our<00:47:39.927> egoism,<00:47:39.928> our<00:47:39.929> consumerism,<00:47:39.930> our<00:47:39.931> plundering<00:47:39.932> of<00:47:39.933> the<00:47:39.934> planet,<00:47:39.935> our

00:47:49.680 --> 00:47:57.120
loading<00:47:49.681> ourselves<00:47:49.682> with<00:47:49.683> potentially<00:47:49.684> lethal<00:47:49.685> weapons,<00:47:49.686> all<00:47:49.687> that<00:47:49.688> kind<00:47:49.689> of<00:47:49.690> stuff.<00:47:49.691> I<00:47:49.692> think<00:47:49.693> all<00:47:49.694> has<00:47:49.695> deep<00:47:49.696> roots

00:47:57.120 --> 00:48:06.160
in<00:47:57.121> the<00:47:57.122> kind<00:47:57.123> of<00:47:57.124> worldview<00:47:57.125> that<00:47:57.126> has<00:47:57.127> dominated<00:47:57.128> until<00:47:57.129> right<00:47:57.130> about<00:47:57.131> now,<00:47:57.132> and<00:47:57.133> that,<00:47:57.134> uh,<00:47:57.135> in<00:47:57.136> if<00:47:57.137> we<00:47:57.138> can<00:47:57.139> find<00:47:57.140> a

00:48:06.160 --> 00:48:14.160
scientifically<00:48:06.161> compelling<00:48:06.162> improved<00:48:06.163> picture<00:48:06.164> of<00:48:06.165> reality<00:48:06.166> that,<00:48:06.167> uh,<00:48:06.168> helps<00:48:06.169> people<00:48:06.170> to<00:48:06.171> feel<00:48:06.172> connected

00:48:14.160 --> 00:48:19.360
with<00:48:14.161> something<00:48:14.162> fundamental<00:48:14.163> in<00:48:14.164> the<00:48:14.165> universe,<00:48:14.166> you<00:48:14.167> know,<00:48:14.168> have<00:48:14.169> a<00:48:14.170> spiritual<00:48:14.171> life<00:48:14.172> of<00:48:14.173> some<00:48:14.174> satisfying

00:48:19.360 --> 00:48:26.720
kind,<00:48:19.361> that<00:48:19.362> could<00:48:19.363> be<00:48:19.364> a,<00:48:19.365> a<00:48:19.366> very<00:48:19.367> good,<00:48:19.368> uh,<00:48:19.369> positive<00:48:19.370> contribution<00:48:19.371> to<00:48:19.372> the<00:48:19.373> very<00:48:19.374> dangerous<00:48:19.375> situation

00:48:26.720 --> 00:48:34.960
that<00:48:26.721> we<00:48:26.722> find<00:48:26.723> ourselves<00:48:26.724> in.<00:48:26.725> Anyway,<00:48:26.726> I'm<00:48:26.727> sorry<00:48:26.728> to<00:48:26.729> kind<00:48:26.730> of<00:48:26.731> go<00:48:26.732> off<00:48:26.733> on<00:48:26.734> that<00:48:26.735> tangent,<00:48:26.736> but<00:48:26.737> it<00:48:26.738> is<00:48:26.739> an<00:48:26.740> important

00:48:34.960 --> 00:48:41.840
part<00:48:34.961> of<00:48:34.962> the<00:48:34.963> current<00:48:34.964> situation,<00:48:34.965> and<00:48:34.966> I,<00:48:34.967> I<00:48:34.968> think<00:48:34.969> the,<00:48:34.970> the<00:48:34.971> kinds<00:48:34.972> of<00:48:34.973> theoretical<00:48:34.974> contributions<00:48:34.975> that<00:48:34.976> people

00:48:41.840 --> 00:48:51.760
like<00:48:41.841> Bernardo<00:48:41.842> and<00:48:41.843> Federico<00:48:41.844> and<00:48:41.845> we<00:48:41.846> are<00:48:41.847> attempting<00:48:41.848> to,<00:48:41.849> to<00:48:41.850> make,<00:48:41.851> uh,<00:48:41.852> could<00:48:41.853> feed<00:48:41.854> into<00:48:41.855> that<00:48:41.856> situation<00:48:41.857> in<00:48:41.858> a

00:48:51.760 --> 00:49:00.560
positive<00:48:51.761> way.<00:48:51.762> I<00:48:51.763> think<00:48:51.764> it's<00:48:51.765> an<00:48:51.766> important<00:48:51.767> point,<00:48:51.768> um,<00:48:51.769> but<00:48:51.770> I<00:48:51.771> wanted<00:48:51.772> to<00:48:51.773> ask<00:48:51.774> you,<00:48:51.775> does<00:48:51.776> metaphysics<00:48:51.777> play<00:48:51.778> a

00:49:00.560 --> 00:49:07.040
role<00:49:00.561> in<00:49:00.562> science<00:49:00.563> in<00:49:00.564> your<00:49:00.565> view,<00:49:00.566> and<00:49:00.567> should<00:49:00.568> it<00:49:00.569> play<00:49:00.570> a<00:49:00.571> role<00:49:00.572> in<00:49:00.573> science?<00:49:00.574> Because<00:49:00.575> on<00:49:00.576> one<00:49:00.577> hand,<00:49:00.578> you<00:49:00.579> could

00:49:07.040 --> 00:49:13.520
say<00:49:07.041> it's<00:49:07.042> useful<00:49:07.043> metaphysics<00:49:07.044> because<00:49:07.045> it's<00:49:07.046> an<00:49:07.047> underlying<00:49:07.048> explanatory<00:49:07.049> model<00:49:07.050> of<00:49:07.051> reality<00:49:07.052> that

00:49:13.520 --> 00:49:20.960
drives<00:49:13.521> essentially<00:49:13.522> the<00:49:13.523> research<00:49:13.524> questions.<00:49:13.525> Now,<00:49:13.526> the<00:49:13.527> opposite<00:49:13.528> view<00:49:13.529> is,<00:49:13.530> uh,<00:49:13.531> metaphysics<00:49:13.532> or<00:49:13.533> philosophy<00:49:13.534> is

00:49:20.960 --> 00:49:27.440
redundant,<00:49:20.961> and<00:49:20.962> science<00:49:20.963> as<00:49:20.964> objective<00:49:20.965> discipline<00:49:20.966> should<00:49:20.967> stay<00:49:20.968> away<00:49:20.969> from<00:49:20.970> philosophy<00:49:20.971> altogether.

00:49:27.440 --> 00:49:36.400
What<00:49:27.441> is<00:49:27.442> your<00:49:27.443> view?<00:49:27.444> Yeah,<00:49:27.445> of<00:49:27.446> course,<00:49:27.447> uh,<00:49:27.448> there<00:49:27.449> are<00:49:27.450> lots<00:49:27.451> of<00:49:27.452> disagreements<00:49:27.453> about<00:49:27.454> these<00:49:27.455> kinds<00:49:27.456> of<00:49:27.457> big

00:49:36.400 --> 00:49:48.080
subjects,<00:49:36.401> but,<00:49:36.402> uh,<00:49:36.403> in<00:49:36.404> my<00:49:36.405> view,<00:49:36.406> and<00:49:36.407> I<00:49:36.408> know<00:49:36.409> it's<00:49:36.410> shared<00:49:36.411> by<00:49:36.412> a<00:49:36.413> number<00:49:36.414> of<00:49:36.415> members<00:49:36.416> of<00:49:36.417> our<00:49:36.418> group,<00:49:36.419> including<00:49:36.420> a

00:49:48.080 --> 00:50:00.080
number<00:49:48.081> of<00:49:48.082> physicists,<00:49:48.083> by<00:49:48.084> the<00:49:48.085> way,<00:49:48.086> uh,<00:49:48.087> science<00:49:48.088> has<00:49:48.089> tended<00:49:48.090> to<00:49:48.091> imagine<00:49:48.092> itself<00:49:48.093> free<00:49:48.094> of<00:49:48.095> metaphysics

00:50:00.080 --> 00:50:08.160
when<00:50:00.081> in<00:50:00.082> fact<00:50:00.083> it<00:50:00.084> invariably<00:50:00.085> comes<00:50:00.086> together<00:50:00.087> with<00:50:00.088> either<00:50:00.089> recognized<00:50:00.090> or<00:50:00.091> unrecognized

00:50:08.160 --> 00:50:20.000
presuppositions<00:50:08.161> of<00:50:08.162> a<00:50:08.163> philosophical<00:50:08.164> sort,<00:50:08.165> um.<00:50:08.166> This<00:50:08.167> actually<00:50:08.168> was<00:50:08.169> a<00:50:08.170> subject<00:50:08.171> of<00:50:08.172> conversation<00:50:08.173> between

00:50:20.000 --> 00:50:27.440
uh,<00:50:20.001> Myers<00:50:20.002> and<00:50:20.003> James<00:50:20.004> at<00:50:20.005> an<00:50:20.006> early<00:50:20.007> date,<00:50:20.008> the<00:50:20.009> reason<00:50:20.010> being<00:50:20.011> that<00:50:20.012> William<00:50:20.013> James,<00:50:20.014> in<00:50:20.015> The<00:50:20.016> Principles<00:50:20.017> of

00:50:27.440 --> 00:50:35.840
Psychology<00:50:27.441> published<00:50:27.442> in<00:50:27.443> 1890,<00:50:27.444> took<00:50:27.445> the<00:50:27.446> view<00:50:27.447> that<00:50:27.448> he<00:50:27.449> was<00:50:27.450> avoiding<00:50:27.451> all<00:50:27.452> philosophical<00:50:27.453> subjects<00:50:27.454> and

00:50:35.840 --> 00:50:46.080
talking<00:50:35.841> only<00:50:35.842> about<00:50:35.843> psychological<00:50:35.844> matters.<00:50:35.845> Myers<00:50:35.846> chastised<00:50:35.847> him<00:50:35.848> on<00:50:35.849> that<00:50:35.850> score,<00:50:35.851> saying<00:50:35.852> metaphysics

00:50:46.080 --> 00:50:57.840
is<00:50:46.081> inescapable,<00:50:46.082> and<00:50:46.083> in<00:50:46.084> fact,<00:50:46.085> in<00:50:46.086> the,<00:50:46.087> the<00:50:46.088> context<00:50:46.089> of<00:50:46.090> Principles<00:50:46.091> of<00:50:46.092> Psychology,<00:50:46.093> there<00:50:46.094> are<00:50:46.095> built-in

00:50:57.840 --> 00:51:06.480
philosophical<00:50:57.841> assumptions<00:50:57.842> about<00:50:57.843> what's<00:50:57.844> real,<00:50:57.845> uh.<00:50:57.846> James<00:50:57.847> was<00:50:57.848> convinced<00:50:57.849> by<00:50:57.850> Myers's<00:50:57.851> arguments,<00:50:57.852> and<00:50:57.853> in

00:51:06.480 --> 00:51:13.360
the<00:51:06.481> briefer<00:51:06.482> course,<00:51:06.483> which<00:51:06.484> he<00:51:06.485> published<00:51:06.486> like<00:51:06.487> two<00:51:06.488> years<00:51:06.489> later,<00:51:06.490> he<00:51:06.491> acknowledges<00:51:06.492> that,<00:51:06.493> said,<00:51:06.494> you<00:51:06.495> know,

00:51:13.360 --> 00:51:24.800
uh,<00:51:13.361> the<00:51:13.362> pursuit<00:51:13.363> psychology<00:51:13.364> has<00:51:13.365> only<00:51:13.366> the<00:51:13.367> hope<00:51:13.368> of<00:51:13.369> a<00:51:13.370> science<00:51:13.371> at<00:51:13.372> present,<00:51:13.373> uh,<00:51:13.374> it's<00:51:13.375> filled<00:51:13.376> with

00:51:24.800 --> 00:51:32.720
philosophical<00:51:24.801> presuppositions<00:51:24.802> that<00:51:24.803> leak<00:51:24.804> in<00:51:24.805> at<00:51:24.806> every<00:51:24.807> joint,<00:51:24.808> uh,<00:51:24.809> so<00:51:24.810> he<00:51:24.811> was<00:51:24.812> clear<00:51:24.813> about<00:51:24.814> that<00:51:24.815> at

00:51:32.720 --> 00:51:37.840
that<00:51:32.721> point,<00:51:32.722> and<00:51:32.723> of<00:51:32.724> course<00:51:32.725> his<00:51:32.726> own<00:51:32.727> development<00:51:32.728> then<00:51:32.729> proceeded<00:51:32.730> in<00:51:32.731> a<00:51:32.732> more<00:51:32.733> philosophical<00:51:32.734> direction<00:51:32.735> after

00:51:37.840 --> 00:51:51.680
1890.<00:51:37.841> Similarly,<00:51:37.842> uh,<00:51:37.843> I'm<00:51:37.844> now<00:51:37.845> working<00:51:37.846> with,<00:51:37.847> uh,<00:51:37.848> a<00:51:37.849> small<00:51:37.850> group<00:51:37.851> of<00:51:37.852> physicists<00:51:37.853> who,<00:51:37.854> uh,<00:51:37.855> are<00:51:37.856> united<00:51:37.857> in<00:51:37.858> number

00:51:51.680 --> 00:51:59.200
one,<00:51:51.681> taking<00:51:51.682> the<00:51:51.683> phenomena<00:51:51.684> that<00:51:51.685> we<00:51:51.686> study<00:51:51.687> at<00:51:51.688> DOPS<00:51:51.689> seriously<00:51:51.690> and<00:51:51.691> wanting<00:51:51.692> to<00:51:51.693> make<00:51:51.694> a<00:51:51.695> place<00:51:51.696> for<00:51:51.697> them

00:51:59.200 --> 00:52:08.400
in<00:51:59.201> their<00:51:59.202> picture<00:51:59.203> of<00:51:59.204> reality,<00:51:59.205> uh,<00:51:59.206> two,<00:51:59.207> share<00:51:59.208> this<00:51:59.209> view<00:51:59.210> that<00:51:59.211> the<00:51:59.212> prevailing<00:51:59.213> picture<00:51:59.214> comes<00:51:59.215> with<00:51:59.216> a

00:52:08.400 --> 00:52:15.520
load<00:52:08.401> of<00:52:08.402> philosophical<00:52:08.403> stuff<00:52:08.404> built<00:52:08.405> in,<00:52:08.406> the,<00:52:08.407> the,<00:52:08.408> the<00:52:08.409> philosophy<00:52:08.410> of<00:52:08.411> physicalism<00:52:08.412> basically,<00:52:08.413> which<00:52:08.414> includes

00:52:15.520 --> 00:52:24.240
a<00:52:15.521> presupposition<00:52:15.522> that<00:52:15.523> the<00:52:15.524> real<00:52:15.525> is<00:52:15.526> exhausted<00:52:15.527> by<00:52:15.528> what<00:52:15.529> is<00:52:15.530> actual,<00:52:15.531> that<00:52:15.532> is,<00:52:15.533> what<00:52:15.534> we<00:52:15.535> find<00:52:15.536> around<00:52:15.537> us.

00:52:24.240 --> 00:52:32.320
Uh,<00:52:24.241> their<00:52:24.242> view,<00:52:24.243> and<00:52:24.244> they're<00:52:24.245> a<00:52:24.246> minority<00:52:24.247> in<00:52:24.248> the<00:52:24.249> foundations<00:52:24.250> of<00:52:24.251> physics<00:52:24.252> community,<00:52:24.253> but<00:52:24.254> as<00:52:24.255> you

00:52:32.320 --> 00:52:38.880
know,<00:52:32.321> the,<00:52:32.322> these<00:52:32.323> are<00:52:32.324> serious<00:52:32.325> people.<00:52:32.326> I'm<00:52:32.327> talking<00:52:32.328> about<00:52:32.329> people<00:52:32.330> like,<00:52:32.331> uh,<00:52:32.332> Tim<00:52:32.333> Eastman,<00:52:32.334> Ruth<00:52:32.335> Kastner,

00:52:38.880 --> 00:52:49.920
Bernard<00:52:38.881> Carr,<00:52:38.882> who<00:52:38.883> comes<00:52:38.884> at<00:52:38.885> it<00:52:38.886> from<00:52:38.887> the<00:52:38.888> kind<00:52:38.889> of<00:52:38.890> cosmology<00:52:38.891> side,<00:52:38.892> uh,<00:52:38.893> hold<00:52:38.894> the<00:52:38.895> view,<00:52:38.896> shared<00:52:38.897> view,<00:52:38.898> that

00:52:49.920 --> 00:52:56.880
in<00:52:49.921> addition<00:52:49.922> to<00:52:49.923> actuality,<00:52:49.924> what<00:52:49.925> we<00:52:49.926> find<00:52:49.927> around<00:52:49.928> us,<00:52:49.929> there<00:52:49.930> is<00:52:49.931> a<00:52:49.932> level<00:52:49.933> of<00:52:49.934> potentiality,<00:52:49.935> normally

00:52:56.880 --> 00:53:05.840
hidden,<00:52:56.881> uh.<00:52:56.882> A<00:52:56.883> lot<00:52:56.884> of<00:52:56.885> this<00:52:56.886> comes<00:52:56.887> through<00:52:56.888> Heisenberg<00:52:56.889> and<00:52:56.890> his<00:52:56.891> view<00:52:56.892> about<00:52:56.893> potentiality.<00:52:56.894> There's<00:52:56.895> a,<00:52:56.896> a<00:52:56.897> realm<00:52:56.898> of

00:53:05.840 --> 00:53:16.640
potentiality<00:53:05.841> that<00:53:05.842> they<00:53:05.843> want<00:53:05.844> to<00:53:05.845> raise<00:53:05.846> to<00:53:05.847> ontological<00:53:05.848> parity<00:53:05.849> with<00:53:05.850> the<00:53:05.851> actual,<00:53:05.852> the<00:53:05.853> actual<00:53:05.854> and

00:53:16.640 --> 00:53:24.560
the<00:53:16.641> potential<00:53:16.642> together<00:53:16.643> constitute<00:53:16.644> reality,<00:53:16.645> and<00:53:16.646> it's<00:53:16.647> in<00:53:16.648> that<00:53:16.649> realm<00:53:16.650> of<00:53:16.651> potentiality<00:53:16.652> that<00:53:16.653> they<00:53:16.654> think

00:53:24.560 --> 00:53:34.400
we<00:53:24.561> will<00:53:24.562> be<00:53:24.563> able<00:53:24.564> to<00:53:24.565> find,<00:53:24.566> uh,<00:53:24.567> the<00:53:24.568> processes<00:53:24.569> that<00:53:24.570> give<00:53:24.571> rise<00:53:24.572> to<00:53:24.573> reality<00:53:24.574> as<00:53:24.575> we<00:53:24.576> experience<00:53:24.577> it<00:53:24.578> and<00:53:24.579> to

00:53:34.400 --> 00:53:42.880
the<00:53:34.401> manifestation<00:53:34.402> of<00:53:34.403> these<00:53:34.404> various<00:53:34.405> unusual<00:53:34.406> psychological<00:53:34.407> abilities,<00:53:34.408> mystical<00:53:34.409> experience,<00:53:34.410> genius,

00:53:42.880 --> 00:53:49.520
psi<00:53:42.881> phenomena<00:53:42.882> that<00:53:42.883> we've<00:53:42.884> been<00:53:42.885> studying<00:53:42.886> at<00:53:42.887> DOPS,<00:53:42.888> and<00:53:42.889> they're<00:53:42.890> of<00:53:42.891> course<00:53:42.892> being<00:53:42.893> studied

00:53:49.520 --> 00:53:57.040
lots<00:53:49.521> of<00:53:49.522> other<00:53:49.523> places<00:53:49.524> in<00:53:49.525> the<00:53:49.526> world.<00:53:49.527> So<00:53:49.528> that<00:53:49.529> was<00:53:49.530> a<00:53:49.531> kind<00:53:49.532> of<00:53:49.533> a<00:53:49.534> long-winded<00:53:49.535> answer,<00:53:49.536> but<00:53:49.537> I<00:53:49.538> hope<00:53:49.539> I<00:53:49.540> got

00:53:57.040 --> 00:54:05.760
to<00:53:57.041> your<00:53:57.042> question<00:53:57.043> eventually.<00:53:57.044> I,<00:53:57.045> I,<00:53:57.046> I<00:53:57.047> think<00:53:57.048> you<00:53:57.049> have<00:53:57.050> a,<00:53:57.051> a<00:53:57.052> third<00:53:57.053> option.<00:53:57.054> I<00:53:57.055> gave<00:53:57.056> you<00:53:57.057> two,<00:53:57.058> you<00:53:57.059> g,<00:53:57.060> you<00:53:57.061> gave

00:54:05.760 --> 00:54:12.880
me<00:54:05.761> the<00:54:05.762> third<00:54:05.763> one,<00:54:05.764> which<00:54:05.765> is<00:54:05.766> metaphysics<00:54:05.767> is<00:54:05.768> part<00:54:05.769> of<00:54:05.770> science,<00:54:05.771> is<00:54:05.772> underlying<00:54:05.773> assumption<00:54:05.774> already,<00:54:05.775> whether

00:54:12.880 --> 00:54:19.040
you'll<00:54:12.881> agree,<00:54:12.882> like,<00:54:12.883> or<00:54:12.884> recognize<00:54:12.885> it,<00:54:12.886> right?<00:54:12.887> That's<00:54:12.888> what<00:54:12.889> you're<00:54:12.890> saying.<00:54:12.891> Yes,<00:54:12.892> we<00:54:12.893> will<00:54:12.894> have<00:54:12.895> metaphysics

00:54:19.040 --> 00:54:25.680
whether<00:54:19.041> we<00:54:19.042> know<00:54:19.043> it<00:54:19.044> or<00:54:19.045> not,<00:54:19.046> and<00:54:19.047> our<00:54:19.048> job<00:54:19.049> is<00:54:19.050> to<00:54:19.051> find<00:54:19.052> a<00:54:19.053> good<00:54:19.054> metaphysics<00:54:19.055> that<00:54:19.056> align<00:54:19.057> itself<00:54:19.058> naturally

00:54:25.680 --> 00:54:32.240
with<00:54:25.681> our<00:54:25.682> science,<00:54:25.683> the<00:54:25.684> empirical<00:54:25.685> side<00:54:25.686> of<00:54:25.687> science,<00:54:25.688> and<00:54:25.689> that's<00:54:25.690> what<00:54:25.691> we're<00:54:25.692> trying<00:54:25.693> to<00:54:25.694> do,<00:54:25.695> and<00:54:25.696> I<00:54:25.697> think

00:54:32.240 --> 00:54:41.120
what<00:54:32.241> Bernardo<00:54:32.242> is<00:54:32.243> trying<00:54:32.244> to<00:54:32.245> do<00:54:32.246> also.<00:54:32.247> Now,<00:54:32.248> I<00:54:32.249> should<00:54:32.250> say<00:54:32.251> Bernardo<00:54:32.252> and<00:54:32.253> I<00:54:32.254> do<00:54:32.255> have<00:54:32.256> one<00:54:32.257> big<00:54:32.258> disagreement.

00:54:41.120 --> 00:54:48.400
Uh,<00:54:41.121> his,<00:54:41.122> his<00:54:41.123> view<00:54:41.124> of<00:54:41.125> survival<00:54:41.126> is<00:54:41.127> quite<00:54:41.128> different<00:54:41.129> from<00:54:41.130> mine.<00:54:41.131> He,<00:54:41.132> he<00:54:41.133> is<00:54:41.134> not<00:54:41.135> so<00:54:41.136> interested<00:54:41.137> in<00:54:41.138> survival

00:54:48.400 --> 00:54:55.200
and<00:54:48.401> the<00:54:48.402> evidence<00:54:48.403> for<00:54:48.404> survival.<00:54:48.405> He,<00:54:48.406> he<00:54:48.407> tends<00:54:48.408> to<00:54:48.409> think,<00:54:48.410> I<00:54:48.411> think<00:54:48.412> for<00:54:48.413> essentially<00:54:48.414> aesthetic<00:54:48.415> reasons,

00:54:55.200 --> 00:55:01.840
uh,<00:54:55.201> based<00:54:55.202> upon<00:54:55.203> his<00:54:55.204> analytic<00:54:55.205> idealism,<00:54:55.206> that<00:54:55.207> what<00:54:55.208> happens<00:54:55.209> when<00:54:55.210> we<00:54:55.211> die<00:54:55.212> is<00:54:55.213> we<00:54:55.214> slip<00:54:55.215> into<00:54:55.216> the<00:54:55.217> shining

00:55:01.840 --> 00:55:11.200
sea<00:55:01.841> and<00:55:01.842> all<00:55:01.843> that,<00:55:01.844> become<00:55:01.845> reunited<00:55:01.846> with<00:55:01.847> the<00:55:01.848> ultimate<00:55:01.849> consciousness,<00:55:01.850> uh,<00:55:01.851> but,<00:55:01.852> and<00:55:01.853> I,<00:55:01.854> I,<00:55:01.855> I<00:55:01.856> fault<00:55:01.857> Bernardo.<00:55:01.858> I've

00:55:11.200 --> 00:55:15.360
complained<00:55:11.201> to<00:55:11.202> him<00:55:11.203> about<00:55:11.204> it<00:55:11.205> when<00:55:11.206> he<00:55:11.207> was<00:55:11.208> writing<00:55:11.209> his<00:55:11.210> chapter,<00:55:11.211> that<00:55:11.212> he<00:55:11.213> needs<00:55:11.214> to<00:55:11.215> take<00:55:11.216> the<00:55:11.217> evidence

00:55:15.360 --> 00:55:21.120
for<00:55:15.361> survival<00:55:15.362> more<00:55:15.363> seriously,<00:55:15.364> and<00:55:15.365> that<00:55:15.366> it<00:55:15.367> can<00:55:15.368> be<00:55:15.369> perfectly<00:55:15.370> well<00:55:15.371> accommodated<00:55:15.372> within<00:55:15.373> his<00:55:15.374> own<00:55:15.375> view.

00:55:21.120 --> 00:55:28.000
I<00:55:21.121> mean,<00:55:21.122> if,<00:55:21.123> if<00:55:21.124> the<00:55:21.125> absolute<00:55:21.126> consciousness<00:55:21.127> can<00:55:21.128> sort<00:55:21.129> of<00:55:21.130> differentiate<00:55:21.131> itself<00:55:21.132> into<00:55:21.133> all<00:55:21.134> of<00:55:21.135> us,<00:55:21.136> there<00:55:21.137> can

00:55:28.000 --> 00:55:34.800
certainly<00:55:28.001> be<00:55:28.002> other<00:55:28.003> levels<00:55:28.004> of<00:55:28.005> differentiation,<00:55:28.006> including<00:55:28.007> a<00:55:28.008> Myers-James-like<00:55:28.009> higher<00:55:28.010> self,<00:55:28.011> maybe

00:55:34.800 --> 00:55:41.520
several<00:55:34.801> stages<00:55:34.802> of<00:55:34.803> higher<00:55:34.804> selves<00:55:34.805> associated<00:55:34.806> with<00:55:34.807> each<00:55:34.808> of<00:55:34.809> us,<00:55:34.810> one<00:55:34.811> of<00:55:34.812> which,<00:55:34.813> or<00:55:34.814> one<00:55:34.815> or<00:55:34.816> more<00:55:34.817> of<00:55:34.818> which

00:55:41.520 --> 00:55:47.680
might<00:55:41.521> support<00:55:41.522> some<00:55:41.523> kind<00:55:41.524> of<00:55:41.525> a<00:55:41.526> survival<00:55:41.527> conception.<00:55:41.528> So<00:55:41.529> I<00:55:41.530> think,<00:55:41.531> uh,<00:55:41.532> where<00:55:41.533> we<00:55:41.534> will<00:55:41.535> ultimately<00:55:41.536> end<00:55:41.537> up

00:55:47.680 --> 00:55:56.240
is<00:55:47.681> somewhere<00:55:47.682> in<00:55:47.683> between<00:55:47.684> where<00:55:47.685> we<00:55:47.686> are<00:55:47.687> and<00:55:47.688> where<00:55:47.689> Bernardo<00:55:47.690> is<00:55:47.691> on<00:55:47.692> the<00:55:47.693> subject<00:55:47.694> of<00:55:47.695> survival.<00:55:47.696> I<00:55:47.697> would

00:55:56.240 --> 00:56:04.720
like<00:55:56.241> to<00:55:56.242> say<00:55:56.243> one<00:55:56.244> more<00:55:56.245> thing<00:55:56.246> about<00:55:56.247> idealism,<00:55:56.248> um.<00:55:56.249> Now,<00:55:56.250> for<00:55:56.251> me,<00:55:56.252> at<00:55:56.253> the<00:55:56.254> beginning<00:55:56.255> of<00:55:56.256> my<00:55:56.257> career,<00:55:56.258> idealism

00:56:04.720 --> 00:56:11.360
was<00:56:04.721> a<00:56:04.722> joke,<00:56:04.723> basically.<00:56:04.724> It<00:56:04.725> was,<00:56:04.726> you<00:56:04.727> know,<00:56:04.728> a<00:56:04.729> crazy<00:56:04.730> idea<00:56:04.731> that<00:56:04.732> some<00:56:04.733> people<00:56:04.734> had<00:56:04.735> had<00:56:04.736> somewhere<00:56:04.737> in<00:56:04.738> the<00:56:04.739> distant

00:56:11.360 --> 00:56:20.080
past,<00:56:11.361> but,<00:56:11.362> uh,<00:56:11.363> no<00:56:11.364> informed<00:56:11.365> scientist<00:56:11.366> could<00:56:11.367> possibly<00:56:11.368> take<00:56:11.369> it<00:56:11.370> seriously<00:56:11.371> at<00:56:11.372> this<00:56:11.373> stage<00:56:11.374> of<00:56:11.375> civilization's

00:56:20.080 --> 00:56:27.280
development.<00:56:20.081> Well,<00:56:20.082> of<00:56:20.083> course,<00:56:20.084> I've<00:56:20.085> changed<00:56:20.086> radically<00:56:20.087> on<00:56:20.088> that<00:56:20.089> front,<00:56:20.090> and<00:56:20.091> I<00:56:20.092> am<00:56:20.093> now<00:56:20.094> a<00:56:20.095> subscriber<00:56:20.096> to<00:56:20.097> some

00:56:27.280 --> 00:56:34.960
as<00:56:27.281> yet<00:56:27.282> ill-defined<00:56:27.283> form<00:56:27.284> of<00:56:27.285> idealism,<00:56:27.286> uh.<00:56:27.287> We<00:56:27.288> aspire<00:56:27.289> to<00:56:27.290> make<00:56:27.291> it<00:56:27.292> into<00:56:27.293> a<00:56:27.294> full-fledged<00:56:27.295> realist<00:56:27.296> idealism,

00:56:34.960 --> 00:56:42.320
but<00:56:34.961> haven't<00:56:34.962> gotten<00:56:34.963> there.<00:56:34.964> But<00:56:34.965> something<00:56:34.966> you<00:56:34.967> often<00:56:34.968> encounter,<00:56:34.969> uh,<00:56:34.970> from<00:56:34.971> other<00:56:34.972> scientists<00:56:34.973> in

00:56:42.320 --> 00:56:50.960
particular<00:56:42.321> and<00:56:42.322> some<00:56:42.323> philosophers<00:56:42.324> as<00:56:42.325> well,<00:56:42.326> is,<00:56:42.327> uh,<00:56:42.328> what's<00:56:42.329> sometimes<00:56:42.330> called<00:56:42.331> the<00:56:42.332> inverse<00:56:42.333> hard<00:56:42.334> problem.

00:56:50.960 --> 00:56:58.160
That<00:56:50.961> is,<00:56:50.962> a<00:56:50.963> physicalist<00:56:50.964> might<00:56:50.965> well<00:56:50.966> say,<00:56:50.967> okay,<00:56:50.968> we're<00:56:50.969> having<00:56:50.970> a<00:56:50.971> hard<00:56:50.972> time<00:56:50.973> explaining<00:56:50.974> consciousness,<00:56:50.975> it's

00:56:58.160 --> 00:57:06.560
true,<00:56:58.161> but<00:56:58.162> we<00:56:58.163> will<00:56:58.164> eventually,<00:56:58.165> you<00:56:58.166> can<00:56:58.167> be<00:56:58.168> sure,<00:56:58.169> that's<00:56:58.170> the<00:56:58.171> promissory<00:56:58.172> materialism<00:56:58.173> business.<00:56:58.174> But<00:56:58.175> look,<00:56:58.176> you

00:57:06.560 --> 00:57:11.280
idealists,<00:57:06.561> you've<00:57:06.562> got<00:57:06.563> exactly<00:57:06.564> the<00:57:06.565> opposite<00:57:06.566> of<00:57:06.567> problem.<00:57:06.568> How<00:57:06.569> do<00:57:06.570> you<00:57:06.571> explain<00:57:06.572> matter<00:57:06.573> from

00:57:11.280 --> 00:57:20.240
consciousness?<00:57:11.281> And<00:57:11.282> for<00:57:11.283> a<00:57:11.284> long<00:57:11.285> time,<00:57:11.286> I<00:57:11.287> took<00:57:11.288> that<00:57:11.289> argument<00:57:11.290> very<00:57:11.291> seriously,<00:57:11.292> uh,<00:57:11.293> but<00:57:11.294> sometime<00:57:11.295> just<00:57:11.296> a

00:57:20.240 --> 00:57:27.600
few<00:57:20.241> years<00:57:20.242> ago,<00:57:20.243> well,<00:57:20.244> I<00:57:20.245> was,<00:57:20.246> yeah,<00:57:20.247> I<00:57:20.248> was<00:57:20.249> in<00:57:20.250> really<00:57:20.251> in<00:57:20.252> the<00:57:20.253> course<00:57:20.254> of<00:57:20.255> working<00:57:20.256> on<00:57:20.257> Consciousness<00:57:20.258> Unbound,

00:57:27.600 --> 00:57:38.240
it<00:57:27.601> suddenly<00:57:27.602> occurred<00:57:27.603> to<00:57:27.604> me<00:57:27.605> that<00:57:27.606> the<00:57:27.607> explanatory<00:57:27.608> challenges<00:57:27.609> to<00:57:27.610> physicalism<00:57:27.611> and<00:57:27.612> idealism<00:57:27.613> are<00:57:27.614> not

00:57:38.240 --> 00:57:47.760
exactly<00:57:38.241> on<00:57:38.242> par.<00:57:38.243> And<00:57:38.244> why<00:57:38.245> is<00:57:38.246> that?<00:57:38.247> Well,<00:57:38.248> we<00:57:38.249> know<00:57:38.250> that<00:57:38.251> we<00:57:38.252> are<00:57:38.253> conscious.<00:57:38.254> There<00:57:38.255> is<00:57:38.256> absolutely<00:57:38.257> no

00:57:47.760 --> 00:57:57.040
doubt<00:57:47.761> that<00:57:47.762> consciousness<00:57:47.763> exists.<00:57:47.764> We<00:57:47.765> all<00:57:47.766> have<00:57:47.767> it.<00:57:47.768> So<00:57:47.769> the<00:57:47.770> hard<00:57:47.771> problem<00:57:47.772> for<00:57:47.773> physicalism<00:57:47.774> is<00:57:47.775> a<00:57:47.776> real<00:57:47.777> problem.

00:57:57.040 --> 00:58:07.120
Now,<00:57:57.041> what's<00:57:57.042> the<00:57:57.043> problem<00:57:57.044> for<00:57:57.045> the<00:57:57.046> idealist?<00:57:57.047> It<00:57:57.048> is<00:57:57.049> not,<00:57:57.050> I<00:57:57.051> submit,<00:57:57.052> to<00:57:57.053> explain<00:57:57.054> matter<00:57:57.055> as<00:57:57.056> matter

00:58:07.120 --> 00:58:14.480
has<00:58:07.121> traditionally<00:58:07.122> been<00:58:07.123> conceived.<00:58:07.124> Matter<00:58:07.125> as<00:58:07.126> traditionally<00:58:07.127> conceived<00:58:07.128> is<00:58:07.129> something<00:58:07.130> we<00:58:07.131> dreamed

00:58:14.480 --> 00:58:22.160
up<00:58:14.481> to<00:58:14.482> help<00:58:14.483> us<00:58:14.484> explain<00:58:14.485> certain<00:58:14.486> regularities<00:58:14.487> in<00:58:14.488> our<00:58:14.489> experience.<00:58:14.490> And<00:58:14.491> what<00:58:14.492> we,<00:58:14.493> what<00:58:14.494> the<00:58:14.495> idealist<00:58:14.496> has<00:58:14.497> to

00:58:22.160 --> 00:58:31.520
explain<00:58:22.161> is<00:58:22.162> those<00:58:22.163> regularities<00:58:22.164> in<00:58:22.165> a<00:58:22.166> different<00:58:22.167> way,<00:58:22.168> not<00:58:22.169> matter<00:58:22.170> as<00:58:22.171> classically<00:58:22.172> conceived.<00:58:22.173> Is<00:58:22.174> that,<00:58:22.175> is<00:58:22.176> that

00:58:31.520 --> 00:58:38.400
intelligible?<00:58:31.521> I've<00:58:31.522> tried<00:58:31.523> saying<00:58:31.524> this<00:58:31.525> in<00:58:31.526> different<00:58:31.527> ways<00:58:31.528> and<00:58:31.529> different<00:58:31.530> times<00:58:31.531> and<00:58:31.532> still<00:58:31.533> haven't<00:58:31.534> got<00:58:31.535> it

00:58:38.400 --> 00:58:48.720
quite<00:58:38.401> right,<00:58:38.402> but<00:58:38.403> I<00:58:38.404> think<00:58:38.405> that<00:58:38.406> argument<00:58:38.407> is<00:58:38.408> basically<00:58:38.409> sound.<00:58:38.410> Yeah,<00:58:38.411> I<00:58:38.412> could<00:58:38.413> dive<00:58:38.414> into<00:58:38.415> what<00:58:38.416> is<00:58:38.417> matter

00:58:48.720 --> 00:58:56.960
and<00:58:48.721> then<00:58:48.722> different,<00:58:48.723> different<00:58:48.724> discussion,<00:58:48.725> wouldn't<00:58:48.726> we?<00:58:48.727> Yeah,<00:58:48.728> does<00:58:48.729> matter<00:58:48.730> really<00:58:48.731> exist<00:58:48.732> as<00:58:48.733> we<00:58:48.734> understand

00:58:56.960 --> 00:59:04.480
it,<00:58:56.961> as<00:58:56.962> materialists<00:58:56.963> understand<00:58:56.964> matter,<00:58:56.965> as<00:58:56.966> this<00:58:56.967> table<00:58:56.968> on<00:58:56.969> the<00:58:56.970> chair<00:58:56.971> I'm<00:58:56.972> sitting<00:58:56.973> on?<00:58:56.974> I<00:58:56.975> was<00:58:56.976> encouraged<00:58:56.977> in

00:59:04.480 --> 00:59:12.160
this<00:59:04.481> direction,<00:59:04.482> by<00:59:04.483> the<00:59:04.484> way,<00:59:04.485> by<00:59:04.486> Henry<00:59:04.487> Stapp,<00:59:04.488> quantum<00:59:04.489> theorist,<00:59:04.490> who<00:59:04.491> was<00:59:04.492> a<00:59:04.493> member<00:59:04.494> of<00:59:04.495> our,<00:59:04.496> uh,<00:59:04.497> Esalen-Shirley

00:59:12.160 --> 00:59:22.480
group,<00:59:12.161> and<00:59:12.162> who<00:59:12.163> said<00:59:12.164> repeatedly<00:59:12.165> at<00:59:12.166> our<00:59:12.167> meetings,<00:59:12.168> matter<00:59:12.169> as<00:59:12.170> classically<00:59:12.171> conceived<00:59:12.172> does<00:59:12.173> not<00:59:12.174> exist

00:59:22.480 --> 00:59:30.160
from<00:59:22.481> his<00:59:22.482> point<00:59:22.483> of<00:59:22.484> view<00:59:22.485> as<00:59:22.486> a<00:59:22.487> major<00:59:22.488> figure<00:59:22.489> in<00:59:22.490> quantum<00:59:22.491> theory.<00:59:22.492> Yeah,<00:59:22.493> and<00:59:22.494> Bernardo<00:59:22.495> says<00:59:22.496> it's<00:59:22.497> just

00:59:30.160 --> 00:59:38.160
a<00:59:30.161> dissociation,<00:59:30.162> a<00:59:30.163> form<00:59:30.164> of<00:59:30.165> dissociation,<00:59:30.166> yeah,<00:59:30.167> which<00:59:30.168> we,<00:59:30.169> which<00:59:30.170> we<00:59:30.171> experience<00:59:30.172> with<00:59:30.173> our<00:59:30.174> senses<00:59:30.175> as<00:59:30.176> a<00:59:30.177> matter

00:59:38.160 --> 00:59:45.520
of<00:59:38.161> course.<00:59:38.162> Yeah,<00:59:38.163> m,<00:59:38.164> I,<00:59:38.165> I<00:59:38.166> have<00:59:38.167> to<00:59:38.168> say<00:59:38.169> that,<00:59:38.170> you<00:59:38.171> know,<00:59:38.172> I'm,<00:59:38.173> I<00:59:38.174> mean,<00:59:38.175> I'm<00:59:38.176> just,<00:59:38.177> I'm<00:59:38.178> really<00:59:38.179> just<00:59:38.180> a<00:59:38.181> poor<00:59:38.182> empirical

00:59:45.520 --> 00:59:51.360
psychologist<00:59:45.521> and<00:59:45.522> neuroscientist<00:59:45.523> accustomed<00:59:45.524> to<00:59:45.525> working<00:59:45.526> down<00:59:45.527> in<00:59:45.528> the<00:59:45.529> trenches,<00:59:45.530> and<00:59:45.531> this

00:59:51.360 --> 00:59:57.840
uh,<00:59:51.361> philosophy<00:59:51.362> and<00:59:51.363> physics<00:59:51.364> stuff<00:59:51.365> is<00:59:51.366> remote<00:59:51.367> from<00:59:51.368> my<00:59:51.369> natural<00:59:51.370> habitat.<00:59:51.371> I<00:59:51.372> don't<00:59:51.373> profess<00:59:51.374> to<00:59:51.375> be<00:59:51.376> expert

00:59:57.840 --> 01:00:07.520
in<00:59:57.841> either<00:59:57.842> area,<00:59:57.843> but<00:59:57.844> the<00:59:57.845> path<00:59:57.846> you're<00:59:57.847> on,<00:59:57.848> you<00:59:57.849> can't<00:59:57.850> avoid<00:59:57.851> them,<00:59:57.852> I'm<00:59:57.853> afraid.<00:59:57.854> Yeah,<00:59:57.855> there<00:59:57.856> is<00:59:57.857> something<00:59:57.858> I

01:00:07.520 --> 01:00:14.320
came<01:00:07.521> across<01:00:07.522> a<01:00:07.523> quote<01:00:07.524> which<01:00:07.525> I<01:00:07.526> wanted<01:00:07.527> to<01:00:07.528> share<01:00:07.529> with<01:00:07.530> you<01:00:07.531> when<01:00:07.532> I<01:00:07.533> was<01:00:07.534> preparing.<01:00:07.535> It's<01:00:07.536> about,<01:00:07.537> um,<01:00:07.538> it's<01:00:07.539> about

01:00:14.320 --> 01:00:22.080
evolutionary<01:00:14.321> panentheism,<01:00:14.322> and<01:00:14.323> the<01:00:14.324> quote<01:00:14.325> is<01:00:14.326> by<01:00:14.327> Brother<01:00:14.328> David<01:00:14.329> Steindl-Rast,<01:00:14.330> a<01:00:14.331> practicing

01:00:22.080 --> 01:00:30.480
Benedictine<01:00:22.081> monk,<01:00:22.082> and<01:00:22.083> that's<01:00:22.084> what<01:00:22.085> he<01:00:22.086> says.<01:00:22.087> I've<01:00:22.088> met<01:00:22.089> him.<01:00:22.090> Really?<01:00:22.091> Oh,<01:00:22.092> that's<01:00:22.093> interesting.<01:00:22.094> Fascinating.<01:00:22.095> Now

01:00:30.480 --> 01:00:38.320
speak<01:00:30.481> on<01:00:30.482> synchronicities.<01:00:30.483> Now,<01:00:30.484> the<01:00:30.485> quote<01:00:30.486> says,<01:00:30.487> there<01:00:30.488> are<01:00:30.489> at<01:00:30.490> least<01:00:30.491> three<01:00:30.492> ways<01:00:30.493> of<01:00:30.494> talking<01:00:30.495> about<01:00:30.496> spirit.

01:00:38.320 --> 01:00:47.360
You<01:00:38.321> can<01:00:38.322> say<01:00:38.323> what<01:00:38.324> spirit<01:00:38.325> is<01:00:38.326> like,<01:00:38.327> you<01:00:38.328> can<01:00:38.329> say<01:00:38.330> what<01:00:38.331> spirit<01:00:38.332> is<01:00:38.333> not,<01:00:38.334> or<01:00:38.335> you<01:00:38.336> can<01:00:38.337> have<01:00:38.338> a<01:00:38.339> direct<01:00:38.340> experience

01:00:47.360 --> 01:00:56.320
of<01:00:47.361> spirit.<01:00:47.362> And<01:00:47.363> the<01:00:47.364> best<01:00:47.365> way<01:00:47.366> to<01:00:47.367> say<01:00:47.368> what<01:00:47.369> spirit<01:00:47.370> is<01:00:47.371> like<01:00:47.372> in<01:00:47.373> today's<01:00:47.374> world<01:00:47.375> is<01:00:47.376> evolutionary<01:00:47.377> panentheism.

01:00:56.320 --> 01:01:04.480
Mhm.<01:00:56.321> So<01:00:56.322> I<01:00:56.323> think<01:00:56.324> there<01:00:56.325> are<01:00:56.326> more<01:00:56.327> people<01:00:56.328> who<01:00:56.329> share<01:00:56.330> your<01:00:56.331> view<01:00:56.332> that<01:00:56.333> that's<01:00:56.334> probably<01:00:56.335> the<01:00:56.336> closest<01:00:56.337> model

01:01:04.480 --> 01:01:12.640
of<01:01:04.481> the<01:01:04.482> truth.<01:01:04.483> Well,<01:01:04.484> or<01:01:04.485> objective<01:01:04.486> reality.<01:01:04.487> Like<01:01:04.488> I<01:01:04.489> said<01:01:04.490> earlier,<01:01:04.491> I,<01:01:04.492> I<01:01:04.493> have<01:01:04.494> a,<01:01:04.495> well,<01:01:04.496> we<01:01:04.497> collectively<01:01:04.498> have<01:01:04.499> a

01:01:12.640 --> 01:01:20.080
strong<01:01:12.641> feeling<01:01:12.642> that<01:01:12.643> that's<01:01:12.644> the<01:01:12.645> right<01:01:12.646> direction<01:01:12.647> to<01:01:12.648> be<01:01:12.649> poking<01:01:12.650> out<01:01:12.651> in.<01:01:12.652> We're<01:01:12.653> not<01:01:12.654> really<01:01:12.655> quite<01:01:12.656> there<01:01:12.657> yet

01:01:20.080 --> 01:01:26.720
in<01:01:20.081> terms<01:01:20.082> of<01:01:20.083> having<01:01:20.084> a<01:01:20.085> adequately<01:01:20.086> detailed<01:01:20.087> theory,<01:01:20.088> but<01:01:20.089> we're<01:01:20.090> moving<01:01:20.091> in<01:01:20.092> that<01:01:20.093> direction,<01:01:20.094> and<01:01:20.095> so<01:01:20.096> far<01:01:20.097> at

01:01:26.720 --> 01:01:33.360
least<01:01:26.721> I<01:01:26.722> don't<01:01:26.723> see<01:01:26.724> any<01:01:26.725> insuperable<01:01:26.726> obstacles.<01:01:26.727> Let<01:01:26.728> me<01:01:26.729> just<01:01:26.730> mention<01:01:26.731> a<01:01:26.732> couple<01:01:26.733> of<01:01:26.734> other<01:01:26.735> things<01:01:26.736> that<01:01:26.737> have

01:01:33.360 --> 01:01:43.760
come<01:01:33.361> up<01:01:33.362> more<01:01:33.363> recently,<01:01:33.364> um.<01:01:33.365> Yeah,<01:01:33.366> we're,<01:01:33.367> I,<01:01:33.368> I<01:01:33.369> mentioned<01:01:33.370> earlier<01:01:33.371> about<01:01:33.372> how<01:01:33.373> the,<01:01:33.374> uh,<01:01:33.375> uh,<01:01:33.376> renaissance<01:01:33.377> in<01:01:33.378> work

01:01:43.760 --> 01:01:49.600
on<01:01:43.761> consciousness,<01:01:43.762> both,<01:01:43.763> both<01:01:43.764> in<01:01:43.765> philosophy<01:01:43.766> and<01:01:43.767> psychology<01:01:43.768> and<01:01:43.769> neuroscience,<01:01:43.770> has<01:01:43.771> been<01:01:43.772> one<01:01:43.773> of<01:01:43.774> the

01:01:49.600 --> 01:02:00.800
uh,<01:01:49.601> strong<01:01:49.602> drivers,<01:01:49.603> uh,<01:01:49.604> of<01:01:49.605> the<01:01:49.606> kind<01:01:49.607> of<01:01:49.608> position<01:01:49.609> that,<01:01:49.610> that<01:01:49.611> we're<01:01:49.612> advocating,<01:01:49.613> um.<01:01:49.614> I've<01:01:49.615> recently<01:01:49.616> come

01:02:00.800 --> 01:02:10.720
to<01:02:00.801> realize<01:02:00.802> that,<01:02:00.803> uh,<01:02:00.804> there<01:02:00.805> is<01:02:00.806> a<01:02:00.807> huge<01:02:00.808> development<01:02:00.809> taking<01:02:00.810> place<01:02:00.811> in<01:02:00.812> theoretical<01:02:00.813> biology,<01:02:00.814> which<01:02:00.815> really

01:02:10.720 --> 01:02:17.280
amounts<01:02:10.721> to<01:02:10.722> a<01:02:10.723> reversion<01:02:10.724> to<01:02:10.725> a<01:02:10.726> point<01:02:10.727> of<01:02:10.728> view<01:02:10.729> that<01:02:10.730> was<01:02:10.731> prominent<01:02:10.732> at<01:02:10.733> the<01:02:10.734> beginning<01:02:10.735> of<01:02:10.736> the<01:02:10.737> 20th<01:02:10.738> century,

01:02:17.280 --> 01:02:24.720
got<01:02:17.281> eclipsed<01:02:17.282> for<01:02:17.283> a<01:02:17.284> while<01:02:17.285> by<01:02:17.286> the<01:02:17.287> rise<01:02:17.288> of<01:02:17.289> molecular<01:02:17.290> biology<01:02:17.291> and<01:02:17.292> so<01:02:17.293> on,<01:02:17.294> uh,<01:02:17.295> but<01:02:17.296> is<01:02:17.297> now<01:02:17.298> coming<01:02:17.299> back<01:02:17.300> very

01:02:24.720 --> 01:02:32.720
strongly,<01:02:24.721> that<01:02:24.722> basically<01:02:24.723> takes<01:02:24.724> the<01:02:24.725> organism<01:02:24.726> as<01:02:24.727> the,<01:02:24.728> uh,<01:02:24.729> as<01:02:24.730> the,<01:02:24.731> the<01:02:24.732> best<01:02:24.733> model<01:02:24.734> of<01:02:24.735> what's<01:02:24.736> at<01:02:24.737> the<01:02:24.738> bottom

01:02:32.720 --> 01:02:41.200
of<01:02:32.721> reality<01:02:32.722> and<01:02:32.723> talking<01:02:32.724> specifically<01:02:32.725> about<01:02:32.726> mental<01:02:32.727> properties<01:02:32.728> of<01:02:32.729> smaller<01:02:32.730> organisms,<01:02:32.731> well<01:02:32.732> below<01:02:32.733> the

01:02:41.200 --> 01:02:48.720
level<01:02:41.201> of<01:02:41.202> those<01:02:41.203> that<01:02:41.204> have<01:02:41.205> central<01:02:41.206> nervous<01:02:41.207> systems<01:02:41.208> and<01:02:41.209> even<01:02:41.210> down<01:02:41.211> at<01:02:41.212> least<01:02:41.213> as<01:02:41.214> far<01:02:41.215> as<01:02:41.216> single<01:02:41.217> cells<01:02:41.218> and

01:02:48.720 --> 01:02:58.480
their<01:02:48.721> constituent<01:02:48.722> organelles<01:02:48.723> things<01:02:48.724> of<01:02:48.725> that<01:02:48.726> sort<01:02:48.727> it's<01:02:48.728> a<01:02:48.729> a<01:02:48.730> big<01:02:48.731> shift<01:02:48.732> and<01:02:48.733> it's<01:02:48.734> partly<01:02:48.735> encouraged

01:02:58.480 --> 01:03:09.520
by<01:02:58.481> the<01:02:58.482> impending<01:02:58.483> collapse<01:02:58.484> of<01:02:58.485> the<01:02:58.486> Neo-Darwinian<01:02:58.487> evolutionary<01:02:58.488> synthesis<01:02:58.489> which<01:02:58.490> has<01:02:58.491> been<01:02:58.492> dogma<01:02:58.493> for

01:03:09.520 --> 01:03:18.080
80<01:03:09.521> plus<01:03:09.522> years<01:03:09.523> there<01:03:09.524> are<01:03:09.525> elements<01:03:09.526> of<01:03:09.527> the<01:03:09.528> standard<01:03:09.529> Darwinian<01:03:09.530> picture<01:03:09.531> that<01:03:09.532> are<01:03:09.533> now<01:03:09.534> known<01:03:09.535> to<01:03:09.536> be<01:03:09.537> false

01:03:18.080 --> 01:03:28.080
and<01:03:18.081> it<01:03:18.082> is<01:03:18.083> clear<01:03:18.084> that<01:03:18.085> some<01:03:18.086> kind<01:03:18.087> of<01:03:18.088> a<01:03:18.089> Lamarckian<01:03:18.090> type<01:03:18.091> element<01:03:18.092> needs<01:03:18.093> to<01:03:18.094> be<01:03:18.095> built<01:03:18.096> into<01:03:18.097> evolutionary<01:03:18.098> theory

01:03:28.080 --> 01:03:36.640
where<01:03:28.081> organisms<01:03:28.082> at<01:03:28.083> many<01:03:28.084> levels<01:03:28.085> contribute<01:03:28.086> to<01:03:28.087> evolution<01:03:28.088> by<01:03:28.089> the<01:03:28.090> decisions<01:03:28.091> that<01:03:28.092> they<01:03:28.093> make<01:03:28.094> in

01:03:36.640 --> 01:03:45.040
their<01:03:36.641> existence<01:03:36.642> some<01:03:36.643> of<01:03:36.644> which<01:03:36.645> can<01:03:36.646> be<01:03:36.647> carried<01:03:36.648> over<01:03:36.649> into<01:03:36.650> the<01:03:36.651> genome<01:03:36.652> and<01:03:36.653> transmitted<01:03:36.654> to<01:03:36.655> offspring<01:03:36.656> this

01:03:45.040 --> 01:03:51.200
is<01:03:45.041> really<01:03:45.042> a<01:03:45.043> big<01:03:45.044> deal<01:03:45.045> uh<01:03:45.046> there's<01:03:45.047> a<01:03:45.048> guy<01:03:45.049> named<01:03:45.050> Dennis<01:03:45.051> Noble<01:03:45.052> you<01:03:45.053> really<01:03:45.054> should<01:03:45.055> get<01:03:45.056> him<01:03:45.057> on<01:03:45.058> get<01:03:45.059> him<01:03:45.060> for<01:03:45.061> an

01:03:51.200 --> 01:03:56.240
interview<01:03:51.201> who's<01:03:51.202> uh<01:03:51.203> one<01:03:51.204> of<01:03:51.205> the<01:03:51.206> drivers<01:03:51.207> of<01:03:51.208> this<01:03:51.209> there's<01:03:51.210> a<01:03:51.211> great<01:03:51.212> paper<01:03:51.213> I<01:03:51.214> don't<01:03:51.215> have<01:03:51.216> it<01:03:51.217> right<01:03:51.218> in

01:03:56.240 --> 01:04:02.480
front<01:03:56.241> of<01:03:56.242> me<01:03:56.243> but<01:03:56.244> uh<01:03:56.245> in<01:03:56.246> which<01:03:56.247> he<01:03:56.248> summarizes<01:03:56.249> all<01:03:56.250> this<01:03:56.251> and<01:03:56.252> it<01:03:56.253> it's<01:03:56.254> particularly<01:03:56.255> interesting<01:03:56.256> to<01:03:56.257> me

01:04:02.480 --> 01:04:09.600
because<01:04:02.481> this<01:04:02.482> discussion<01:04:02.483> uh<01:04:02.484> has<01:04:02.485> striking<01:04:02.486> parallels<01:04:02.487> to<01:04:02.488> the<01:04:02.489> whole<01:04:02.490> conversation<01:04:02.491> about<01:04:02.492> psi<01:04:02.493> phenomena

01:04:09.600 --> 01:04:17.600
within<01:04:09.601> science<01:04:09.602> there<01:04:09.603> is<01:04:09.604> a<01:04:09.605> small<01:04:09.606> group<01:04:09.607> of<01:04:09.608> people<01:04:09.609> who<01:04:09.610> are<01:04:09.611> determined<01:04:09.612> defenders<01:04:09.613> of<01:04:09.614> the<01:04:09.615> evolution

01:04:17.600 --> 01:04:30.880
orthodoxy<01:04:17.601> and<01:04:17.602> who<01:04:17.603> have<01:04:17.604> kept<01:04:17.605> conflicting<01:04:17.606> uh<01:04:17.607> facts<01:04:17.608> out<01:04:17.609> of<01:04:17.610> textbooks<01:04:17.611> uh<01:04:17.612> away<01:04:17.613> from<01:04:17.614> grant<01:04:17.615> mechanisms

01:04:30.880 --> 01:04:38.480
away<01:04:30.881> from<01:04:30.882> publication<01:04:30.883> mechanisms<01:04:30.884> who<01:04:30.885> are<01:04:30.886> trying<01:04:30.887> to<01:04:30.888> suppress<01:04:30.889> opposition<01:04:30.890> people<01:04:30.891> like<01:04:30.892> Jerry<01:04:30.893> Coyne<01:04:30.894> and<01:04:30.895> uh

01:04:38.480 --> 01:04:47.360
Richard<01:04:38.481> Dawkins<01:04:38.482> for<01:04:38.483> example<01:04:38.484> well-meaning<01:04:38.485> I'm<01:04:38.486> sure<01:04:38.487> they<01:04:38.488> think<01:04:38.489> they're<01:04:38.490> defending<01:04:38.491> the<01:04:38.492> truth<01:04:38.493> and<01:04:38.494> yet<01:04:38.495> as

01:04:47.360 --> 01:04:59.120
uh<01:04:47.361> as<01:04:47.362> this<01:04:47.363> person<01:04:47.364> and<01:04:47.365> others<01:04:47.366> have<01:04:47.367> shown<01:04:47.368> there<01:04:47.369> are<01:04:47.370> facts<01:04:47.371> established<01:04:47.372> experimental<01:04:47.373> facts<01:04:47.374> about

01:04:59.120 --> 01:05:06.960
molecular<01:04:59.121> biology<01:04:59.122> and<01:04:59.123> the<01:04:59.124> genome<01:04:59.125> and<01:04:59.126> so<01:04:59.127> on<01:04:59.128> that<01:04:59.129> contradict<01:04:59.130> the<01:04:59.131> standard<01:04:59.132> model<01:04:59.133> of<01:04:59.134> evolution<01:04:59.135> at

01:05:06.960 --> 01:05:16.000
its<01:05:06.961> core<01:05:06.962> stuff<01:05:06.963> induced<01:05:06.964> in<01:05:06.965> organisms<01:05:06.966> by<01:05:06.967> their<01:05:06.968> behaviors<01:05:06.969> in<01:05:06.970> their<01:05:06.971> particular<01:05:06.972> environments<01:05:06.973> can

01:05:16.000 --> 01:05:23.040
get<01:05:16.001> back<01:05:16.002> into<01:05:16.003> the<01:05:16.004> genome<01:05:16.005> and<01:05:16.006> be<01:05:16.007> carried<01:05:16.008> forward<01:05:16.009> in<01:05:16.010> evolution<01:05:16.011> that's<01:05:16.012> a<01:05:16.013> huge<01:05:16.014> deal<01:05:16.015> how<01:05:16.016> does<01:05:16.017> mainstream

01:05:23.040 --> 01:05:28.400
science<01:05:23.041> deal<01:05:23.042> with<01:05:23.043> anomalous<01:05:23.044> so-called<01:05:23.045> anomalous<01:05:23.046> phenomena<01:05:23.047> today<01:05:23.048> could<01:05:23.049> it<01:05:23.050> be<01:05:23.051> that<01:05:23.052> they<01:05:23.053> simply

01:05:28.400 --> 01:05:35.920
we<01:05:28.401> still<01:05:28.402> don't<01:05:28.403> have<01:05:28.404> the<01:05:28.405> tools<01:05:28.406> to<01:05:28.407> measure<01:05:28.408> um<01:05:28.409> what's<01:05:28.410> what's<01:05:28.411> happening<01:05:28.412> in<01:05:28.413> the<01:05:28.414> brain<01:05:28.415> or<01:05:28.416> you<01:05:28.417> know<01:05:28.418> in<01:05:28.419> the

01:05:35.920 --> 01:05:45.600
body<01:05:35.921> for<01:05:35.922> example<01:05:35.923> during<01:05:35.924> NDE<01:05:35.925> nor<01:05:35.926> can<01:05:35.927> we<01:05:35.928> um<01:05:35.929> do<01:05:35.930> reproducibility<01:05:35.931> or<01:05:35.932> perform<01:05:35.933> reproducibility<01:05:35.934> which

01:05:45.600 --> 01:05:52.560
is<01:05:45.601> a<01:05:45.602> required<01:05:45.603> methodological<01:05:45.604> uh<01:05:45.605> yeah<01:05:45.606> a<01:05:45.607> tenet<01:05:45.608> of<01:05:45.609> science<01:05:45.610> right<01:05:45.611> so<01:05:45.612> how<01:05:45.613> can<01:05:45.614> you<01:05:45.615> reproduce<01:05:45.616> and

01:05:52.560 --> 01:05:58.720
if<01:05:52.561> somebody<01:05:52.562> has<01:05:52.563> cardiac<01:05:52.564> arrest<01:05:52.565> it's<01:05:52.566> just<01:05:52.567> to<01:05:52.568> begin<01:05:52.569> with<01:05:52.570> it's<01:05:52.571> unethical<01:05:52.572> and<01:05:52.573> to<01:05:52.574> to<01:05:52.575> end<01:05:52.576> with

01:05:58.720 --> 01:06:06.800
is<01:05:58.721> dangerous<01:05:58.722> so<01:05:58.723> what<01:05:58.724> what's<01:05:58.725> the<01:05:58.726> current<01:05:58.727> state<01:05:58.728> of<01:05:58.729> affairs<01:05:58.730> well<01:05:58.731> um<01:05:58.732> we're<01:05:58.733> certainly<01:05:58.734> on<01:05:58.735> a<01:05:58.736> steep

01:06:06.800 --> 01:06:16.960
learning<01:06:06.801> curve<01:06:06.802> still<01:06:06.803> about<01:06:06.804> all<01:06:06.805> this<01:06:06.806> neuroimaging<01:06:06.807> stuff<01:06:06.808> uh<01:06:06.809> and<01:06:06.810> there<01:06:06.811> you<01:06:06.812> know<01:06:06.813> there<01:06:06.814> hardly<01:06:06.815> a<01:06:06.816> week

01:06:16.960 --> 01:06:25.360
goes<01:06:16.961> by<01:06:16.962> when<01:06:16.963> some<01:06:16.964> picture<01:06:16.965> doesn't<01:06:16.966> appear<01:06:16.967> in<01:06:16.968> a<01:06:16.969> mainstream<01:06:16.970> media<01:06:16.971> location<01:06:16.972> you<01:06:16.973> know<01:06:16.974> weekly<01:06:16.975> news

01:06:25.360 --> 01:06:31.520
source<01:06:25.361> or<01:06:25.362> something<01:06:25.363> of<01:06:25.364> you<01:06:25.365> know<01:06:25.366> pictures<01:06:25.367> of<01:06:25.368> brains<01:06:25.369> with<01:06:25.370> colored<01:06:25.371> spots<01:06:25.372> in<01:06:25.373> them<01:06:25.374> supposedly<01:06:25.375> explaining

01:06:31.520 --> 01:06:38.800
you<01:06:31.521> know<01:06:31.522> this<01:06:31.523> or<01:06:31.524> that<01:06:31.525> cognitive<01:06:31.526> capacity<01:06:31.527> um<01:06:31.528> a<01:06:31.529> lot<01:06:31.530> of<01:06:31.531> that<01:06:31.532> stuff<01:06:31.533> will<01:06:31.534> vanish<01:06:31.535> with<01:06:31.536> the<01:06:31.537> progress

01:06:38.800 --> 01:06:43.520
of<01:06:38.801> science<01:06:38.802> we've<01:06:38.803> got<01:06:38.804> to<01:06:38.805> learn<01:06:38.806> a<01:06:38.807> lot<01:06:38.808> about<01:06:38.809> how<01:06:38.810> to<01:06:38.811> use<01:06:38.812> these<01:06:38.813> techniques<01:06:38.814> responsibly<01:06:38.815> and

01:06:43.520 --> 01:06:51.040
especially<01:06:43.521> how<01:06:43.522> to<01:06:43.523> do<01:06:43.524> a<01:06:43.525> better<01:06:43.526> job<01:06:43.527> of<01:06:43.528> taking<01:06:43.529> into<01:06:43.530> account<01:06:43.531> what<01:06:43.532> people<01:06:43.533> are<01:06:43.534> experiencing<01:06:43.535> finding<01:06:43.536> good

01:06:51.040 --> 01:06:57.760
ways<01:06:51.041> of<01:06:51.042> having<01:06:51.043> them<01:06:51.044> report<01:06:51.045> their<01:06:51.046> experience<01:06:51.047> and<01:06:51.048> connecting<01:06:51.049> that<01:06:51.050> to<01:06:51.051> the<01:06:51.052> things<01:06:51.053> that<01:06:51.054> we<01:06:51.055> can<01:06:51.056> measure

01:06:57.760 --> 01:07:02.640
uh<01:06:57.761> you<01:06:57.762> know<01:06:57.763> your<01:06:57.764> question<01:06:57.765> is<01:06:57.766> a<01:06:57.767> very<01:06:57.768> general<01:06:57.769> one<01:06:57.770> and<01:06:57.771> it<01:06:57.772> has<01:06:57.773> different<01:06:57.774> answers<01:06:57.775> in<01:06:57.776> different

01:07:02.640 --> 01:07:09.760
specific<01:07:02.641> contexts<01:07:02.642> probably<01:07:02.643> but<01:07:02.644> in<01:07:02.645> general<01:07:02.646> terms<01:07:02.647> I<01:07:02.648> don't<01:07:02.649> see<01:07:02.650> any<01:07:02.651> reason<01:07:02.652> why<01:07:02.653> we<01:07:02.654> cannot

01:07:09.760 --> 01:07:18.080
uh<01:07:09.761> get<01:07:09.762> deep<01:07:09.763> into<01:07:09.764> spiritual<01:07:09.765> matters<01:07:09.766> with<01:07:09.767> the<01:07:09.768> tools<01:07:09.769> of<01:07:09.770> science<01:07:09.771> uh<01:07:09.772> that<01:07:09.773> doesn't<01:07:09.774> necessarily<01:07:09.775> mean<01:07:09.776> that

01:07:18.080 --> 01:07:27.760
we<01:07:18.081> can<01:07:18.082> um<01:07:18.083> I<01:07:18.084> mean<01:07:18.085> we're<01:07:18.086> never<01:07:18.087> going<01:07:18.088> to<01:07:18.089> be<01:07:18.090> able<01:07:18.091> to<01:07:18.092> visualize<01:07:18.093> conscious<01:07:18.094> experience<01:07:18.095> with<01:07:18.096> a<01:07:18.097> neuroimaging

01:07:27.760 --> 01:07:34.320
device<01:07:27.761> these<01:07:27.762> are<01:07:27.763> two<01:07:27.764> kind<01:07:27.765> of<01:07:27.766> separate<01:07:27.767> worlds<01:07:27.768> distinct<01:07:27.769> worlds<01:07:27.770> but<01:07:27.771> they<01:07:27.772> can<01:07:27.773> be<01:07:27.774> correlated<01:07:27.775> uh<01:07:27.776> and

01:07:34.320 --> 01:07:44.960
I<01:07:34.321> personally<01:07:34.322> think<01:07:34.323> that<01:07:34.324> as<01:07:34.325> I<01:07:34.326> said<01:07:34.327> earlier<01:07:34.328> I<01:07:34.329> think<01:07:34.330> there's<01:07:34.331> a<01:07:34.332> big<01:07:34.333> uh<01:07:34.334> future<01:07:34.335> in<01:07:34.336> neurophysiological<01:07:34.337> um

01:07:44.960 --> 01:07:54.640
psychophysiological<01:07:44.961> study<01:07:44.962> of<01:07:44.963> conditions<01:07:44.964> conducive<01:07:44.965> to<01:07:44.966> not<01:07:44.967> only<01:07:44.968> psi<01:07:44.969> performance<01:07:44.970> but<01:07:44.971> the<01:07:44.972> induction<01:07:44.973> and

01:07:54.640 --> 01:08:02.560
stabilization<01:07:54.641> of<01:07:54.642> unusual<01:07:54.643> states<01:07:54.644> of<01:07:54.645> consciousness<01:07:54.646> and<01:07:54.647> I<01:07:54.648> do<01:07:54.649> think<01:07:54.650> we'll<01:07:54.651> learn<01:07:54.652> how<01:07:54.653> to<01:07:54.654> how<01:07:54.655> to<01:07:54.656> do<01:07:54.657> that

01:08:02.560 --> 01:08:10.480
there's<01:08:02.561> a<01:08:02.562> big<01:08:02.563> practical<01:08:02.564> dimensions<01:08:02.565> to<01:08:02.566> the<01:08:02.567> science<01:08:02.568> that<01:08:02.569> will<01:08:02.570> appear<01:08:02.571> so<01:08:02.572> do<01:08:02.573> you<01:08:02.574> think<01:08:02.575> this

01:08:10.480 --> 01:08:16.080
so-called<01:08:10.481> anomalous<01:08:10.482> phenomena<01:08:10.483> will<01:08:10.484> become<01:08:10.485> part<01:08:10.486> of<01:08:10.487> the<01:08:10.488> mainstream<01:08:10.489> science<01:08:10.490> at<01:08:10.491> some<01:08:10.492> point<01:08:10.493> because

01:08:16.080 --> 01:08:22.400
DOPS<01:08:16.081> the<01:08:16.082> the<01:08:16.083> Division<01:08:16.084> of<01:08:16.085> Perceptual<01:08:16.086> Studies<01:08:16.087> where<01:08:16.088> you<01:08:16.089> work<01:08:16.090> is<01:08:16.091> still<01:08:16.092> probably<01:08:16.093> 100%<01:08:16.094> correct

01:08:22.400 --> 01:08:29.120
me<01:08:22.401> if<01:08:22.402> I'm<01:08:22.403> wrong<01:08:22.404> 100%<01:08:22.405> privately<01:08:22.406> funded<01:08:22.407> so<01:08:22.408> it's<01:08:22.409> not<01:08:22.410> a<01:08:22.411> mainstream<01:08:22.412> science<01:08:22.413> yet<01:08:22.414> right<01:08:22.415> of<01:08:22.416> course<01:08:22.417> we

01:08:29.120 --> 01:08:36.240
encourage<01:08:29.121> people<01:08:29.122> who<01:08:29.123> want<01:08:29.124> to<01:08:29.125> support<01:08:29.126> this<01:08:29.127> research<01:08:29.128> please<01:08:29.129> feel<01:08:29.130> free<01:08:29.131> to<01:08:29.132> do<01:08:29.133> so<01:08:29.134> but<01:08:29.135> will<01:08:29.136> it<01:08:29.137> ever<01:08:29.138> become

01:08:36.240 --> 01:08:44.000
part<01:08:36.241> of<01:08:36.242> mainstream<01:08:36.243> science<01:08:36.244> yeah<01:08:36.245> these<01:08:36.246> are<01:08:36.247> of<01:08:36.248> course<01:08:36.249> questions<01:08:36.250> about<01:08:36.251> uh<01:08:36.252> the<01:08:36.253> science<01:08:36.254> process<01:08:36.255> and

01:08:44.000 --> 01:08:51.760
I've<01:08:44.001> said<01:08:44.002> before<01:08:44.003> in<01:08:44.004> several<01:08:44.005> places<01:08:44.006> and<01:08:44.007> we'll<01:08:44.008> say<01:08:44.009> again<01:08:44.010> I<01:08:44.011> think<01:08:44.012> that<01:08:44.013> uh<01:08:44.014> some<01:08:44.015> future<01:08:44.016> generation<01:08:44.017> of<01:08:44.018> uh

01:08:51.760 --> 01:08:58.880
uh<01:08:51.761> sociologists<01:08:51.762> and<01:08:51.763> historians<01:08:51.764> and<01:08:51.765> philosophers<01:08:51.766> of<01:08:51.767> science<01:08:51.768> will<01:08:51.769> make<01:08:51.770> an<01:08:51.771> excellent<01:08:51.772> living<01:08:51.773> trying<01:08:51.774> to

01:08:58.880 --> 01:09:04.320
figure<01:08:58.881> out<01:08:58.882> why<01:08:58.883> it<01:08:58.884> took<01:08:58.885> the<01:08:58.886> scientific<01:08:58.887> community<01:08:58.888> so<01:08:58.889> long<01:08:58.890> to<01:08:58.891> take<01:08:58.892> these<01:08:58.893> phenomena<01:08:58.894> on<01:08:58.895> board<01:08:58.896> as

01:09:04.320 --> 01:09:12.240
real<01:09:04.321> you<01:09:04.322> know<01:09:04.323> I<01:09:04.324> I<01:09:04.325> think<01:09:04.326> the<01:09:04.327> battle<01:09:04.328> is<01:09:04.329> over<01:09:04.330> in<01:09:04.331> fact<01:09:04.332> has<01:09:04.333> been<01:09:04.334> over<01:09:04.335> for<01:09:04.336> a<01:09:04.337> while<01:09:04.338> it's<01:09:04.339> just<01:09:04.340> that

01:09:12.240 --> 01:09:19.600
most<01:09:12.241> of<01:09:12.242> the<01:09:12.243> combatants<01:09:12.244> aren't<01:09:12.245> aware<01:09:12.246> of<01:09:12.247> it<01:09:12.248> yet<01:09:12.249> uh-huh<01:09:12.250> so<01:09:12.251> it's<01:09:12.252> a<01:09:12.253> question<01:09:12.254> of<01:09:12.255> change<01:09:12.256> of<01:09:12.257> changing

01:09:19.600 --> 01:09:25.840
generation<01:09:19.601> of<01:09:19.602> scientists<01:09:19.603> or<01:09:19.604> something<01:09:19.605> science<01:09:19.606> science<01:09:19.607> makes<01:09:19.608> progress<01:09:19.609> one<01:09:19.610> funeral<01:09:19.611> at<01:09:19.612> a<01:09:19.613> time<01:09:19.614> I've

01:09:25.840 --> 01:09:35.440
heard<01:09:25.841> somewhere<01:09:25.842> yeah<01:09:25.843> Max<01:09:25.844> Planck<01:09:25.845> William<01:09:25.846> William<01:09:25.847> James<01:09:25.848> said<01:09:25.849> 100<01:09:25.850> and<01:09:25.851> something<01:09:25.852> years<01:09:25.853> ago<01:09:25.854> that<01:09:25.855> uh<01:09:25.856> we

01:09:35.440 --> 01:09:45.040
have<01:09:35.441> to<01:09:35.442> mark<01:09:35.443> our<01:09:35.444> progress<01:09:35.445> in<01:09:35.446> half<01:09:35.447> centuries<01:09:35.448> uh<01:09:35.449> okay<01:09:35.450> interesting<01:09:35.451> what<01:09:35.452> advice<01:09:35.453> can<01:09:35.454> we<01:09:35.455> give<01:09:35.456> to<01:09:35.457> people<01:09:35.458> who

01:09:45.040 --> 01:09:50.240
want<01:09:45.041> to<01:09:45.042> study<01:09:45.043> anomalous<01:09:45.044> phenomena<01:09:45.045> and<01:09:45.046> who<01:09:45.047> people<01:09:45.048> who<01:09:45.049> want<01:09:45.050> to<01:09:45.051> study<01:09:45.052> consciousness<01:09:45.053> why<01:09:45.054> should<01:09:45.055> we

01:09:50.240 --> 01:09:59.120
take<01:09:50.241> this<01:09:50.242> research<01:09:50.243> and<01:09:50.244> an<01:09:50.245> anomalous<01:09:50.246> phenomena<01:09:50.247> such<01:09:50.248> seriously<01:09:50.249> well<01:09:50.250> uh<01:09:50.251> they<01:09:50.252> should<01:09:50.253> be<01:09:50.254> taken<01:09:50.255> seriously

01:09:59.120 --> 01:10:06.960
in<01:09:59.121> my<01:09:59.122> opinion<01:09:59.123> because<01:09:59.124> there's<01:09:59.125> an<01:09:59.126> abundance<01:09:59.127> of<01:09:59.128> good<01:09:59.129> evidence<01:09:59.130> for<01:09:59.131> them<01:09:59.132> but<01:09:59.133> it<01:09:59.134> is<01:09:59.135> true<01:09:59.136> at<01:09:59.137> present

01:10:06.960 --> 01:10:13.760
that<01:10:06.961> that<01:10:06.962> whole<01:10:06.963> subject<01:10:06.964> is<01:10:06.965> still<01:10:06.966> anathema<01:10:06.967> in<01:10:06.968> a<01:10:06.969> lot<01:10:06.970> of<01:10:06.971> places<01:10:06.972> um<01:10:06.973> now<01:10:06.974> I<01:10:06.975> personally<01:10:06.976> think<01:10:06.977> what's

01:10:13.760 --> 01:10:20.400
going<01:10:13.761> to<01:10:13.762> happen<01:10:13.763> is<01:10:13.764> that<01:10:13.765> uh<01:10:13.766> psychical<01:10:13.767> research<01:10:13.768> will<01:10:13.769> eventually<01:10:13.770> get<01:10:13.771> reabsorbed<01:10:13.772> into<01:10:13.773> a<01:10:13.774> larger

01:10:20.400 --> 01:10:27.360
science<01:10:20.401> of<01:10:20.402> consciousness<01:10:20.403> and<01:10:20.404> I<01:10:20.405> would<01:10:20.406> strongly<01:10:20.407> recommend<01:10:20.408> particularly<01:10:20.409> to<01:10:20.410> young<01:10:20.411> people<01:10:20.412> heading<01:10:20.413> in

01:10:27.360 --> 01:10:36.000
this<01:10:27.361> direction<01:10:27.362> that<01:10:27.363> they<01:10:27.364> get<01:10:27.365> a<01:10:27.366> degree<01:10:27.367> in<01:10:27.368> something<01:10:27.369> like<01:10:27.370> either<01:10:27.371> standard<01:10:27.372> neuroscience<01:10:27.373> or<01:10:27.374> consciousness

01:10:36.000 --> 01:10:43.600
neuroscience<01:10:36.001> and<01:10:36.002> there<01:10:36.003> are<01:10:36.004> programs<01:10:36.005> now<01:10:36.006> appearing<01:10:36.007> at<01:10:36.008> a<01:10:36.009> lot<01:10:36.010> of<01:10:36.011> places<01:10:36.012> uh<01:10:36.013> get<01:10:36.014> into<01:10:36.015> the<01:10:36.016> field<01:10:36.017> in

01:10:43.600 --> 01:10:52.000
that<01:10:43.601> way<01:10:43.602> be<01:10:43.603> very<01:10:43.604> careful<01:10:43.605> who<01:10:43.606> you<01:10:43.607> talk<01:10:43.608> to<01:10:43.609> about<01:10:43.610> interests<01:10:43.611> in<01:10:43.612> parapsychology<01:10:43.613> with<01:10:43.614> the<01:10:43.615> idea<01:10:43.616> that<01:10:43.617> uh

01:10:52.000 --> 01:11:00.960
you'll<01:10:52.001> eventually<01:10:52.002> be<01:10:52.003> able<01:10:52.004> to<01:10:52.005> pursue<01:10:52.006> all<01:10:52.007> dimensions<01:10:52.008> of<01:10:52.009> the<01:10:52.010> subject<01:10:52.011> as<01:10:52.012> you<01:10:52.013> wish<01:10:52.014> but<01:10:52.015> it's<01:10:52.016> just<01:10:52.017> smart<01:10:52.018> to

01:11:00.960 --> 01:11:10.240
be<01:11:00.961> careful<01:11:00.962> at<01:11:00.963> the<01:11:00.964> beginning<01:11:00.965> in<01:11:00.966> particular<01:11:00.967> you<01:11:00.968> have<01:11:00.969> a<01:11:00.970> hobby<01:11:00.971> horse<01:11:00.972> called<01:11:00.973> mystical<01:11:00.974> experiences<01:11:00.975> because

01:11:10.240 --> 01:11:17.760
you<01:11:10.241> often<01:11:10.242> talk<01:11:10.243> about<01:11:10.244> them<01:11:10.245> and<01:11:10.246> you<01:11:10.247> often<01:11:10.248> mention<01:11:10.249> that<01:11:10.250> uh<01:11:10.251> the<01:11:10.252> research<01:11:10.253> on<01:11:10.254> mystical<01:11:10.255> experiences

01:11:17.760 --> 01:11:26.560
even<01:11:17.761> in<01:11:17.762> non-mainstream<01:11:17.763> uh<01:11:17.764> science<01:11:17.765> is<01:11:17.766> it's<01:11:17.767> largely<01:11:17.768> ignored<01:11:17.769> as<01:11:17.770> a<01:11:17.771> topic<01:11:17.772> am<01:11:17.773> I<01:11:17.774> correct<01:11:17.775> that<01:11:17.776> what<01:11:17.777> you're

01:11:26.560 --> 01:11:35.040
saying<01:11:26.561> so<01:11:26.562> I<01:11:26.563> wanted<01:11:26.564> to<01:11:26.565> ask<01:11:26.566> you<01:11:26.567> why<01:11:26.568> is<01:11:26.569> that<01:11:26.570> the<01:11:26.571> case<01:11:26.572> mhm<01:11:26.573> what<01:11:26.574> do<01:11:26.575> we<01:11:26.576> mean<01:11:26.577> by<01:11:26.578> mystical<01:11:26.579> experience

01:11:35.040 --> 01:11:40.000
because<01:11:35.041> I<01:11:35.042> think<01:11:35.043> it<01:11:35.044> could<01:11:35.045> be<01:11:35.046> a<01:11:35.047> range<01:11:35.048> of<01:11:35.049> phenomena<01:11:35.050> and<01:11:35.051> do<01:11:35.052> you<01:11:35.053> have<01:11:35.054> maybe<01:11:35.055> a<01:11:35.056> couple<01:11:35.057> of<01:11:35.058> interesting

01:11:40.000 --> 01:11:46.480
examples<01:11:40.001> that<01:11:40.002> could<01:11:40.003> illustrate<01:11:40.004> it<01:11:40.005> I<01:11:40.006> think<01:11:40.007> uh<01:11:40.008> mystical<01:11:40.009> experiences<01:11:40.010> have<01:11:40.011> been<01:11:40.012> problematic<01:11:40.013> for

01:11:46.480 --> 01:11:55.200
science<01:11:46.481> so<01:11:46.482> far<01:11:46.483> particularly<01:11:46.484> because<01:11:46.485> they<01:11:46.486> clearly<01:11:46.487> come<01:11:46.488> out<01:11:46.489> of<01:11:46.490> this<01:11:46.491> kind<01:11:46.492> of<01:11:46.493> spiritual<01:11:46.494> dimension<01:11:46.495> of

01:11:55.200 --> 01:12:05.440
uh<01:11:55.201> human<01:11:55.202> life<01:11:55.203> associated<01:11:55.204> with<01:11:55.205> religion<01:11:55.206> a<01:11:55.207> lot<01:11:55.208> of<01:11:55.209> scientists<01:11:55.210> see<01:11:55.211> uh<01:11:55.212> the<01:11:55.213> development<01:11:55.214> of<01:11:55.215> science<01:11:55.216> as

01:12:05.440 --> 01:12:15.440
overcoming<01:12:05.441> um<01:12:05.442> traditional<01:12:05.443> religious<01:12:05.444> pictures<01:12:05.445> of<01:12:05.446> the<01:12:05.447> world<01:12:05.448> uh<01:12:05.449> and<01:12:05.450> I<01:12:05.451> think<01:12:05.452> there's<01:12:05.453> a<01:12:05.454> lot<01:12:05.455> of<01:12:05.456> truth

01:12:15.440 --> 01:12:23.680
in<01:12:15.441> that<01:12:15.442> at<01:12:15.443> the<01:12:15.444> same<01:12:15.445> time<01:12:15.446> my<01:12:15.447> personal<01:12:15.448> belief<01:12:15.449> is<01:12:15.450> that<01:12:15.451> the<01:12:15.452> the<01:12:15.453> rise<01:12:15.454> of<01:12:15.455> secular<01:12:15.456> humanism<01:12:15.457> in

01:12:23.680 --> 01:12:34.400
particular<01:12:23.681> which<01:12:23.682> portrays<01:12:23.683> this<01:12:23.684> inevitable<01:12:23.685> conflict<01:12:23.686> between<01:12:23.687> science<01:12:23.688> and<01:12:23.689> religion<01:12:23.690> has<01:12:23.691> been<01:12:23.692> unfortunate

01:12:34.400 --> 01:12:40.320
um<01:12:34.401> in<01:12:34.402> the<01:12:34.403> sense<01:12:34.404> that<01:12:34.405> it's<01:12:34.406> kind<01:12:34.407> of<01:12:34.408> caused<01:12:34.409> us<01:12:34.410> to<01:12:34.411> throw<01:12:34.412> out<01:12:34.413> the<01:12:34.414> baby<01:12:34.415> with<01:12:34.416> the<01:12:34.417> bathwater<01:12:34.418> as<01:12:34.419> we've

01:12:40.320 --> 01:12:48.560
grown<01:12:40.321> up<01:12:40.322> scientifically<01:12:40.323> and<01:12:40.324> I<01:12:40.325> see<01:12:40.326> what's<01:12:40.327> going<01:12:40.328> on<01:12:40.329> now<01:12:40.330> is<01:12:40.331> our<01:12:40.332> beginning<01:12:40.333> to<01:12:40.334> recover<01:12:40.335> the<01:12:40.336> baby<01:12:40.337> and

01:12:48.560 --> 01:12:57.920
to<01:12:48.561> integrate<01:12:48.562> it<01:12:48.563> with<01:12:48.564> a<01:12:48.565> larger<01:12:48.566> picture<01:12:48.567> of<01:12:48.568> science<01:12:48.569> itself<01:12:48.570> uh<01:12:48.571> I<01:12:48.572> mean<01:12:48.573> you<01:12:48.574> know<01:12:48.575> there<01:12:48.576> there<01:12:48.577> are<01:12:48.578> lots<01:12:48.579> of

01:12:57.920 --> 01:13:10.800
scientists<01:12:57.921> now<01:12:57.922> even<01:12:57.923> now<01:12:57.924> who<01:12:57.925> have<01:12:57.926> a<01:12:57.927> spiritual<01:12:57.928> life<01:12:57.929> quietly<01:12:57.930> privately<01:12:57.931> usually<01:12:57.932> kept<01:12:57.933> strictly

01:13:10.800 --> 01:13:17.920
separate<01:13:10.801> from<01:13:10.802> their<01:13:10.803> day<01:13:10.804> jobs<01:13:10.805> I<01:13:10.806> mean<01:13:10.807> William<01:13:10.808> James<01:13:10.809> in<01:13:10.810> his<01:13:10.811> characteristic<01:13:10.812> way<01:13:10.813> pointed<01:13:10.814> this<01:13:10.815> out<01:13:10.816> a<01:13:10.817> 100

01:13:17.920 --> 01:13:30.000
plus<01:13:17.921> years<01:13:17.922> ago<01:13:17.923> he<01:13:17.924> he<01:13:17.925> talked<01:13:17.926> about<01:13:17.927> how<01:13:17.928> uh<01:13:17.929> um<01:13:17.930> modern<01:13:17.931> laboratory<01:13:17.932> scientists<01:13:17.933> good<01:13:17.934> Christian<01:13:17.935> husbands<01:13:17.936> and

01:13:30.000 --> 01:13:39.440
fathers<01:13:30.001> as<01:13:30.002> he<01:13:30.003> put<01:13:30.004> it<01:13:30.005> um<01:13:30.006> materialists<01:13:30.007> in<01:13:30.008> their<01:13:30.009> day<01:13:30.010> jobs<01:13:30.011> and<01:13:30.012> you<01:13:30.013> know<01:13:30.014> good<01:13:30.015> Christian<01:13:30.016> fathers

01:13:39.440 --> 01:13:46.080
at<01:13:39.441> night<01:13:39.442> holding<01:13:39.443> together<01:13:39.444> thus<01:13:39.445> loosely<01:13:39.446> the<01:13:39.447> two<01:13:39.448> ends<01:13:39.449> of<01:13:39.450> a<01:13:39.451> chain<01:13:39.452> they<01:13:39.453> are<01:13:39.454> careless<01:13:39.455> of<01:13:39.456> the

01:13:46.080 --> 01:13:55.120
intermediate<01:13:46.081> connection<01:13:46.082> typical<01:13:46.083> James<01:13:46.084> colorful<01:13:46.085> beautiful<01:13:46.086> language<01:13:46.087> and<01:13:46.088> I<01:13:46.089> think<01:13:46.090> there's<01:13:46.091> a<01:13:46.092> lot<01:13:46.093> of

01:13:55.120 --> 01:14:01.440
that<01:13:55.121> going<01:13:55.122> on<01:13:55.123> I<01:13:55.124> think<01:13:55.125> the<01:13:55.126> the<01:13:55.127> level<01:13:55.128> of<01:13:55.129> spiritual<01:13:55.130> interest<01:13:55.131> among<01:13:55.132> scientists<01:13:55.133> is<01:13:55.134> really<01:13:55.135> quite<01:13:55.136> a<01:13:55.137> bit

01:14:01.440 --> 01:14:09.040
higher<01:14:01.441> than<01:14:01.442> you<01:14:01.443> might<01:14:01.444> think<01:14:01.445> from<01:14:01.446> the<01:14:01.447> scientific<01:14:01.448> literature<01:14:01.449> itself<01:14:01.450> and<01:14:01.451> I<01:14:01.452> think<01:14:01.453> what<01:14:01.454> we're<01:14:01.455> and

01:14:09.040 --> 01:14:17.120
our<01:14:09.041> colleagues<01:14:09.042> are<01:14:09.043> doing<01:14:09.044> basically<01:14:09.045> is<01:14:09.046> trying<01:14:09.047> to<01:14:09.048> find<01:14:09.049> ways<01:14:09.050> of<01:14:09.051> reconciling<01:14:09.052> science<01:14:09.053> and<01:14:09.054> spirituality

01:14:17.120 --> 01:14:23.360
not<01:14:17.121> not<01:14:17.122> so<01:14:17.123> much<01:14:17.124> with<01:14:17.125> particular<01:14:17.126> traditional<01:14:17.127> faiths<01:14:17.128> in<01:14:17.129> fact<01:14:17.130> I<01:14:17.131> mean<01:14:17.132> a<01:14:17.133> lot<01:14:17.134> of<01:14:17.135> people<01:14:17.136> there

01:14:23.360 --> 01:14:29.120
are<01:14:23.361> a<01:14:23.362> lot<01:14:23.363> of<01:14:23.364> people<01:14:23.365> out<01:14:23.366> there<01:14:23.367> who<01:14:23.368> recognize<01:14:23.369> the<01:14:23.370> evils<01:14:23.371> of<01:14:23.372> physicalism<01:14:23.373> and<01:14:23.374> its<01:14:23.375> contribution<01:14:23.376> to<01:14:23.377> our

01:14:29.120 --> 01:14:36.480
the<01:14:29.121> problems<01:14:29.122> of<01:14:29.123> our<01:14:29.124> civilization<01:14:29.125> and<01:14:29.126> who<01:14:29.127> want<01:14:29.128> to<01:14:29.129> find<01:14:29.130> some<01:14:29.131> kind<01:14:29.132> of<01:14:29.133> a<01:14:29.134> re-enchantment<01:14:29.135> of<01:14:29.136> the<01:14:29.137> world

01:14:36.480 --> 01:14:43.120
but<01:14:36.481> for<01:14:36.482> many<01:14:36.483> of<01:14:36.484> them<01:14:36.485> that<01:14:36.486> amounts<01:14:36.487> to<01:14:36.488> going<01:14:36.489> back<01:14:36.490> to<01:14:36.491> some<01:14:36.492> earlier<01:14:36.493> state<01:14:36.494> of<01:14:36.495> things<01:14:36.496> including<01:14:36.497> perhaps<01:14:36.498> one

01:14:43.120 --> 01:14:50.080
of<01:14:43.121> the<01:14:43.122> traditional<01:14:43.123> faiths<01:14:43.124> um<01:14:43.125> I'm<01:14:43.126> not<01:14:43.127> interested<01:14:43.128> in<01:14:43.129> creating<01:14:43.130> a<01:14:43.131> new<01:14:43.132> religion<01:14:43.133> or<01:14:43.134> anything<01:14:43.135> like<01:14:43.136> that

01:14:50.080 --> 01:14:57.920
but<01:14:50.081> I<01:14:50.082> do<01:14:50.083> think<01:14:50.084> that<01:14:50.085> the<01:14:50.086> way<01:14:50.087> forward<01:14:50.088> is<01:14:50.089> to<01:14:50.090> find<01:14:50.091> an<01:14:50.092> expanded<01:14:50.093> picture<01:14:50.094> of<01:14:50.095> reality<01:14:50.096> drawing<01:14:50.097> upon<01:14:50.098> science

01:14:57.920 --> 01:15:08.640
that<01:14:57.921> makes<01:14:57.922> room<01:14:57.923> for<01:14:57.924> spiritual<01:14:57.925> experiences<01:14:57.926> and<01:14:57.927> perhaps<01:14:57.928> helps<01:14:57.929> people<01:14:57.930> to<01:14:57.931> have<01:14:57.932> such<01:14:57.933> experiences

01:15:08.640 --> 01:15:15.360
that's<01:15:08.641> where<01:15:08.642> I<01:15:08.643> think<01:15:08.644> we're<01:15:08.645> really<01:15:08.646> headed<01:15:08.647> the<01:15:08.648> mystical<01:15:08.649> experiences<01:15:08.650> what's<01:15:08.651> behind<01:15:08.652> it<01:15:08.653> is<01:15:08.654> it

01:15:15.360 --> 01:15:23.520
because<01:15:15.361> people<01:15:15.362> often<01:15:15.363> say<01:15:15.364> that<01:15:15.365> there<01:15:15.366> is<01:15:15.367> this<01:15:15.368> inner<01:15:15.369> drive<01:15:15.370> that<01:15:15.371> that<01:15:15.372> sort<01:15:15.373> of<01:15:15.374> brought<01:15:15.375> them<01:15:15.376> to

01:15:23.520 --> 01:15:32.320
to<01:15:23.521> to<01:15:23.522> those<01:15:23.523> experiences<01:15:23.524> Bernardo<01:15:23.525> call<01:15:23.526> it<01:15:23.527> daimon<01:15:23.528> sometimes<01:15:23.529> is<01:15:23.530> it<01:15:23.531> our<01:15:23.532> inner<01:15:23.533> nature<01:15:23.534> to<01:15:23.535> have<01:15:23.536> those

01:15:32.320 --> 01:15:39.920
at<01:15:32.321> least<01:15:32.322> for<01:15:32.323> part<01:15:32.324> of<01:15:32.325> us<01:15:32.326> I<01:15:32.327> I<01:15:32.328> think<01:15:32.329> you<01:15:32.330> know<01:15:32.331> we're<01:15:32.332> to<01:15:32.333> have<01:15:32.334> a<01:15:32.335> mystical<01:15:32.336> experience<01:15:32.337> is<01:15:32.338> to<01:15:32.339> take<01:15:32.340> a<01:15:32.341> step

01:15:39.920 --> 01:15:47.040
in<01:15:39.921> the<01:15:39.922> direction<01:15:39.923> of<01:15:39.924> that<01:15:39.925> higher<01:15:39.926> reality<01:15:39.927> that<01:15:39.928> Bernardo<01:15:39.929> and<01:15:39.930> we<01:15:39.931> both<01:15:39.932> think<01:15:39.933> is<01:15:39.934> out<01:15:39.935> there<01:15:39.936> really

01:15:47.040 --> 01:15:54.240
um<01:15:47.041> what's<01:15:47.042> behind<01:15:47.043> it<01:15:47.044> is<01:15:47.045> there<01:15:47.046> evolutionary<01:15:47.047> advantage<01:15:47.048> why<01:15:47.049> why<01:15:47.050> keep<01:15:47.051> on<01:15:47.052> having<01:15:47.053> it<01:15:47.054> you<01:15:47.055> know

01:15:54.240 --> 01:15:59.200
some<01:15:54.241> of<01:15:54.242> us<01:15:54.243> or<01:15:54.244> most<01:15:54.245> of<01:15:54.246> us<01:15:54.247> actually<01:15:54.248> people<01:15:54.249> don't<01:15:54.250> don't<01:15:54.251> talk<01:15:54.252> about<01:15:54.253> it<01:15:54.254> but<01:15:54.255> dreams<01:15:54.256> and

01:15:59.200 --> 01:16:06.080
premonitions<01:15:59.201> and<01:15:59.202> synchronicities<01:15:59.203> and<01:15:59.204> it's<01:15:59.205> just<01:15:59.206> we<01:15:59.207> ignore<01:15:59.208> it<01:15:59.209> but<01:15:59.210> it's<01:15:59.211> it's<01:15:59.212> there<01:15:59.213> it's<01:15:59.214> like<01:15:59.215> part

01:16:06.080 --> 01:16:12.800
of<01:16:06.081> our<01:16:06.082> reality<01:16:06.083> which<01:16:06.084> we<01:16:06.085> completely<01:16:06.086> ignore<01:16:06.087> but<01:16:06.088> then<01:16:06.089> what's<01:16:06.090> behind<01:16:06.091> it<01:16:06.092> survival<01:16:06.093> evolutionary

01:16:12.800 --> 01:16:18.640
advantage<01:16:12.801> or<01:16:12.802> what<01:16:12.803> what<01:16:12.804> what's<01:16:12.805> it<01:16:12.806> in<01:16:12.807> your<01:16:12.808> view<01:16:12.809> well<01:16:12.810> one<01:16:12.811> one<01:16:12.812> of<01:16:12.813> the<01:16:12.814> points<01:16:12.815> that<01:16:12.816> Dennis<01:16:12.817> Noble

01:16:18.640 --> 01:16:25.920
makes<01:16:18.641> is<01:16:18.642> that<01:16:18.643> this<01:16:18.644> reconceptualization<01:16:18.645> of<01:16:18.646> biology<01:16:18.647> in<01:16:18.648> terms<01:16:18.649> of<01:16:18.650> cognitive<01:16:18.651> capacities<01:16:18.652> and

01:16:25.920 --> 01:16:33.280
even<01:16:25.921> very<01:16:25.922> small<01:16:25.923> organisms<01:16:25.924> that<01:16:25.925> can<01:16:25.926> get<01:16:25.927> incorporated<01:16:25.928> into<01:16:25.929> evolutionary<01:16:25.930> advance

01:16:33.280 --> 01:16:39.840
uh<01:16:33.281> that<01:16:33.282> drastically<01:16:33.283> changes<01:16:33.284> things<01:16:33.285> it<01:16:33.286> allows<01:16:33.287> evolution<01:16:33.288> to<01:16:33.289> move<01:16:33.290> in<01:16:33.291> a<01:16:33.292> direction<01:16:33.293> that<01:16:33.294> gradually

01:16:39.840 --> 01:16:46.560
provides<01:16:39.841> higher<01:16:39.842> access<01:16:39.843> greater<01:16:39.844> degrees<01:16:39.845> of<01:16:39.846> access<01:16:39.847> to<01:16:39.848> this<01:16:39.849> underlying<01:16:39.850> higher<01:16:39.851> reality

01:16:46.560 --> 01:16:54.640
and<01:16:46.561> it's<01:16:46.562> certainly<01:16:46.563> true<01:16:46.564> I<01:16:46.565> mean<01:16:46.566> the<01:16:46.567> mysticism<01:16:46.568> is<01:16:46.569> a<01:16:46.570> enormous<01:16:46.571> subject<01:16:46.572> mainly<01:16:46.573> it's<01:16:46.574> been<01:16:46.575> the<01:16:46.576> preserve<01:16:46.577> of

01:16:54.640 --> 01:17:02.080
religious<01:16:54.641> studies<01:16:54.642> up<01:16:54.643> to<01:16:54.644> now<01:16:54.645> but<01:16:54.646> I<01:16:54.647> think<01:16:54.648> it<01:16:54.649> lends<01:16:54.650> itself<01:16:54.651> to<01:16:54.652> various<01:16:54.653> kinds<01:16:54.654> of<01:16:54.655> scientific<01:16:54.656> approaches

01:17:02.080 --> 01:17:08.240
and<01:17:02.081> the<01:17:02.082> the<01:17:02.083> general<01:17:02.084> tendency<01:17:02.085> in<01:17:02.086> terms<01:17:02.087> of<01:17:02.088> impact<01:17:02.089> on<01:17:02.090> philosophy<01:17:02.091> is<01:17:02.092> to<01:17:02.093> push<01:17:02.094> in<01:17:02.095> the<01:17:02.096> direction<01:17:02.097> of

01:17:08.240 --> 01:17:15.840
idealism<01:17:08.241> and<01:17:08.242> William<01:17:08.243> James<01:17:08.244> in<01:17:08.245> the<01:17:08.246> Varieties<01:17:08.247> has<01:17:08.248> already<01:17:08.249> said<01:17:08.250> that<01:17:08.251> in<01:17:08.252> his<01:17:08.253> philosophy<01:17:08.254> chapter<01:17:08.255> he

01:17:15.840 --> 01:17:24.640
said<01:17:15.841> mystical<01:17:15.842> experiences<01:17:15.843> point<01:17:15.844> inescapably<01:17:15.845> in<01:17:15.846> the<01:17:15.847> direction<01:17:15.848> of<01:17:15.849> some<01:17:15.850> kind<01:17:15.851> of<01:17:15.852> idealism<01:17:15.853> like<01:17:15.854> us

01:17:24.640 --> 01:17:30.560
he<01:17:24.641> wasn't<01:17:24.642> real<01:17:24.643> clear<01:17:24.644> about<01:17:24.645> exactly<01:17:24.646> what<01:17:24.647> kind<01:17:24.648> and<01:17:24.649> I<01:17:24.650> think<01:17:24.651> it's<01:17:24.652> still<01:17:24.653> up<01:17:24.654> for<01:17:24.655> grabs<01:17:24.656> exactly<01:17:24.657> where<01:17:24.658> this

01:17:30.560 --> 01:17:41.040
will<01:17:30.561> actually<01:17:30.562> come<01:17:30.563> out<01:17:30.564> but<01:17:30.565> I<01:17:30.566> think<01:17:30.567> that<01:17:30.568> is<01:17:30.569> the<01:17:30.570> clear<01:17:30.571> tendency<01:17:30.572> philosophically<01:17:30.573> and<01:17:30.574> what<01:17:30.575> mystical

01:17:41.040 --> 01:17:50.160
experiences<01:17:41.041> tend<01:17:41.042> to<01:17:41.043> do<01:17:41.044> for<01:17:41.045> people<01:17:41.046> who<01:17:41.047> are<01:17:41.048> lucky<01:17:41.049> enough<01:17:41.050> to<01:17:41.051> have<01:17:41.052> them<01:17:41.053> for<01:17:41.054> whatever<01:17:41.055> reason<01:17:41.056> is<01:17:41.057> to<01:17:41.058> put

01:17:50.160 --> 01:17:59.200
them<01:17:50.161> in<01:17:50.162> direct<01:17:50.163> touch<01:17:50.164> with<01:17:50.165> that<01:17:50.166> higher<01:17:50.167> aspect<01:17:50.168> of<01:17:50.169> reality<01:17:50.170> that's<01:17:50.171> normally<01:17:50.172> invisible<01:17:50.173> to<01:17:50.174> us

01:17:59.200 --> 01:18:08.560
the<01:17:59.201> relationship<01:17:59.202> between<01:17:59.203> the<01:17:59.204> brain<01:17:59.205> and<01:17:59.206> the<01:17:59.207> mind<01:17:59.208> um<01:17:59.209> are<01:17:59.210> our<01:17:59.211> minds<01:17:59.212> confined<01:17:59.213> to<01:17:59.214> our<01:17:59.215> brains<01:17:59.216> or<01:17:59.217> do

01:18:08.560 --> 01:18:16.800
they<01:18:08.561> extend<01:18:08.562> far<01:18:08.563> beyond<01:18:08.564> our<01:18:08.565> brains<01:18:08.566> well<01:18:08.567> I<01:18:08.568> think<01:18:08.569> the<01:18:08.570> latter<01:18:08.571> of<01:18:08.572> course<01:18:08.573> and<01:18:08.574> um<01:18:08.575> the<01:18:08.576> uh<01:18:08.577> our<01:18:08.578> three

01:18:16.800 --> 01:18:26.880
books<01:18:16.801> explain<01:18:16.802> how<01:18:16.803> we<01:18:16.804> got<01:18:16.805> to<01:18:16.806> that<01:18:16.807> view<01:18:16.808> of<01:18:16.809> things<01:18:16.810> particularly<01:18:16.811> the<01:18:16.812> first<01:18:16.813> the<01:18:16.814> I<01:18:16.815> think<01:18:16.816> the<01:18:16.817> uh<01:18:16.818> the

01:18:26.880 --> 01:18:35.920
First<01:18:26.881> is<01:18:26.882> a,<01:18:26.883> I<01:18:26.884> think<01:18:26.885> that's<01:18:26.886> a<01:18:26.887> contribution<01:18:26.888> that<01:18:26.889> will<01:18:26.890> last.<01:18:26.891> It<01:18:26.892> has<01:18:26.893> real<01:18:26.894> staying<01:18:26.895> power.<01:18:26.896> It's<01:18:26.897> gotten

01:18:35.920 --> 01:18:43.360
way<01:18:35.921> more<01:18:35.922> circulation<01:18:35.923> than<01:18:35.924> most<01:18:35.925> books<01:18:35.926> of<01:18:35.927> that<01:18:35.928> sort.<01:18:35.929> I<01:18:35.930> should<01:18:35.931> say<01:18:35.932> that<01:18:35.933> that's<01:18:35.934> partly<01:18:35.935> thanks<01:18:35.936> to<01:18:35.937> Eben

01:18:43.360 --> 01:18:51.360
Alexander,<01:18:43.361> you<01:18:43.362> know,<01:18:43.363> the<01:18:43.364> author<01:18:43.365> of<01:18:43.366> Proof<01:18:43.367> of<01:18:43.368> Heaven,<01:18:43.369> a<01:18:43.370> neuroscientist<01:18:43.371> who<01:18:43.372> had<01:18:43.373> a,<01:18:43.374> was<01:18:43.375> put<01:18:43.376> in<01:18:43.377> a<01:18:43.378> coma<01:18:43.379> by<01:18:43.380> a

01:18:51.360 --> 01:18:59.120
bacterial<01:18:51.361> infection<01:18:51.362> of<01:18:51.363> his<01:18:51.364> brain.<01:18:51.365> Uh,<01:18:51.366> he<01:18:51.367> says<01:18:51.368> in<01:18:51.369> his<01:18:51.370> book,<01:18:51.371> his<01:18:51.372> first<01:18:51.373> book,<01:18:51.374> Proof<01:18:51.375> of<01:18:51.376> Heaven,<01:18:51.377> that<01:18:51.378> title,<01:18:51.379> by

01:18:59.120 --> 01:19:04.800
the<01:18:59.121> way,<01:18:59.122> was<01:18:59.123> supplied<01:18:59.124> by<01:18:59.125> the<01:18:59.126> publisher,<01:18:59.127> not<01:18:59.128> by<01:18:59.129> Eben<01:18:59.130> Alexander.<01:18:59.131> Anyway,<01:18:59.132> somewhere<01:18:59.133> in<01:18:59.134> that<01:18:59.135> book,

01:19:04.800 --> 01:19:12.560
he<01:19:04.801> refers<01:19:04.802> to<01:19:04.803> our<01:19:04.804> book<01:19:04.805> as<01:19:04.806> a<01:19:04.807> sort<01:19:04.808> of<01:19:04.809> one-stop<01:19:04.810> source<01:19:04.811> of<01:19:04.812> information<01:19:04.813> about<01:19:04.814> lots<01:19:04.815> of<01:19:04.816> the<01:19:04.817> relevant

01:19:12.560 --> 01:19:19.120
subjects.<01:19:12.561> And<01:19:12.562> when<01:19:12.563> he<01:19:12.564> published<01:19:12.565> that<01:19:12.566> book,<01:19:12.567> which<01:19:12.568> has<01:19:12.569> sold<01:19:12.570> millions<01:19:12.571> of<01:19:12.572> copies,<01:19:12.573> the<01:19:12.574> sales<01:19:12.575> of<01:19:12.576> ours

01:19:19.120 --> 01:19:26.240
doubled<01:19:19.121> instantly.<01:19:19.122> So<01:19:19.123> he's<01:19:19.124> responsible<01:19:19.125> for<01:19:19.126> a<01:19:19.127> good<01:19:19.128> bit<01:19:19.129> of<01:19:19.130> our<01:19:19.131> success,<01:19:19.132> but<01:19:19.133> it<01:19:19.134> is<01:19:19.135> getting<01:19:19.136> around,<01:19:19.137> and

01:19:26.240 --> 01:19:34.080
uh,<01:19:26.241> we<01:19:26.242> also,<01:19:26.243> by<01:19:26.244> the<01:19:26.245> way,<01:19:26.246> we<01:19:26.247> were<01:19:26.248> enabled<01:19:26.249> by<01:19:26.250> John<01:19:26.251> Cleese<01:19:26.252> to<01:19:26.253> buy<01:19:26.254> a<01:19:26.255> bunch<01:19:26.256> of<01:19:26.257> copies<01:19:26.258> ourselves

01:19:34.080 --> 01:19:41.040
and<01:19:34.081> distribute<01:19:34.082> them<01:19:34.083> individually<01:19:34.084> to<01:19:34.085> targeted<01:19:34.086> persons<01:19:34.087> in<01:19:34.088> the<01:19:34.089> academic<01:19:34.090> mainstream,<01:19:34.091> a<01:19:34.092> few<01:19:34.093> of

01:19:41.040 --> 01:19:52.320
whom<01:19:41.041> responded,<01:19:41.042> including,<01:19:41.043> uh,<01:19:41.044> Tom<01:19:41.045> Nagel,<01:19:41.046> who<01:19:41.047> thanked<01:19:41.048> us<01:19:41.049> for<01:19:41.050> a<01:19:41.051> copy.<01:19:41.052> And<01:19:41.053> I,<01:19:41.054> I,<01:19:41.055> I<01:19:41.056> don't<01:19:41.057> really

01:19:52.320 --> 01:20:01.040
know<01:19:52.321> this,<01:19:52.322> but<01:19:52.323> I<01:19:52.324> suspect<01:19:52.325> it<01:19:52.326> may<01:19:52.327> have<01:19:52.328> encouraged<01:19:52.329> him<01:19:52.330> to<01:19:52.331> write<01:19:52.332> his<01:19:52.333> wonderful<01:19:52.334> book,<01:19:52.335> Mind<01:19:52.336> and<01:19:52.337> Cosmos,<01:19:52.338> short

01:20:01.040 --> 01:20:10.080
book.<01:20:01.041> I<01:20:01.042> mean,<01:20:01.043> Tom<01:20:01.044> Nagel<01:20:01.045> doesn't<01:20:01.046> want<01:20:01.047> to<01:20:01.048> embrace<01:20:01.049> any<01:20:01.050> kind<01:20:01.051> of<01:20:01.052> religious<01:20:01.053> doctrine.<01:20:01.054> He's<01:20:01.055> not,<01:20:01.056> not

01:20:10.080 --> 01:20:17.360
interested<01:20:10.081> in<01:20:10.082> theology<01:20:10.083> at<01:20:10.084> all,<01:20:10.085> although<01:20:10.086> he<01:20:10.087> admires<01:20:10.088> some<01:20:10.089> theologians<01:20:10.090> like<01:20:10.091> Alvin<01:20:10.092> Plantinga<01:20:10.093> at<01:20:10.094> Notre

01:20:17.360 --> 01:20:27.200
Dame.<01:20:17.361> Uh,<01:20:17.362> but<01:20:17.363> he<01:20:17.364> takes<01:20:17.365> for<01:20:17.366> granted<01:20:17.367> that<01:20:17.368> physicalism<01:20:17.369> cannot<01:20:17.370> account<01:20:17.371> for<01:20:17.372> the,<01:20:17.373> all<01:20:17.374> the<01:20:17.375> properties<01:20:17.376> of

01:20:27.200 --> 01:20:34.160
minds<01:20:27.201> and<01:20:27.202> consciousness,<01:20:27.203> and<01:20:27.204> his<01:20:27.205> book<01:20:27.206> really<01:20:27.207> goes<01:20:27.208> on<01:20:27.209> from<01:20:27.210> that.<01:20:27.211> That's<01:20:27.212> the<01:20:27.213> starting<01:20:27.214> point.

01:20:34.160 --> 01:20:39.440
So<01:20:34.161> I<01:20:34.162> think<01:20:34.163> we<01:20:34.164> may<01:20:34.165> have<01:20:34.166> privately<01:20:34.167> encouraged<01:20:34.168> him<01:20:34.169> in<01:20:34.170> that<01:20:34.171> direction,<01:20:34.172> or<01:20:34.173> at<01:20:34.174> least<01:20:34.175> I<01:20:34.176> hope<01:20:34.177> so,<01:20:34.178> because

01:20:39.440 --> 01:20:48.960
I<01:20:39.441> think<01:20:39.442> that's<01:20:39.443> a<01:20:39.444> wonderful<01:20:39.445> book,<01:20:39.446> and<01:20:39.447> boy,<01:20:39.448> did<01:20:39.449> it<01:20:39.450> cause<01:20:39.451> tremors<01:20:39.452> in<01:20:39.453> the<01:20:39.454> physicalist<01:20:39.455> establishment.

01:20:48.960 --> 01:20:57.280
Do,<01:20:48.961> do<01:20:48.962> we<01:20:48.963> have<01:20:48.964> an<01:20:48.965> idea<01:20:48.966> by<01:20:48.967> what<01:20:48.968> mechanism<01:20:48.969> are<01:20:48.970> our<01:20:48.971> minds<01:20:48.972> extended<01:20:48.973> beyond<01:20:48.974> our<01:20:48.975> brains?<01:20:48.976> Would<01:20:48.977> morphic

01:20:57.280 --> 01:21:04.320
resonance<01:20:57.281> be<01:20:57.282> one<01:20:57.283> of<01:20:57.284> the<01:20:57.285> hypotheses?<01:20:57.286> Uh,<01:20:57.287> it's<01:20:57.288> among<01:20:57.289> the<01:20:57.290> contenders,<01:20:57.291> yeah.

01:21:04.320 --> 01:21:14.160
What<01:21:04.321> is<01:21:04.322> the<01:21:04.323> role<01:21:04.324> of<01:21:04.325> the<01:21:04.326> brain?<01:21:04.327> How<01:21:04.328> do<01:21:04.329> you<01:21:04.330> see<01:21:04.331> the<01:21:04.332> brain?<01:21:04.333> Well,<01:21:04.334> uh,<01:21:04.335> in<01:21:04.336> my<01:21:04.337> everyday<01:21:04.338> role<01:21:04.339> as<01:21:04.340> a<01:21:04.341> scientist,

01:21:14.160 --> 01:21:21.120
I<01:21:14.161> immediately<01:21:14.162> lapse<01:21:14.163> into<01:21:14.164> dualism,<01:21:14.165> think<01:21:14.166> of<01:21:14.167> the<01:21:14.168> brain<01:21:14.169> as<01:21:14.170> a<01:21:14.171> conventional,<01:21:14.172> I<01:21:14.173> mean<01:21:14.174> a<01:21:14.175> complicated<01:21:14.176> but

01:21:21.120 --> 01:21:28.880
conventional<01:21:21.121> physical<01:21:21.122> object.<01:21:21.123> And<01:21:21.124> the<01:21:21.125> way<01:21:21.126> I<01:21:21.127> think<01:21:21.128> of<01:21:21.129> it<01:21:21.130> in<01:21:21.131> relation<01:21:21.132> to<01:21:21.133> mind<01:21:21.134> is<01:21:21.135> what<01:21:21.136> goes<01:21:21.137> on<01:21:21.138> in<01:21:21.139> the

01:21:28.880 --> 01:21:36.720
brain<01:21:28.881> conditions<01:21:28.882> the<01:21:28.883> expression<01:21:28.884> of<01:21:28.885> a<01:21:28.886> mentality<01:21:28.887> that's<01:21:28.888> much<01:21:28.889> larger<01:21:28.890> than<01:21:28.891> we<01:21:28.892> normally<01:21:28.893> think<01:21:28.894> of<01:21:28.895> it

01:21:36.720 --> 01:21:45.200
and<01:21:36.721> is<01:21:36.722> inherently<01:21:36.723> beyond<01:21:36.724> the<01:21:36.725> brain<01:21:36.726> but<01:21:36.727> expresses<01:21:36.728> itself<01:21:36.729> in<01:21:36.730> conjunction<01:21:36.731> with<01:21:36.732> the<01:21:36.733> ongoing<01:21:36.734> activities

01:21:45.200 --> 01:21:51.440
of<01:21:45.201> the<01:21:45.202> brain.<01:21:45.203> I<01:21:45.204> tend<01:21:45.205> to<01:21:45.206> think<01:21:45.207> like<01:21:45.208> Henri<01:21:45.209> Bergson<01:21:45.210> that,<01:21:45.211> uh,<01:21:45.212> one<01:21:45.213> of<01:21:45.214> the<01:21:45.215> primary<01:21:45.216> functions<01:21:45.217> of<01:21:45.218> the

01:21:51.440 --> 01:21:58.320
brain<01:21:51.441> is<01:21:51.442> to<01:21:51.443> act<01:21:51.444> as<01:21:51.445> a<01:21:51.446> sensory-motor<01:21:51.447> interface,<01:21:51.448> collecting<01:21:51.449> information<01:21:51.450> about<01:21:51.451> the<01:21:51.452> environment

01:21:58.320 --> 01:22:09.600
and<01:21:58.321> allowing<01:21:58.322> us<01:21:58.323> to<01:21:58.324> act<01:21:58.325> upon<01:21:58.326> it,<01:21:58.327> and<01:21:58.328> that<01:21:58.329> a<01:21:58.330> lot<01:21:58.331> of<01:21:58.332> the<01:21:58.333> deeper<01:21:58.334> parts<01:21:58.335> of<01:21:58.336> the<01:21:58.337> mind<01:21:58.338> lie<01:21:58.339> beyond<01:21:58.340> the<01:21:58.341> brain.

01:22:09.600 --> 01:22:16.400
The<01:22:09.601> brain<01:22:09.602> for<01:22:09.603> you<01:22:09.604> would<01:22:09.605> be<01:22:09.606> like<01:22:09.607> a<01:22:09.608> filter,<01:22:09.609> or<01:22:09.610> if<01:22:09.611> he,<01:22:09.612> that's<01:22:09.613> a<01:22:09.614> commonly<01:22:09.615> used<01:22:09.616> metaphor,<01:22:09.617> the<01:22:09.618> filter.

01:22:16.400 --> 01:22:24.000
James<01:22:16.401> was<01:22:16.402> the<01:22:16.403> one<01:22:16.404> who<01:22:16.405> first<01:22:16.406> explicitly<01:22:16.407> formulated<01:22:16.408> this.<01:22:16.409> You<01:22:16.410> know,<01:22:16.411> he,<01:22:16.412> he<01:22:16.413> gave<01:22:16.414> an<01:22:16.415> Ingersoll<01:22:16.416> lecture<01:22:16.417> at

01:22:24.000 --> 01:22:32.400
Harvard<01:22:24.001> in<01:22:24.002> 1897,<01:22:24.003> which<01:22:24.004> was<01:22:24.005> published<01:22:24.006> the<01:22:24.007> following<01:22:24.008> year,<01:22:24.009> in<01:22:24.010> which<01:22:24.011> he<01:22:24.012> says<01:22:24.013> explicitly,<01:22:24.014> it,<01:22:24.015> it<01:22:24.016> was<01:22:24.017> called

01:22:32.400 --> 01:22:37.760
something<01:22:32.401> like<01:22:32.402> Two<01:22:32.403> Supposed<01:22:32.404> Objections<01:22:32.405> to<01:22:32.406> the<01:22:32.407> Doctrine<01:22:32.408> of<01:22:32.409> Immortality,<01:22:32.410> and<01:22:32.411> one<01:22:32.412> of<01:22:32.413> those

01:22:37.760 --> 01:22:45.200
objections<01:22:37.761> was<01:22:37.762> of<01:22:37.763> course<01:22:37.764> that<01:22:37.765> mind<01:22:37.766> really<01:22:37.767> is<01:22:37.768> just<01:22:37.769> brain,<01:22:37.770> brain<01:22:37.771> activity,<01:22:37.772> therefore<01:22:37.773> when<01:22:37.774> the<01:22:37.775> brain<01:22:37.776> dies

01:22:45.200 --> 01:22:53.840
it's<01:22:45.201> gone.<01:22:45.202> And<01:22:45.203> in<01:22:45.204> response<01:22:45.205> to<01:22:45.206> that,<01:22:45.207> he<01:22:45.208> said,<01:22:45.209> well,<01:22:45.210> uh,<01:22:45.211> the<01:22:45.212> correlation<01:22:45.213> between<01:22:45.214> mental<01:22:45.215> and<01:22:45.216> physical<01:22:45.217> stuff

01:22:53.840 --> 01:23:01.360
encourages<01:22:53.841> a<01:22:53.842> lot<01:22:53.843> of<01:22:53.844> people,<01:22:53.845> particularly<01:22:53.846> scientific<01:22:53.847> people,<01:22:53.848> to<01:22:53.849> think<01:22:53.850> that<01:22:53.851> mind<01:22:53.852> is<01:22:53.853> generated,<01:22:53.854> produced<01:22:53.855> by

01:23:01.360 --> 01:23:09.760
brain<01:23:01.361> activity,<01:23:01.362> but<01:23:01.363> it's<01:23:01.364> possible<01:23:01.365> to<01:23:01.366> think<01:23:01.367> of<01:23:01.368> it<01:23:01.369> in<01:23:01.370> a<01:23:01.371> different<01:23:01.372> way,<01:23:01.373> uh,<01:23:01.374> such<01:23:01.375> that<01:23:01.376> the<01:23:01.377> brain<01:23:01.378> simply

01:23:09.760 --> 01:23:20.720
um,<01:23:09.761> uh,<01:23:09.762> transmits<01:23:09.763> or<01:23:09.764> permits,<01:23:09.765> uh,<01:23:09.766> activities<01:23:09.767> that<01:23:09.768> originate<01:23:09.769> elsewhere<01:23:09.770> beyond<01:23:09.771> it.<01:23:09.772> And<01:23:09.773> it<01:23:09.774> was<01:23:09.775> clear

01:23:20.720 --> 01:23:31.680
that<01:23:20.721> he<01:23:20.722> preferred<01:23:20.723> that<01:23:20.724> interpretation.<01:23:20.725> He,<01:23:20.726> uh,<01:23:20.727> alludes<01:23:20.728> to<01:23:20.729> Fechner<01:23:20.730> in<01:23:20.731> that<01:23:20.732> context<01:23:20.733> and<01:23:20.734> Myers.

01:23:31.680 --> 01:23:38.800
Uh,<01:23:31.681> filter<01:23:31.682> has<01:23:31.683> come<01:23:31.684> along<01:23:31.685> more<01:23:31.686> recently.<01:23:31.687> I<01:23:31.688> think<01:23:31.689> it<01:23:31.690> was<01:23:31.691> actually<01:23:31.692> Aldous<01:23:31.693> Huxley<01:23:31.694> who,<01:23:31.695> uh,<01:23:31.696> first<01:23:31.697> talked

01:23:38.800 --> 01:23:45.760
about,<01:23:38.801> you<01:23:38.802> know,<01:23:38.803> there's<01:23:38.804> a<01:23:38.805> mind<01:23:38.806> at<01:23:38.807> large,<01:23:38.808> a<01:23:38.809> big<01:23:38.810> mind<01:23:38.811> out<01:23:38.812> there<01:23:38.813> somewhere,<01:23:38.814> uh,<01:23:38.815> which<01:23:38.816> expresses<01:23:38.817> it<01:23:38.818> through

01:23:45.760 --> 01:23:52.640
our<01:23:45.761> brain,<01:23:45.762> and<01:23:45.763> he<01:23:45.764> thought<01:23:45.765> of<01:23:45.766> the<01:23:45.767> brain<01:23:45.768> as<01:23:45.769> a<01:23:45.770> kind<01:23:45.771> of<01:23:45.772> filter<01:23:45.773> or<01:23:45.774> a<01:23:45.775> valve,<01:23:45.776> a<01:23:45.777> reducing<01:23:45.778> valve,<01:23:45.779> that<01:23:45.780> was

01:23:52.640 --> 01:23:58.720
what<01:23:52.641> he<01:23:52.642> thought<01:23:52.643> of.<01:23:52.644> And<01:23:52.645> that's<01:23:52.646> not<01:23:52.647> really,<01:23:52.648> that's<01:23:52.649> not<01:23:52.650> quite<01:23:52.651> satisfactory,<01:23:52.652> because<01:23:52.653> on<01:23:52.654> that<01:23:52.655> picture

01:23:58.720 --> 01:24:05.040
you<01:23:58.721> know,<01:23:58.722> what<01:23:58.723> comes<01:23:58.724> out,<01:23:58.725> the<01:23:58.726> measly<01:23:58.727> trickle<01:23:58.728> that<01:23:58.729> comes<01:23:58.730> out<01:23:58.731> of<01:23:58.732> the<01:23:58.733> reducing<01:23:58.734> valve,<01:23:58.735> is<01:23:58.736> of<01:23:58.737> exactly

01:24:05.040 --> 01:24:10.800
the<01:24:05.041> same<01:24:05.042> sort<01:24:05.043> as<01:24:05.044> the<01:24:05.045> big<01:24:05.046> reservoir<01:24:05.047> behind.<01:24:05.048> But<01:24:05.049> things<01:24:05.050> are<01:24:05.051> really<01:24:05.052> much<01:24:05.053> more<01:24:05.054> complicated<01:24:05.055> than

01:24:10.800 --> 01:24:18.400
that.<01:24:10.801> There,<01:24:10.802> there's<01:24:10.803> this<01:24:10.804> richer,<01:24:10.805> more<01:24:10.806> complicated<01:24:10.807> kind<01:24:10.808> of<01:24:10.809> mentality<01:24:10.810> behind<01:24:10.811> the<01:24:10.812> scenes<01:24:10.813> that<01:24:10.814> expresses

01:24:18.400 --> 01:24:25.040
itself<01:24:18.401> only<01:24:18.402> partially<01:24:18.403> and<01:24:18.404> fitfully,<01:24:18.405> depending<01:24:18.406> on<01:24:18.407> conditions<01:24:18.408> in<01:24:18.409> the<01:24:18.410> brain,<01:24:18.411> which<01:24:18.412> we<01:24:18.413> presently<01:24:18.414> don't

01:24:25.040 --> 01:24:31.600
know<01:24:25.041> much<01:24:25.042> about,<01:24:25.043> but<01:24:25.044> I'll<01:24:25.045> say<01:24:25.046> a<01:24:25.047> little<01:24:25.048> more<01:24:25.049> about<01:24:25.050> that<01:24:25.051> in<01:24:25.052> a<01:24:25.053> moment,<01:24:25.054> uh,<01:24:25.055> but<01:24:25.056> which<01:24:25.057> we<01:24:25.058> have<01:24:25.059> the<01:24:25.060> capacity

01:24:31.600 --> 01:24:41.680
to<01:24:31.601> learn<01:24:31.602> a<01:24:31.603> whole<01:24:31.604> lot<01:24:31.605> about,<01:24:31.606> and<01:24:31.607> will,<01:24:31.608> I'm<01:24:31.609> sure,<01:24:31.610> um,<01:24:31.611> yeah.<01:24:31.612> What<01:24:31.613> I<01:24:31.614> wanted<01:24:31.615> to,<01:24:31.616> uh,<01:24:31.617> mention<01:24:31.618> was<01:24:31.619> that<01:24:31.620> in

01:24:41.680 --> 01:24:47.360
uh,<01:24:41.681> Beyond<01:24:41.682> Physicalism,<01:24:41.683> there's<01:24:41.684> one<01:24:41.685> chapter<01:24:41.686> in<01:24:41.687> there<01:24:41.688> by<01:24:41.689> a<01:24:41.690> neurobiologist,<01:24:41.691> David<01:24:41.692> Presti,

01:24:47.360 --> 01:24:58.480
from<01:24:47.361> Berkeley,<01:24:47.362> and<01:24:47.363> myself,<01:24:47.364> about<01:24:47.365> physiological<01:24:47.366> conditions,<01:24:47.367> uh,<01:24:47.368> related<01:24:47.369> to,<01:24:47.370> um,<01:24:47.371> expressions<01:24:47.372> of<01:24:47.373> psi,

01:24:58.480 --> 01:25:08.960
uh,<01:24:58.481> genius,<01:24:58.482> and<01:24:58.483> mystical<01:24:58.484> experience.<01:24:58.485> And<01:24:58.486> in<01:24:58.487> it,<01:24:58.488> uh,<01:24:58.489> we,<01:24:58.490> at<01:24:58.491> the<01:24:58.492> end<01:24:58.493> of<01:24:58.494> that<01:24:58.495> chapter,<01:24:58.496> we<01:24:58.497> tentatively<01:24:58.498> pointed

01:25:08.960 --> 01:25:17.360
to<01:25:08.961> one<01:25:08.962> aspect<01:25:08.963> of<01:25:08.964> brain<01:25:08.965> function<01:25:08.966> that<01:25:08.967> seems<01:25:08.968> to<01:25:08.969> be<01:25:08.970> especially<01:25:08.971> closely<01:25:08.972> connected<01:25:08.973> with<01:25:08.974> this<01:25:08.975> subject,

01:25:17.360 --> 01:25:25.200
uh,<01:25:17.361> and<01:25:17.362> it's<01:25:17.363> become<01:25:17.364> clear,<01:25:17.365> in<01:25:17.366> particular,<01:25:17.367> not,<01:25:17.368> not<01:25:17.369> only,<01:25:17.370> but<01:25:17.371> in<01:25:17.372> particularly<01:25:17.373> through<01:25:17.374> the<01:25:17.375> initial

01:25:25.200 --> 01:25:35.200
uh,<01:25:25.201> neuroimaging<01:25:25.202> studies<01:25:25.203> of<01:25:25.204> responses<01:25:25.205> to<01:25:25.206> psychedelics.<01:25:25.207> In<01:25:25.208> particular,<01:25:25.209> there<01:25:25.210> was<01:25:25.211> a<01:25:25.212> study<01:25:25.213> published<01:25:25.214> in<01:25:25.215> 2012

01:25:35.200 --> 01:25:42.240
by<01:25:35.201> a<01:25:35.202> British<01:25:35.203> group<01:25:35.204> using<01:25:35.205> injected<01:25:35.206> psilocybin<01:25:35.207> together<01:25:35.208> with<01:25:35.209> functional<01:25:35.210> magnetic<01:25:35.211> resonance

01:25:42.240 --> 01:25:53.280
imagery,<01:25:42.241> two<01:25:42.242> kinds.<01:25:42.243> And<01:25:42.244> what<01:25:42.245> it<01:25:42.246> showed,<01:25:42.247> which<01:25:42.248> was<01:25:42.249> totally<01:25:42.250> amazing<01:25:42.251> to<01:25:42.252> everybody,<01:25:42.253> was<01:25:42.254> that,<01:25:42.255> contrary

01:25:53.280 --> 01:26:00.240
to<01:25:53.281> expectation,<01:25:53.282> no<01:25:53.283> increases<01:25:53.284> in<01:25:53.285> activity<01:25:53.286> were<01:25:53.287> found<01:25:53.288> anywhere<01:25:53.289> in<01:25:53.290> the<01:25:53.291> brain,<01:25:53.292> and<01:25:53.293> in

01:26:00.240 --> 01:26:07.760
particular,<01:26:00.241> the<01:26:00.242> thing<01:26:00.243> that<01:26:00.244> correlated<01:26:00.245> best<01:26:00.246> with<01:26:00.247> the<01:26:00.248> intensity<01:26:00.249> of<01:26:00.250> experience<01:26:00.251> was<01:26:00.252> the

01:26:07.760 --> 01:26:15.280
deactivation<01:26:07.761> and<01:26:07.762> decoupling<01:26:07.763> of<01:26:07.764> major<01:26:07.765> nodes<01:26:07.766> of<01:26:07.767> a<01:26:07.768> brain<01:26:07.769> system<01:26:07.770> only<01:26:07.771> recently<01:26:07.772> recognized,<01:26:07.773> called

01:26:15.280 --> 01:26:26.000
the<01:26:15.281> default<01:26:15.282> mode<01:26:15.283> network,<01:26:15.284> which<01:26:15.285> can<01:26:15.286> be<01:26:15.287> understood<01:26:15.288> as<01:26:15.289> essentially<01:26:15.290> embodying<01:26:15.291> the<01:26:15.292> everyday<01:26:15.293> self<01:26:15.294> or<01:26:15.295> ego.

01:26:26.000 --> 01:26:33.440
And<01:26:26.001> this<01:26:26.002> is<01:26:26.003> coherent<01:26:26.004> with<01:26:26.005> Myers's<01:26:26.006> own<01:26:26.007> doctrine.<01:26:26.008> Myers<01:26:26.009> had<01:26:26.010> a<01:26:26.011> principle<01:26:26.012> to<01:26:26.013> the<01:26:26.014> effect<01:26:26.015> that<01:26:26.016> the

01:26:33.440 --> 01:26:43.040
subliminal<01:26:33.441> self<01:26:33.442> can<01:26:33.443> express<01:26:33.444> itself<01:26:33.445> in<01:26:33.446> proportion<01:26:33.447> to<01:26:33.448> the<01:26:33.449> obeyance<01:26:33.450> of<01:26:33.451> the<01:26:33.452> supraliminal<01:26:33.453> or<01:26:33.454> everyday

01:26:43.040 --> 01:26:49.600
self.<01:26:43.041> And<01:26:43.042> this<01:26:43.043> is<01:26:43.044> right<01:26:43.045> in<01:26:43.046> line,<01:26:43.047> of<01:26:43.048> course,<01:26:43.049> with,<01:26:43.050> uh,<01:26:43.051> meditation<01:26:43.052> traditions<01:26:43.053> which<01:26:43.054> tell<01:26:43.055> you<01:26:43.056> that<01:26:43.057> you<01:26:43.058> got

01:26:49.600 --> 01:26:55.360
to<01:26:49.601> shut<01:26:49.602> down<01:26:49.603> all<01:26:49.604> the<01:26:49.605> normal<01:26:49.606> chatter<01:26:49.607> that's<01:26:49.608> going<01:26:49.609> on<01:26:49.610> inside,<01:26:49.611> and<01:26:49.612> if<01:26:49.613> you<01:26:49.614> can<01:26:49.615> do<01:26:49.616> that,<01:26:49.617> then<01:26:49.618> this<01:26:49.619> higher

01:26:55.360 --> 01:27:03.120
stuff<01:26:55.361> can<01:26:55.362> begin<01:26:55.363> to<01:26:55.364> flood<01:26:55.365> in.<01:26:55.366> And<01:26:55.367> that's<01:26:55.368> what<01:26:55.369> was<01:26:55.370> seen<01:26:55.371> in<01:26:55.372> the,<01:26:55.373> this,<01:26:55.374> this<01:26:55.375> first<01:26:55.376> big,<01:26:55.377> uh,<01:26:55.378> psychedelic

01:27:03.120 --> 01:27:10.480
neuroimaging<01:27:03.121> study,<01:27:03.122> and<01:27:03.123> it's<01:27:03.124> been<01:27:03.125> seen<01:27:03.126> in<01:27:03.127> additional<01:27:03.128> psychedelic<01:27:03.129> neuroimaging<01:27:03.130> studies,<01:27:03.131> and<01:27:03.132> also<01:27:03.133> in<01:27:03.134> studies

01:27:10.480 --> 01:27:19.040
of<01:27:10.481> things<01:27:10.482> like<01:27:10.483> meditation,<01:27:10.484> some<01:27:10.485> studies<01:27:10.486> of<01:27:10.487> meditation,<01:27:10.488> uh,<01:27:10.489> mediumistic<01:27:10.490> trance,<01:27:10.491> and<01:27:10.492> so<01:27:10.493> on.

01:27:19.040 --> 01:27:31.360
So<01:27:19.041> that<01:27:19.042> seems<01:27:19.043> to<01:27:19.044> be<01:27:19.045> one<01:27:19.046> component,<01:27:19.047> certainly,<01:27:19.048> of,<01:27:19.049> uh,<01:27:19.050> brain<01:27:19.051> activity<01:27:19.052> related<01:27:19.053> to<01:27:19.054> these<01:27:19.055> higher<01:27:19.056> phenomena.

01:27:31.360 --> 01:27:42.160
Where<01:27:31.361> do<01:27:31.362> you<01:27:31.363> think<01:27:31.364> memories<01:27:31.365> are<01:27:31.366> stored?<01:27:31.367> Oh<01:27:31.368> boy,<01:27:31.369> well,<01:27:31.370> um,<01:27:31.371> I<01:27:31.372> refer<01:27:31.373> everybody<01:27:31.374> to<01:27:31.375> Alan<01:27:31.376> Gauld's<01:27:31.377> excellent<01:27:31.378> chapter

01:27:42.160 --> 01:27:51.440
in,<01:27:42.161> uh,<01:27:42.162> in<01:27:42.163> Irreducible<01:27:42.164> Mind<01:27:42.165> for<01:27:42.166> a<01:27:42.167> detailed<01:27:42.168> answer<01:27:42.169> to<01:27:42.170> that,<01:27:42.171> uh,<01:27:42.172> but<01:27:42.173> I<01:27:42.174> don't<01:27:42.175> think<01:27:42.176> they're<01:27:42.177> in<01:27:42.178> the<01:27:42.179> brain<01:27:42.180> at

01:27:51.440 --> 01:27:58.480
all,<01:27:51.441> and<01:27:51.442> I'm<01:27:51.443> not<01:27:51.444> the<01:27:51.445> only<01:27:51.446> person<01:27:51.447> who<01:27:51.448> thinks<01:27:51.449> that<01:27:51.450> way.<01:27:51.451> Certainly,<01:27:51.452> if<01:27:51.453> there<01:27:51.454> is<01:27:51.455> survival,<01:27:51.456> then<01:27:51.457> memories

01:27:58.480 --> 01:28:05.120
must<01:27:58.481> be<01:27:58.482> somewhere<01:27:58.483> else.<01:27:58.484> I<01:27:58.485> don't<01:27:58.486> think<01:27:58.487> they're<01:27:58.488> in<01:27:58.489> the<01:27:58.490> form<01:27:58.491> of<01:27:58.492> traces,<01:27:58.493> or<01:27:58.494> at<01:27:58.495> least<01:27:58.496> not<01:27:58.497> traces<01:27:58.498> as

01:28:05.120 --> 01:28:15.760
we<01:28:05.121> customarily<01:28:05.122> think<01:28:05.123> of<01:28:05.124> them,<01:28:05.125> uh,<01:28:05.126> like<01:28:05.127> Myers<01:28:05.128> and<01:28:05.129> James.<01:28:05.130> I'm<01:28:05.131> inclined<01:28:05.132> to<01:28:05.133> think<01:28:05.134> that,<01:28:05.135> um,<01:28:05.136> experiences

01:28:15.760 --> 01:28:24.640
that<01:28:15.761> we<01:28:15.762> have<01:28:15.763> continue<01:28:15.764> to<01:28:15.765> exist<01:28:15.766> somewhere.<01:28:15.767> This<01:28:15.768> is<01:28:15.769> a<01:28:15.770> big<01:28:15.771> part<01:28:15.772> of<01:28:15.773> Alfred<01:28:15.774> North<01:28:15.775> Whitehead's<01:28:15.776> process

01:28:24.640 --> 01:28:33.440
metaphysics,<01:28:24.641> the<01:28:24.642> basic<01:28:24.643> elements<01:28:24.644> of<01:28:24.645> which<01:28:24.646> are<01:28:24.647> what<01:28:24.648> he<01:28:24.649> calls<01:28:24.650> occasions<01:28:24.651> of<01:28:24.652> experience,<01:28:24.653> and

01:28:33.440 --> 01:28:41.120
they're<01:28:33.441> objectively<01:28:33.442> immortal,<01:28:33.443> and<01:28:33.444> the<01:28:33.445> entirety<01:28:33.446> of<01:28:33.447> the<01:28:33.448> history<01:28:33.449> of<01:28:33.450> experience<01:28:33.451> is<01:28:33.452> potentially

01:28:41.120 --> 01:28:49.200
available<01:28:41.121> to<01:28:41.122> the<01:28:41.123> creation<01:28:41.124> of<01:28:41.125> any<01:28:41.126> new<01:28:41.127> experience<01:28:41.128> in<01:28:41.129> his<01:28:41.130> system.<01:28:41.131> I<01:28:41.132> think<01:28:41.133> something<01:28:41.134> like<01:28:41.135> that<01:28:41.136> is<01:28:41.137> the

01:28:49.200 --> 01:28:58.000
case.<01:28:49.201> You<01:28:49.202> do<01:28:49.203> believe<01:28:49.204> that<01:28:49.205> we,<01:28:49.206> that<01:28:49.207> our<01:28:49.208> physical<01:28:49.209> body,<01:28:49.210> or<01:28:49.211> we<01:28:49.212> survive<01:28:49.213> death,<01:28:49.214> right?<01:28:49.215> And<01:28:49.216> if<01:28:49.217> so,<01:28:49.218> who<01:28:49.219> or

01:28:58.000 --> 01:29:06.080
what<01:28:58.001> survives<01:28:58.002> death?<01:28:58.003> Certainly,<01:28:58.004> uh,<01:28:58.005> can't<01:28:58.006> offer<01:28:58.007> any<01:28:58.008> definite<01:28:58.009> answer<01:28:58.010> to<01:28:58.011> that<01:28:58.012> question<01:28:58.013> at<01:28:58.014> the<01:28:58.015> moment.

01:29:06.080 --> 01:29:13.600
In<01:29:06.081> fact,<01:29:06.082> uh,<01:29:06.083> let<01:29:06.084> me<01:29:06.085> say<01:29:06.086> first<01:29:06.087> that,<01:29:06.088> uh,<01:29:06.089> we<01:29:06.090> can't<01:29:06.091> even<01:29:06.092> say<01:29:06.093> for<01:29:06.094> sure<01:29:06.095> that<01:29:06.096> everybody<01:29:06.097> does<01:29:06.098> survive

01:29:13.600 --> 01:29:20.800
or<01:29:13.601> for<01:29:13.602> how<01:29:13.603> long,<01:29:13.604> or<01:29:13.605> in<01:29:13.606> what<01:29:13.607> circumstances.<01:29:13.608> There's<01:29:13.609> no<01:29:13.610> reason<01:29:13.611> to<01:29:13.612> believe<01:29:13.613> a<01:29:13.614> priori<01:29:13.615> that<01:29:13.616> the<01:29:13.617> same

01:29:20.800 --> 01:29:26.640
thing<01:29:20.801> happens,<01:29:20.802> everybody<01:29:20.803> follows<01:29:20.804> the<01:29:20.805> same<01:29:20.806> path,<01:29:20.807> uh,<01:29:20.808> you<01:29:20.809> know,<01:29:20.810> maybe<01:29:20.811> what<01:29:20.812> happens<01:29:20.813> to<01:29:20.814> you<01:29:20.815> depends

01:29:26.640 --> 01:29:34.800
on<01:29:26.641> how<01:29:26.642> you<01:29:26.643> behave<01:29:26.644> while<01:29:26.645> you're<01:29:26.646> in<01:29:26.647> the<01:29:26.648> flesh,<01:29:26.649> um,<01:29:26.650> but<01:29:26.651> Myers<01:29:26.652> had<01:29:26.653> a<01:29:26.654> quite<01:29:26.655> definite<01:29:26.656> idea<01:29:26.657> about<01:29:26.658> this.

01:29:34.800 --> 01:29:42.000
He<01:29:34.801> thought<01:29:34.802> it<01:29:34.803> was<01:29:34.804> the<01:29:34.805> subliminal<01:29:34.806> self,<01:29:34.807> capital<01:29:34.808> S,<01:29:34.809> capital<01:29:34.810> S,<01:29:34.811> that<01:29:34.812> survived.<01:29:34.813> This<01:29:34.814> is<01:29:34.815> the<01:29:34.816> larger<01:29:34.817> self<01:29:34.818> in

01:29:42.000 --> 01:29:50.240
which<01:29:42.001> the<01:29:42.002> everyday<01:29:42.003> ego<01:29:42.004> is<01:29:42.005> embedded,<01:29:42.006> uh,<01:29:42.007> and<01:29:42.008> that's<01:29:42.009> potentially<01:29:42.010> consistent<01:29:42.011> with<01:29:42.012> the<01:29:42.013> what<01:29:42.014> we<01:29:42.015> see<01:29:42.016> in<01:29:42.017> the

01:29:50.240 --> 01:29:58.080
cases<01:29:50.241> of<01:29:50.242> the<01:29:50.243> reincarnation<01:29:50.244> type.<01:29:50.245> There<01:29:50.246> is<01:29:50.247> some<01:29:50.248> carryover<01:29:50.249> of,<01:29:50.250> uh,<01:29:50.251> not<01:29:50.252> only<01:29:50.253> specific<01:29:50.254> memories<01:29:50.255> but

01:29:58.080 --> 01:30:05.680
specific<01:29:58.081> personality<01:29:58.082> characteristics,<01:29:58.083> tendencies,<01:29:58.084> and<01:29:58.085> all<01:29:58.086> that<01:29:58.087> from<01:29:58.088> one<01:29:58.089> life<01:29:58.090> to<01:29:58.091> the<01:29:58.092> next.<01:29:58.093> Haven't

01:30:05.680 --> 01:30:16.160
seen<01:30:05.681> any<01:30:05.682> direct<01:30:05.683> evidence<01:30:05.684> of<01:30:05.685> something<01:30:05.686> like<01:30:05.687> karma,<01:30:05.688> you<01:30:05.689> know,<01:30:05.690> where<01:30:05.691> your<01:30:05.692> next<01:30:05.693> life<01:30:05.694> is<01:30:05.695> a<01:30:05.696> kind<01:30:05.697> of<01:30:05.698> moral

01:30:16.160 --> 01:30:21.760
um,<01:30:16.161> response<01:30:16.162> to<01:30:16.163> your,<01:30:16.164> how<01:30:16.165> you<01:30:16.166> behaved<01:30:16.167> in<01:30:16.168> your<01:30:16.169> previous<01:30:16.170> life,<01:30:16.171> anything<01:30:16.172> like<01:30:16.173> that.<01:30:16.174> It<01:30:16.175> may<01:30:16.176> be<01:30:16.177> the

01:30:21.760 --> 01:30:28.640
case<01:30:21.761> over<01:30:21.762> a<01:30:21.763> larger<01:30:21.764> time<01:30:21.765> scale,<01:30:21.766> who<01:30:21.767> knows,<01:30:21.768> uh,<01:30:21.769> but<01:30:21.770> I<01:30:21.771> think<01:30:21.772> something<01:30:21.773> like<01:30:21.774> that,<01:30:21.775> not<01:30:21.776> necessarily<01:30:21.777> in

01:30:28.640 --> 01:30:36.320
quite<01:30:28.641> the<01:30:28.642> form<01:30:28.643> that<01:30:28.644> Myers,<01:30:28.645> uh,<01:30:28.646> held,<01:30:28.647> is<01:30:28.648> probably<01:30:28.649> the<01:30:28.650> case.<01:30:28.651> And<01:30:28.652> this<01:30:28.653> is<01:30:28.654> the<01:30:28.655> essence<01:30:28.656> of<01:30:28.657> my<01:30:28.658> disagreement

01:30:36.320 --> 01:30:43.920
with<01:30:36.321> Bernardo,<01:30:36.322> by<01:30:36.323> the<01:30:36.324> way,<01:30:36.325> that<01:30:36.326> I<01:30:36.327> think<01:30:36.328> we<01:30:36.329> have<01:30:36.330> to<01:30:36.331> pay<01:30:36.332> attention<01:30:36.333> to<01:30:36.334> the<01:30:36.335> evidence<01:30:36.336> for,<01:30:36.337> uh,<01:30:36.338> survival<01:30:36.339> of

01:30:43.920 --> 01:30:51.280
personality.<01:30:43.921> I<01:30:43.922> mean,<01:30:43.923> there<01:30:43.924> are<01:30:43.925> some<01:30:43.926> cases<01:30:43.927> in<01:30:43.928> which<01:30:43.929> it<01:30:43.930> looks<01:30:43.931> for<01:30:43.932> all<01:30:43.933> the<01:30:43.934> world<01:30:43.935> as<01:30:43.936> though

01:30:51.280 --> 01:30:58.640
uh,<01:30:51.281> the<01:30:51.282> entire<01:30:51.283> mind<01:30:51.284> of<01:30:51.285> a<01:30:51.286> certain<01:30:51.287> person<01:30:51.288> is<01:30:51.289> still<01:30:51.290> operative<01:30:51.291> following<01:30:51.292> physical<01:30:51.293> death.

01:30:58.640 --> 01:31:08.320
One<01:30:58.641> of<01:30:58.642> the<01:30:58.643> best<01:30:58.644> cases<01:30:58.645> of<01:30:58.646> that<01:30:58.647> sort<01:30:58.648> is<01:30:58.649> the<01:30:58.650> case<01:30:58.651> of,<01:30:58.652> uh,<01:30:58.653> G.P.,<01:30:58.654> a,<01:30:58.655> uh,<01:30:58.656> young<01:30:58.657> guy<01:30:58.658> who<01:30:58.659> had<01:30:58.660> died<01:30:58.661> in<01:30:58.662> a<01:30:58.663> fall,

01:31:08.320 --> 01:31:17.760
uh,<01:31:08.321> soon<01:31:08.322> began<01:31:08.323> communicating<01:31:08.324> through<01:31:08.325> the<01:31:08.326> medium<01:31:08.327> Mrs.<01:31:08.328> Piper,<01:31:08.329> um,<01:31:08.330> William<01:31:08.331> James<01:31:08.332> was<01:31:08.333> a<01:31:08.334> keen<01:31:08.335> student<01:31:08.336> of<01:31:08.337> that

01:31:17.760 --> 01:31:24.880
subject.<01:31:17.761> Yeah,<01:31:17.762> I<01:31:17.763> mean,<01:31:17.764> sometimes<01:31:17.765> the<01:31:17.766> evidence<01:31:17.767> that<01:31:17.768> comes<01:31:17.769> through<01:31:17.770> is<01:31:17.771> not<01:31:17.772> just<01:31:17.773> a<01:31:17.774> matter<01:31:17.775> of

01:31:24.880 --> 01:31:33.760
you<01:31:24.881> know,<01:31:24.882> facts<01:31:24.883> that<01:31:24.884> can<01:31:24.885> be<01:31:24.886> verified,<01:31:24.887> but<01:31:24.888> a<01:31:24.889> kind<01:31:24.890> of<01:31:24.891> verisimilitude<01:31:24.892> in<01:31:24.893> the,<01:31:24.894> uh,<01:31:24.895> appearance<01:31:24.896> or<01:31:24.897> the,<01:31:24.898> the

01:31:33.760 --> 01:31:41.360
character<01:31:33.761> of<01:31:33.762> the<01:31:33.763> communications<01:31:33.764> that<01:31:33.765> show<01:31:33.766> the<01:31:33.767> same<01:31:33.768> kind<01:31:33.769> of<01:31:33.770> vocabulary,<01:31:33.771> diction,<01:31:33.772> sense<01:31:33.773> of<01:31:33.774> humor,

01:31:41.360 --> 01:31:51.760
uh,<01:31:41.361> detailed<01:31:41.362> knowledge<01:31:41.363> of<01:31:41.364> specific<01:31:41.365> shared<01:31:41.366> events,<01:31:41.367> that<01:31:41.368> sort<01:31:41.369> of<01:31:41.370> thing.<01:31:41.371> It<01:31:41.372> can<01:31:41.373> be<01:31:41.374> quite<01:31:41.375> hair-raising<01:31:41.376> in

01:31:51.760 --> 01:31:59.360
its<01:31:51.761> best<01:31:51.762> forms.<01:31:51.763> And<01:31:51.764> of<01:31:51.765> course,<01:31:51.766> there's<01:31:51.767> a<01:31:51.768> great<01:31:51.769> deal<01:31:51.770> of<01:31:51.771> mediumistic<01:31:51.772> communication<01:31:51.773> that's<01:31:51.774> just<01:31:51.775> twaddle

01:31:59.360 --> 01:32:08.720
and<01:31:59.361> rubbish,<01:31:59.362> as<01:31:59.363> many<01:31:59.364> critics<01:31:59.365> have<01:31:59.366> noticed,<01:31:59.367> but,<01:31:59.368> uh,<01:31:59.369> in<01:31:59.370> this<01:31:59.371> field<01:31:59.372> you<01:31:59.373> need<01:31:59.374> to<01:31:59.375> be<01:31:59.376> discriminating<01:31:59.377> and,<01:31:59.378> uh,<01:31:59.379> be

01:32:08.720 --> 01:32:17.200
prepared<01:32:08.721> to<01:32:08.722> ignore<01:32:08.723> twaddle<01:32:08.724> in<01:32:08.725> order<01:32:08.726> to<01:32:08.727> get<01:32:08.728> to<01:32:08.729> the<01:32:08.730> good<01:32:08.731> stuff,<01:32:08.732> shall<01:32:08.733> we<01:32:08.734> say.<01:32:08.735> So<01:32:08.736> you<01:32:08.737> don't<01:32:08.738> think<01:32:08.739> that

01:32:17.200 --> 01:32:25.120
we<01:32:17.201> are<01:32:17.202> sort<01:32:17.203> of<01:32:17.204> points<01:32:17.205> of<01:32:17.206> view<01:32:17.207> of<01:32:17.208> a<01:32:17.209> large<01:32:17.210> universal<01:32:17.211> consciousness<01:32:17.212> going<01:32:17.213> after<01:32:17.214> death,<01:32:17.215> going<01:32:17.216> back<01:32:17.217> to<01:32:17.218> that

01:32:25.120 --> 01:32:35.760
field?<01:32:25.121> Yeah,<01:32:25.122> I,<01:32:25.123> I<01:32:25.124> do<01:32:25.125> share<01:32:25.126> Bernardo's<01:32:25.127> sense<01:32:25.128> that<01:32:25.129> the<01:32:25.130> ultimate<01:32:25.131> aim<01:32:25.132> of<01:32:25.133> the<01:32:25.134> whole<01:32:25.135> process,<01:32:25.136> whatever<01:32:25.137> it<01:32:25.138> is,

01:32:35.760 --> 01:32:43.360
is<01:32:35.761> to<01:32:35.762> allow<01:32:35.763> us<01:32:35.764> to<01:32:35.765> merge<01:32:35.766> fully<01:32:35.767> with<01:32:35.768> that<01:32:35.769> higher<01:32:35.770> consciousness<01:32:35.771> which<01:32:35.772> exists<01:32:35.773> within<01:32:35.774> us<01:32:35.775> as<01:32:35.776> in<01:32:35.777> all

01:32:43.360 --> 01:32:51.680
things,<01:32:43.361> uh,<01:32:43.362> but<01:32:43.363> I<01:32:43.364> imagine<01:32:43.365> it<01:32:43.366> as<01:32:43.367> being<01:32:43.368> a<01:32:43.369> longer<01:32:43.370> and<01:32:43.371> harder<01:32:43.372> road,<01:32:43.373> I<01:32:43.374> think,<01:32:43.375> than<01:32:43.376> he<01:32:43.377> does.<01:32:43.378> He<01:32:43.379> thinks<01:32:43.380> it

01:32:51.680 --> 01:33:01.040
happens<01:32:51.681> automatically<01:32:51.682> to<01:32:51.683> everyone<01:32:51.684> when<01:32:51.685> we<01:32:51.686> die.<01:32:51.687> I<01:32:51.688> rather<01:32:51.689> doubt<01:32:51.690> that.<01:32:51.691> Not<01:32:51.692> that<01:32:51.693> we<01:32:51.694> know,<01:32:51.695> nobody,<01:32:51.696> nobody

01:33:01.040 --> 01:33:09.200
really<01:33:01.041> knows,<01:33:01.042> except<01:33:01.043> those<01:33:01.044> to<01:33:01.045> whom<01:33:01.046> it's<01:33:01.047> happened.<01:33:01.048> Whatever<01:33:01.049> it<01:33:01.050> is,<01:33:01.051> is<01:33:01.052> consciousness<01:33:01.053> fundamental,<01:33:01.054> or

01:33:09.200 --> 01:33:16.880
is<01:33:09.201> there<01:33:09.202> something<01:33:09.203> else<01:33:09.204> underneath<01:33:09.205> it?<01:33:09.206> That's<01:33:09.207> the,<01:33:09.208> uh,<01:33:09.209> the<01:33:09.210> main<01:33:09.211> idea<01:33:09.212> that<01:33:09.213> people<01:33:09.214> like<01:33:09.215> Bernardo<01:33:09.216> and

01:33:16.880 --> 01:33:26.080
I<01:33:16.881> share,<01:33:16.882> that<01:33:16.883> the<01:33:16.884> ultimate<01:33:16.885> reality<01:33:16.886> is<01:33:16.887> a<01:33:16.888> higher<01:33:16.889> consciousness<01:33:16.890> of<01:33:16.891> some<01:33:16.892> sort<01:33:16.893> about<01:33:16.894> which<01:33:16.895> we<01:33:16.896> don't

01:33:26.080 --> 01:33:33.280
know<01:33:26.081> very<01:33:26.082> much.<01:33:26.083> It's<01:33:26.084> irreducible,<01:33:26.085> like<01:33:26.086> what,<01:33:26.087> what<01:33:26.088> is<01:33:26.089> saying,<01:33:26.090> the<01:33:26.091> consciousness<01:33:26.092> is<01:33:26.093> omnipresent,<01:33:26.094> omni-

01:33:33.280 --> 01:33:41.200
potent,<01:33:33.281> irreducible,<01:33:33.282> and<01:33:33.283> fundamental.<01:33:33.284> So<01:33:33.285> there<01:33:33.286> is<01:33:33.287> nothing,<01:33:33.288> no<01:33:33.289> reality<01:33:33.290> beyond<01:33:33.291> that.<01:33:33.292> Actually,<01:33:33.293> that's,<01:33:33.294> I

01:33:41.200 --> 01:33:48.240
believe<01:33:41.201> that<01:33:41.202> is<01:33:41.203> true.<01:33:41.204> Okay,<01:33:41.205> so<01:33:41.206> you<01:33:41.207> share<01:33:41.208> that<01:33:41.209> point<01:33:41.210> of<01:33:41.211> view,<01:33:41.212> and<01:33:41.213> that's<01:33:41.214> also<01:33:41.215> part<01:33:41.216> of<01:33:41.217> your<01:33:41.218> theory<01:33:41.219> of<01:33:41.220> the

01:33:48.240 --> 01:33:54.640
realist<01:33:48.241> idealism,<01:33:48.242> right?<01:33:48.243> Yes.<01:33:48.244> Okay,<01:33:48.245> are<01:33:48.246> you<01:33:48.247> planning<01:33:48.248> to<01:33:48.249> develop<01:33:48.250> that<01:33:48.251> theory<01:33:48.252> further?<01:33:48.253> Are<01:33:48.254> we<01:33:48.255> expecting

01:33:54.640 --> 01:34:04.640
a<01:33:54.641> new<01:33:54.642> book<01:33:54.643> coming?<01:33:54.644> Uh,<01:33:54.645> well,<01:33:54.646> we,<01:33:54.647> we<01:33:54.648> are<01:33:54.649> partway<01:33:54.650> into<01:33:54.651> formulating<01:33:54.652> a<01:33:54.653> book<01:33:54.654> for,<01:33:54.655> um,<01:33:54.656> you<01:33:54.657> know,<01:33:54.658> I'm<01:33:54.659> almost<01:33:54.660> 85

01:34:04.640 --> 01:34:10.400
years<01:34:04.641> old<01:34:04.642> now,<01:34:04.643> and<01:34:04.644> I'm<01:34:04.645> not<01:34:04.646> sure<01:34:04.647> how<01:34:04.648> much<01:34:04.649> time<01:34:04.650> I<01:34:04.651> have<01:34:04.652> left,<01:34:04.653> but,<01:34:04.654> uh,<01:34:04.655> I<01:34:04.656> hope<01:34:04.657> to<01:34:04.658> get<01:34:04.659> that<01:34:04.660> out<01:34:04.661> sometime

01:34:10.400 --> 01:34:19.760
in<01:34:10.401> the<01:34:10.402> next<01:34:10.403> year<01:34:10.404> or<01:34:10.405> two.<01:34:10.406> Okay,<01:34:10.407> that's<01:34:10.408> very<01:34:10.409> good.<01:34:10.410> Do<01:34:10.411> you<01:34:10.412> have<01:34:10.413> any<01:34:10.414> final<01:34:10.415> thoughts<01:34:10.416> or<01:34:10.417> quote<01:34:10.418> or<01:34:10.419> something

01:34:19.760 --> 01:34:24.800
for<01:34:19.761> our<01:34:19.762> audience<01:34:19.763> that,<01:34:19.764> or<01:34:19.765> maybe<01:34:19.766> something<01:34:19.767> we<01:34:19.768> should<01:34:19.769> have<01:34:19.770> discussed<01:34:19.771> and<01:34:19.772> we<01:34:19.773> haven't<01:34:19.774> touched

01:34:24.800 --> 01:34:32.080
uh,<01:34:24.801> upon?<01:34:24.802> Well,<01:34:24.803> not,<01:34:24.804> not<01:34:24.805> really.<01:34:24.806> I<01:34:24.807> mean,<01:34:24.808> what<01:34:24.809> I'd<01:34:24.810> mainly<01:34:24.811> like<01:34:24.812> to<01:34:24.813> emphasize<01:34:24.814> to<01:34:24.815> people<01:34:24.816> is<01:34:24.817> what<01:34:24.818> an<01:34:24.819> exciting

01:34:32.080 --> 01:34:40.560
time<01:34:32.081> we<01:34:32.082> live<01:34:32.083> in,<01:34:32.084> uh,<01:34:32.085> I<01:34:32.086> think<01:34:32.087> the,<01:34:32.088> for<01:34:32.089> the<01:34:32.090> first<01:34:32.091> time<01:34:32.092> in<01:34:32.093> my<01:34:32.094> own<01:34:32.095> long<01:34:32.096> career,<01:34:32.097> I<01:34:32.098> really<01:34:32.099> feel<01:34:32.100> that<01:34:32.101> the<01:34:32.102> winds

01:34:40.560 --> 01:34:48.320
of<01:34:40.561> change<01:34:40.562> are<01:34:40.563> now<01:34:40.564> blowing,<01:34:40.565> uh.<01:34:40.566> The<01:34:40.567> physicalist<01:34:40.568> bunker<01:34:40.569> has<01:34:40.570> big<01:34:40.571> cracks<01:34:40.572> in<01:34:40.573> it,<01:34:40.574> and<01:34:40.575> they're<01:34:40.576> widening.

01:34:48.320 --> 01:34:56.240
Uh,<01:34:48.321> the<01:34:48.322> possibility<01:34:48.323> of<01:34:48.324> change<01:34:48.325> is<01:34:48.326> upon<01:34:48.327> us<01:34:48.328> in<01:34:48.329> various<01:34:48.330> interconnected<01:34:48.331> areas,<01:34:48.332> such<01:34:48.333> as<01:34:48.334> consciousness

01:34:56.240 --> 01:35:03.760
research,<01:34:56.241> evolutionary<01:34:56.242> theory,<01:34:56.243> biological<01:34:56.244> theory,<01:34:56.245> and<01:34:56.246> the<01:34:56.247> kind<01:34:56.248> of<01:34:56.249> stuff<01:34:56.250> that<01:34:56.251> we've<01:34:56.252> been<01:34:56.253> involved<01:34:56.254> in,<01:34:56.255> that

01:35:03.760 --> 01:35:13.920
all<01:35:03.761> is<01:35:03.762> coherent<01:35:03.763> and<01:35:03.764> leading<01:35:03.765> in<01:35:03.766> a,<01:35:03.767> uh,<01:35:03.768> definitely<01:35:03.769> more<01:35:03.770> positive<01:35:03.771> philosophical<01:35:03.772> direction.<01:35:03.773> So,<01:35:03.774> um,<01:35:03.775> it

01:35:13.920 --> 01:35:20.800
would<01:35:13.921> be<01:35:13.922> great<01:35:13.923> to<01:35:13.924> be<01:35:13.925> a<01:35:13.926> continuing<01:35:13.927> part<01:35:13.928> of<01:35:13.929> that<01:35:13.930> development<01:35:13.931> as<01:35:13.932> it<01:35:13.933> occurs,<01:35:13.934> and<01:35:13.935> I<01:35:13.936> certainly<01:35:13.937> encourage

01:35:20.800 --> 01:35:29.040
young<01:35:20.801> people<01:35:20.802> looking<01:35:20.803> at<01:35:20.804> all<01:35:20.805> this<01:35:20.806> to,<01:35:20.807> uh,<01:35:20.808> take<01:35:20.809> it<01:35:20.810> seriously<01:35:20.811> and<01:35:20.812> look<01:35:20.813> for<01:35:20.814> a<01:35:20.815> path,<01:35:20.816> path<01:35:20.817> forward<01:35:20.818> in<01:35:20.819> it.

01:35:29.040 --> 01:35:37.520
We<01:35:29.041> need<01:35:29.042> you.<01:35:29.043> Any<01:35:29.044> online<01:35:29.045> resources<01:35:29.046> or<01:35:29.047> books<01:35:29.048> you<01:35:29.049> mentioned,<01:35:29.050> anything<01:35:29.051> else<01:35:29.052> that<01:35:29.053> could<01:35:29.054> be<01:35:29.055> helpful

01:35:37.520 --> 01:35:46.320
where<01:35:37.521> people<01:35:37.522> can<01:35:37.523> find<01:35:37.524> more<01:35:37.525> about<01:35:37.526> your<01:35:37.527> books,<01:35:37.528> your<01:35:37.529> work?<01:35:37.530> Uh,<01:35:37.531> well,<01:35:37.532> Irreducible<01:35:37.533> Mind<01:35:37.534> actually<01:35:37.535> had<01:35:37.536> a

01:35:46.320 --> 01:35:52.480
an<01:35:46.321> annotated<01:35:46.322> bibliography<01:35:46.323> of<01:35:46.324> psychical<01:35:46.325> research,<01:35:46.326> pointing<01:35:46.327> people<01:35:46.328> to<01:35:46.329> what<01:35:46.330> we<01:35:46.331> regard<01:35:46.332> as<01:35:46.333> some<01:35:46.334> of

01:35:52.480 --> 01:35:58.080
the<01:35:52.481> high<01:35:52.482> points<01:35:52.483> of<01:35:52.484> that<01:35:52.485> literature.<01:35:52.486> It's<01:35:52.487> really<01:35:52.488> a<01:35:52.489> quite<01:35:52.490> vast<01:35:52.491> subject.<01:35:52.492> Very<01:35:52.493> few<01:35:52.494> mainstream<01:35:52.495> kind

01:35:58.080 --> 01:36:03.840
of<01:35:58.081> people<01:35:58.082> have<01:35:58.083> any<01:35:58.084> idea<01:35:58.085> how<01:35:58.086> much<01:35:58.087> is<01:35:58.088> there.<01:35:58.089> Hundreds<01:35:58.090> of<01:35:58.091> thousands<01:35:58.092> of<01:35:58.093> serious<01:35:58.094> pages<01:35:58.095> of

01:36:03.840 --> 01:36:10.640
serious<01:36:03.841> work<01:36:03.842> by<01:36:03.843> serious<01:36:03.844> people.<01:36:03.845> Uh,<01:36:03.846> consciousness,<01:36:03.847> there,<01:36:03.848> you<01:36:03.849> know,<01:36:03.850> there<01:36:03.851> are<01:36:03.852> consciousness<01:36:03.853> research

01:36:10.640 --> 01:36:17.120
societies,<01:36:10.641> programs<01:36:10.642> in<01:36:10.643> consciousness<01:36:10.644> research,<01:36:10.645> both<01:36:10.646> philosophical<01:36:10.647> and<01:36:10.648> neuroscientific

01:36:17.120 --> 01:36:24.400
appearing<01:36:17.121> in<01:36:17.122> various<01:36:17.123> universities.<01:36:17.124> Uh,<01:36:17.125> there's<01:36:17.126> Parapsychological<01:36:17.127> Association<01:36:17.128> in<01:36:17.129> the<01:36:17.130> US,<01:36:17.131> which<01:36:17.132> is

01:36:24.400 --> 01:36:34.000
uh,<01:36:24.401> it's<01:36:24.402> actually<01:36:24.403> the<01:36:24.404> main,<01:36:24.405> uh,<01:36:24.406> scientific<01:36:24.407> organization<01:36:24.408> under<01:36:24.409> the<01:36:24.410> auspices<01:36:24.411> of<01:36:24.412> the<01:36:24.413> AAAS<01:36:24.414> in<01:36:24.415> the,<01:36:24.416> in<01:36:24.417> the

01:36:34.000 --> 01:36:40.480
United<01:36:34.001> States.<01:36:34.002> There's<01:36:34.003> the<01:36:34.004> Society<01:36:34.005> for<01:36:34.006> Psychical<01:36:34.007> Research<01:36:34.008> in<01:36:34.009> England,<01:36:34.010> has<01:36:34.011> a<01:36:34.012> website,<01:36:34.013> they<01:36:34.014> have<01:36:34.015> an

01:36:40.480 --> 01:36:46.800
encyclopedia<01:36:40.481> which<01:36:40.482> is<01:36:40.483> a<01:36:40.484> lot<01:36:40.485> more<01:36:40.486> reliable<01:36:40.487> than<01:36:40.488> Wikipedia<01:36:40.489> as<01:36:40.490> a<01:36:40.491> source<01:36:40.492> of<01:36:40.493> information<01:36:40.494> about<01:36:40.495> the

01:36:46.800 --> 01:36:54.560
subject.<01:36:46.801> So,<01:36:46.802> there,<01:36:46.803> there<01:36:46.804> is<01:36:46.805> information<01:36:46.806> to<01:36:46.807> be<01:36:46.808> found<01:36:46.809> quite<01:36:46.810> easily,<01:36:46.811> really,<01:36:46.812> and<01:36:46.813> lots<01:36:46.814> of<01:36:46.815> it<01:36:46.816> that

01:36:54.560 --> 01:37:00.160
in<01:36:54.561> fact,<01:36:54.562> that's<01:36:54.563> the<01:36:54.564> real<01:36:54.565> trick.<01:36:54.566> There's<01:36:54.567> so<01:36:54.568> much<01:36:54.569> of<01:36:54.570> it<01:36:54.571> that<01:36:54.572> one<01:36:54.573> needs<01:36:54.574> to<01:36:54.575> be<01:36:54.576> very<01:36:54.577> judicious<01:36:54.578> in<01:36:54.579> trying

01:37:00.160 --> 01:37:09.360
to<01:37:00.161> pick<01:37:00.162> your<01:37:00.163> way<01:37:00.164> through<01:37:00.165> it.<01:37:00.166> Ed,<01:37:00.167> thank<01:37:00.168> you<01:37:00.169> very<01:37:00.170> much<01:37:00.171> for<01:37:00.172> this<01:37:00.173> interview,<01:37:00.174> for<01:37:00.175> your<01:37:00.176> thoughts,<01:37:00.177> for

01:37:09.360 --> 01:37:15.520
your<01:37:09.361> challenging,<01:37:09.362> uh,<01:37:09.363> yeah,<01:37:09.364> answers,<01:37:09.365> because<01:37:09.366> people,<01:37:09.367> I<01:37:09.368> think,<01:37:09.369> they<01:37:09.370> are<01:37:09.371> thought-provoking.

01:37:15.520 --> 01:37:17.520
Really,<01:37:15.521> thank<01:37:15.522> you<01:37:15.523> for<01:37:15.524> having<01:37:15.525> me.<01:37:15.526> I<01:37:15.527> hope<01:37:15.528> people<01:37:15.529> enjoy<01:37:15.530> it,<01:37:15.531> hope<01:37:15.532> it<01:37:15.533> serves<01:37:15.534> the<01:37:15.535> purpose.<01:37:15.536> [Music]

```